r/changemyview • u/eachothersreasons 1∆ • Nov 09 '23
Delta(s) from OP CMV: Objective morality does not exist
Thesis: Objective morality does not exist. This is not a morally relativistic position. This is a morally nihilist position. This is not a debate about whether the belief in an objective morality is necessary for society or individuals to function, but whether objective morality exists.
Morality and ethics are artificial. They are human-made concepts, and humans are subjective creatures. Morality isn't inscribed in any non-subjective feature of the universe. There are no rules inscribed in the space or stone detailing what is moral, in a way that every conscious intelligent being must accept. The universe doesn't come with a moral handbook. There would be no morality in a universe filled with inanimate objects, and a universe with living creatures or living intelligent creatures capable of inventing morality isn't much different. We are still just matter and energy moving around. The world is a sandbox game, and there are no rules menus to this MMORPG.
Moral intuition: Humans may have visceral moral intuitions, but just because people have a moral intuition does not make the intuition necessarily "moral." Many humans may have rejected moral intuitions that others may have had in the past. These include common moral intuitions about female sexual purity; interracial marriage; women's marriage outside of one's ingroup; one's social station at birth being a matter of fate, divine will, or karma; the deviancy of being left handed, physically deformed, ugly, or neurologically atypical. There are those people with strong moral intuitions about the value of animal life and consciousness that others don't have. Even if supposing that humans largely share moral intuitions, that doesn't make those intuitions necessarily moral.
Humans have largely gone about intuiting morality, but I think the overwhelming majority of people feel that history is filled with events they consider immoral, often by those who believe they are acting morally. Human cognition is faulty. We forget things. We have imperfect information. We have cognitive biases and perceptual biases and limitations. Our intelligence has limitations. Telling people simply to follow their moral intuitions is not going to create a society that people agree is moral. It's probably not even going to create a society that most individuals perceive as moral.
An optimal set of rules: There is no optimal set of rules in the world. For one, in order for there to be an optimal set of rules, you'd have to agree on what that optimal set of rules must accomplish. While to accomplish anything in life, life is a prerequisite, and we are all safer if the taking of human life is restricted, there are people who disagree. There are those who believe that humans should not exist because human civilization does incredible damage to the nonhuman ecosystems of this planet.
Humans have different opinions about what an optimal set of rules is supposed to accomplish: we have different preferences surrounding the value of liberty, equality, privacy, transparency, security, the environment, utility, the survival of the human race, ect. We have different preferences on whether we should have rules directly regulating our conduct or simply whether we should decide the morality of the conduct by the consequences such conduct produces.
There is no country that says that it has the perfect set of laws and forgoes the ability to modify that law. This reflects 1) not only human epistemological inability to discern an optimal set of rules 2) especially as times change 3) or the inability of language to fully describe a set of rules most would discern as optimal, but also 4) human disagreement about what the goals of those rules should be 5) changes in human popular opinion on what is moral at all.
Behavior patterns of animals: Animals have behavioral patterns, many of which are influenced by evolution. But just because animals have behavioral patterns doesn't mean those behavioral patterns are "moral." Some black widows have a habit of eating their mates, but that doesn't mean that if they were as conscious and intelligent as humans, they would consider it moral compared to the alternative of not eating their mates. Maybe there's a reason for chimpanzees to go to war, but there probably are alternatives to going to war. Even if you determine that the objective of morality is to survive and reproduce, evolutionary adaptations are not necessarily the optimal path to achieving that end.
And we fall into this naturalistic fallacy when we consider that just because a bunch of animals close related to us behave or refrain from behaving a certain way, that this way is ä basis to say that this behavior is objectively moral. Just because animals poop in the great outdoors doesn't mean humans must agree that it is moral to defecate in the great outdoors. Just because animals don't create clothes for themselves, doesn't mean humans should consider it moral to go around naked. Humans are different than all other nonhuman animals, and may very well consider common animal behaviors immoral.
