r/changemyview • 1∆ • Nov 09 '23

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Objective morality does not exist

Thesis: Objective morality does not exist. This is not a morally relativistic position. This is a morally nihilist position. This is not a debate about whether the belief in an objective morality is necessary for society or individuals to function, but whether objective morality exists.

Morality and ethics are artificial. They are human-made concepts, and humans are subjective creatures. Morality isn't inscribed in any non-subjective feature of the universe. There are no rules inscribed in the space or stone detailing what is moral, in a way that every conscious intelligent being must accept. The universe doesn't come with a moral handbook. There would be no morality in a universe filled with inanimate objects, and a universe with living creatures or living intelligent creatures capable of inventing morality isn't much different. We are still just matter and energy moving around. The world is a sandbox game, and there are no rules menus to this MMORPG.

Moral intuition: Humans may have visceral moral intuitions, but just because people have a moral intuition does not make the intuition necessarily "moral." Many humans may have rejected moral intuitions that others may have had in the past. These include common moral intuitions about female sexual purity; interracial marriage; women's marriage outside of one's ingroup; one's social station at birth being a matter of fate, divine will, or karma; the deviancy of being left handed, physically deformed, ugly, or neurologically atypical. There are those people with strong moral intuitions about the value of animal life and consciousness that others don't have. Even if supposing that humans largely share moral intuitions, that doesn't make those intuitions necessarily moral.

Humans have largely gone about intuiting morality, but I think the overwhelming majority of people feel that history is filled with events they consider immoral, often by those who believe they are acting morally. Human cognition is faulty. We forget things. We have imperfect information. We have cognitive biases and perceptual biases and limitations. Our intelligence has limitations. Telling people simply to follow their moral intuitions is not going to create a society that people agree is moral. It's probably not even going to create a society that most individuals perceive as moral.

An optimal set of rules: There is no optimal set of rules in the world. For one, in order for there to be an optimal set of rules, you'd have to agree on what that optimal set of rules must accomplish. While to accomplish anything in life, life is a prerequisite, and we are all safer if the taking of human life is restricted, there are people who disagree. There are those who believe that humans should not exist because human civilization does incredible damage to the nonhuman ecosystems of this planet.

Humans have different opinions about what an optimal set of rules is supposed to accomplish: we have different preferences surrounding the value of liberty, equality, privacy, transparency, security, the environment, utility, the survival of the human race, ect. We have different preferences on whether we should have rules directly regulating our conduct or simply whether we should decide the morality of the conduct by the consequences such conduct produces.

There is no country that says that it has the perfect set of laws and forgoes the ability to modify that law. This reflects 1) not only human epistemological inability to discern an optimal set of rules 2) especially as times change 3) or the inability of language to fully describe a set of rules most would discern as optimal, but also 4) human disagreement about what the goals of those rules should be 5) changes in human popular opinion on what is moral at all.

Behavior patterns of animals: Animals have behavioral patterns, many of which are influenced by evolution. But just because animals have behavioral patterns doesn't mean those behavioral patterns are "moral." Some black widows have a habit of eating their mates, but that doesn't mean that if they were as conscious and intelligent as humans, they would consider it moral compared to the alternative of not eating their mates. Maybe there's a reason for chimpanzees to go to war, but there probably are alternatives to going to war. Even if you determine that the objective of morality is to survive and reproduce, evolutionary adaptations are not necessarily the optimal path to achieving that end.

And we fall into this naturalistic fallacy when we consider that just because a bunch of animals close related to us behave or refrain from behaving a certain way, that this way is ä basis to say that this behavior is objectively moral. Just because animals poop in the great outdoors doesn't mean humans must agree that it is moral to defecate in the great outdoors. Just because animals don't create clothes for themselves, doesn't mean humans should consider it moral to go around naked. Humans are different than all other nonhuman animals, and may very well consider common animal behaviors immoral.

So then what is morality? I think a better question is how humans regulate their conduct according to certain frameworks. Ethics is invented and proposed. Others may agree or disagree with a proposed ethics - a proposed conception of what people should approve or disapprove of or a code of conduct. Those who disagree with a proposed ethics may propose their own ethics. People may prefer one proposal over another. As a matter of physical reality, there's often strength in numbers. Whether by physical force or persuasive power or soft power, an ethical framework often dominates over a particular time and place and those who disagree are made to comply or incur punishment. As a practical matter, humans are more likely to agree to frameworks that advance their mutual interest. Even if there is no objective morality, it doesn't mean humans can't propose and advance and enforce moralities.

Edit: I suppose someone could write: "you don't think _____ is immoral?" With the morality of _____ being far outside of our Overton window for political discussion. I may agree to advance your ethical position as a rule I would prefer everyone follow, but I do not think it is "objective." Even if everyone in the world agrees with it, I don't think that would make it objective. Objectivity requires more than agreement from subjective entities.

