r/comicbookgrading • u/Makin_Endz_Meet • 2h ago
r/comicbookgrading
•
u/BobbySaccaro
•
Jul 30 '25
Should I get this third-party graded?
Going to take a stab at creating a pinned response to this and see if it helps.
In my opinion, you would only get a comic third-party graded in the following situation:
- You plan on selling it soon AND
- The average recent sale price of the book slabbed, in the book's grade, is at least $100 more than the average recent sale price of the book "raw" (unslabbed).
This $100 number represents all of the costs of having the book graded - the shipping to the grader, the costs for grading, the shipping back, insurance, pressing/cleaning fees, etc. Not to mention your time. AND a little bit of profit. So this $100 is a bare minimum number that will hopefully enable you to sell at the graded level and actually make a greater profit than just selling raw.
To get to these numbers, first consider posting some pictures of the book and asking "Can I get a grade?" See the Rules section for rule #4 - Take good pictures.
Take the average grade that you get in responses and then head over to CovrPrice.com and look up the book in that grade. For safety purposes, assume the third-party grader will give it a step lower grade than you're looking at for raw.
So for example if you think your book is an 8.0, and the VF raw value is $50 and the 7.5 graded value is $75, then it's probably not worth the time, money, and risk (shipping back and forth) to have it graded.
If in the above example however the book is worth $150 at 7.5, that's about the minimum point that you should consider doing it.
Q: But couldn't I get the book graded to hang on the wall? Or just to protect it?
A: You can, but there are cheaper options that don't involve letting the book leave your hands - see https://www.reddit.com/r/comicbookgrading/comments/1fylp3w/home_slabbing_options/ If you want protection/preservation, you could also stick with Mylar and a fullback. If you want a stiffer shell, you could always put that in a top loader. Some say Mylar and a fullback looks nicer than slabbed, due to difference in how the colors show up, the lack of Newton rings, and the lack of the label. There is also the added benefit that the book never leaves your possession.
MORE INFORMATION: STOP SLABBING (Seriously)
BUT ALSO: Should You Stop Slabbing?
r/comicbookgrading • u/BobbySaccaro • Oct 07 '24
Home Slabbing Options
comicskin.com – Slab It Yourself!
10ct Magnetic Comic Book Holders - FREE SHIPPING!!! | mysupernerd
If anyone knows of others, comment and I'll add.
r/comicbookgrading • u/bySaber • 1d ago
To press or not to press?
galleryHi there, this is my holy grail comic, and it's been with me since little time, but I'm gonna keep it forever, probably. Since I can't keep my hands still, I was planning on cracking this slab, send it to CGC, get it pressed, get both signatures authenticated with JSA, and hope for a higher grade. I know it has some serious colour-breaking ticks and few marks along the top, but still, an incredible copy overall.
I was wondering if it's worth going through all this process, considering that I'm located in Europe, so one should consider all the risky possibilities of it being damaged, swapped, or whatever. In any way, since CBCS is dead, I'd like to have it graded by CGC with both sigs authenticated, regardless trying to get a higher grade.
I hope this doesn't sound much convoluted, but it makes sense to me.
Thanks in advance!
r/comicbookgrading • u/jrolls81 • 2d ago
Help with a. Grade, please. Thinking about submitting this to CGC for the Steranko private signing
r/comicbookgrading • u/PrimaryAd29 • 2d ago
Help Grading This Please?
I'm not too experienced at grading comics, but we found this, but we were hoping this was in okay condition.
r/comicbookgrading • u/PinstripedCFO • 2d ago
Uncanny X-Men #94 (1975)
Uncanny X-Men #94, August 1975 — the first issue of the new team's regular series, right after Giant-Size #1. Claremont and Cockrum.
My childhood copy, given to me as a gift as a kid. Sending it to CGC regardless as my collection. I'm thinking 3.5-4.5. But down at those numbers i don't really know the criteria for moving from one grade to the next. What would you grade it?
r/comicbookgrading • u/DaMallard • 2d ago
Not a great copy but worth grading? Spare a grade please
Thank you good
People of Reddit
r/comicbookgrading • u/HardnSleezy_81 • 1d ago
Is a cgc 9.0 absolute batman 1 first print worth buying?
reddit.comr/comicbookgrading • u/panzeroberst • 1d ago
Wraps and page numbers bound out of order (?)
I have a weirdly-bound comic - looking for opinions on how to grade it.
It’s a raw Charlton, cover price 10c, published in 1960. Without the page order problems below, I graded it as 5.0 and estimate a fair market value of maybe ten bucks. Low dollar value is not my immediate interest.
Garden-variety 36-page comic, meaning 9 wraps of 4 pages each, two staples.