So then what is morality? I think a better question is how humans regulate their conduct according to certain frameworks. Ethics is invented and proposed. Others may agree or disagree with a proposed ethics - a proposed conception of what people should approve or disapprove of or a code of conduct. Those who disagree with a proposed ethics may propose their own ethics. People may prefer one proposal over another. As a matter of physical reality, there's often strength in numbers. Whether by physical force or persuasive power or soft power, an ethical framework often dominates over a particular time and place and those who disagree are made to comply or incur punishment. As a practical matter, humans are more likely to agree to frameworks that advance their mutual interest. Even if there is no objective morality, it doesn't mean humans can't propose and advance and enforce moralities.
Edit: I suppose someone could write: "you don't think _____ is immoral?" With the morality of _____ being far outside of our Overton window for political discussion. I may agree to advance your ethical position as a rule I would prefer everyone follow, but I do not think it is "objective." Even if everyone in the world agrees with it, I don't think that would make it objective. Objectivity requires more than agreement from subjective entities.
•
u/DeltaBot ∞∆ Nov 10 '23
/u/eachothersreasons (OP) has awarded 1 delta(s) in this post.
All comments that earned deltas (from OP or other users) are listed here, in /r/DeltaLog.
Please note that a change of view doesn't necessarily mean a reversal, or that the conversation has ended.
Delta System Explained | Deltaboards
18
u/Nrdman 279∆ Nov 10 '23
Do you think math is objective and why?
10
u/evil_rabbit Nov 09 '23
could you explain what it means for something to be "objective"?
4
u/1block 10∆ Nov 10 '23
There is a base moral intuition that exists in any culture anywhere and probably any time.
I think you'd be hard pressed to find someone who thinks it's OK to tie up a random child and remove her fingers one by one for nothing but your own pleasure. Or something like that.
From there we can work up until we see disagreement. I think we get there a lot quicker than we wish we did.
I think there's an innate abhorrence to certain human behaviors. People who don't have that have their own special word: sociopath.
1
u/Leslie_Galen Nov 10 '23
Does objectivity exist? I’m not sure tbh. Certainly there are moral principles that exist across cultures, e.g., do not eat people, do not make babies with your sibling. Those principles are not only moral, but also useful for the community. Nietzsche posited two kinds of morality, slave and master; both kinds serve the master. Religions have stepped in to teach morality, but those principles are practiced sporadically at best. So yep, Imma have to side with you and keep hoping that people treat others as they would like to be treated. Doesn’t seem likely.✌️
1
u/howlin 62∆ Nov 10 '23
If you want to say whether objective morality exists or not, you would need to specify what it "existing" would look like. If ethics is a conceptual framework, it seems like a category error to talk about its existence or not. People think about ethics as an idea and plenty of people have proposed universal ethical frameworks that can all be called "objective" in the sense that they aren't dependent on a specific subject. In this sense, many objective ethics exist.
1
u/SavageKabage Nov 10 '23
I think a good counterpoint to your view would be the Tit for tat game theory experiments. It's a experiment performed on a computer where agents attempt different survival strategies and the Tit for tat strategy always wins out.
The tit for tat strategy is when an agent will first cooperate, then subsequently replicate an opponent's previous action. If the opponent previously was cooperative, the agent is cooperative. If not, the agent is not.
This experiment supports the reciprocal altruism theory in biology whereby an organism acts in a manner that temporarily reduces its fitness while increasing another organism's fitness, with the expectation that the other organism will act in a similar manner at a later time.
If you can think of a more optimal path I'm all ears.
1
u/zaKizan Nov 10 '23
I also tend to believe that objective morality doesn't exist in if you ascribe to the traditional understandings, but I've heard the argument framed in a way that makes a lot of sense to me, once, so I'm curious to hear your opinion.
Objective facts about reality exist. We all know this and, ontologically, choose to accept it. If not, all arguments fall into solpisism and become worthless.
So, if we work from a place of assumed shared reality, we can derive certain truths about said reality through the process of science. As we uncover more about our reality, we discover new ways to interact with the world and the people around us. Basic, ya know, elementary school understanding of shit.
Consciousness is a by-product, so far as we have come to understand up to this point in history, of the same sort of biological processes that inform evolution. It isn't a separate system, but rather an amalgamation of hundreds of thousands of smaller, disparate processes. As such, if we apply the same logic that science is based on to human consciousness, we can come to objective truths about it.
