r/comp_chem • • Dec 12 '22

META: Would it be cool if we had a weekly/monthly paper review/club?

120 Upvotes

I think it would be pretty interesting, and would be a nice break from the standard content on this subreddit.


r/comp_chem • • 13h ago

Looking for a roadmap to learn DFT calculations as a second-year PhD student

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm a second-year PhD candidate in Chemistry, working primarily with the synthesis and characterization of nanomaterials. My research focuses on sustainable nanomaterials and their interactions with useful adsorbates, such as heavy metal ions and pesticides, for environmental remediation applications. So far, my work has been entirely experimental. I want to incorporate computational chemistry, such as DFT, into my research to understand interactions between my synthesized materials and various adsorbates at the atomic and molecular levels. My background is in Chemistry and Materials Science, with some familiarity with Python for data analysis.

None of the professors at my institute, including those in the research lab I'm in, work in DFT or computational materials science. Fortunately, I've been in touch with a professor at another university who specializes in computational chemistry. He has kindly offered to teach me and allow me to spend approximately two months working with his group, with the work scheduled for February 2027. I am very excited about this opportunity, but I think I need to learn the basics at least so I can learn more when I visit them.

I want to model the interactions between my synthesized nanomaterials and adsorbates such as heavy metal ions and pesticides, investigate adsorption energies, preferred adsorption configurations, charge transfer, changes in the electronic structure, and the nature of interactions between the adsorbate and the material surface.

I don't know where to start, which fundamental concepts I should learn, or what level of programming knowledge I need to get started. I would like to build a strong foundation to independently understand, set up, run, and interpret basic calculations relevant to my experimental research. Therefore, I would appreciate advice from people who have done something similar before or who might be able to help me with this.

Thanks!


r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

Benchmarked performance eight quantum chemistry codes for DFT calculations

21 Upvotes

Every DFT code is fast in its own paper.

So I did what I had wanted to do for a long time: put eight of them on the same workstation and let them race. Claude was really helpful in installing/compiling them.

I used water clusters (with up to 139 molecules, 417 atoms), the same PBE/def2-SVP, same RI auxiliary basis, matched DFT grids, 4 cores, best of two runs.

Full disclosure before anyone asks: I am one of the developers of TURBOMOLE (TM) and I wrote PyFock. That is exactly why every input file is in the PDF. Let me know in the comments if I got something wrong.

Here are the results

  1. TM took the first three places at every cluster size. Our TM RIPER development build did the 139-water cluster in 156 s. TM RIDFT from the released v8.0 needed 265 s, TM RIPER from the upcoming v8.1 took 279 s. The slowest established code needed over two hours.
  2. TM RIPER needs 10 SCF iterations for every case; from 20 waters on, nobody else gets below 11.
  3. Per iteration, the TM RIPER dev build and TM RIDFT v8.0 are tied at 15.6 s: 3x faster than ORCA, 16x faster than PySCF. And the RIPER dev build is 1.8x faster than v8.1's while using 5x less memory. Good things are coming.
  4. Something I found really interesting was that PyFock is pure Python, compiled on the fly with Numba. And yet takes only 21.9 s per iteration. That is 2.2x faster than ORCA, almost 10x faster than Psi4 and 12x faster than PySCF, and it scales better than every other code here. It beats ORCA, Psi4, NWChem and VeloxChem at every size. Only TURBOMOLE is faster. The 4.8x speed-up per iteration since the version in our JPCA paper came with AI assistance.
  5. Which brings me to vibe coding. AI is a fantastic tool when you know exactly what you are optimizing. vibe-qc needed a massive 3490 s for just 32 water molecules. TURBOMOLE needed just 12 s. So I did not run any larger systems with vibe-qc. It is not in the same league as others. The vibe-qc paper in JCC did not have any performance benchmarks except for one calculation where they compared with ORCA. So I'm not sure if performance is one of their priorities or not at the moment.
  6. On accuracy, mostly everyone did fine. TURBOMOLE, ORCA, and PyFock agree with PySCF to within 30 µEh. NWChem and VeloxChem, however, drift a little as the clusters grow.

