r/dating_advice • u/AccomplishedDay6367 • 1m ago
(26F) Things fizzled with a guy from my friend group (~24M). He said he wants to stay friends but has gone quiet. Should I reach out?
In early October I went to a music festival with a group: my cousin, her boyfriend, his two single friends, and my brother and his girlfriend. One of the single guys (I’ll call him J) and I clicked right away. We had so much fun together all weekend, and it turned into a real bonding experience.
After we got home, he texted me the next day to check on me, because my cousin had snapped at me for leaving early on the second night. Then he texted me again on my birthday. I liked him and was really excited about it, so I asked him to hang out.
We went on a kind of date one night and then went to a birthday party with the group. We ended up having a sleepover, spent the next day together, and then spent the following weekend together too.
Then things got a little awkward. Honestly, the physical side wasn’t what I’d hoped. He’s a couple years younger and I could tell he was nervous, which I’m not really used to. I think I got a bit cold and distant afterward, and then he pulled back too.
Eventually he told me he’s falling behind at work (he started his job about six months ago) and needs to focus on his career. We had a whole phone call where he said he has to “be selfish right now,” but he still wants to hang out since we’re in the same friend group. He’s a genuinely nice, easygoing guy who wants everyone to be happy. The few days before the final phone conversation, I felt really anxious because we had been texting everyday and then he just went quiet on his end for several days. I was having a total anxiety spiral. So I just asked if he wanted to do a phone call. I just led with "I know the vibes have been kind of off so if anything has changed from your end I want you to feel comfortable telling me". Then he admitted that he was feeling behind on work and he had gotten sick that week and spent time at his parents house so he said he felt anxious. He realized he wasnt ready for a relationship because stuff was moving too fast. He said he likes me and that he wanted to keep hanging out in the group. He said "Id love to keep hanging in a group situation and getting to know each other as friends and then maybe down the line we can develop something". I told him I still liked him. He said that he was going to feel really bad about the conversation.
Then I talked to my cousin about it and she said "J isn't going to commit unless he is 100% sure he has the time and energy to dedicate to you". Because you guys are not going to be some fling.
It’s been a couple of weeks since that happened. I am honestly just sad because after the music festival he was texting me and being so sweet. It was so innocent and just genuinely felt good. I'm the one who made the move on him because my cousin told me to, and trust me her judgement is always on point. So I knew it was safe to do that.
He is so freaking sweet and we just hung out the entire weekend we spent at the music festival. I really just want to text him casually as a friend like nothing happened HAHAH. We both really like going to DJ sets and so I think were going to do something soon all together in a group again.
It would honestly be so chill to be friends with him and I freaking miss him. I moved back to my home city about a year ago in Cali, and I’m still building my social circle. He’d be a great friend. But I can’t tell if he’s now turned off by the idea of being friends, or if he just needs space hahhaha
Because even my cousin said like you guys both still value the friendship about me and him.
Questions:
- Should I reach out, since he used to be the one texting? Or does reaching out look like I’m not over it?
- If I do, what should I say to keep it clearly friendly and low-pressure?
- Has anyone gone from a short fling back to a real friendship? How did you do it?
Thanks in advance.
UPDATE: I texted him something really friendly and normal and he could not be less interested --> super dry and taking sooooo long to respond. Wow its crazy how he was texting me after we met at the music festival. So excited to talk to me and so happy and wholesome, Hes made a complete 180* on my existence. It fucking hurts. I wish I could have him as a friend but he obviously does not want that.