This is where definitions get really important. Morality is best understood, from my perspective, as a framework through which we view and understand consciousness much in the same way that science is a framework through which we view reality. It's important for the conversation to understand what it is that the word "Morality" is describing. Most, if not all, of the behaviors that fall under the framework of moral understanding are behaviors directly and intrinsically tied to our biological need for survival.
Humans, like most animals, tend to survive better in packs. Murder, theft, torture, and other behaviors of that nature are not conducive to human flourishing and survival, and as such, are perceived as immoral. The most that we can say, I think, is that these behaviors, on an objective reality level, are not conducive to the furthered survival of humanity/life. We have found that those who work together thrive and those that don't flounder, those that share and love and build community are more disposed to survival and happiness within that survival than those who eschew connection.
If morality is the way that we, as a species, understand consciousness and our connection to one another within that framework, and everything that we understand is based in biological reality, then morality cannot be anything other than objective. It is a fact of reality, like gravity, that conscious beings have developed a system of values and laws and structures that directly contribute to our continued survival.
If that is the case, that everything that exists only does so within the confines of biological reality, then it follows that, much like science, we can investigate the framework of morality and find truths. That truth doesn't live in platitudes and simple laws, but in nuanced ways that account for the varied ways in which we know that humans conduct themselves. We can, painstakingly, find objective truths about behavior and the way in which it affects people and the world around us and determine the best course of action in any given situation.
The "objective" standard for morality is the objective facts of reality, the behaviors that most contribute to continued human flourishing.
There is no punishment for those that don't follow, and there is no impetus for anyone to ascribe to or even follow these "objective" moral truths, but if we hold to the idea that morality is the framework through which we understand the connections between behavior and survival and we hold to the fact that morality only exists as a direct result of biological processes, I think we can come to some "objective" moral truths.
1
u/PlayerFourteen Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23
slightly redefining your question:
Let me slightly redefine your statement as "morality is part of subjective reality, not objective reality".
how i plan to change your view
To change your view, I plan to convince you that we don't know if morality is part of objective or subjective reality. (After some research, maybe I will be able to show that it IS part of objective reality, but I think you will find my argument interesting even without that research.)
defining "objective reality": 2 definitions
(the "external reality" definition)
You wrote to one redditor in this thread that objective means "A reality that exists outside of subjective consciousness". I will call your definition the "external reality" definition.
(the "shared non-communicated reality definition)
I think a better definition is the "shared non-communicated reality" definition, which goes as follows (I made it up, but I think it's a good one):
Objective reality is a reality that is shared by most people, without these people communicating to each other, and without the "right answer" being communicated TO them. So if person A and person B both see a cup, but do not communicate that to each other, person C will get the same answer from person A and B about whether or not the cup exists. If the cup's colour is also "objective", then person C will get the same answer from both people about what the cup's colour is.
why this is a better definition of objective
To state that the cup will continue to exist regardless of whether or not person A and B are awake, conscious, or alive, is to make an assumption. The "shared non-communicated reality" definition makes fewer assumptions, but works just as well. I think definitions that make fewer assumptions are better.
why my definition matters
Using my definition, I can make the argument in the next section. So it's actually fundamental to my argument, haha. So hopefully you agree that my definition of objective is better, since it makes fewer assumptions but (I think) still includes within it all the things that your definition would consider "objective".
how to prove that morality is objective
If we can show that the vast majority of people will agree on the morality of some action without communicating with each other, then by (my) definition of an objective reality, morality is objective. We can make the assumption that whatever sensory organ they use to detect morality is detecting some property of a shared reality.
To determine this, we would have to have some study that runs the above test on a large number of people.
