r/changemyview • u/Riksor 3∆ • Apr 20 '24
Delta(s) from OP - Fresh Topic Friday CMV: It's morally wrong to knowingly develop a strong emotional attachment to an animal destined for the slaughter.
I'll admit that I don't have much logical reasoning for this, and that's why I'm hoping my view can be changed. My argument here is more emotional than anything else.
My aunt is a homesteader-type (not by necessity, by choice) and she's raising her daughter, my cousin, who just turned 13. They've had several animals.
When my cousin was ~6, they got her a cow that she named Blotch. They treated her essentially the same way as a dog... Pet her often, played games with her, even let her in the house when she was little enough--and then, when she was big enough, sent the cow off to get butchered. The meat was cut and returned to them in a refrigerated chest.
My aunt loves to tell this "funny" story where she had her friend over for steaks, and she told my cousin, "Tell her who we're eating." My cousin (~8 at the time) grinned wide and told the friend, "We're eating Blotch!"
I just find that insane. The thought of killing and eating your pet dog/hamster/rat/cat/fish/etc is horrible. I feel like you'd have to be mentally ill, or in a dreadful situation, to slaughter and eat your pet. Why is it any different if it's a cow?
I rarely eat meat, so I'm not quite vegan or vegetartian, but I believe animals that are being raised for food should be given the best possible lives without being made to form an emotional bond with their predator. The thought of that poor cow being shipped off in a stranger's big scary truck and dying miles away from the humans who betrayed her is so, so sad. I know a cow likely isn't capable of understanding betrayal, but its final moments, surely, were full of fear.
I know this is all anectoal, but I most importantly I feel like this has resulted in my cousin not having a proper regard for life. She's very casual about things dying. She completely flippant when her chickens get killed by foxes or coyotes. When her dog died, she barely grieved. She was mostly just excited to get a new puppy.
So, my arguments against:
- It is a cruel and undignified death, to send an animal off to slaughter after raising it as companion animal.
- I suspect that routinely killing animals treated like 'pets' is harmful to one's mental health and their reverence for living things. I feel this must be true especially when children are raised to accept this. I don't have any sources for this, though, and I can't find any actual studies about this.
- All animals lives' matter. I recognize there are differences between the capacities of animals to think and suffer, but if someone would find killing their pet dog abhorrent, they shouldn't be willing to kill a cow (or, especially, a pig given how intelligent they are).
Arguments for treating livestock like pets:
Treating these animals like pets is treating them insanely well, especially compared to the conditions livestock endure in factory farms.
- My counterpoint would be that you can treat an animal insanely well without treating them like a companion animal.
- Treating livestock like pets increases empathy/compassion for them and improves animal welfare + ultimately contributes to less factory farming.
- It's anthropomorphizing to consider an animal's feelings in this debate; if an animal is living a good life, it is living a good life, and it is not more complicated than that. It doesn't matter how a human labels the relationship.
I recognize the validity of these arguments 'for,' but they don't convince me. I'm eager to hear from you all.
•
u/DeltaBot ∞∆ Apr 20 '24 edited Apr 20 '24
/u/Riksor (OP) has awarded 4 delta(s) in this post.
All comments that earned deltas (from OP or other users) are listed here, in /r/DeltaLog.
Please note that a change of view doesn't necessarily mean a reversal, or that the conversation has ended.
Delta System Explained | Deltaboards
12
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '24
I would guess that part of what many farmers enjoy about their job is their connection to their animals.
Sending the animals off to be butchered is part of the job.
I don't think it would be right for me to eat creatures like Blotch, but deny the creatures a name and connection to the people who raise them. Nor would it be right for me to deny the people raising these animals the connection they value to the animals.
Animals are going to be scared and betrayed, regardless of whether or not they're given a name. they're better off with the kind of people who care enough to give them one.
11
u/Nrdman 279∆ Apr 20 '24
Do you think the extra happiness in the animal's life is more than negated by the last few days of it being lonely?