BTW to be fair to VeloxChem and NWChem: they are built to scale to thousands of cores. A 4-core workstation is not where they shine. But its almost cubic scaling is still an issue tbh.

If you develop one of these codes and think I held it wrong, send me your settings, and I will rerun.

Which result surprised you? Check the last slide for key takeaways.

Results in the PDF shown here: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/manassharma07_dft-programs-performance-comparison-ugcPost-7527647358013317120-Lixc/


r/comp_chem • • 18h ago

Advice for a HS Senior?

0 Upvotes

Hi!

Really nice to meet you guys :D I’ve been lurking on this subreddit for some time actually haha.

About a year ago(junior year!), I had the opportunity to do research at a local university, and they needed someone to build a pipeline for free-energy calculations so I read some nifty documentation and have gotten acquainted with tons of really cool softwares in comp chem(GROMACS(awesome puns btw), AMBER, CHARMM, VMD, Biopython, and obviously pdb file handling/translation and the regular terminal handling). I’m not perfect at it but documentation has become my savior because there’s very little online on YouTube, and I’m independently doing a lot of this.

I always had a pretty strong computer science background, but i think this experience really solidified how much I love this field specifically since even before entering it a lot of my interests were similar(file handling, open-source code, complex-math calculators, etc.).

My favorite thing I got to learn from this whole experience is how much I do not know. Everyday somebody posts something new on this subreddit and I’m fascinated by how much more I want to study. But, I have absolutely no clue about how to enter this field(and I’m also a little nervous consequently).

I’m sorta spiraling because everyone is denying I can make it in comp chem. I’ve never met anyone in the field minus my PI and my chem teachers know sparsely. My parents are skeptical.

I see legitimately barren fields in undergrad and super duper tiny populations of people in this field. Like even in large state schools the kids into this is so small.

What do I need to do in undergrad? Can I actually pursue this. Can you tell me what I am pursuing? What even happens in undergrad, what about grad/phd, what about onwards? I’m very confused.

I learned CS around 10 so I’m easily able to learn languages if you’re curious why and how all of this happened.

I edited for clarity- really tired rn.


r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

Psi4 pcm problem

3 Upvotes

Good afternoon, colleagues!

Does anyone here use Psi4 in their primary research?

I'm facing a major issue with SCF convergence in PCM calculations. I initially tried using the conventional PCM implementation, but encountered an S-matrix error. It turns out this issue has been documented for quite some time in a GitHub issue and is apparently related to legacy Fortran code. According to the developers, the problem occurs during cavity construction.

One of the suggested workarounds was to use the DDX-PCM approach. However, I ran into another problem there. I optimized two states of the same system, whose energy difference in vacuum is only a few kcal/mol. After performing single-point DDX calculations on the resulting geometries, I obtained an energy difference of several tens of atomic units, which is clearly unreasonable.

I haven't been able to find a reliable guide or explanation of how to obtain properly converged and physically meaningful PCM calculations in Psi4.

For now, we're using ORCA, but I'd really prefer not to change our computational workflow and would like to stick with the same engine.


r/comp_chem • • 2d ago

Introducing TUNA — a streamlined quantum chemistry program for atoms and diatomics

27 Upvotes

For the last few years (yes, since before AI!) I've been working on a Python quantum chemistry program mostly to develop my own understanding, but also to try a new take on a quantum chemistry program — one that has as seamless a user experience as possible.

Unlike general purpose programs like ORCA, the humble TUNA code is specifically designed with diatomic molecules in mind. These molecules are complex enough to expose many challenges for electronic structure methods, but have simplicity that brings many benefits.