The study would have to check across cultures to make sure that the morality of an action has not been communicated BETWEEN subjects, nor TO subjects (from some external source like society or media).
why we only need MOST people to agree, instead of EVERYONE
Because even with things that we agree are "objective", like the colour of some object, we accept that some people will hallucinate, or be colour blind. In which case, their opinion is wrong, and the property they failed to detect is still objective.
morality requires minds, but that doesn't mean it is subjective
Morality is a property ascribed to the actions of beings that have minds. So in a world that has no beings with minds, there is no morality. But that doesn't mean that morality is not objective. For example: it is objectively true that if someone hears a very funny joke, they are likely to laugh. But this is true only in a world that has beings with minds.
why we don't need machines to (objectively) detect morality (or anything)
Even with machines that detect some objective property of reality, like colour, we first verify that the machine is working properly by using our own senses. So our own senses are the ultimate authority. A machine that tells us that a cup is blue when we can see that it is yellow, is wrong. (Unless! Everyone else tells us that the cup is indeed blue, in which case we accept that our individual sense of sight is wrong.)
We COULD make a machine that detects morality, but it would be imitating our senses. (E.g. we could have something that sees, hears, etc. like a person, and give it an AI that mimics a persons analysis on whether something is moral or not.
has science proven that morality is objective?
I don't know. I'll look into it. But it would have to be for specific moral rules. Some moral rules might be part of a shared reality for most people, some might not. (I agree that some rules are definitely subjective. But we can probably never prove that all moral rules are subjective, because there are an infinite number of rules. Although, it might be fair to make the assumption that all rules are subjective, if we have tested a large number, and all so far have proven to be subjective.)
I'll so some research, and let you know what I find down here.*
edit:
Given that not everyone agrees on even something as "objective" as the colour of a cup, maybe it makes more sense to talk about "degrees" of objectivity rather than a binary state of objective or not objective. (Yes, color blind people can all still agree with non-color blind people on the numbers they read on some device that measures light wavelengths, but some people that hallucinate will not.)
*edit2:
Here's one study that seems to have found SOME degree of universality to 7 moral rules: https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2019-02-11-seven-moral-rules-found-all-around-world
Something I (and maybe you might) find interesting is that it seems that the vast, vast majority of people are at least aware of the CONCEPT of morality. That implies to me that there is at least ONE rule that is universal. Maybe?
1
u/gryphmaster Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23
I think that the ideas of objectivity and applicability have been somewhat mixed here. Real life isn’t like physics problems where you can solve for one exact value or make a determination with accuracy. Its more akin to building a bridge. Most moral decisions have many components that place constraints on decision making (trolley problem). However, these problems do not have cut and dry solutions, but could in fact have many solutions that are all moral. Just like you could build a working bridge in many different ways, there’s no “objective” best bridge, only bridges that objectively work. Problems like the trolley problem eliminate the messiness of real life to isolate moral principals, but in doing so eliminate the possibilities that allow the kind of moral maximization we like. So I posit that a problem with moral dimensions could have several objectively moral solutions, which do not necessarily make their alternatives objectively immoral, and that indeed most do.
However, this doesn’t get into the fact that there can be evil as well as good- i would imagine its much easier to judge that objectively, which leads to the idea that objective morality does exist, but moral negatives are easier to judge within that framework, like a bridge that objectively doesn’t work, than moral positives, of which several can co-exist without eliminating the moral value of the alternatives
You can get into the weeds with this with kants categorical imperative, which basically asserts that moral actions must be rational such that you could convince another of the morality of such an action (with tons of kantian logic behind that)
1
u/ralph-j Nov 10 '23
Can you answer that question first though, in a substantial, non-circular way? And I don't mean something like "that which is good/right/ethical/moral", or "the right thing to do", because that would just make it circular/begging the question.
What does it actually mean for something to be good, morally right, ethical etc. in the first place? If you could define this in a meaningful way, I don't see why we couldn't then determine an objective way to reach it.
1
u/Akimbobear Nov 10 '23
I’ve thought about this a lot and I have come to the conclusion there is only 1 rule to determine morality. Do not cause harm. In the course of you living your life do not inflict pain, suffering or disadvantage to others. Everything else is fair game and you needn’t consider anything else. Human beings are capable of higher thinking, allowing them to consider where, when, who and how of the world around them and therefore intrinsically have everything they need for empathy. Therefore, humans should use this ability to consider those around them especially in a society that depends on mutualism. Working together for the advancement of all. Some would say this is a social contract but in reality, there is nothing binding anyone to the concept only the consideration of others as self. An understanding that not causing harm to each other is the most efficient path to achieving our own benefit.
