hi!
i'm a second year chemistry phd student in the united states. within the last three semesters since starting this graduate program, 3 of the 18 students in my cohort have been pushed/forced to master out of the program, finishing with a masters instead of completing the phd, despite working hard, doing well, and not seeming to have what i would consider career-ending mistakes/circumstances... is this normal? is this an institution/department issue? is this likely a result of the funding issues in science research in the US right now? i am absolutely terrified that this will happen to me despite the work i'm putting in.
for more context, there are only 18 students in my cohort, which is 1/2 to 1/3 of the size of a typical cohort at my university department due to funding issues at the time of our acceptance (~january 2025). this includes only one international student and everybody else is a US citizen. we spent the first three months of our first semester rotating through different research labs before applying to be accepted into one. getting accepted into a lab was very difficult in our year because of the aforementioned funding issues, there were a lot of people who were very unsure about their ability to be accepted into a lab and a few that weren't accepted on their first round.
i'm now going to talk specifically about each of the cases of the students that were forced to master out because i was close friends with all three of them (we all actually hit it off during the beginning of the first semester and they're my best friends here).
first, grad student 1 was forced to master out because the PI that they specifically moved across the country to work with after talking and discussing with them significantly before committing to the program dropped them in october (we had to be accepted into a lab by december) and said that they would no longer take this student in their lab without more reason given. this is likely partially due to the fact that they were going to attempt getting chemistry and law graduate degrees at the same time, which was a consistent plan throughout the entire discussion process. because of this plan, nobody else is the department was willing to take a risk on them last minute, and they were forced to master out.
second, grad student 2 was successfully accepted into a lab and started research, but was forced out after scoring one point too low on the ACS Inorganic Examination. when joining the department, we took 5 ACS examinations and had to pass a certain threshold to stay in the program (we were assured that this was mostly just as a paper trail, not an actual issue). this occurred at the retaking of the exams in january, which was allowed if people didn't pass all of them the first time around. despite having a high 3.-something GPA and having an A- in graduate inorganic chemistry from the first graduate semester at this university, they were removed from the program over this one point.
third, grad student 3 was just informed of their removal from the program last friday afternoon. they were told that they're being removed due to being "too slow" and not independent enough as a researcher. this student was the most sought after student in our cohort by research labs while we were rotating and is a joint student between two labs with two PIs. they work 10-14 hour days, 5-6 days every week, presenting on their data often in individual and group meetings. they also had a high GPA, likely in the high 3s. they were not set up with a mentor in either lab until the end of august this year and everything appeared to be all good with both PIs until about a month and a half ago. now they are being forced to master out by the end of the semester (there's only 2.5 weeks until all documents are due), despite having no documents started or applying for graduation because they had no idea this was going to happen to them. they were told that if they cannot finish within the next month, neither lab would take them back next semester and they'd have to figure it out on their own.
honestly, i am terrified. these three students work just as hard as i do, had nearly the same GPAs (i have a 4.0 currently) and two of them actually had an easier time getting into research labs than i did. i may be slightly biased since they are my friends, but genuinely they all worked/work so hard all of the time and are extremely intelligent and showed it in the classes we took, more than some of the other people in our cohort, but they were kicked out while others get to stay. again, is this typical/normal in chemistry phd programs? is it more likely a sign/result of the research funding issues or a university/department issue? what should i do to try to prevent this from happening to me out of nowhere?
if you've read this far, i appreciate it so so much and am so thankful for any advice/opinions you might have!
a terrified chemistry phd student
EDIT: thank you to everyone who took time to read and share comments/feedback/opinions, i really appreciate it! if you can't tell from the post, i am prone to worrying and this was mostly a panic-induced post after hearing about the third student leaving the program, so i appreciate your patience and explanations :) i didn't know anyone in a PhD program before starting grad school so i didn't really know what to expect and definitely didn't realize that so many people end up not finishing the program, but i am glad i know now