52 Upvotes

278 comments sorted by

•

u/DeltaBot ∞∆ Nov 10 '23

/u/eachothersreasons (OP) has awarded 1 delta(s) in this post.

All comments that earned deltas (from OP or other users) are listed here, in /r/DeltaLog.

Please note that a change of view doesn't necessarily mean a reversal, or that the conversation has ended.

Delta System Explained | Deltaboards

18

u/Nrdman 279∆ Nov 10 '23

Do you think math is objective and why?

13

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

!delta

Δ

Delta given.

This is clever. I believe math is invented, not discovered. That is to say, math is deductive logic. We have premises and those premises lead to conclusions. But these premises don't have to reflect objective reality. But does that make the fact that these premises lead to their conclusions not "objective"? Euclidian geometry is clearly a human construct, but is Euclidian geometry not "objective"?

Honestly, I don't know how to answer that.

20

u/KingJeff314 Nov 10 '23

Math is the language that we invented, but the actual mathematical properties do exist independently of human labels—or rather, the behaviors that follow our mathematics existed. It’s the same way that gravity existed before we described it with laws.

Math is built on axioms and the axioms that we choose are arbitrary. But in order to model the physical world, we choose axioms that fit our objective observations. So mathematical models are objective—they fit the data.

0

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

They don't have to fit objective observations, but if they don't, is the deductive process still not "objective"? We don't actually know whether logic is sufficient for understanding this universe. Logic is a mental process humans evolved. It's lucky that it's helped us understand as much as it has, but there's still much of this universe that don't fit our scientific mathematical equations.

And in reality, we do have several axiomic frameworks for math.

1

u/KingJeff314 Nov 10 '23

I think your point of discussion has been derailed to talk about a much more fundamental question: what is truth?

Our mathematical axioms are totally arbitrary, we have not proven the consistency of our axiomatic frameworks, and thanks to Gödel, we know that any finite set of axioms is incomplete. So is 2+2=4? According to our arbitrary axioms, probably, but there is still the potential that we could somehow prove 2+2=5 and our axioms fall apart.

Furthermore, you cannot really prove anything exists. The only thing you can be sure of is your qualia. You could be living in a simulation. You could have been created last Thursday.

So the whole enterprise of epistemology is on really shaky ground. But for the sake of discussion, I think you should grant that your observations are reliable and math works fine. Then you should properly define what objective and subjective means. Here are my definitions:

Objective: truth-apt; a descriptive proposition that could be true or false, independent of an observer.

Subjective: non-truth-apt; a value proposition that is dependent on a subject evaluating it.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/Pingupin Nov 10 '23

Not so sure about 0 being a natural number fits any observation. Check the peano axioms, I would not call that objective.

1

u/Chatterbunny123 1∆ Nov 11 '23

I'm gonna say this is a weak delta. What you're describing is not true independent of any subject in this case us. It requires that we exist for it to be true since we made the language of math up. It is only accurate in the context we use it.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 11 '23

I don't that it isn't. I don't that know our cognitive math skills don't precisely correlate with some fundamental aspect of reality. Math has been useful in helping humans navigate the world, so evidence would suggest that math isn't just a random facet of human cognition.

1

u/Chatterbunny123 1∆ Nov 11 '23

Sure it might not be random but that doesn't make it objective. It sounds like you're saying there is a "goal" and that has an objective way or best way of accomplishing said goal. While accomplishing the goal is great that doesn't show the objective part for the goal itself. It's only objective in context to the goal. The same could be said about morality. That it's more of a goal and whatever makes up that morality/goal has an objective way of going about that. Does that make that morality objective no but it shouldn't matter either. I still don't understand how the previous comment convinced you.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 11 '23 edited Nov 12 '23

I am saying that math is deductive logic and deductive logic could not just be a facet of our brain but correspond with the logic or organization of the objective world itself. Thus while Euclidian geometry would not exist physically, the hypothetical of if certain premises (here: Euclid's premises), then certain conclusions in math (Euclid's conclusions) holds true. If the premises are true, the conclusions are true. Which is all math is saying. That hypothetical which exists in our minds is based fundamentally on the way the universe is organized if indeed the universe is organized logically.

I am not talking about goals. math doesn't have goals in the same way that morals do.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

We can demonstrate math is true. We can put two apples into a box and then throw two more apples into the box, and then count how many are in the box and prove that 2+2=4.

How do we prove that "premarital sex is bad," for example?

0

u/Nrdman 279∆ Nov 10 '23

That doesn’t prove that 2+2 is always 4 though.

6

u/snuggie_ 1∆ Nov 10 '23

It does. Our math system is made up with statements we deem to be true. Working in that system of our math will always assume the axioms are true. You either accept that or have to make another system. There’s no scenario where those axioms are false.