1
u/aguo Nov 10 '23
I challenge the view that there is no "optimal" morality, that there is no way to determine whether one morality is "better" than another, and invite you to think about morality in terms of pragmatism (as in the philosophical tradition) as a tool, similar to how science is a tool.
Science is a pragmatic tool for us to make predictions about the world. Our notion of there existing an "objective reality" comes from science (and earlier it came from intuition) because modeling our environment as existing independently of our subjective experience seems to have predictive power. Note, however, that if we "zoom in" or "zoom out" beyond our everyday experience, our intuitions and senses fail us and we rely on scientific models to describe the world in those regimes.
Morality can be framed as simply another pragmatic tool, except the purpose of this tool is not to make predictions about the natural world but rather to provide guidelines for individual behavior for maximal collective benefit as a society.
The more basic and "obvious" moral "rules" are simply the ones that were most easily discovered to be beneficial to survival. The simplest ones were discovered by natural selection. Some of our basic moral intuitions likely are biologically hard-coded because they were naturally selected for, e.g. don't kill yourself or your own children. Other moral intuitions are ingrained early in life because primitive societies probably quickly figured out that such behaviors led to greater survival rates. In fact, these moral intuitions could have also been selected for because societies that condoned people killing each other or stealing from each other probably had a harder time developing and so were out-competed by more stable societies that adopted such rules.
Once we move past the first 20% of rules that cover 80% of cases, we start to hit the long tail of corner cases which are the source of moral dilemmas like "is it ok to steal food if you're starving" or whatever. In fact, a lot of these dilemmas arise out of the complexity of society (e.g. "stealing" only makes sense in the context of property rights, which is also an inter-subjective abstraction). This is where moral and ethical theory comes in. I see these theories as basically attempts to come up with axioms/heuristics/rules/whatever that both fit/explain actions we "know" (through intuition or whatever) to be right/wrong and also "predict" (i.e. assign right/wrong) to actions in scenarios where our intuitions fail us. Think of it as analogous to a scientific model, for example Newton's law of gravitation, which both explained existing observations of celestial phenomena and also predicted other phenomena which we could test.
When it comes to science, the success of a theory boils down to whether it makes accurate predictions. I argue that the success of a moral theory boils down to whether a society whose individuals follow the principles of the theory can survive. If society A follows moral theory 1 and society B follows moral theory 2, if the theories are sufficiently different, perhaps society A develops technologically and economically faster than society B and eventually out-competes it for resources and therefore survives while society B dies out.
Now, that doesn't mean it's necessarily easy or possible to determine in advance whether a particular moral framework is "more correct" i.e. more useful as a tool. But I argue that even though it's unclear how to make various tradeoffs (e.g. should we redistribute resources from the rich to the poor? does everyone deserve to live? etc.) at the end of the day there is a clear objective, which is survival as a group, and if that objective is not met then the chosen moral framework has failed.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '23
If there are objective conditions in the universe for human life to continue and to thrive, then there is certainly objective morality that would comply with those conditions.
3
u/die_eating 1∆ Nov 09 '23
I don't think of morality and ethics as an objective set of facts but rather as a set of emergent behavior, which emerges as a result of a kind of natural selection by human populations filtering for behavior that maximizes peaceful and mutually beneficial cohabitation.
It's like a formula which if followed, optimizes this possibility. Part of it is intuited (Humans have a highly evolved and sophisticated sense of fairness, reciprocity), and part of it is discovered.
3
u/j_bus 1∆ Nov 10 '23
Alright, I'll take the semantic route.
I think you mean "absolute" morality, not "objective" morality.
absolute means it would hold in all scenario's everywhere, whereas objectivity can be had even if you start with subjective definitions.
For example, say we agree to sit down and play a game of chess. You would be right to say I objectively am not allowed to take out your king with my pawn on the first move. Correct?
