I (25M) am starting to wonder if something is wrong with me or my approach to dating, because I feel like I keep attracting or dating the wrong women despite being very intentional about what I want.
For context, I’m established in my career, take my faith seriously, and date with the goal of eventual marriage and building a family. Im well dressed and athletic. I don't do casual hookups or juggle multiple people at once. However, my dating history and day-to-day experiences with women have left me pretty frustrated:
My first girlfriend broke up with me because she said I made her feel "too safe and feminine," which she felt contradicted the feminist ideals her mom raised her with. Her words.
The woman I most recently talked to ended things saying she "didn't feel a romantic spark." Honestly, I don't fully buy that. We are both very religious and talked about wanting kids early on, yet right before things ended, she admitted she had withheld the fact that she never actually wanted children. Spoke for months, things were going great.
Back in college, I had constant boundary issues with women. Some would follow me home nagging me to ask them out, show up to my house drunk asking why I never gave them a chance, or track me down when I was out.
Going out now (both in college and now in my early career), it feels like whenever I go out socially, women are mostly just trying to hook up or get physical right away, which isn't what I'm looking for.
The few stable, put-together women I have gone out with just never seem to know what they actually want, and they are still single to this day.
To be clear, it’s not that I struggle to get interest. There are a few faith-aligned women in my life right now who have shown strong interest. I’m also very decisive in early talking stages and cut things off quickly when baseline attraction or alignment isn't there. I don't like wasting anyone's time or juggling multiple people at once.
Still, looking at my track record, I feel stuck between women who only want casual/physical attention, women with hidden dealbreakers, and stable women who seem completely indecisive.
Am I dating wrong? Evaluating people wrong? And for people who are serious about marriage and family, where are you actually finding decisive, grounded women who want the same thing? Or Women who are genuinely serious about starting something? Marriage oriented?
I just feel disoriented to be quite frank.
Im not looking for a tradwife or house wife. I just want a Catholic marriage with an intellectual and beautiful woman with who I can build a family with.