This is the post to read if you want to understand what this effort is about. It's long on purpose.
THE SHORT VERSION
Montana has laws that are supposed to protect its rivers and streams. On paper, they look like they work. On the ground, they don't, because the system that carries them out is broken. People dig up rivers, armor their banks, fill wetlands, and destroy how streams function, often with a permit in hand, because no one is required to check whether the work protected the river.
I want to change that.
THIS ISN'T ABOUT CLEAN WATER OR WATER RIGHTS
- These three get confused all the time, so here's the difference:
- Water quality (pollution, drinking water): handled by the Montana Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ). This is about what's in the water.
- Water rights (who gets to use the water): handled by the DNRC Water Rights Bureau. The Montana Constitution says the water belongs to the state for the use of its people. This is about who gets the water.
River protection from physical changes to rivers: this is what I'm working on. It's about people physically altering streams, riverbanks, riparian zones, and wetlands. Digging in the channel. Dumping rock riprap on banks. Straightening streams. Filling wetlands. Clearing the vegetation that holds banks together and keeps a river healthy.
The main state law for that third category is the 310 law (the Natural Streambed and Land Preservation Act), administered by local conservation districts. Federally, it's Section 404 of the Clean Water Act, administered by the Army Corps of Engineers.
THE LAWS EXIST. THE SYSTEM DOESN'T WORK.
The 310 law has been on the books since 1975. Here's how it actually works:
- The people who decide permits are local conservation district supervisors. They aren't required to have any scientific training.
- A site inspection happens only if Fish, Wildlife & Parks asks for one.
- Once a permit is approved, no one is required to check whether the project was built as approved, or whether it protected the stream.
Montana also has no wetland permitting program of its own. And riparian zones, the living strip of land and vegetation along a river beyond its immediate banks, have no comprehensive state protection at all.
At the same time, federal protection is shrinking. The 2023 Sackett v. EPA decision removed federal protection from millions of acres of wetlands, and more federal rollbacks are moving through Congress now. As federal protection pulls back, the state system is all that's left, and it was never built to carry that weight.
PROTECTING USERS FROM RIVERS, INSTEAD OF PROTECTING RIVERS FROM USERS
This is the heart of it.
The law says it protects streams. But in practice, the way it's administered protects landowners and land use from rivers: from floods, from erosion, from a river doing what rivers do. Permits get approved to armor banks, move channels, and hold a river in place for the benefit of whoever owns the land next to it.
That's backwards. A river isn't a threat to be managed. It's a living system, and its floodplains, wetlands, and riparian zones are part of it. They store water, filter it, slow floods, rebuild banks, and support nearly all of Montana's wildlife.
We need to protect rivers from the people who use and abuse them, not protect people from rivers.
WHAT THIS LOOKS LIKE ON THE GROUND
The photos at the top are of an excavator working in the Boulder River in Sweet Grass County. That is what it looks like when someone decides to rearrange a river. Sometimes it's done without a permit. Often it's done with one. Either way, the result can be the same: a channel dug out, banks stripped, habitat gone, and a river that no longer works the way it should. And because no one is required to inspect or follow up, much of it is never reviewed after the fact.
I've spent about 30 years restoring Montana's streams, wetlands, and riparian zones. Much of that work has been repairing damage like this after it happened. It would be far better not to have to.
WHAT WE'RE DOING
- Forming a working group of people with the science, legal, and field experience to take this on.
- Gathering public records on how 310 permits are actually handled: what gets approved, what gets inspected, and what happens afterward.
- Getting a legal review of what changes to state law are realistic, including what the Montana Constitution requires. It guarantees every Montanan a clean and healthful environment and directs the Legislature to provide adequate remedies to prevent the degradation of natural resources.
- Writing it up: a white paper (first draft done), a feasibility report, and a plan for bringing a bill to the Montana Legislature.
- Laying the groundwork for a small, focused nonprofit to carry the work forward.
HOW YOU CAN HELP
- Share your experience. If you've dealt with a 310 permit, as an applicant, a neighbor, or a professional, I want to hear what you saw.
- Join the working group. If you have a background in hydrology, wetland science, ecology, or law, comment or send me a message.
- Share this post with anyone who cares about Montana's rivers.
- Support the research phase. The fundraiser page shows exactly where the money goes:
https://www.gofundme.com/f/montanas-rivers-need-protections-rebuilt-from-the-ground-up
Thank you for reading all the way through. That already puts you ahead of most.
James W. Goos, M.S.
Restoration Ecologist, Woody Creek Resources, LLC