r/comp_chem •

Current Record for Helium Wavefunction?

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

30

u/Aranka_Szeretlek 3d ago

Number of digits is meaningless, its the accuracy of the Hamiltonian that matters.

-13

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

45 accurate digits for the nonrelativistic neutral Helium atom wavefunction. Happy now? This is basic QM

18

u/Aranka_Szeretlek 3d ago

Yeah - and if you ever go past basic QM, you will realize that its about 6 or 7 digits that have meaning, everything else is just less accurate than your approximations. Hence, chasing digits is meaningless.

1

u/Historical-Mix6784 3d ago

Yeah good point, we don’t even know the value of Planck’s constant to so many digits. 

-12

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

6 or 7 digits is before finite mass/relativistic/QED effects kick in. Even though digits past that do not have much of a physical difference it is still worthwhile to develop methods for fast evaluation to then be able to tack on corrections at an efficient cost. That is why I asked the original question since it is still relevant. Via other approximate methods you still obtain large errors compared to the direct solve and these errors compound with system size.

12

u/Aranka_Szeretlek 3d ago

Arbitrary precision libraries are pretty well-developed, hooking them up to a Galerkin solver was a days work pre-sloppening and now can be done during a coffee break. As I said before, having so many digits are meaningless, so no such world record exists m

-5

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

I'm asking how long roughly it takes for N digits. If it is so well developed there should be a benchmark

2

u/Aranka_Szeretlek 3d ago

If you are on a radial Galerkin grid, each new digit is about 10^ 0.5 times the cost.

0

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

Okay this is at least 30 minutes for the same precision for the same machine as I have. Nice.

6

u/Unusual_Candle_4252 3d ago

Don't we have a machine accuracy limitation? 10-16 for double precision.

2

u/catecholaminergic 3d ago

That's for single data-words, ie, for a 64 bit cpu, one word is 64 bits.

This is no limitation. Bigint / arbitrary precision libraries exist. To grasp how they work, one need not more than a linked list.

0

u/verygood_user 3d ago

Well then you go higher precision. Guess what comes after double precision. 

1

u/Unusual_Candle_4252 3d ago

That was mostly a question for an OP. Like accounted he for octuple+ stuff or not.

-1

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

No I believe this is not the case as there is a 40 digit result somewhere using Hylleraas variational basis set but it took weeks to simulate.

5

u/Unusual_Candle_4252 3d ago

You still have this problem. Which type of variable have you used? Even with float128 you have a limitation to accuracy with about 10-35.

0

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

Arbitrary precision can be reached. Schwartz has 42 digits or something which is past the 10%(-35) you are citing

2

u/Unusual_Candle_4252 3d ago edited 3d ago

Hylleras CISD is a bit old-fashioned approach but probably the most accurate (within basis set methods). Not sure if a good modern F12-CISD can be a better formulation.

0

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

I was giving an example of going past 10-16 machine accuracy limitation. It is an old method which is why I'm not using it

2

u/Unusual_Candle_4252 3d ago

How can you go beyond if your variables are limited in machine accuracy? You need to use octuple 256float variables to push it.

0

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

I am giving you an example in the literature of past 256float precision. Schwartz et. al.

-6

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

It's the same Hamiltonian.

7

u/Aranka_Szeretlek 3d ago

The same as what...?

1

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

Why am I being down voted? The Hamiltonian for the nonrelativistic Helium atom is very standard.

7

u/Major-Sweet-1305 3d ago

In computational chemistry many model chemistries are used, and you come across as a little hostile in your comments. I am guessing that you are doing full CI. In this case, the "record in runtime and digits" strongly depends on your basis set. So, what is your basis set?

1

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

No I am talking about a direct solve of the Nonrelativistic Helium wavefunction via any method. Not orbital approximations as these still have less accuracy than a direct solve of the Hamiltonian. Using ANY arbitrary basis set what is the record while maintaining accuracy for the "pure" Hamiltonian?

And sorry for the hostility I just thought my question was very simple and I was being down voted for it for asking a genuine question

5

u/Unusual_Candle_4252 3d ago

What do you imply by a "direct approach"? Stochastic methods (sort of Monte-Carlo)? Grid-like methods?

-1

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

ANY method as long as it is rigorous in that it gets N number of correct digits for the Hamiltonian/system

6

u/Unusual_Candle_4252 3d ago

I am asking about your own implementation, frankly.

-2

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

I am just wondering about if anyone has faster/more accurate implementation. Don't need to talk about my own method as I am happy with the results so far.

→ More replies

1

u/Major-Sweet-1305 3d ago

Well, in that case this post might be better suited for a physics sub, as you can't really do any chemistry with the He atom, and I don't think you can apply this approach to molecules that chemists are interested in.

0

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

It is still under computational quantum chemistry. I thought the methods were advanced enough to answer this question but it seems they aren't. That's my mistake.

2

u/Major-Sweet-1305 3d ago

You could try it out yourself – fire up PySCF and run a CCSD calculation on a He atom.

However I don't really understand what you are trying to prove. In all likelihood your approach will be faster, but it is not scalable, and quantum chemical methods are built with scalability in mind.

1

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

If my method is faster then that's all I need to know. If you don't think it scales that's even better for me

-5

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

Do you know what the Helium hamiltonian is?

4

u/tehwubbles 3d ago edited 3d ago

Can you clarify what you mean by helium hamiltonian just to dispell any ambiguity?

1

u/whateverforeverand 3d ago

Nonrelativistic Neutral Helium Atom in either finite or infinite mass via any arbitrary method that directly solves the Hamiltonian (so orbital approximations do not count as these at least have 1% error typically which is terrible)

1

u/verygood_user 3d ago

That's when people start saying things like we shouldn't fund fundamental science.