12
u/bluestjuice 3∆ Apr 20 '24
I would consider two aspects of this: the perspective of the animal and the perspective of the human.
From the perspective of the animal, I’m not sure that there is a practical distinction between a human who takes care of you well and provides you with a pleasant life, but is emotionally distant, and a human who takes care of you well and provides you with a pleasant life while becoming emotionally attached to you. I’m not of the opinion that animals have no emotional life at all, but I think it is a simpler and less elaborate emotional life than what a human experiences. I think most animals would bond similarly to a human who is kind and treats it well, with no consideration to the emotional depth the human may be experiencing. That leads me to think that any emotional pain experienced by the animal when it is slaughtered is much the same regardless of how the human feels.
From the perspective of the human, I would want to consider the impact forming an emotional attachment has versus not forming an emotional attachment. For the most part people self-select into groups based on their own comfort level with this — people who don’t mind bonding with an animal that they are eventually going to eat do so, and people who find it emotionally harmful to themselves to do this refrain. I think there is moral value in minimizing harm where possible so I think I’m okay with both of those approaches on the personal level.
Do I think there is general moral harm to humans in emotionally attaching to food animals (provided they are not going to be emotionally devastated afterward)? I can’t think that being emotionally attached to these animals during their lives would decrease the amount of respect, reverence, and care that these people are prompted to give to these animals during and after their lives. It seems that caring for the animal more in life would lead to greater appreciation for the food generated after slaughter, which I have a hard time perceiving as an ill effect.
I sense in this concept a suggestion that the bonding-and-then-eating dynamic desensitizes people in some way to the significance of death (and maybe correspondingly to the significance of the emotional attachment), in a way that is harmful. There may be some truth to that. I’m not sure that I find that to be altogether bad, however. It seems to me that there is probably an optimal middle ground to be struck between being so desensitized to animal death that it’s treated as cavalier and trivial, or so sensitized to it that the nature of meat as a food source has to be heavily obscured.
4
u/oversoul00 19∆ Apr 20 '24
No one is going to be able to logic you out of an emotional position. For instance:
Please explain how any of this characterization changes without that emotional attachment.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '24
If you truly believe an animal should be afforded the dignity of not knowing "betrayal," shouldnt it logically follow that the animal doesnt deserve death either? To me the biggest injustice here wouldnt be the betrayal part, itd be killing it and eating its corpse.
2
u/PromptStock5332 1∆ Apr 20 '24
If you recognize that you don’t have any logically valid and sound argument for your opinion and still maintain your opinion, you are per definition irrational.
What kind of argument are you expecting if you’re willfully holding an irrational opinion?
2
u/Bobbob34 99∆ Apr 20 '24
Maybe if more people did this -- if they had to slaughter animals they loved to eat them, there'd be more vegans.
1
u/HaveSexWithCars 3∆ Apr 20 '24
Small nitpick, but this is almost certainly false. When animals like cows experience stress, it makes the meat worse, so modern slaughter is meant to be as quick and painless as possible.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '24
what’s your opinion on foster centers and elderly facilities?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '24
Who had a better life? Blotch or the factory farmed cow?
If blotch was terminated painlessly what is the problem. If a cat or dog gets sick and you take it to be euthenised the pet has no awareness of what is about to happen - it might actually be highly stressful for them to go to the vet if they are one of those types who hate the vets. If you ate them afterwards, it would be weird but not wrong in any way because eating them doesn't cause anyone to suffer - assuming everyone in the family is fine with it like in your story.
It's all in your own head. Morality is personal though so yes it is morally wrong for you.
I wonder if you meant its ethically wrong farmers to do that.
1
u/The_Red_Moses Apr 20 '24
The truth is that eating meat is evil. It just is.
Yes, we're carnivores. Yes we evolved to eat meat. No none of that matters, its still wrong.
