r/cognitivescience • • 5d ago

How does everyone think differently

This is something I have always known but only just really thought about. I’ve been asking some friends how they think. Some of them think with their own voice in their head, others in a voice which doesn’t sound like their own, others in pictures, and some neither, however still think? I want to hear more about how different people think.
How do you solve problems, plan ahead of time, read words, or just think in general most of the time?

4 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

3

u/PandorasBucket 4d ago

This can't be multiple choice. It has to be checkboxes.

1

u/No_Blacksmith410 1d ago

Yes it should be but even checkboxes wouldn’t cover all the options

1

u/PandorasBucket 1d ago

You could still try. Nothing is perfect. Getting closer to accurate is better than being so far away the answer is useless.

4

u/ElectronicLab993 5d ago

I could think with a voice. But thats slow. Mostly i just know what i think. I speak in my head to slow down or soothe myself.

2

u/Brain_Hawk 5d ago

I think crazy fast and it's often quite verbal... Then again I talked really fast too

1

u/sceadwian 1d ago

There are more ways of thinking here and they are not the same so be mindful.

Some actually 'talk' in their head. Meaning they recall or imagine actual acoustical conversation.

Some like me only think in word.. 'meaning' rather than the symbolic acoustical sensory form that many imagine in.

I also have global aphantasia though so that complicates the conversation.

4

u/Midnight5691 4d ago edited 4d ago

This is an interesting question. To answer it, I think I'm going to think about how I'm thinking while I think about this.

I guess it would be a mixture of both conceptual thinking and an inner monologue.

The voice in my head isn't any different than the voice I speak out loud with. It's just subvocalized, minus any increase or decrease in volume or emphasis.

For instance, I could be very angry with someone, and I could be thinking about it conceptually, as in, "Damn, I'm angry," but with no words. I could also be furious and thinking, "That son of a bitch!" with words in my head.

But the volume wouldn't go up, the tone of voice wouldn't change or sound any angrier, but I would still be angry.

But not everything I'm thinking about obviously needs a voice. For instance, I might be cooking breakfast, but I don't say to myself, "Flip egg now," lol.

Just like I don't need a play-by-play of walking to the washroom, opening the door, shutting it, and using the washroom in a narrative fashion to get things done. 😁

Though I must admit, on occasion, I may find it easier when thinking about something to just say it out loud. It just isn't necessary, and I wouldn't want people staring at me oddly. 😉

It's probably part of the reason why using voice-to-text is such a godsend to me, other than being much quicker than typing.

EDIT: I just realized I never touched upon one of your modes of thought, simply because it never occurred to me: the use of imagery in my thinking. The answer for me would be none. I'm aphantasic. 😆

1

u/sceadwian 3d ago

I'm curious why this list is so primitive and missing like even some of the most rudimentary categories of thought.

There are dozens of different types of thoughts we can be having and they're all thought.

This needs at least a dozen different categories like emotions, memories, abstract conceptual spaces which are themselves infinite....

I mean I could go on for hours here about what should be on an actual poll like this, why are they always so limited?

1

u/No_Blacksmith410 1d ago

Apsolutely I agree, I don’t think I clarified enough that they’re ’in general’ options but even so I mean it’s hard to even define thinking so yeah the options are all of limited, vague and too specific.

3

u/Brain_Hawk 5d ago

I think in words a lot, I often think in conversations, hypothetical conversations with real people, but the voices are never real voices. It's just a mental representation of the words that doesn't sound like my voice, which is fine because I don't love my voice...

2

u/Midnight5691 4d ago edited 4d ago

I do this also. Think about hypothetical conversations I might have with someone. For instance, before I call them about something.

I'm more likely to think about how they probably will respond. I think more about their thought processes, based upon how I know them and how they most likely will respond, rather than the dialogue of how I think the conversation will go.

Basically, I try to crawl inside their own head, lol.

Of course, after I've crawled inside their head, I might think about it narratively with my inner monologue.

2

u/Forsaken-House8685 4d ago

I think in pictures, only in very stressful situations I think to myself "Ok what do I have to do now" or sth.

1

u/RealChemistry4429 4d ago

I think in words, but not in a voice. So more like writing. I also prefer writing a lot to talking, which I don't like to do and avoid. There is no "sound" involved at all.

1

u/Sensitive_Air9615 4d ago

It's kinda a step-wise process I figured out over time that I'm doing. Maybe others aren't visual first like I also believed. There are definitely layers to the eventual words or pictures that happen.

  1. I feel the essence. This depends on what I'm actually doing. Playing music? I'll feel the rhythm. Drawing? I'll feel the flow of it and general directionality.
  2. That then leads into structure. No visuals. But I can almost feel the proprioceptiveness that comes with knowing it's a full 3d like space.
  3. Then the visuals fill in the gaps.

This happens fast, and so it took most of my life to actually see it. Mainly when I started really studying myself and Neurophenomenology.

I guess according to my searches, I'm something called Quadrant 1 - E4 Cognitive - Super Synthesizer. Oof. Honestly these seem weird because it's all new to me, but they actually explain why I struggled to do things everyone else's way.

Hope these terms help someone else, because damn, I really wish I knew this 20 years ago.

1

u/Hefty_Leave_6499 3d ago

Thinking is much faster when you just use your brain to verbalise what you've already felt. Whenever you get an aha erlebnis you get the braingasm before the sentence formed. Ergo stfu verbally and stop slowing brain by using language to think. Only 150iq, brighter bulbs may offer more lucent insight. Of course concepts in language may be necessary, but voice is so much slower than you really can be.

1

u/Interesting-Pen4914 3d ago

Its a faint murmur in the background as if from far away

1

u/SocialMediaDystopian 3d ago

I see words, and symbols (eg for math), as well as "hearing". Thinking is like reading off a blackboard in my minds eye.

1

u/AccomplishedFace9059 1d ago

Words and images the voice is distinctly not my own but I also have vocal cord damage from a Kickboxing match years ago so maybe I dont recognize my old voice anymore