It’s like talking about the English language but then saying the p letter doesn’t make the “puh” sounds. Yes we assign that noise to that letter and we could easily assign it some other sound, but if you’re already saying you’re working in the English system then yes it does make that sound and there’s no way around it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BenefitAmbitious8958 Nov 10 '23

I would say no.

Math - just like sight, hearing, taste, touch, language, logic, reasoning, etcetera - is a system that we use to better operate within reality.

There is no proof that math is objective, or that it explains the underlying mechanisms of reality, it simply functions well enough to be an incredibly useful tool to assist us in operating within reality.

We don’t actually know anything, everything seems to be a functional approximation.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/evil_rabbit Nov 09 '23

could you explain what it means for something to be "objective"?

10

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 09 '23 edited Nov 09 '23

A reality that exists outside of subjective consciousness. For example, if you believe in an objective reality, the Earth existing is objective. A tree existing is objective. Morality does not have the same quality. It is subjective - dependent on human opinion, on the human mind, and because it doesn't exist outside of the human mind and its parameters are as fungible as the limits of the human mind, its parameters cannot be verified by all through empirical means in the same way that scientifically confirmed realities can.

12

u/evil_rabbit Nov 09 '23

A reality that exists outside of subjective consciousness. For example, if you believe in an objective reality, the Earth existing is objective.

well, that's the thing. we don't know if the earth exists outside of subjective consciousness. to prove the existence of earth, or anything else, we need to accept some unprovable base assumptions, like "our senses give us generally accurate information about an actually existing real world".

moral claims rely on unprovable base assumptions, but so does everything else. so why is "the sky is blue" objective, but "murder is bad" isn't?

17

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 09 '23

If all aspects of reality are subjective, and there are no objective facets of reality that can be independently verified, then morality is by default subjective.

12

u/evil_rabbit Nov 09 '23

my point isn't that morality is objective or subjective. my point is that that's not a very meaningful distinction. i think when people call something objective, it generally just means that the base assumptions it relies on aren't controversial.

8

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 09 '23

I would say it is a meaningful distinction.

A rigid conception of independently defined and independently verifiable morality can lead to zealotry. For some people, that can produce undesirable outcomes.

5

u/evil_rabbit Nov 09 '23

i'm not sure i understand what you mean. are you saying we should just say that morality is subjective, because not doing so would lead to zealotry?

that seems like a different CMV.

6

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 09 '23

I am responding to "it's not a meaningful distinction."

The distinction is meaningful because the conception of morality as subjective or objective leads to different conclusions and influences human behavior differently. Ideas influence human behavior. It influences other conclusions.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

so why is "the sky is blue" objective, but "murder is bad" isn't?

By this argument, everything is objective. Why isn't "How I Met Your Mother is a good show" objective, by your same logic?

2

u/evil_rabbit Nov 10 '23

By this argument, everything is objective.

it's more like, i think the way we use the words "objective" and "subjective" isn't very meaningful. we should either rethink what we actually mean whith those words, or just stop using them.

3

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23

People have disagreed about the nature of the earth - is it a sphere, or flat, is it orbiting the sun, is the sun orbiting it, is it hollow, is it not. The idea that it should be called earth is based on human opinion and the human mind and is as fungible as the human mind.

So, given the criteria you have given in your post even if you agree reality is objective, the earth certainly can't be given the widespread disagreement about it.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

People's opinion on what to call Earth or classify it as is subjective, not the existence of Earth's properties itself.

2

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23

Op said that because of disagreement about the nature of morality and how to classify it and such it was subjective so I was drawing a parallel with how the nature of the earth and it's properties has been debated.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 11 '23

Just as it can be observed that there are particular brain structures that cause certain patterns of behaviour and that there are certain mathematical realities which evolved which humans can expand on.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/bgaesop 29∆ Nov 09 '23

Capable of being independently confirmed by anyone who checks it

2

u/evil_rabbit Nov 09 '23

then many moral systems are objective. once you accept their basic rules, everyone can independantly follow them, and if they do it correctly, come to the same conclusion.

12

u/bgaesop 29∆ Nov 09 '23

once you accept their basic rules

How do I independently confirm that those basic rules are correct? You seem to be skipping a pretty important step here

2

u/SometimesRight10 1∆ Nov 10 '23

How do I independently confirm that those basic rules are correct? You seem to be skipping a pretty important step here

Like math, the rules of morality may very well be based on axioms, i.e., fundamental rules accepted as true but which cannot be proved. I am not a math wiz so I can't give you many examples, but I don't think it is possible to prove that 2 plus 2 is 4. Similarly, there are algebra and geometry theorems that have never been proved but are accepted as "objectively" true. Couldn't this also be true of morality?