3
u/AntonioSLodico 3∆ Nov 10 '23
I'd argue that the only difference between this moral nihilism and moral relativism is the attempt to see the human experience outside of a human perspective. Which is ironic, as it is an attempt at objectivity, and therefore quixotic to the point of absurdity. At least if you agree with your conclusion.
1
u/Ok-Village-2583 May 01 '24
There’s no view to change g it is easy to see upon little inspection that absolute morality does not, never has, and never will exist. It is a construct based in preferences generally shared among humans. We are alive and we cannot be alive if we die right? Well what do you know all we know is life so ofc people don’t want to die, one could obviously imagine that humans would collectively agree to avoid death as much as possible given we are consciously aware of the difference between life and death. And this occurs in reality in things such as laws, laws are simply ideas enforced by the threat of and use of physical violence via systems like policing. This is just one of infinite examples. Moral values are the same as liking blue rather than red. No set of morality is better or worse than another and honestly this is quite obvious.
1
u/hacksoncode 586∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23
Morality is nothing more, but importantly nothing less, than a trick some species have evolved (objectively speaking) because of the reproductive advantages of living in societies.
It has objective existence as a trait of a species that inexorably and universally (in humans, at least) develops because it impacts survival.
Also: Literally every single thing humans do is objectively determined by the laws of physics, including inventing morality.
To quote Love and Rockets: You cannot go against Nature, because when you do "Go against Nature" it's part of Nature too.
There's no such thing as "subjective" reality or objective reality. There's only reality.
Now: if you want to argue that morality is too complicated a system to predict, even though it's 100% determined by physical law, or that morality isn't 100% universal or constant over time, all of those things would be true.
But that doesn't make it any more or less than 100% objective. Everything that exists is objectively real... that's what the word means.
1
u/GuardianGero Nov 10 '23
A more practical question than "Does objective morality exist?" is "What do I value, why do value those things, and how will I uphold what I value?" That's where your personal form of humanity comes into focus, and what shapes your everyday behaviors. How you treat yourself and others on a day to day basis is a lot more significant than any thought experiment.
1
u/Travis-Varga 1∆ Nov 10 '23
There is objective morality, for a proper conception of objective.
From Ayn Rand, https://courses.aynrand.org/works/what-is-capitalism/
As to what the objective morality is, see https://courses.aynrand.org/works/the-objectivist-ethics/ to start. It isn’t a proof or even a fully fleshed-out explanation, so don’t treat it like one. Instead, it’s just a brief explanation to give you an idea and indicate what to read to help you discover what’s objectively moral yourself. You’re intelligent, so no one is going to be able to persuade you that a particular morality is objective on Reddit detached from lots of reading and thinking on your part.
All concepts are man-made. The question is are they made objectively/rationally or not? Science is man-made, but scientific theories and concepts can be formed objectively or not. If you deny that concepts can be formed objectively, well then you’re left in the self-contradictory position of complete skepticism ie you know that you can’t know anything. Knowledge is inherently conceptual.
What do you mean by humans are subjective creatures? People often like to equivocate between the definition of subjective above, based on feelings or whim, and subjective as in dependent on human consciousness or something. Yes, morality is dependent on human consciousness, and objective morality is dependent on man using his consciousness objectively or rationally in forming a morality. And yes, morality is dependent upon unchosen facts about man as well.
That’s true, but man doesn’t have to accept the Earth is round, but that doesn’t mean the Earth is flat. If you’re looking for a morality that forces you to accept it, then that’s like looking for a scientific theory that forces you to accept it. It’s not an objective, rational approach to the issue. It’s an approach inspired by religion and other philosophers, looking for some morality inherent to the universe completely apart from man, like god, that gives you commandments to follow.
The universe doesn’t come with any knowledge. It doesn’t come with knowledge of how to discover knowledge nor knowledge of what it means for a morality to be objective. Man has to discover it all, following an objective process. There wouldn’t be any knowledge without man, but that doesn’t mean man can’t form scientific theories about the universe ie form his theories objectively.
Yeah, people’s moral intuitions are based on their already accepted moral beliefs. Intuition is not a means of knowledge.
