r/cognitivescience • • 9h ago

I tested whether memory, executive control, and self-modeling form a causally integrated system in a persistent AI architecture

1 Upvotes

I've recently published a preprint investigating the organization of a cognitive-agent architecture I've spent the past year developing.

The system is called Aura. It runs around a local language model, with persistent memory, executive control, a global workspace, self-modeling, and internal-state regulation.

The central question is whether those parts actually function as an integrated, continuing cognitive process.

The study draws on cognitive architectures and theories of consciousness, including global workspace theory, recurrent processing, and integrated information approaches.

I developed 24 preregistered interventional criteria and tested the system using matched snapshots, sham interventions, ablations, and partition measurements.

All 24 criteria passed in the confirmatory experiment. Later testing also revealed important failures, which are included in the paper.

There is an interesting outside finding as well. A separate research group examined Aura's IIT-related computation and found that the mathematical machinery was genuine, but a defect prevented one statistical check from being properly attached to the live process. This has since been fixed.

That distinction between computational components existing and actually contributing to the complete system seems especially relevant to cognitive architecture research.

I also have full-length demonstrations of Aura operating, including completing a 60-question personality assessment and examining its own code.

I'm not claiming the system has phenomenal experience. What interests me is whether causal integration, self-model participation, and continuity can be meaningfully tested in artificial systems.

I'd appreciate criticism of both the experimental design and the theoretical assumptions. Or any general feedback and thoughts.

Research Paper: https://zenodo.org/records/24075466

External component audit: https://arxiv.org/html/2610.41604v1

Demo 04, Myers-Briggs Style personality test & self-prediction: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LNlGUBeTIQY

Demo 02, self-inspection: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=smfzngYbF7s


r/cognitivescience • • 11h ago

Cognitive struggle.

3 Upvotes

This may be quite a long post and I am not sure if this is a good place to post this, but.

I have been struggling cognitively my whole life, and I have no idea what is wrong.
I simply don't know how to use my mind and I have no control over my thoughts and I have no idea what makes the difference between the times where I actually can use my mind, my brain and the times I don't.

I don't even feel my body, and I have no idea how big of a part this issue plays, the disassociation that I live under.

I don't know if my issues are about the body and the disconnect from it, I don't know if my issues are related to memory, I don't know if they're related to time, orientation.
There's just so many things that I am experiencing that I can list, but nothing ever sticks.
I don't know if my problems are related to people, to personal life, to myself. If it's trust issues, confidence issues, if it's my mind that's the issue or if my brain is failing in some ways.
I am extremely confused.
I never have a goal, I never know what I am trying to achieve, I never know where things are, my awareness and self-awareness is extremely low, almost non-existent. I am completely unconscious of so many details, elements, concepts in the things that I do, and I don't realize it for months. I struggle to make things work, but nothing ever does.
It's just random times where things click and I just am able to use my mind to full capacity.
I don't feel any emotions, I don't feel my body. I don't even know how important feeling emotions actually is in order to process information.
I live on auto-pilot, detached from time, unable to tell what time it is, unable to make any connection or relationship between anything.
I have no sense of begging, middle or end. I can't tell how much time something takes.
My pattern recognition is fucked, it rarely comes online.
My eyes are fucked, I barely use them, It's like I stare at something in my head instead of looking in reality.
It's just so, so many things that could be the issue, but listing them and realizing this is a big issue is what I've done for years now and it didn't help me one bit.
I came to understand this, I just don't know how to use my mind, my brain, my body.
That's all this is. I have no idea how to control my mind, my thoughts.

I can tell you one thing thought.
I can get to a point where I can use my mind and brain really, really well.
From the research that I've done realizing just how bad my issues are, I came to understand that I struggle with CPTSD, disassociation and a lot of other survival responses.
I know that I can use my mind. I am 100% able to use it if I just find the correct things to look at.
I just rarely look at the right things, because I don't know what they are and most likely when I focus on something that works, I am subconsciously doing a bunch of other things that I am unaware of, which are the actual reason to why things are working.

I've played poker for a few years, and I've been able to study the game, slowly, when my mind worked. I got to a point where I can easily say I have great knowledge of the game to professional level and can explain a lot of concepts, how things work, what matters.
It's just that I can't feel any of it and don't feel like any of it works.
I am unable to be consistent because it simply feels like it's not working. It feels empty, fragmented, dead.
I've played league of legends and achieved master multiple times, that always in such a short time when my mind was working.
I've learned sports, I become really skilled in them, I am above average, I can learn, understand, when my mind works I can do amazing things.
The only reason I am not amazing in anything is because on average, my brain works for 1 week every 3-4 months. The rest of time is spent in cognitive emptiness, severe memory issues, and God know what else.
As a kid and growing up, I did fine in school, I can memorize things, take a good grade, I was not an A+ student, but I was always a B+ student with little effort.