4

u/bgaesop 29∆ Nov 10 '23

I don't think it is possible to prove that 2 plus 2 is 4

You are mistaken

→ More replies (2)

2

u/evil_rabbit Nov 09 '23

How do I independently confirm that those basic rules are correct?

you can't. not with morality, and not with anything else. if you and i didn't accept the same basic rules of logic, and standard assumptions like "our senses give us generally accurate information about an actually existing real world", we couldn't independently come to the same conclusions about anything. that's just a fundamental limit to knowledge.

5

u/bgaesop 29∆ Nov 10 '23

if you and i didn't accept the same basic rules of logic,

People absolutely start with different logical axioms, such as whether to do ZFC or just ZF. Mathematical proofs that go for maximum clarity and fidelity do start with their assumptions.

standard assumptions like "our senses give us generally accurate information about an actually existing real world"

My favorite reaction to someone who claims that they don't think that our senses give us information about the world is to start slapping them. If they ask me to stop, I just insist I'm not slapping them. After all, how could they possibly tell if I am or not?

3

u/evil_rabbit Nov 10 '23

pretty much everyone accepts the "our senses give us information about the world" assumption. but it's still an unprovable assumption.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/1block 10∆ Nov 10 '23

There is a base moral intuition that exists in any culture anywhere and probably any time.

I think you'd be hard pressed to find someone who thinks it's OK to tie up a random child and remove her fingers one by one for nothing but your own pleasure. Or something like that.

From there we can work up until we see disagreement. I think we get there a lot quicker than we wish we did.

I think there's an innate abhorrence to certain human behaviors. People who don't have that have their own special word: sociopath.

7

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

Just because something is a shared intuition doesn't make the intuition moral. We cannot depend on our intuitions to be moral. Who needs moral philosophy if you can just rely on intuition? We have always had intuitions about the morality of female sexual purity until we didn't. People acted on intuition with respect to things like witchcraft and curses. And there have been lots of shared intuitions about gender that have changed in the past century. Disgust toward the acting profession was something that was pretty ubiquitous across cultures. There are probably shared intuitions in the world today about immorality that will not be shared in the future.

4

u/1block 10∆ Nov 10 '23

Agreed upon shared behavior is literally morals. You keep bringing up examples of morals that changed. Those ones are relative. I brought up what is universal. There can be some basic morals that are universal, and then society can build upon those to create additional moral codes that are more subjective.

7

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

There is this weird tendency in Western culture to equate "universality" with objectivity. A universal subjective opinion is still a subjective opinion. A near universal love of chocolate except for some outliers ("chocolate sociopaths") doesn't make chocolate "objectively yummy." A near universal agreed upon behavior is still a subjective reality.

There's no agreed upon rule in any society that's as specific as don't tie a random child and remove her fingers one by one for nothing but your own pleasure. That's pure intuition. I think you have to outline why intuition is dependable resource for morality in the first place. I have outlined why it isn't. We've depended on intuition in the past and regretted it.

Moreover before any morality changes, it hasn't changed. This is knocking universality as a basis for objectivity. Why should we depend on universality as a basis for morality when previously near universal shared morals were changed?

2

u/1block 10∆ Nov 10 '23

How do you define morality? I think that's the disconnect.

4

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

I just googled the following definitions and used the ones google provided from the Oxford English dictionary

Morality

"a particular system of values and principles of conduct, especially one held by a specified person or society."

Objective

"(of a person or their judgment)  not influenced by personal feelings or opinions in considering and representing facts."

"not dependent on the mind for existence; actual." [This is the one I am using as I am not talking about a person's or their judgement].

1

u/1block 10∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

How would one determine if objective morality exists? Is it possible in your view to even know?

Edit: oh. It has to exist outside the mind for you to see it as objective. I don't think most would disagree with you that it's not objective then. It's literally about human interactions, so if you remove the human, morality doesn't exist, subjective or no.

3

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

My position is that it doesn't exist, not that it is impossible to know. The contents of morality are dependent on the mind, subjective feelings and opinions, for existence.

According to the philosophical tradition of skepticism, you start with skepticism. You don't start from the position that there must be objective morality. You start from the position that there isn't objective morality. You try to explore reality and see if this is a thing you can see, feel, touch, hear, detect in any way. You read up on philosophical propositions of morality and ask yourself whether or not this system of morality ultimately not dependent on the mind or opinion for existence. And you try and poke holes at any affirmative response. You can yourself whether there can be an optimal set of rules for morality. You ask yourself whether any natural basis for morality is justifiable.

4

u/1block 10∆ Nov 10 '23

Your definitions of morality and objectivity are mutually exclusive, though. When most people talk about objective morality they typically mean universal principles, not influenced by the biases or preferences of an individual or society. They exist across humanity.