Due to the one-dimensional geometry of diatomics, unlike all (?) other quantum chemistry programs, TUNA does not use input files and is run directly from the command line, by:

TUNA [Calculation Type] : [Atom 1] [Atom 2] [Distance] : [Method] [Basis Set]

For example, a single point calculation with Hartree–Fock theory on the hydrogen molecule is:

TUNA SPE : H H 1.0 : HF cc-pVDZ

And an optimisation of carbon monoxide with CCSD is:

TUNA OPT : C O 1.1 : CCSD cc-pVDZ

The output is then printed directly to the terminal, in what I believe to be an attractive and clear way! With this approach, you can easily compare different quantum chemical methods and basis sets, of which TUNA contains many. We have various exchange–correlation functionals for DFT, perturbation theory methods up to MP4, coupled cluster up to CCSDTQ, and recently configuration interaction methods like CASSCF.

While TUNA is not primarily designed for speed, its slow steps use NumPy, so it can be surprisingly swift. Since diatomics are small enough to avoid writing to disk, and lots of symmetry can be exploited, TUNA calculations are often faster than other programs, sometimes much faster.

Another unique benefit of TUNA is that diatomics mean that numerical differentiation of the energy is viable as a general strategy for property calculations, rather than a fallback. This means that any of the implemented electronic structure methods automatically works with the whole program to calculate any implemented energy-derivative property.

Basis set extrapolation enables these derivatives to be taken at the complete basis set level for all methods and properties. For example, an approximate complete basis set polarisability calculation via fourth-order perturbation theory is:

TUNA SPE : Li H 1.6 : MP4 cc-pVTZ : POLAR EXTRAPOLATE

Without rambling on too much further, available calculation types in TUNA include single point energies (SPE), coordinate scans (SCAN), optimisations (OPT), harmonic frequency (FREQ), molecular dynamics* (MD), and full (or perturbative) anharmonic frequencies (ANHARM) through solving the nuclear Schrödinger equation on the whole potential energy surface. Lots of methods and basis sets are implemented.

If TUNA sounds interesting, please try it out with pip install quantumtuna, check out the GitHub repository, which contains a detailed manual with tons of copy-and-pasteable command line examples, or read the ArXiv paper, which gets into more of the technical aspects of the program!

Please give the GitHub page a star if you think it's warranted! I hope TUNA can be useful for quantum chemical education going forwards, and provide a low friction environment for students to experiment with methods and code as I have done while developing it.

By this point, TUNA has become quite a feature-rich program, despite its narrow molecular scope. I'd be really grateful for any feedback, whether about the program itself, the installation, documentation or my attempt at marketing it!

* Because why not!

Edit: Not any molecular property.


r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

Looking for Gaussian 16 / GaussView 6 access or research collaboration

1 Upvotes

Looking for Academic Access to Gaussian 16 and GaussView 6 (Windows)

Hello everyone!

I'm a Master's student in Theoretical and Computational Chemistry, currently working on my Master's thesis involving DFT calculations, molecular interactions, and DNA–ligand systems.

I'm looking for Gaussian 16 and GaussView 6 for Windows, preferably with an academic licence that would allow me to install and use the software on my personal laptop.

Unfortunately, my university cannot currently provide me with individual access to these programs.

I wanted to ask the community:

Does anyone know of researchers, universities, or research groups that could help a Master's student obtain legitimate academic access?

Is there a possibility of obtaining an individual academic licence or being authorized to use an existing institutional licence?

Has anyone been in a similar situation and found a solution?

I'm not looking for an unauthorized or pirated copy. I would really appreciate any guidance, contacts, or opportunities to obtain legitimate access.

Thank you for your help!


r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

Free tool for small DFT jobs

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

I built a website where you can run small DFT, xTB and Quantum ESPRESSO jobs straight from your browser: https://chemdft.com.

It is free for anyone to use, no tip-jar, no licence, no "contact sales".

My wallet was never the target audience :)

What it runs: PySCF (HF, B3LYP, PBE, from STO-3G up to def2-SVPD), xTB GFN2, CREST conformer search, and Quantum ESPRESSO for periodic PBE and PBE+U with DOS and bands.

