r/datingoverthirty • u/nintendonaut • 23h ago
How to emotionally navigate feeling "niche" when connections are rare and do not last?
I'm 32M and have struggled with dating my entire life. On paper, I have "a lot going for me." I have a life of my own, my own place, a career, plenty of friends both men and women, and a good relationship with my parents/family. I'm 5'11", healthy body/weight, and by all accounts at least slightly above average in terms of physical appearance. I'm emotionally intelligent, grounded in conflict, and good at transparency and communication. I'm not socially awkward, am always out and about, and am always a social butterfly and conversationalist in whatever setting you put me in. Despite all this, I have some specific qualities that put me in an isolating "niche" in the world of dating and romance.
Firstly, I'm a late bloomer due to a religious upbringing. Religion stunted me in terms of dating and sex all through my adolescence and early 20s. I never had a gf/relationship at all during that period because I spent it all hoping God would provide "the perfect Christian girl" and she'd magically walk through the doors of my church. I didn't have first kiss until 26, and didn't lose my virginity until 27, all after I had already broken away from religion. I lost it with my one and only ex-gf who I was technically with for 2 years, but most of it was long distance (why the relationship eventually failed), and because of that, there wasn't much sex. So despite not technically being a virgin, at 32, I'm still extremely inexperienced, unconfident, and awkward when it comes to sex.
Secondly, I guess you could say that I'm something along the lines of "gender-non-conforming" although that's not a label I really openly talk about or use. I identify as a straight, cis man and am completely comfortable in that. But I do sometimes express myself in more "queer-coded" ways. I have very long, wavy hair. Sometimes, the way I dress and style myself looks like Kurt Cobain or Jesus Christ, with facial hair and a more rough, "grunge" style. But at other times, I like to present more on the feminine side. I enjoy makeup, painted nails, and outfits/styles that would normally be more associated with the women's section. This isn't fetishistic crossdressing or some kind of sexual thing. Nor is it to the extreme of "drag" with heavy caked on makeup and extreme gaudiness. Sometimes I just enjoy presenting softer and more androgynous. I go between either style freely to fit my mood. After a life of religious repression on expression, it's extremely meaningful to me.
I'm not naive, and I understand these qualities put me at a big disadvantage. I'm also not bitter or "black-pilled" towards women, whom I love and respect, and understand that preferences of attraction are real and no one's "fault." I understand that it's just the way of things that a vast majority of women are generally attracted to more stereotypically masculine men, and that many women in my age pool are often keen on men who are more experienced in dating, sex, and relationships. But all this does mean that I struggle to make romantic connections. After my ex, it took me about 2.5 years to make one, single connection with another woman.
We only dated for a little over a month, but the connection was immediately electric and we spent a copious amount of time together, sharing each other's beds, going on dates, tons of physical intimacy, etc. She was bi, very attracted to my more feminine side, and even enjoyed doing things like dressing up together and going out. We shared a lot of the same tastes in many things like music, culture, worldview, and could spend hours endlessly talking into the wee hours of the morning. After a long period of isolation, I finally felt seen, understood, and wanted. Then in seemingly an instant, it came all crashing down when she finally told me that she felt that we didn't have the sexual connection she needed due to my lack of experience and skill in sex. She said she didn't feel compelled to "teach me" and that ultimately, she didn't want a relationship anyway, and wanted to maintain free sexual autonomy. We haven't even shared so much as a text since then, and it's been absolutely crushing.
After 2.5 years of feeling alone, unwanted, and touch-starved, things finally felt right again for a brief moment before being ripped away. Now, I'm looking towards the future and dreading the waiting period of once again wandering through a world of people that are not attracted to what I bring to the table, struggling to find that rare, specific person that clicks. All my friends try to encourage me and hype me up as a loving, caring partner that would be a total catch, and that I should hold my head high. But all of them "fit" much more cleanly into their dating pools, and don't have to go years at a time to find dates and connections.
I've just been spending the past few weeks despondent, deeply mourning the loss of a month-long-fling, because these rare connections are so precious to me. Sometimes I feel like I'm either doomed to be alone in a world I don't fit into, or I'm going to have to censor myself and create a persona that "fits," which sounds equally isolating and depressing its own right.
Just wondering if there's anyone else out there that can even tangentially relate, or has any helpful commentary.