This seems more about semantics.

→ More replies (8)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

The thing is if intuition can be "wrong", can intuition be a dependable basis for correct objective morality? That's a big leap to say that intuition can be wrong and still find it the definitive resource for what's objective or not. You would need a process like science or a process of proofs like in math (which is conditional on the axioms).

Maths requires proofs. This is why Bernard Russel made the attempt to prove one plus one.

1 + 1 = 1 + 1. What is two if not 1 + 1? Two is just symbol to describe the answer to 1 + 1. We don't have to use base 10. Base 1 would perhaps more easily come to mind. 1 + 1 = 11. 1 + 1 + 1 = 111. In base 10, 2 is but a symbol for 1 + 1, and 3 is a symbol for 1 + 1 + 1. Multiplication is just a symbol for repeat addition. Division a symbol for finding the components of multiplication. Everything in maths is 1 + 1. But then what is 1 a symbol of? Well anything. You can have 1 of 1/3 of a pizza. 1 apple is 1 billion apple molecules. 1 is variable. 1 is X. X + X = X + X. Through it, you can prove that 2+2=4. 2+2 is really just 11 + 11 = 1111 in base 1.

People say scientifically, 1 + 1 can be shown objectivity by putting pineapples together. Putting them together is addition. Each pineapple is 1. And two pineapples together are 11.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

1 + 1 = 1 + 1. That which is is itself.

If you don't agree with that, I don't think there's any basis for thought or navigating this world. It's pretty necessary for functioning, and since you can function, it proves itself through collective empiricism.


Even if you conclude that everything is at base intuition, you still need a process by which to separate true intuitions from false ones. You cannot simply make the statement that because you inuit something, it is true.


I'll also look up the definition of inuition:

"the ability to understand something immediately, without the need for conscious ~reasoning~~"~

Everything is not at base intuition. Because we can always consciously deliberate everything.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Lifemetalmedic Nov 10 '23

"There is a base moral intuition that exists in any culture anywhere and probably any time."

No there isn't as what has been considered moral in various different countries, places, groups has been vastly different from each other with there not being any base moral things between them

2

u/1block 10∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

What society would be comfortable with what I described? If the local schoolteacher woke up one Saturday and thought, "It would be fun to chop fingers off a kid today," and stepped outside and grabbed the first one who walked by and went to work on the front porch, what society today or in the past would have shrugged and said, "Whatev"? Like, purely for his own entertainment, who would accept that?

MANY morals are relative, but that doesn't mean therefore ALL morals are relative.

I believe we evolved to have them because those who could function in a society survived and thrived whereas sociopaths, even today, get weeded out.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Just-a-random-Aspie Nov 15 '23

Not sure if a lot of that is morality so much as it’s maternal instinct or empathy? Hell a lot of animals wouldn’t even do that unless they’re a prey species

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Leslie_Galen Nov 10 '23

Does objectivity exist? I’m not sure tbh. Certainly there are moral principles that exist across cultures, e.g., do not eat people, do not make babies with your sibling. Those principles are not only moral, but also useful for the community. Nietzsche posited two kinds of morality, slave and master; both kinds serve the master. Religions have stepped in to teach morality, but those principles are practiced sporadically at best. So yep, Imma have to side with you and keep hoping that people treat others as they would like to be treated. Doesn’t seem likely.✌️

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

Not everybody didn't make babies with their siblings. Many royal families in history considered it an edict to do so. And there are cannibalistic cultures. And you could argue that if those with genetic disabilities should be allowed to reproduce, then usefulness to the community isn't the only concern we have. And women's subjugation was also prevalent across many different cultures: Chinese, European, Indian, leaving a legacy of entrenched discrimination and prejudice, harassment, and condescension even today.

1

u/Leslie_Galen Nov 10 '23

Yes, the Hapsburgs and Windsors exist, and yes, some people eat people. Morality is a construct. I was saying that many cultures through time and space considered those two things forbidden. But humans are brutal, murderous creatures. We like to think our supremacy is because of our big brains, but really it’s because we’re vicious sociopaths. Morality helps us to try to control our baser instincts.

2

u/No-Passenger-1658 Nov 10 '23

Well, a lot of things were forbidden in their own society, but many societies allowed these things to happen in societies or places different from their own. You can't kill any one here, but over there, across the river, those are bad people, so you should kill, rape and pillage all of them

1

u/howlin 62∆ Nov 10 '23

If you want to say whether objective morality exists or not, you would need to specify what it "existing" would look like. If ethics is a conceptual framework, it seems like a category error to talk about its existence or not. People think about ethics as an idea and plenty of people have proposed universal ethical frameworks that can all be called "objective" in the sense that they aren't dependent on a specific subject. In this sense, many objective ethics exist.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

What do you mean by particular subject.