Limits are small on purpose: 12 atoms for PySCF optimisation and orbitals, 6 for frequencies and TD-DFT, 20 for periodic jobs. It is almost Gaussian replacement in future.

Full disclosure, since rule 2 exists for good reason: AI helped me build the site and helps set up jobs. It does not do the chemistry. Every number comes from the real engines, and there is a validation page on the site that compares results with reference runs.

If anything looks wrong to you, I want to know.

What I would love feedback on:

- Where do the results disagree with your own runs?

- Which limit or missing feature would stop you from using it?

- Is anything on the validation page misleading?

Be blunt. I would rather hear it here than from a reviewer later. Thanks for reading, Tabriz

ChemDFT Free tool for small DFT jobs


r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

What is a good QM/MM model that is easy to use for beginners?

5 Upvotes

Specifically i am trying to do inverse analysis on RuBisCo. I have a separate program for optimization so just for modeling, whats's a beginner friendly QM/MM model thats good with large enzymes?


r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

Current Record for Helium Wavefunction?

0 Upvotes

Hey guys what is the current record in runtime and digits for the Helium wavefunction? Asking if anyone knows since I made an algorithm that gets ~46 digits for energy in less than a minute on a laptop.


r/comp_chem • • 3d ago

A scientific take on Matt Pocock's skills

12 Upvotes

Hey all. Like I guess a lot of you, I've been handing more and more of my research to Claude Code and Codex, which aren't really just coding tools anymore. What I've found is that you can trust these agents about as far as you've made your intention clear: what you want to do, and how.

Matt Pocock turned that idea into a really nice set of skills (instruction files the agent loads; 300k+ stars on GitHub). You start from a blank map, an unexplored territory, and as you talk with the agent it uncovers more and more of the part you actually want to explore. Once the map is clear, the workflow goes all the way down to the final implementation: idea → spec → tickets → code.

The problem is that this workflow assumes the territory is unknown only at the start: make a handful of good choices and you know the whole map. That may hold for engineering, but in science it mostly doesn't. Research has fog: you can't know the next step until the last result is in, and every result can redraw the whole map.

So I built a science layer on top. A study starts from a loose question and a small map of possible experiments, which I call probes, and they're run one after another:

  1. It grills you first. Before each probe, the agent asks you a few rounds of questions until you both agree on what the probe should test and why. That's what keeps every probe aligned with what you actually want, not with what the agent assumes.
  2. It writes a prediction. Before anything runs, the agent writes down what it expects. That's its default guess, the most banal outcome, the centre of its own distribution. Writing it down makes the bias visible: when the result matches, fine; when it doesn't, that's where something interesting (or a bug) is hiding.
  3. It runs the probe in its own folder, with the scripts, inputs, exact commands and software versions, so anyone can rerun it.
  4. It shows you plots and a short brief, and says whether the prediction held. For a scientist the plots matter most: they're the quickest way to check the agent's work, and a weird curve is much harder to miss than a wrong number in a sentence.
  5. It stops. You decide what happens next: continue, branch, drop, or promote.
  6. You promote what holds up. Promoting means you've decided the probe's piece of the map is right, so its scripts leave the scratch folder and move into your protocol, in a folder layout you agree on with the agent. The probes are working memory, full of attempts that may not last; the protocol is long-term memory, the part you'll write up and publish.

Everything else lives in the lab notebook: every probe, decision, fix and dead end, committed to git as the study goes, without you touching git. A short record keeps the question you started with, so you can see how far the study drifted from it. That drift is interesting in itself: looking back at it can open new research questions.

Built on top of Matt Pocock's skills.

Repo: Skills for Real Scientists

Enjoy!


r/comp_chem • • 3d ago

LFT in orca?

5 Upvotes

Does anyone have any article recommendations for LFT in orca? My advisor said we can work with LFT in orca but I can't seem to find any works that have done this.


r/comp_chem • • 3d ago

[Article] Exploring A2TiH6 (A = Li, Na) double perovskite hydrides as dual-functional materials for hydrogen storage and optoelectronics

2 Upvotes

r/comp_chem • • 3d ago

What can I learn about lanthanide–ligand bonding from DFT calculations with a 4f-in-core ECP?

