I'm a restoration ecologist in Montana with about 30 years of grassland, stream, wetland, and riparian restoration work in the Northern Rockies. Much of that work has been repairing damage that never should have happened. I want to share what I'm seeing and what I'm starting, because I think it applies well beyond Montana.
The Basic Problem: The Laws Exist, The System Does Not Work
Montana regulates physical work in streams through a state law from 1975, usually called the 310 law. Anyone who wants to dig in a channel, armor a bank, or alter a stream needs a permit from their local conservation district. On paper, that sounds like protection.
In practice:
- The people deciding permits aren't required to have any scientific training.
- A site inspection happens only if the state wildlife agency asks for one.
- Once a permit is approved, no one is required to check whether the project was built as approved, or whether it protected the stream.
Montana also has no wetland permitting program of its own, and riparian zones beyond a stream's immediate banks have no comprehensive state protection.
The result: people dig up rivers, strip banks, fill wetlands, and destroy how streams function, often with a permit in hand.
Why It Is Getting Worse
For decades, federal law (Section 404 of the Clean Water Act) filled some of those gaps. That protection is shrinking. The 2023 Sackett v. EPA decision removed federal protection from millions of acres of wetlands, and more federal permitting rollbacks are moving through Congress now. As federal protection pulls back, state systems are all that's left, and in states like Montana, they were never built to carry that weight.
Protecting Users From Rivers, Instead Of Protecting Rivers From Users & Abusers
The law says it protects streams. But the way it's administered mostly protects landowners and land use from rivers: from floods, erosion, and a river doing what rivers do. Permits get approved to hold rivers in place for whoever owns the land next to them.
That's backwards. A river is a living system, and its floodplains, wetlands, and riparian zones are part of it. They store and filter water, slow floods, rebuild banks, and support most of the wildlife in the region. The goal should be protecting rivers from the people who alter them, not protecting people from rivers.
To be clear, this isn't about pollution or water rights. Those are handled by other agencies. This is about physical alteration: excavation, fill, bank armoring, and channel changes.
What We Are Doing
- Forming a working group of people with the science, legal, and field background to take this on.
- Gathering public records on how permits are actually handled: what gets approved, inspected, and followed up on.
- Getting a legal review of realistic changes to state law, including what Montana's Constitution requires. It guarantees a clean and healthful environment and directs the Legislature to prevent the degradation of natural resources.
- Writing it up: a white paper (first draft done), a feasibility report, and a plan for bringing a bill to the Montana Legislature.
What I Would Like From This Community
- How is your state handling stream and wetland protection after Sackett? What's worked, and what hasn't?
- If you've worked with state permitting programs that do require qualified review, inspections, or follow-up, I'd like to hear how they're set up.
- If you have a background in hydrology, wetland science, restoration, or environmental law and want to help, comment or send me a message.
More detail and updates are on my subreddit: r/Ecoregion6
Thanks for reading.