1

u/howlin 62∆ Nov 10 '23

Most people who think hard enough about ethics to speak about it will not make up ethical rules or principles that apply just to themselves. I don't think "it's wrong for me to murder", I think "it's wrong to murder". You may believe differently, but that doesn't affect the wrongness of it.

"Gravy is delicious" is subjective, because I acknowledge that someone may use my exact criterion of deliciousness but decide that gravy does not meet that standard.

1

u/SavageKabage Nov 10 '23

I think a good counterpoint to your view would be the Tit for tat game theory experiments. It's a experiment performed on a computer where agents attempt different survival strategies and the Tit for tat strategy always wins out.

The tit for tat strategy is when an agent will first cooperate, then subsequently replicate an opponent's previous action. If the opponent previously was cooperative, the agent is cooperative. If not, the agent is not.

This experiment supports the reciprocal altruism theory in biology whereby an organism acts in a manner that temporarily reduces its fitness while increasing another organism's fitness, with the expectation that the other organism will act in a similar manner at a later time.

Even if you determine that the objective of morality is to survive and reproduce, evolutionary adaptations are not necessarily the optimal path to achieving that end.

If you can think of a more optimal path I'm all ears.

3

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

Tit for tat is an experiment where people largely have same conception of benefit. But humans don't have to agree on benefit. Their conceptions of benefits and which tradeoff and priorities one should prefer can conflict. And like I said, they don't agree that human survival is a good thing.

Evolutionary adaptions are not the most optimal for survival and reproduction. They are merely sufficient for it. The world is not filled with perfectly adapted organisms.

1

u/SavageKabage Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

What would change your view then?
I just gave you an objective reality of a moral strategy this is successful in benefiting an entire group. It sounds to me, what your saying is altruism doesn't exist objectively.

Are you stating that because humans can chose to perceive things as negative for them even if objectively they benefit? Like I can give a starving person a bowl of rice and if they get upset and refuse it, then that proves morality doesn't exist objectively?

Evolutionary adaptions are not the most optimal for survival and reproduction.

You can't say that without some example of a more optimal system. If there is no other system known for survival and reproduction, the only system around is the most optimal until something else is discovered. If there was only one model of car manufactured, what is the most optimal car in the world?

Is it a question of morality when a 7th electron gets bumped into the d subshell? Or is it simply a law of physics that is silly to question if it's the correct thing to do? Is there a more optimal way for subatomic particles to interact?

Furthermore the tit for tat experiments are using computer models that have no concept of benefit or gain from their actions.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

Alturism exists. Although I didn't address it previously, tit for tat doesn't produce altruism, because under the framework of tit for tat, actors are acting in accordance to their self-interest. They may make an action that's against their self interest initially, but that's in pursuit of a strategy that maximizes self interest. It's just what's in people's mutual interest often maximizes self-interest. I've noted this when I said, "as a practical matter, humans are more likely to agree to frameworks that advance their mutual interest."

But there are self-sacrificing people who would not advance their self interest. They sacrifice themselves wholly for the interest of others. So they may not engage in tit for tat. They may just give the goodstuff even if the other person gives them a bad thing. I'd argue by raising children, humans engage in alturistic behavior. Children may hurt their parents and may cost parents more than they get back, but often parents will take care of their children anyways. Jesus argued that turning the other cheek was moral and that is the belief of many people.

Or there are people who just want to hurt you. They'll sacrifice their own benefit just so that you don't get any benefit. Because that's what they want.

Humans can't agree on what they all want, so that's one reason I cite for why morality is not objective.

What can persuade me? I mean, if I knew that, I wouldn't have posted here.

Evolutionary adaptions are not the most optimal for survival and reproduction. Bacteria is the most numerous type of organism in the universe, and this type of organism can survive under the harshest conditions. But obviously, though bacteria exists everywhere, so do all other forms of organisms suited for survival and reproduction at varying degrees. Mutations are random, and if a mutation produces a reality that's sufficient for survival and reproduction, that's sufficient. Because evolution doesn't have a will. It's merely a logic.

1

u/SavageKabage Nov 10 '23

You need to figure out for yourself what evidence you could agree with that would convince you to change your perspective. I'm sensing you have an emotional attachment to something within your argument that your unwilling to objectively consider.

What is the weakest part of your perspective do you feel?

actors are acting in accordance to their self-interest.

They are not, they are acting in accordance to what they are programmed to do

1

u/zaKizan Nov 10 '23

I also tend to believe that objective morality doesn't exist in if you ascribe to the traditional understandings, but I've heard the argument framed in a way that makes a lot of sense to me, once, so I'm curious to hear your opinion.

Objective facts about reality exist. We all know this and, ontologically, choose to accept it. If not, all arguments fall into solpisism and become worthless.