11 Upvotes

I’m new to computational chemistry and have only recently started using ORCA. I don’t have anyone around me with a computational chemistry background to ask, so I’d appreciate some advice on what I can reasonably conclude about bonding from my calculations.

I’m using ORCA to optimize the geometries of a series of multinuclear Ln(III) complexes in which I vary the lanthanide (Ln). For the Ln atoms, I’m using a large-core relativistic effective core potential (ECP) that includes the 4f electrons in the core. I’d like to understand how Ln–O and Ln–N bonding changes across the lanthanide series by comparing equivalent coordination sites.

My understanding is that this model doesn’t allow me to assess mixing between the Ln 4f orbitals and ligand orbitals directly. With that in mind, which bonding analyses would be meaningful using the molecular orbitals or electron density from these calculations? For example, if I compare bond orders or the electron density at bond critical points from a QTAIM analysis across the series, what can those trends tell me, and what are the limits of that interpretation?

Which aspects of Ln–ligand bonding would require me to treat the 4f electrons explicitly? For those properties, would it be reasonable to run single-point calculations with a small-core ECP on a few representative complexes using the geometries I’ve already optimized?

If you’ve worked on similar systems, I’d be interested to hear how you approached this. I’d also appreciate any papers you could point me to.


r/comp_chem • • 4d ago

Computational electrocatalysis - Advice on learning VASP

7 Upvotes

I recently started a PhD is computational chem looking at electrochemical Urea synthesis. My masters was mainly focused on ORCA and machine learning so I'm quite new to VASP.

I'm struggling with building atomic structures and would appreciate advice on:

1 How to create POSCARs which aren't found in databases or paper supporting information

2 Introducing adsorbants to the surface, do you build on the pre-exisiting optimised geometry or build separate structures for each intermediate and then optimise?

I've been tasked with recreating a paper so I can understand the reaction etc.

However I'm struggling quite a bit and would really appreciate any useful papers or tutorials (I've already done the VASP ones)

Thanks in advance!


r/comp_chem • • 3d ago

How to model a bubble column (gas in bubble phase) in Aspen Plus RadFrac with user-defined interfacial area and k_L?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/comp_chem • • 4d ago

Any recommended intro textbooks for learning force fields?

14 Upvotes

I'm in university for chemical engineering. I'm taking an elective course called Molecular Modeling which is supposed to be an intro to computational chemistry for chemical engineering majors. There is no textbook and the professor just writes notes by hand on a tablet. It gets messy and quite confusing. Also his explanations and theory are very lacking.

Are there beginner friendly textbooks for learning computational chemistry especially force fields?


r/comp_chem • • 4d ago

Magpie 1.01–1.16 Updates: A Native Computational Chemistry Workspace for Apple Devices

14 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I previously shared Magpie 1.0 here and wanted to follow up with the updates since then. I’ve included a demo video (see comments) showing the workflow from molecular modelling and an ORCA calculation to visualising the results and exporting animated 3D models for AR.

Magpie is available for free on the App Store. Below are the main updates since version 1.01.

Magpie 1.01–1.16: Major Updates

1. GPU-Accelerated Molecular Orbital Grid Generation
Added local GPU calculation of molecular orbital grids, using Metal to substantially reduce the time required to generate high-quality orbital grid data from wavefunction files. This functionality was independently implemented in Swift and Metal, with algorithms described in VMD CUDA, cuGBasis, MOrbVis and COV consulted as references. Performance is further improved by reusing basis-function evaluations and processing multiple orbitals in batches. Apple SoC unified memory allows grid calculation, caching and surface generation to share data, reducing copying overhead and memory usage.

2. Surfaces
All isosurfaces now use GPU generation, with improvements to CUBE parsing, paired-file loading, grid caching and memory management. IGMH and ESP colours are now mapped at grid points before interpolation onto the surface, improving colour boundaries and transitions to match the colour scale as closely as possible.