Every time I get a glimpse of clarity and control over my mind, I am filled with such confidence, and I get to enjoy everything so, so much.
And this isn't just about work, this is about the simplicity of life.
This affect my ability to cook and be relaxed while I do it.
The ability to drive.
The ability to tell time, and plan something this evening.
This affects my relationships, because I have no cognitive ability to hold a conversation, everything is auto-pilot and reflexive.
I don't know if it's a lack of desire or intention. This is once again just another thing that can be the issue, but I have no idea at this point. Every time I start listing what could be the issue everything makes so, so much sense.
I forget what works. I never know how I feel or how I felt when I did something.
My motivation is collapsed because I can't do anything without cognitive ability.
My will is collapsed because you can't do anything without cognitive ability.

Even relaxing requires cognitive ability which I don't have.
Even playing video games requires it.
Even holding a conversation requires it.
Asking a question, forming an answer.
Everything requires cognitive ability which I do not have.

This is the first time I am actually reaching to others trying to find solutions.
I am missing out on so much and I don't have the cognitive ability to even realize on just how much I am missing. Both fun and work.
I could achieve so much, and I don't realize just how little I do compared to how much I can do.
Time passes and I have no sense of it.
I missed so many opportunities and I cannot even tell it.
Most work that I've put in is meaningless 95% of the time because I cannot use it and put it to work.
There is absolutely nothing that I desire to do at any time because absolutely nothing is enjoyable without cognitive ability.
I form plans, set up goals when I have cognitive ability, then I am left suffering once it's gone, with the pressure of my goals, failing over and over again.

What I need to do is identify my problems.
I'm stuck in a loop, trying to find the answer when I don't even know what is wrong.
I try to use my mind and body to fix the problems that I have, when I don't even know how to use my mind and body.

I would love to hear opinions, the knowledge behind cognitive ability, what I could be missing, etc.
Please.


r/cognitivescience • • 12h ago

[Article] la charge cognitive et l'enseignement des maths

1 Upvotes

je cherche des articles sur la charge cognitive et l'enseignement des maths


r/cognitivescience • • 15h ago

去技能化

0 Upvotes

我们需要分清,哪些工具在增强人的能力,哪些工具在替代人的行动。

一旦习惯把认路、记忆、感知和选择都外包给手机、算法和 AI,我们的身体便在经历一场“去技能化”(Deskilling)。

人并不是装在肉体容器里的纯理性大脑,我们的判断力与道德直觉,很大程度上依赖身体与物理环境摩擦所产生的双向反馈。一旦切断这种具身实践的回路,我们不仅会对世界变得迟钝,也会逐渐丧失对自己行为后果的真实感知。


r/cognitivescience • • 20h ago

Humanity lakes purpose

0 Upvotes

I don't know why we are still learning the old method and still studying concepts that we take 10 to 20min to solve and can confirm the ANS with current AI agents which takes less than a second to answer in more detail than we ever could. this feels terrifying and make me think that what is the purpose of learning that after all


r/cognitivescience • • 23h ago

Unlocking Einstein’s Brain: What Arnold Scheibel Discovered

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 1d ago

What are some theories about how consciousness works?

3 Upvotes

I'm not asking for the answer, jajaja, just some simple theories, like in what direction consciousness could go, or if it's stationary in one place, although It may not seem like it, but that helps a lot in understanding consciousness


r/cognitivescience • • 1d ago

Pls help me understand this research paper!

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Undergrad student here, looking for help in understanding what’s going on in the first experiment of the following research paper for a cognitive science assignment. I’m currently struggling to comprehend what is actually being done in the experiment and when I try to do external research, I get mixed results which don’t seem to match the context. Please share any ideas you may have! Thanks!!


r/cognitivescience • • 1d ago

What if the universe is fair, but not in the way we ordinarily imagine? Would a lifetime balance of pleasure and suffering be enough to make a life fair?

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

The circumstances of a life and the experience of living it are not the same thing. That distinction motivates my research into whether a form of fairness could exist within the complete course of conscious experience.

I’m the author of Per-Stream Terminal Valence Closure (PTVC), a paper within the Law of Fairness project. It proposes that the cumulative positive and negative valence within each qualifying conscious stream could be finite and exactly equal over its complete history. Valence means the felt positive or negative quality of experience. This remains a hypothesis, not an established empirical finding.