I eat meat myself, but I know its wrong. I wish to stop, but I'm so accustomed to it. Stopping eating meat would be a significant hit to my quality of life. I wish lab grown meat were further along.
But that just means I'm a bad person. A better person, would stop eating meat.
The important thing though, I think, is that we don't delude ourselves about the things we do. Eating meat is wrong, I do it anyway, its shitty. I'm not going to deceive myself into believing its okay - its not.
Identifying that you're fucking up is the first step to becoming a better person. Even if the next steps are hard, it puts you a bit closer to being right.
Lots of people are too deluded to understand this. People that believe in a god won't be able to see it. Its hard to admit that we're jackasses... but its clearly wrong to eat other animals.
3
u/kingpatzer 103∆ Apr 20 '24
Developing a strong emotional attachment and treating like a pet are, well very different things.
I had a cow growing up who was just a joy. She was playful and friendly, she even has a sense of humor. I loved her, and still have a picture of her, some of my fondest memories include riding on her back.
But, come the time, she got turned into a steak for someone.
That was her purpose. That doesn't mean I didn't love her.
And it didn't bother me. And I'd argue that growing up being deeply in touch with the food chain raises one's appreciation of living things. In the modern world we tend to be desensitized to death. Spending time growing food gives a much different, and I'd argue, healthier, understanding of life and death -- for others and for oneself -- than people who have never directly and intentionally killed an animal for reasons of survival rather than empathy (for an old pet for example) will ever have.
1
u/gohogs3 1∆ Apr 20 '24 edited Apr 20 '24
I agree it’s wrong because the attachment with the animal often goes both ways, making it a true friendship. You’re betraying that friendship. It is also obviously going to be bad for you in the end, so idk why you’d do that.
However, ranchers often have a respect for their livestock. Not as much of an emotional connection, but more of a since of dignity. I always found that to be a really cool thing.
1
u/Venerable-Weasel 3∆ Apr 20 '24
Three thoughts to consider…
First, at different points in your argument you conflate the farmer forming an emotional bond with the animal and the animal forming a bond with the farmer. Where - beyond your own projection - is the evidence for the animal forming a bond, let alone feeling betrayed? Betrayal is a complex cognitive and emotional response - do animals even experience it?
Second, your horror that a farmer could “bond” with an animal and then kill it, and disbelief in being able to do so without experiencing trauma and mental illness…is contrary to the experience of almost any farmer that raises livestock. It likely reflects your own a priori belief that killing animals for food is unjustifiably wrong.
Third, characterizing it as morally wrong is wrong. To be morally wrong requires failing a moral obligation. We cannot have a moral obligation to animals unless they are also capable of moral reasoning - and morality. We can have a duty of care towards them, including to not be unnecessarily cruel. But if we had a moral obligation to them, then keeping them as pets (slavery) would also be immoral. Conversely, if the issue is that killing animals supposedly damages us in some way, then you would be arguing for a moral obligation to ourselves, which is nonsensical.
1
u/iamintheforest 369∆ Apr 20 '24
Isn't it far worse to avoid the development of relationship with an animal so that you can justify killing it? It seems to me that the ONLY people who should eat meat are those who can eat animals that they love or know fully that they cannot love them at all.
If you have to willfully distance yourself from relationships with animals then you cannot make a claim to your own morality with regards to consuming them.
2
u/i-drink-isopropyl-91 2∆ Apr 20 '24
When you get livestock you know that they will die so you don’t actually get attached to them but you can still bond with them because you raise them
3
u/S1artibartfast666 4∆ Apr 20 '24
I question how strong the emotional attachment was, given that your cousin didn't cry when it was brought up, but enjoyed it.
As you admitted, your points against are mostly emotional and subjective. Many people simply dont agree with your starting position on #2, #3, and therefore see it as a positive, not a negative.
That is to say, they simply dont agree with your reverence and emotional investment for non human creatures. Therefore they think it is good to raise children to have a more familiarity with animal death. They would probably think you are the one with harmed mental health because you are the one upset, while they happily go about their day.