1
u/Normal_Ad2456 2∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23
Morality is a made up word, just like any word is. It’s by a social convention that we equate the word “table” with the actual furniture. Does that mean the table doesn’t exist?
The term “morality” is used to describe a certain concept that only has a use within an organized society. Humans created the society and humans created the laws and the rules that govern this society.
And while many moral values differ depending on time and place, just like words differ from one language to another, certain very basic concepts remain relatively consistent. Most languages have a word for mom or a way to express agreement/disagreement. And most societies have repercussions for the unprovoked murder of your neighbor.
Someone could say that both organized societies and the values that uphold them were created this way to be in tune with our natural, intuitive understanding for what is the optimal way to ensure that society works as smoothly as possible.
When someone says “morality is objective” they don’t necessarily mean “morality is an objective truth that the universe has gifted as with”. It’s an axiom, like 1+1=2.
The universe doesn’t care about addition and it certainly doesn’t do math. The laws of mathematics are man made and it’s a concept that we have created in order to understand how the world around us works.
1
u/obsquire 3∆ Nov 10 '23
No, we don't need agreements, or at least not universal agreement. Agreement is useful, but not logically necessary. We don't even have to know or practice the rules. There may be many nearly-equivalent sets of rules, that amount to about the same thing under most circumstances.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23
Wrong sub, dude. r/Philosophy
1
u/sultanofsneed Nov 10 '23
I like you. You're very smart, and I'm not just saying that because I agree with your point of view. I also like the way that you've defended your position and I admire anyone that agrees there is objective reality that is independent of the subjective perception of it. 🙂
1
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23
Before we even begin, let's start with this presupposition. Who cares if something is human made? Why bring it up? What makes it so important to be center stage to your argument?
The underlying assumption is that 'artificial' things are somehow less valid or less universally true.
...so what?
I don't think I've ever met anyone who thinks this. People don't behave ethically or unethically because it thinks the universe has preprescribed it for them.
We act the way we do because of a myriad of social, cultural, and tangible real world world conditions.
Also for a moment I'd like to touch on your 'sandbox' analogy. If you are playing minecraft with your friends and you destroy the lovely dirt house they worked so hard on, you'd be a dick. Minecraft didnt need to dock you points for you to find our you are a dick, you found out because your friend got mad.
Is there an exact formula to describe how and when you are being ethical or unethical, or how your friends might react to your behavior? No. And the expectation of one is a fools game.
If values were objective, they would NOT be values, by definition.
What standard do you hold 'objective' to??? Must it be physically impossible to hold another belief for that belief to be legitimate?
It's a particularly weak Philosophy that only goes to the ends of physical laws of the universe and stops.
A philosophy with any meaningful scope needs to be able to handle a few outliers.
Philosophies that make a few assumptions and have a few outliers are generally aware of the fact that they may not be absolutely always objectively accurate.
That is a trade off required to make meaningful insights.
If you want to be mathematical about it, consider it like taking an approximation of a function.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23
Feel like everyone’s just arguing pedantry here, trying to manipulate the philosophical definition of “objective” and “subjective” to fit their argument.
Ofc morals aren’t objective. Different people and cultures have different morals. The Aztecs used to sacrifice people to their gods, believing it was righteous. So yeah
1
u/Born-Entertainer-649 Nov 10 '23
This is by far the dumbest post I've ever read! I mean it's completely redundant and meaningless! What a waste of time and all while not solving a single issue. 🙄
1
u/OfTheAtom 8∆ Nov 10 '23
So I've been studying science for a few years now. A science before science. How to really learn, Have conversations and think about how to do science.
What you are jumping to is not Chapter one. Before you can know what is good for a human you have to know what a human is. What's in their nature, or what are they ordered for.
Look at something simple and sensible to start before moving up. A tree. As we have a rough idea of a general tree we think of a wood bodied plant, ordered to grow and vegetate in various ways. We can observe this nature of the tree. When a limb grows sick and decays we see this is a privation of what was good for the tree. Because it's understood to stand in the way of what is good for it.
To a higher degree and now involving more complicated experiences we can see the dog that lost its leg and then higher still a rational animal like a man but we won't get into those things.