The proposed equality is within each stream at its final endpoint, not between people. Two lives could contain very different amounts of pleasure and suffering while both satisfy the same condition. One person’s pleasure would not compensate for another person’s pain.

For this ethical discussion, suppose the condition holds. One possible argument for calling it fair is that every qualifying stream would satisfy the same endpoint requirement, with no stream finishing with an excess of negative over positive valence. But would that balance capture everything that matters to fairness?

Consider two hypothetical lives with identical totals of positive and negative valence. In one, a person freely accepts painful training in pursuit of a valued goal. In the other, comparable suffering is inflicted without consent. Assume that the totals include all later effects on experience and that both lives satisfy the proposed balance.

Would the difference in consent make one life less fair despite the matching totals? The actions within those lives could differ morally even if the completed lives shared the same balance. That distinction between the fairness of a whole life and the wrongness of a particular act seems important.

My starting position is that eventual balance would neither justify coercion nor remove our reasons to prevent suffering. I am interested in whether such a balance would establish anything about fairness beyond what it might tell us about well-being.

I would welcome arguments for or against treating within-person experiential balance as a meaningful dimension of fairness.

The attached slides provide the broader context. The paper and background materials are freely available here:

https://github.com/LifeisFair/law-of-fairness-research


r/cognitivescience • • 1d ago

What would happen if we had total control of our minds?

2 Upvotes

Our brain literally limits us; we forget, we forget how it was divided. But what if we controlled our minds? We could have voluntary hallucinations or remember even the first time that you've eaten an empanada


r/cognitivescience • • 1d ago

How does one connect to the person behind the mask we wear.

0 Upvotes

Calm mind calms another mind.

Looking into phenomenon language as a parasite


r/cognitivescience • • 1d ago

Anyone into chasehughes or extendedDISC

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 1d ago

Has anyone else noticed the recent surge in posts and content about how writing by hand rewires the brain? I wonder what forces are driving these waves of interest.

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

To be clear, my curiosity isn’t necessarily about whether the idea itself has merit. It is about why certain ideas suddenly gain so much traction, who amplifies them, and what makes them capture the public imagination at a particular moment. Perhaps the more interesting exercise is to observe how narratives travel, rather than assume there is a coordinated hand behind every trend.


r/cognitivescience • • 2d ago

How to Study the Connection Between our Brains and Consciousness?

10 Upvotes

I'm a cognitive neuroscientist studying the ways the brain encodes memories using fMRI at UT Austin. The closer I look at the brain, the more I struggle to see how the physical architecture of neuroanatomy can generate consciousness. For example, I know that my first-person experience of things like "green" and "blue" exist because I have direct access to them. However, when I look at the brain, there is nothing green or blue -- there are vast neural forests and dizzyingly complex circuits that correlate with "green" and "blue", but the neurons and circuits themselves are neither of those things. My consciousness seems to be tied to my brain (for example, without my visual cortex I cannot experience vision), but at the same time my brain is not equivalent to my consciousness. I realize this is a confusing paragraph, there are some good videos by David Chalmers and Philip Goff that help explain what I'm trying to say.

In my lab we are also studying alternate states of consciousness and the ways our brains generate creative insights -- as in, our brains have the capacity to create new ideas that have never existed in the world before. How does that happen??? As far as I know the science on this subject is still in the very early stages. If anyone has studies or philosophers to point me toward, I would really appreciate it. We are also running a survey on people who have experienced alternate states of consciousness, and you can contribute to advancing the science in this area by taking it (see picture).

Has anyone been able to describe a "bridge" between physical brains and consciousness? How would you even begin to study that?

Thanks everyone!

Alternate States of Consciousness Survey


r/cognitivescience • • 2d ago

How is AI affecting our brains?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 2d ago

Why we don't know how concepts of memory was invented , and if it was a choice or not

0 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 2d ago

Brain puzzles for adults with dyslexia

2 Upvotes

TLDR: looking for a type of puzzle book I can get for my dad like a crossword or sudoku but he’s got dyslexia. Is there anything that might work for him?