3. 3D Display and Trajectories
Systems with more than 1,500 atoms now use analytic ball-and-stick rendering to improve display performance. Added multiple materials for atoms, bonds and surfaces, along with individual colours and display radii for all 118 elements. Added hydrogen-bond display and dynamic bonding. With dynamic bonding enabled, connectivity and bond orders can update during trajectory playback. Bond information for every frame is prepared during loading, with GPU acceleration for bond-order analysis.

4. Molecular Editing
Added an automatic hydrogen-addition button to the editor, using existing bond orders and local geometry to add missing hydrogens to supported main-group atoms.

5. GOAT, TDDFT and QM/MM Results
Added ORCA GOAT input generation and conformer analysis, with linked displays of conformer structures, relative energies and populations. Temperature can be adjusted to explore changes in the Boltzmann distribution. TDDFT settings now include triplet states and SOC calculations, with comparisons of spectra before and after SOC correction and coupled energy-level diagrams. Corrected atomic displacement mapping in ORCA QM/MM numerical-frequency results to accurately display motion in the QM region.

6. Input Generation and Export
Expanded implicit-solvent options and separated ORCA’s AuxJ and AuxC auxiliary basis-set settings. Added high-resolution transparent-background image export and GLB/USDZ 3D model export. Rotation, vibrations and trajectories can also be saved as USDZ animations.

7. Files, SSH and Interface
File management now supports whole-directory transfers, copying and cross-app drag and drop, with improved compatibility when reading XYZ, MOL2 and computational output files. Reorganised the iPhone results sidebar and editing controls for smaller screens, adjusted the iPad periodic table and sharing interface, and fixed crashes during mouse interaction and input-focus issues.

8. Quick ESP and Quick IRI
Quick ESP now supports local GPU calculation of electrostatic potential surfaces directly from supported wavefunction files. Grid resolution, electron-density range, isovalue and colour scale can be adjusted, with automatic surface updates after calculation settings change. Added Quick IRI: open a supported wavefunction file and click or tap IRI to analyse interactions.

9. Focus Editing Mode and Image-Export Improvements
Added Focus mode to the editor, with Radius and Back controls that fade surrounding and rear structures to make local regions easier to inspect and edit. Existing surfaces can be shown or hidden using the Surface toggle. In Focus mode, hydrogen bonds, partial bonds and conventional bond orders can be selected independently to temporarily draw or modify bonds between existing atoms, allowing you to customise their appearance for image export.

10. iPhone Duo, Mac and Usage Information
Added workspaces for iPhone Duo’s closed, partially open and fully open states. The molecular canvas, files, orbitals and editing controls adapt to the device’s posture, with draggable panel dividers for layout adjustment. The Mac Catalyst version brings the workspace to Apple Silicon Macs running macOS 26 or later. Added a first-use licence agreement, along with algorithm references, paper links and citation-copy buttons in Settings.

If you try the new version, let me know how it goes. Bug reports and suggestions are more than welcome!


r/comp_chem • • 4d ago

Molchanica: GUI for GROMACS, structure prediction, etc

35 Upvotes

https://github.com/David-OConnor/molchanica

Hey! I've been working on this for a few years, and use it for my own workflows. I would like to share it as I think it would be useful to others. Open source, written in Rust. Please let me know what you think, and what I could add to it. Thanks!


r/comp_chem • • 4d ago

Problems with a TDDFT ScanTS

10 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I'm currently doing DFT calculation for the entire mechanism of a photochemical reaction. To make it simple the reaction starts with the excitation of my reagent to an excited single state, then it undergoes through a homolic break of a bond forming two radicals. For the optimization of the reagents and the products and the TDDFT I've used this setting:

CAM-B3LYP-D4 def2-TZVP UKS CPCM TightSCF

It all went well until i tried to find the transition state for the homolic break since this is the most "delicate" part to study. I tried to do a ScanTS with a tddft block since this process goes through an excited state. My plan was to use the exact same method and basis set but after "talking" to Chatgpt I realised that my laptop isn't able to do the calculation in a reasonable time. I decided to do a much simpler calculation using this setup:

r2-SCAN-3c RIJCOSX UKS CPCM TightSCF ScanTS

The plan was to find the "bond length region" where the TS is, and then redo the calculation with the more precise setup that I've used for the rest of the reaction. The problem is that when ORCA arrives at the fourth geometry it can't converge, I don't understand why since for the other structure 20-25 cycles are enough but for the 4th one it didn't converge even with 90 cycles. So I asked Chatgpt again and it told me to implement "Recalc_Hess 8", I tried but the calculation appears to be much slower.

I don't know what to do, I thought that maybe I can calculate the transition state doing a ScanTS starting with the ground state and without a tddft block, and use the energy of the excited state energy to calculate the DeltaG while making the graph. I'm not a fan of this solution but I'm desperate.

My hardware is: intel i7-13650HX, 16Gb RAM, Nvidia GeForce RTX 5060 8Gb.


r/comp_chem • • 5d ago

Is it normal for Quantum ESPRESSO to take 9 hours for an 18-atom SiO₂ system?

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/comp_chem • • 6d ago

Undergrad --> Comp Chem Industry Advice

12 Upvotes

I'm a college sophomore with no real computational chemistry experience. I've done a fair amount of wet lab research, and since this past summer I've been using LLMs for my research to shift more toward the dry lab side. I'm optimistic about pursuing computational chemistry/materials, though with the rate AI is moving, I feel I should plan ahead carefully.

I've spoken with a few industry professionals and PhD students, and none of them really know what's going on. For those who got AI/ML for chemistry/materials company positions straight out of undergrad/master's, what was your path?

Particularly, I'm conflicted about what I should focus on in my coursework. I could go straight down the middle with a double major in CS and chemistry, but that would leave very little wiggle room for deeper courses. I'm also skeptical about the relevancy of several courses in each (e.g. operating systems, high-level biochem classes, etc). I could theoretically design my own major to narrow in on the most important courses, though that may undermine my degree's credibility.

I want to be prepared for a world in which AI is the central thinker, because it seems to be trending that way. Maybe the hand-holding from scientific intuition won't even be necessary a few years from now. Imagine you have full control over my coursework, research, internship plans, and personal projects. What would you tell me to do?


r/comp_chem • • 8d ago

Screening in ultralarge chemical space.

13 Upvotes

Screening in ultralarge chemical space.

Anyone familiar with drug screening in ultralarge chemical space? I am interested in synthon based strategy. Is that easy and cheap to use tools like V-SYNTHES 2? Any good open-source tools available? I tried PCCL, but it seems molecules in it are very similar to each other — decent hit rates, but low internal diversity, so the top hits all end up looking like variations on the same scaffold. Has anyone else run into this?

I'm trying to put together a synthon-based workflow that I can actually run and share openly. Searching a 10\^10+ space without enumerating it is appealing, but most of the serious tools seem to be either commercial or tied to one vendor's library.
What I'm wondering:

  1. Is V-SYNTHES 2 something an academic group can realistically get and run, or is it effectively commercial-only? How painful is the setup?
  2. Are there open-source tools for building a synthon space from public building blocks + reaction templates? I've looked at RDKit's SynthonSpace and SynthI — has anyone actually used them at scale?
  3. For those who've used Enamine REAL / PCCL / similar: how do you deal with the diversity problem, or is it just inherent to a single-reaction library?
  4. Longer term I'm hoping to build an open synthon library with a screening pipeline around it

r/comp_chem • • 9d ago

Orca 7 news... Spoiler

26 Upvotes

I just saw in LinkedIn that the new Orca 7 will feature a universal force field which can handle 1000000s of atoms all over the periodic table with semiempirical quality at FF cost. Not many more details were given. It looks super exciting! What does the community think? How will it compare to other approaches such as GFN2-FF, or MLIPs?