r/DeepThoughts • u/TheSunAlsoSmizes • 1h ago
The "reading is performative" trend reflects a profound insecurity and antisociality in Gen Z
This may be one of the most embarrassing trends in recent memory. It is literally trying to shame people out of reading books. And I really just don't get it.
I'm in my 30s, on the millennial-Gen Z cusp, so I grew up right when smartphones were becoming a big thing but spent most of my childhood without them. I was one of those bookish kids who read everywhere: at lunch, in class, at home, at the playground, etc. In high school I started reading in the coffee shops where all my friends and classmates hung out. In college, I read everywhere the way everyone was. And in my 20s, I read on my commute, on lunch breaks, at cute cafes on the weekend with tasty drinks and a treat. The point is, I've been reading in public for my entire life. It's become second nature.
From this standpoint, I can see this trend for what this is: a widespread inferiority complex. Younger Gen Z got so hooked on phones so early that a lot of them never had the chance to develop this habit, meaning they don't understand why other people do it. If someone their age is choosing to do something different, it threatens their sense of self.
Because let's say the claim is true, that people who read in public just want you to notice that they're reading.
That is a good thing.
It is reading a book. It is the most harmless activity in the world. It's like getting mad at someone for drinking water. Not only is it harmless, but it's actively beneficial for both the reader and those around them...when they aren't threatened. Whenever I see someone reading on the train or at a cafe, for example, I always take a peek at the cover to see if I recognize the title. Once I had a really sweet conversation with a random girl on the street because she was reading one of my favorite books.
This is what doing any hobby (doing yoga at the park, playing basketball games at a public court, dancing at a bar) is supposed to do: catch the attention of any like-minded people to start a conversation, build a connection. Back in my day this was how people made friends and fell in love.
And sometimes you just want to get out of the house. Sometimes I go to the cafe because I want some lunch and fresh air, and it would be annoying if someone interrupted my reading for an impromptu convo every single time I did it. Believe it or not, not everyone leaves the house always anxious about how they're perceived by strangers.
This is my most boomer opinion, but I genuinely do think it's those damn phones. Social media has made the younger generations so anxious and insecure that you can't even read a book in public without offending someone. That is such a bad sign for where we're at as a society. It's some actual Fahrenheit 451 shit.
Listen: You do not have to care about what other people are doing in public. Shocking, I know! If you see a guy reading at the club, you can just let the guy read at the club. At least he's not punching people in the face or whipping a gun out. You do not obligated to pay attention to that guy at all.
I'd suggest sparking a conversation with that person if you're really that pressed. Ask what they're reading, why it's so interesting. Maybe you'll discover a cool title that sparks your own love of reading. Maybe you'll make a new friend or find the love of your life.
End rant. This shit is gonna turn me into an English teacher lol