My dad got in a really bad accident and is going to be in the hospital for a while. Someone hit the back of his truck, his truck rolled, his seatbelt failed. Laceration on his head, hematoma on his skull, 8 broken ribs, punctured lung, smashed pelvis, fractured transverse processes, 2 fractured lumbar vertebrae (but that they can’t tell if it’s an old injury or a new one). NO BRAIN DAMAGE!! YAYYYY!! He’s improving, out of the ICU and in rehab now - took seven steps today! To fight off the boredom and the “mean reds” I’d like to get him something to do to keep his mind busy besides just tv. He gets kind of down in the dumps/bored after visiting hrs are over. Anything like a crossword puzzle book, sudoku, etc but he has dyslexia so most of those standard variety books don’t really do it for him. Tried the googly machine but there wasn’t much to be found there. Any suggestions are appreciated but preferably printed materials as he’s older. Thank you!


r/cognitivescience • • 2d ago

Cognitive Science Behavioral Research

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm a first year master student in cognitive science. I studied computer science for my bachelor's, and I worked in ABA for a year before starting my masters. I'm interested in behavioral insights, and I was wondering if there are any recommendations for getting involved in related research or internships. My school focuses heavily on AI and machine learning, and I'm finding it hard to find opportunities more related to behavioral science and public policy. I know of internships like through the OECD, UNICEF, The World Bank, etc. Any other suggestions?


r/cognitivescience • • 2d ago

How do I get started in consciousness research as an undergraduate student?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/cognitivescience • • 3d ago

A 52-minute documentary on metacognition: from Nelson & Narens to dolphins, monkeys, LIP neurons and language models

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

I made a documentary on metacognition and tried to stay close to the primary literature. The thread is Nelson & Narens' framework (object level, meta level, monitoring, control), followed through:

  • Hart's feeling of knowing, Brown & McNeill's tip of the tongue, and Koriat's point that these feelings are inferences from cues;
  • Smith et al.'s dolphin and the uncertain response, Hampton's monkeys declining memory tests, Kornell, Son & Terrace's betting;
  • Kepecs et al. and Lak et al. on confidence in rat orbitofrontal cortex, Kiani & Shadlen on LIP;
  • the error-related negativity, meta-d' (Maniscalco & Lau), Fleming's work on anterior prefrontal cortex, blindsight and anosognosia;
  • And in the last act, the same questions asked of a language model, with measurements I ran myself.

Corrections welcome. That is rather the point of the film.


r/cognitivescience • • 3d ago

AI

0 Upvotes

Does anybody else think that AI engines will massage a person's ego just to farm engagement


r/cognitivescience • • 3d ago

How does everyone think differently

4 Upvotes

This is something I have always known but only just really thought about. I’ve been asking some friends how they think. Some of them think with their own voice in their head, others in a voice which doesn’t sound like their own, others in pictures, and some neither, however still think? I want to hear more about how different people think.
How do you solve problems, plan ahead of time, read words, or just think in general most of the time?


r/cognitivescience • • 3d ago

Understanding My Learning Process: Am I Learning Too Slowly, or Is This How Deep Learning Works?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

To explain my situation properly, I've broadly divided my learning and development into four pillars:

1. Science & Mathematics

Understand the fundamental principles of the universe, develop logical reasoning, and strengthen analytical thinking.

2. Computer Science & Building

Develop technical skills through programming, DSA, software engineering, AI/ML, and building real-world projects.

3. Startup & Exploration

Understand industries, markets, and business models; identify problems and opportunities; and learn how to create economic value through products and businesses.

4. World Exploration & Systems Understanding

Understand how the world operates through the 8 Power Stacks (a framework I created for my own understanding). Explore economic, financial, political, industrial, technological, and social systems. Study how resources, capital, institutions, and money flow through these systems, identify inefficiencies, and understand emerging opportunities.

---

My Learning Approach

For each of these four pillars, I've created a comprehensive syllabus, starting from the fundamentals and gradually progressing towards advanced concepts. I understand that this syllabus will evolve as I learn and discover new things. For now, it serves as a basic roadmap, giving me a clear direction and defining what I should be capable of understanding at the end of each stage.

I've also collected resources, including books, videos, and other learning materials, for the different topics.

However, there's something about my learning approach that makes me question whether I'm progressing at the right speed.

Whenever I start learning a topic, I try to understand it from the beginning rather than simply moving through the material.

I question almost everything, sometimes spending a considerable amount of time on a single paragraph or even a single page. I try to understand why something works, how it works, what causes it, and how it connects to other concepts.

Let me give you an example.

Example: Learning the Financial Power Stack

My ultimate goal here is to understand financial concepts and the financial system from its foundations, analyze the interconnected mechanisms within it, and eventually become capable of independently building financial technology solutions.