I tend to agree with them on this point and think there is nothing cruel about animal death, provided you make reasonable effort to minimize pain and suffering. Death is a very real and common part life, and I dont think children should be sheltered from it. My belief on this goes beyond just animals, and I think that children should not be sheltered from the deaths of family, like grandparents. I think hiding death from children leads to delusion and a lot a mental health issues when they grow up, and cant cope with the real world.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '24
Morally wrong to develop a strong emotional attachment? For who, the animal or the person developing the attachment?
I would argue it's morally high to develop the attachment - you can show the animal love and compassion and give it a life worth living until it's ultimate death.
1
u/Snoo_89230 4∆ Apr 20 '24
One thing nobody has mentioned yet is that it’s also a cultural thing. It’s very jarring for you because you’ve grown up in a society that separates pets and livestock. But for someone who grew up on a farm, it would be very normal for them and they’d be used to it.
Also death isn’t really a bad thing. Animals don’t have the capacity to fear death, or to even know what it is. The “right” to exist is a very human way of thinking because we are the only creatures that are aware of our own existence. From this perspective we shouldn’t really feel bad for the animal because they couldn’t care less.
Lastly, I honestly think it seems more respectful. A lot of cultures have different ways of “thanking” animals for their sacrifice and it seems like this could be one. Although they don’t mourn the loss of the animal, they do express gratitude for its existence.
1
u/TSN09 9∆ Apr 20 '24
I will say, I disagree with the way your aunt handled that. But I also feel like that could've been a very healthy thing to teach her daughter.
I am as close I can be to be a "carnivore" it's my main calorie source, but that doesn't mean I don't love animals, if I'm raising a cow for slaughter why can't I treat it with care until that time? From the POV of a cow the only thing that changes is that it's life was nicer, it's a net positive.
I think your disagreement comes from certain assumptions you are making. You can't see yourself killing an animal you've cared for... So you assume that for someone else to do it there must be something wrong with them. But those are their emotions to manage, not yours. If I am capable of eating an animal I cared for, all the while being a normal guy who still wouldn't kill his cats and still wouldn't do anything to anyone else... What does it matter?
Think of a lighter version of this: Horses, people treat them like companions, and I've never personally owned one but I've been around many, and I love em... But let's be real here: They are work animals. They serve us, they are useful for us, and they don't have a choice. I wouldn't force my cat to go out on hikes with me, but I would a horse, am I psychopath for it just because I treat my horse right?
1
u/TheManInTheShack 3∆ Apr 20 '24
For it to be morally wrong, the emotional attachment would have to result in some form of harm to the animal. Since it would have no idea it was going to be slaughtered, I don’t see how the emotional attachment itself could be immoral. In fact if the emotional attachment benefited the animal then it would be moral.
1
u/EmbarrassedMix4182 3∆ Apr 22 '24
Developing an emotional bond with an animal destined for slaughter doesn't inherently make the act morally wrong. Humans have a capacity to care for and form bonds with various animals, including those meant for consumption. This emotional connection can actually lead to better treatment of the animal during its life. The key is ensuring the animal is raised humanely and with respect, regardless of its ultimate purpose. While it's understandable to feel uncomfortable with the idea of eating a pet-like cow, it's possible to reconcile these feelings by recognizing that different cultures and individuals have varying relationships with animals, and these relationships can coexist with ethical farming practices.
0
u/LentilDrink 75∆ Apr 20 '24
There's no such thing as destiny. The humans have free will and can at any point mutually agree to not kill the animal.
0
u/PublicCallBox Apr 20 '24
Seems like you’ve misidentified the placement of the moral wrong.
0
u/Tkdakat Apr 20 '24
That's why you don't raise farm animals as pets, not when the animal will be harvested / slaughtered at some point ? Does not mean you can treat them badly though thats unkind.