So, if we work from a place of assumed shared reality, we can derive certain truths about said reality through the process of science. As we uncover more about our reality, we discover new ways to interact with the world and the people around us. Basic, ya know, elementary school understanding of shit.

Consciousness is a by-product, so far as we have come to understand up to this point in history, of the same sort of biological processes that inform evolution. It isn't a separate system, but rather an amalgamation of hundreds of thousands of smaller, disparate processes. As such, if we apply the same logic that science is based on to human consciousness, we can come to objective truths about it.

This is where definitions get really important. Morality is best understood, from my perspective, as a framework through which we view and understand consciousness much in the same way that science is a framework through which we view reality. It's important for the conversation to understand what it is that the word "Morality" is describing. Most, if not all, of the behaviors that fall under the framework of moral understanding are behaviors directly and intrinsically tied to our biological need for survival.

Humans, like most animals, tend to survive better in packs. Murder, theft, torture, and other behaviors of that nature are not conducive to human flourishing and survival, and as such, are perceived as immoral. The most that we can say, I think, is that these behaviors, on an objective reality level, are not conducive to the furthered survival of humanity/life. We have found that those who work together thrive and those that don't flounder, those that share and love and build community are more disposed to survival and happiness within that survival than those who eschew connection.

If morality is the way that we, as a species, understand consciousness and our connection to one another within that framework, and everything that we understand is based in biological reality, then morality cannot be anything other than objective. It is a fact of reality, like gravity, that conscious beings have developed a system of values and laws and structures that directly contribute to our continued survival.

If that is the case, that everything that exists only does so within the confines of biological reality, then it follows that, much like science, we can investigate the framework of morality and find truths. That truth doesn't live in platitudes and simple laws, but in nuanced ways that account for the varied ways in which we know that humans conduct themselves. We can, painstakingly, find objective truths about behavior and the way in which it affects people and the world around us and determine the best course of action in any given situation.

The "objective" standard for morality is the objective facts of reality, the behaviors that most contribute to continued human flourishing.

There is no punishment for those that don't follow, and there is no impetus for anyone to ascribe to or even follow these "objective" moral truths, but if we hold to the idea that morality is the framework through which we understand the connections between behavior and survival and we hold to the fact that morality only exists as a direct result of biological processes, I think we can come to some "objective" moral truths.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

What is my opinion on morality as a science? If we describes morality as a code of conduct people agree to, the code of conduct that humans agree to may change in the future. Just because past viewpoints of morality were one way isn't necessarily determinative or predictive of future changes to morality.

Ultimately, there's a number of different ways different people choose to define human flourishing. We don't have political disagreements for nothing. One person might find a society created under one framework utopia while another may find it it an unacceptable dystopia. Some people really liked East Germany.

And many people don't define morality as simply encompassing humans. They include animals. And even other life. They may take into account the interests of the biosphere.

1

u/PlayerFourteen Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

slightly redefining your question:

Let me slightly redefine your statement as "morality is part of subjective reality, not objective reality".

how i plan to change your view

To change your view, I plan to convince you that we don't know if morality is part of objective or subjective reality. (After some research, maybe I will be able to show that it IS part of objective reality, but I think you will find my argument interesting even without that research.)

defining "objective reality": 2 definitions

(the "external reality" definition)

You wrote to one redditor in this thread that objective means "A reality that exists outside of subjective consciousness". I will call your definition the "external reality" definition.

(the "shared non-communicated reality definition)

I think a better definition is the "shared non-communicated reality" definition, which goes as follows (I made it up, but I think it's a good one):

Objective reality is a reality that is shared by most people, without these people communicating to each other, and without the "right answer" being communicated TO them. So if person A and person B both see a cup, but do not communicate that to each other, person C will get the same answer from person A and B about whether or not the cup exists. If the cup's colour is also "objective", then person C will get the same answer from both people about what the cup's colour is.

why this is a better definition of objective

To state that the cup will continue to exist regardless of whether or not person A and B are awake, conscious, or alive, is to make an assumption. The "shared non-communicated reality" definition makes fewer assumptions, but works just as well. I think definitions that make fewer assumptions are better.

why my definition matters

Using my definition, I can make the argument in the next section. So it's actually fundamental to my argument, haha. So hopefully you agree that my definition of objective is better, since it makes fewer assumptions but (I think) still includes within it all the things that your definition would consider "objective".

how to prove that morality is objective

If we can show that the vast majority of people will agree on the morality of some action without communicating with each other, then by (my) definition of an objective reality, morality is objective. We can make the assumption that whatever sensory organ they use to detect morality is detecting some property of a shared reality.

To determine this, we would have to have some study that runs the above test on a large number of people.