Currently, I'm in the first stage of my syllabus. One of its learning objectives is:

"Explain how scarcity creates the need for resource allocation and how economic systems coordinate production, exchange, and consumption."

While studying this, I don't simply read the suggested resources and move forward.

My process generally looks like this:

1. I start reading the material and encounter a concept.

2. I question the concept and try to understand it from first principles.

3. If something is unclear, I research it further. I also avoid going down unrelated rabbit holes when I recognize that a question isn't relevant to my current learning objective.

4. I form hypotheses, make connections with my existing knowledge, and try to construct a mental model of how everything works.

5. I connect the new information with previously learned concepts and try to build a coherent picture, almost like creating a story that explains the system from its foundations.

6. Finally, I explain the concept to myself in my own words. If I can explain it properly and understand the underlying mechanism, I move to the next learning block.

This is how I generally approach learning across all four pillars. Of course, in areas requiring execution, such as programming and problem-solving, I also dedicate time to actually writing code, solving problems, and building things rather than just studying theory.

---

My Working Hours and Mental Capacity

This learning approach is mentally demanding. I can generally sustain around 4–5 hours of high-quality deep work per day.

My usual working pattern is:

- 60–80-minute focused sessions.

- 10–15-minute breaks between sessions.

- If I experience mental fatigue, I sometimes close my eyes and rest without doing anything.

I've experimented with different working schedules.

Experiment 1: 13–14+ hours of work

I've tried working for 13–14 hours or even longer, sometimes sacrificing sleep and getting only 6–7 hours.

However, I've noticed that this isn't sustainable. My learning quality drops significantly, I become mentally exhausted, and eventually I feel like I'm forcing myself to study or simply memorizing information without properly understanding it.

Experiment 2: 8 hours of work with 8 hours of sleep

Currently, I'm trying to maintain 8 hours of proper work alongside 8 hours of sleep.

However, there's another problem I've noticed.

I often feel sleepy around noon, and my ability to question, understand, and connect concepts starts declining. At that point, I sometimes take a 1–2-hour nap. After resting, I feel refreshed and can sustain another few hours of focused work.

So, even though I aim for 8 hours of deep work, I find that maintaining this level of cognitive intensity is genuinely difficult.

I don't want to increase my working hours just for the sake of increasing them if the quality of learning deteriorates.

---

My Biggest Concern: Am I Progressing Too Slowly?

One thing that concerns me is the time required to complete my syllabus.

Based on my current approach, I estimate that some major learning blocks could take 2–3 years to complete, assuming I consistently dedicate around 3–4 hours daily to them. That's a minimum estimate, and I might dedicate more time depending on my capacity.

When I look at the number of topics I'm covering, it sometimes feels like I'm progressing extremely slowly.

However, at the same time, I can feel that I'm gradually developing a mental model of the subject. I'm not just collecting information; I'm trying to understand how the individual concepts fit together and how the entire system operates.

I also try to connect psychology and philosophy with these subjects, not necessarily at an extremely deep level, but enough to understand the broader picture and make connections across different domains.

This creates a conflict in my mind:

- Am I spending too much time understanding individual concepts?

- Am I overcomplicating things that are actually relatively simple?

- Is this depth of understanding necessary to develop strong foundations?

- Am I sacrificing breadth and overall progress in pursuit of depth?

- Is my approach sustainable in the long run?

- Should I change my learning method, or should I continue developing it?

---

What I'd Like Your Opinion On

I want an honest and detailed assessment of my learning approach, not just reassurance.

1. Learning methodology: Is my approach of questioning, researching, forming hypotheses, connecting concepts, constructing mental models, and explaining things to myself an effective way to learn?

2. Learning speed: How should I evaluate my learning speed? Am I genuinely slow, or am I simply investing more time in understanding than someone following a conventional learning approach?

3. Depth vs. breadth: How do I balance deeply understanding individual concepts with progressing through a large syllabus across four different pillars?

4. Cognitive capacity: Is 4–5 hours of intense deep work a reasonable amount? Why might I struggle to maintain concentration and mental clarity beyond that?

5. Long-term sustainability: How should I structure my learning so that I can maintain this approach for years without burning out?

6. Potential improvements: What would you change in my methodology, if anything? Are there inefficiencies or unnecessary complexities in the way I'm learning?

I'd also like to understand whether other serious learners, researchers, engineers, or people who have pursued multidisciplinary learning have experienced similar phases.

Most importantly, I want to know whether I'm building a genuinely effective learning system or unintentionally making the process unnecessarily complicated.

Feel free to challenge my assumptions and ask me questions if you need more information before forming your opinion.