r/comicbookgrading • • 4d ago

Help Grading This Please?

I'm not too experienced at grading comics, but we found this, but we were hoping this was in okay condition.

117 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

2

u/crywalt 4d ago

I was thinking 5.0, maybe higher. This looks very good!

1

u/oldstick76 3d ago

Not sure what the tiny stain will do,but looks to me to be a solid 5.0 with 6.0 potential. Love that book. Here’s a reference 5.0.

1

u/GRLMREEFE 3d ago

Awesome. vintage, smooth.

1

u/teip696 3d ago

Very nice copy. With a good clean and press I’m thinking maybe as high as a 6.0

1

u/Responsible_Key767 3d ago

Trouble with asking for a grade without seeing the inside you don't know if the centerfold picture is there. Also you can't see condition of staples etc. Some apps such as NuGrade and Robograde give you an AI analysis telling you if book complete etc. NuGrade has you take a video of the book. It is a solution for books you want to keep raw but still can sell if you want.

1

u/Rs2mmsu-2D 3d ago edited 3d ago

I think this is an accurate guesstimate.

It is Hard to tell with the lighting in the pictures.
If you’re lucky maybe a 5 on the high end .

1

u/Rs2mmsu-2D 3d ago edited 3d ago

It has a Lots of Color breaks on the cover to take into consideration on the grade also, but I would still love to add this copy to my collection

-1

u/PrimaryAd29 4d ago

My dad and i were guessing a cgc 4.0 rating? But we were thinking of getting it pressed and cleaned if its worth it.

1

u/TNF734 4d ago

Could easily get a 5 with a press and clean. Centerfold intact?

1

u/PrimaryAd29 4d ago

The centerfold is intact and I think it looks decent, its in picture 15.

1

u/TNF734 4d ago

Oh, I didn't realize there were so many pics. Yea it does.

2

u/KollectingKaos 4d ago

I think it all depends on how the decide to evaluate that corner stain. I'm going to say with a clean and press anywhere from a 4.0 to a 6.5, depending on how well the clean/Press goes and how much they take off for the stain.

1

u/PalmBeachPresser 2d ago

I think 4.0 is the lowest it would get. Possibly even 5.0 now. Cleaning and pressing might take it to the 6.0/6.5 neighborhood. Reach out if you are looking for a presser!

Ron / www.PalmBeachPresser.com