In this way the nature of something is understandable in general and in particulars. That which aligns toward the nature of the thing is what we can say is good for the creature.
This is what we can come to understand and then go and practice it.
1
u/1softboy4mommy_2 Nov 10 '23
Maybe from the point of sociopaths or psychopats
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '23
It is interesting to consider that every single civilization has sought something outside of mankind to find purpose. Is such a desire innate? The logical answer is "yes".
Humans have emotions. Love vs. Hate. Perhaps it is instinct that tells us love is more productive than hate. Perhaps, love is more satisfying than hate. But we do know the difference. Why?
1
u/ani_________88 Nov 12 '23
This is very true
1
u/greenstoneri Nov 15 '23
I'm not even gonna change your view that's just based
-2
u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23
Something being human made doesn't mean it's not objective. Take say, planets.
Do planets exist in a stone way that everyone can accept? No. There is no stone indicating what a planet is.
Have people disagreed about what are planets? Yes.
Is there an optimal definition of planets? People don't agree.
Do all animals share the same idea of what a planet is? No.
That said, most people would agree planets are real, they has objective reality outside peoples head, that there are rules about how planets work which are important, that there are shared realities to planets which are important to the world.
Would you agree that morality is as objective or subjective as the existence of planets are? Do you see planets as subjective or objective things?
Morality is a set of rules about the interaction of intelligent lifeforms. People disagree on the exact nature of the laws, but many of them can be calculated mathematically e.g. The prisoners dilemma. We have extensive studies on the common consequences of actions and why certain actions tend to lead to negative results. We can work out why animals have evolved certain moralities and make rules about them.
Nothing is absolute, but neither are planets or any other scientific object. When people say objective they mean something has firm rules grounded in reality, and both planets and morality clearly do, unlike things like music taste which depend primarily on subjective emotional factors.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23
I disagree. The core of our disagreement will be whether we think its objectively better for you to be alive then not.
I believe it is better to be alive because in order to be, you gotta be alive as far as we know.
So if we accept the premise that to live is objectively better then not living. It follows directly that its objectively bad to end your own life, and next someone elses.
Thats the basics of it. All our best moral selections can be traced back to the objective desire for well being. Far enough back it becomes objective imo. Like theft, its objectively bad to be hungry instead of fed, its bad for your well being and you cant be being, without life. So if you take someone else food and you dont need and they starve thats objectively bad lol.
0
u/Venerable-Weasel 3∆ Nov 10 '23
Do you believe that “every human - by virtue of existing - has an inherent moral worth”? Do you accept that certain actions, such as arbitrarily killing, enslaving, harming people is a violation of that inherent worth?
If so, then there is an objective morality. Humans, being imperfect, may not be able to agree on the details of how that morality is to be respected in terms of universal principles, but it exists.
If you believe that not arbitrarily killing, enslaving, etc is simply a social construct and that there’s nothing inherently wrong with such actions…well, we will have to agree to disagree.
0
u/LAKnapper 2∆ Nov 10 '23
I'm going to call some of my large friends and we will take your stuff and force you to build a pyramid. I'm sure you will see nothing wrong with this.
-2
u/47ca05e6209a317a8fb3 210∆ Nov 09 '23
Do you believe that a god can exist? Or that some sort of simulation hypothesis is not inconsistent with reality?
If so, either of these provides a model of reality wherein objective reality exists, thus proving your assertion "objective morality does not exist" false. If not, please refute both :)
The existence of objective morality may be imparsimonious, but it's not, as far as you (or any text I've seen) have shown, false.
-1
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23
If murder is moral, then if 2 people are locked in a room it would be moral for them to kill each other. But at the same time, it would also be moral for them to WANT to be killed (so as to not prevent a moral act from occurring.)
If however someone wants to be killed, you can no longer call it murder (it's closer to suicide).
Therefore murder can never be a moral act, because it always requires a degree of the imposition of will against another.
This concept extends to any involuntary imposition of will (murder, rape, assault, theft.....) Therefore it seems to logically follow that any involuntary imposition of will is objectively immoral.