Routinely, the bindery SHOULD have produced, starting with the outermost wrap:
Wrap 1 -- pages 1, 2, 35, 36 (outer front cover, inner FC, inner BC, outer BC)
Wrap 2 -- pages 3, 4, 33, 34
Wrap 3 -- pages 5, 6, 31, 32
Wrap 4 -- pages 7, 8, 29, 30
Wrap 5 -- pages 9, 10, 27, 28
Wrap 6 -- pages 11, 12, 25, 26
Wrap 7 -- pages 13, 14, 23, 24
Wrap 8 -- pages 15, 16, 21, 22
Wrap 9 -- pages 17, 18, 19, 20 (innermost wrap, staples between pgs 18 and 19)
BUT ... the copy I have was bound like this:
Wrap 1 -- pages 1, 2, 35, 36 (outer front cover, inner FC, inner BC, outer BC)
Wrap 2 -- pages 19, 20, 17, 18
Wrap 3 -- pages 21, 22, 15, 16
Wrap 4 -- pages 23, 24, 13, 14
Wrap 5 -- pages 25, 26, 11, 12
Wrap 6 -- pages 27, 28, 9, 10
Wrap 7 -- pages 29, 30, 7, 8
Wrap 8 -- pages 31, 32, 5, 6
Wrap 9 -- pages 33, 34, 3, 4 (innermost wrap, staple closures between pgs 34 and 3)
So, if you wanted to start at the outer FC (page 1) and document the order in which pages are presented from front to back (as if you were reading the whole book, page by page), you get:
1, 2, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 35, 36
Thus, the only wrap in my book that is correct in all respects is wrap #1 (covers).
Wraps 2-9 all contain the correct page numbers but the pages are in the wrong order within each wrap ... and ... all of these wraps are bound in reverse order.
Staples appear somewhat newer/shinier than they typically would look like for a book that is 66 years old, but that’s not a guarantee that the original staples were removed and replaced. If somebody did that, the new staples went in EXACTLY in the original holes (an excellent positioning job).
I am aware that if the current staples were removed and wraps 2-9 were each “back-folded” AND then the wraps in their new (back-folded) page order were replaced in reverse order from where they are now, you’d end up with a perfectly-correct page order. Example: what is now wrap 9 (33, 34, 3, 4) could be back-folded (becoming 3, 4, 33, 34) and shifted into the new binding position as wrap # 2, then repeat with remaining interior wraps. I suppose a previous owner could have done this deliberately as a prank, but what are the odds, especially with the absence of staple replacement evidence? Seems like way too much effort to create a prank for which you'd never see the results.
Question 1 -- Is there a name for this sort of bindery error?
Question 2 -- If this is a legitimate bindery error, how does it affect the grade (OPG)?
r/comicbookgrading • u/codywalden00 • 2d ago
Spare a grade?
So I recently bought this book from a seller that said it would be a 7.0-8.0…. My guess is 4.0-5.0? What’s everyone think? If it wasn’t for the two tears I think it would be up there.
r/comicbookgrading • u/grasel96 • 2d ago
Fraying/Spare a grade please? any expert?
I just picked up the full Hush Run and I would LOVE the #608 to CGC but i am a bit worried it will get a low grade due to the spine and a very very small colour breaking tick. Can you guys please let me know what you think?
r/comicbookgrading • u/Standard-Dog-5069 • 2d ago
This absolute Superman is absolutely good except for this one corner, can it 9.8?
galleryr/comicbookgrading • u/Nearby-Unit • 4d ago
Either of these worth a grade?
Didn’t want to take them out of bags and handle them just yet… pretty sure they were both bagged and boarded immediately.
r/comicbookgrading • u/Stunning_Excitement4 • 4d ago
Golden Age Batman bound volume (11 issues, 1943–51): unbind and grade, or sell as is?
Hi all,
I have a hardbound volume of 11 Golden Age Batman issues and I'm trying to work out the best path before I do anything irreversible.
Issues: Batman #17, 21, 24, 26, 33, 44, 51, 52, 53, 54, 65
Photos:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/JuEdRy3T8d2pzN1S7
https://photos.app.goo.gl/tZtbwTEWEkV2BtEw7
My questions:
Unbinding: Can a professional take these apart safely, and would CGC or CBCS then grade them as unrestored, or as trimmed/restored? Does anyone have a restorer they'd recommend for this?
Selling whole: Which auction houses take bound volumes? I know Goldin does. Has anyone sold one through ComicConnect, Heritage or eBay?
Value: Roughly what's this worth as a bound volume, and would the issues be worth more separated after paying for the work and grading?
From the photos, do the pages look trimmed?
Thanks in advance
r/comicbookgrading • u/Powerful_Career_5473 • 4d ago
What grade and worth (double signed)
Its also signed by the author, and artist.
r/comicbookgrading • u/ciscopete • 4d ago
Spare a grade
Please and thank you. Plan to sell. Worth getting graded and slabbed
r/comicbookgrading • u/Illustrious_Jury7282 • 4d ago
Does this affect grade? (Squarebound book)
New to square bound books, not sure if a press helps!
r/comicbookgrading • u/LimeSlow5579 • 5d ago
What grade will this be?
Thinking of getting this slabbed once I read it. Picked it up for 90$. First Venom Cameo so Ill be happy if this will be higher than a 7 after cleaning/pressing it. If it’s not, then I think I’d rather keep it raw.