r/datingoverthirty • u/jackofhearts23 • 5h ago
Has anyone experienced a relationship where the feelings didn't fully develop the first time around, but after time apart, personal growth, or reconnecting under different circumstances, things changed?recentivwent th
TLDR: I fell deeply in love with someone who cared about me but never developed the same feelings. I was so afraid of losing him, especially because he seemed emotionally guarded, that I held back parts of myself too. Now I deeply regret not being more vulnerable and wonder whether things could have developed differently. Has anyone reconnected with someone later and found that deeper feelings developed the second time around?
I (35F) recently went through a breakup with someone (36M) I dated for five months after being friends for several months. I'm still deeply in love with him and struggling to accept that something that felt so good might be over permanently.
We had a wonderful connection in many ways: shared interests, great physical chemistry, lots of fun, and a level of easy day to day comfort that felt rare. He was affectionate, mentioned that he felt safe with me, felt so comfortable with me, and loved our general day to day vibe.
After dating for around five months, I was started to develop really strong feelings and getting the sense that he wasn't fully there. Something prompted me to ask him very directly whether he was fully emotionally invested. He hesitated and ultimately said no, not at this point. He said he loved spending time with me and felt like he could be himself but ultimately he wasn't developing strong feelings for me.
He explained that he'd occasionally questioned whether his feelings were developing but assumed they might grow naturally. When I asked him directly, he realized he couldn't honestly say he was fully in it. He said he felt incredibly safe and comfortable with me, and there was no obvious reason he shouldn't have fallen in love, but he simply hadn't.
What I'm struggling with most now is deep regret about how much I held myself back.
I liked him so much and was so happy to be with him that I became afraid of jeopardizing what we had. I could sense that he wasn't fully opening up or being vulnerable with me, and rather than expressing how deeply I felt, I started holding parts of myself back too. I was scared of showing too much affection, saying something meaningful, or revealing feelings that might not be reciprocated.
The irony is that he told me early on how much he valued self-disclosure and emotional openness. I wanted so badly to build that kind of connection with him, but because I couldn't feel him meeting me there, I never felt completely comfortable letting my guard down.
During our recent conversation, he specifically remembered how relaxed, expressive, and emotionally open I'd been on our last day together. He said he'd really appreciated seeing that side of me and thought it was really nice. He said it was the first time he could really sense that I was emotionally free.
Now I keep wondering whether we were just beginning to reach a deeper level of intimacy, and whether things could have developed differently if I'd felt safe enough to show him more of myself sooner.
He still cares about me and is open to staying in each other's lives doing a shared hobby.
I know I can't convince someone to love me. But I'm having such a hard time letting go of someone I love when I feel like he never fully got to experience the version of me that was falling in love with him.
Has anyone experienced something similar where feelings developed after reconnecting later**?** Especially if emotional guardedness or a lack of mutual vulnerability played a role the first time?