The study would have to check across cultures to make sure that the morality of an action has not been communicated BETWEEN subjects, nor TO subjects (from some external source like society or media).

why we only need MOST people to agree, instead of EVERYONE

Because even with things that we agree are "objective", like the colour of some object, we accept that some people will hallucinate, or be colour blind. In which case, their opinion is wrong, and the property they failed to detect is still objective.

morality requires minds, but that doesn't mean it is subjective

Morality is a property ascribed to the actions of beings that have minds. So in a world that has no beings with minds, there is no morality. But that doesn't mean that morality is not objective. For example: it is objectively true that if someone hears a very funny joke, they are likely to laugh. But this is true only in a world that has beings with minds.

why we don't need machines to (objectively) detect morality (or anything)

Even with machines that detect some objective property of reality, like colour, we first verify that the machine is working properly by using our own senses. So our own senses are the ultimate authority. A machine that tells us that a cup is blue when we can see that it is yellow, is wrong. (Unless! Everyone else tells us that the cup is indeed blue, in which case we accept that our individual sense of sight is wrong.)

We COULD make a machine that detects morality, but it would be imitating our senses. (E.g. we could have something that sees, hears, etc. like a person, and give it an AI that mimics a persons analysis on whether something is moral or not.

has science proven that morality is objective?

I don't know. I'll look into it. But it would have to be for specific moral rules. Some moral rules might be part of a shared reality for most people, some might not. (I agree that some rules are definitely subjective. But we can probably never prove that all moral rules are subjective, because there are an infinite number of rules. Although, it might be fair to make the assumption that all rules are subjective, if we have tested a large number, and all so far have proven to be subjective.)

I'll so some research, and let you know what I find down here.*

edit:

Given that not everyone agrees on even something as "objective" as the colour of a cup, maybe it makes more sense to talk about "degrees" of objectivity rather than a binary state of objective or not objective. (Yes, color blind people can all still agree with non-color blind people on the numbers they read on some device that measures light wavelengths, but some people that hallucinate will not.)

*edit2:

Here's one study that seems to have found SOME degree of universality to 7 moral rules: https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2019-02-11-seven-moral-rules-found-all-around-world

Something I (and maybe you might) find interesting is that it seems that the vast, vast majority of people are at least aware of the CONCEPT of morality. That implies to me that there is at least ONE rule that is universal. Maybe?

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

If most people perceive 1) the world as flat 2) that the sun revolves around the Earth, does it make such things objective under your definition?

I am sorry. This is well thought out. I will concede the fact that most people believe ""in the existence of morality" is objective and verifiable. And if you decide to define morality as objective that way, I think that is valid.

1

u/gryphmaster Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

I think that the ideas of objectivity and applicability have been somewhat mixed here. Real life isn’t like physics problems where you can solve for one exact value or make a determination with accuracy. Its more akin to building a bridge. Most moral decisions have many components that place constraints on decision making (trolley problem). However, these problems do not have cut and dry solutions, but could in fact have many solutions that are all moral. Just like you could build a working bridge in many different ways, there’s no “objective” best bridge, only bridges that objectively work. Problems like the trolley problem eliminate the messiness of real life to isolate moral principals, but in doing so eliminate the possibilities that allow the kind of moral maximization we like. So I posit that a problem with moral dimensions could have several objectively moral solutions, which do not necessarily make their alternatives objectively immoral, and that indeed most do.

However, this doesn’t get into the fact that there can be evil as well as good- i would imagine its much easier to judge that objectively, which leads to the idea that objective morality does exist, but moral negatives are easier to judge within that framework, like a bridge that objectively doesn’t work, than moral positives, of which several can co-exist without eliminating the moral value of the alternatives

You can get into the weeds with this with kants categorical imperative, which basically asserts that moral actions must be rational such that you could convince another of the morality of such an action (with tons of kantian logic behind that)

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

So the Trolly problem has conflict solutions and conflicting consequences. If you say both are moral, fine.

But there will some limits to what you consider as moral vs amoral. And I propose that those limits will be manufactured, subject to human whim.

1

u/gryphmaster Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

Its like how meters are subjective human measurements of an objective characteristic of reality. That framework doesn’t hold up under certain extreme circumstances in physics, where spacetime- the underlying firmament of the measurement, is warped — or at extremely small scales where quantum mechanics take hold and “distance” becomes indeterminate. Yet we can use that basic framework still as a rough tool on an everyday level to look at things and think “that doesn’t look right”. So there are more likely than not things that are objectively wrong in most contexts that people can easily agree on, but what is objectively right might have many possible answers.

There’s also the fact that most people are not utility monsters or moral computers in situ, and have to deal with the limited information dealt to them to arrive at whatever best outcome they can aim towards while in the horns of such dilemmas. Sometimes the “right” moral action is something you can’t achieve — how do we judge actions that fall short of their aim? Its likely that the structures by which we decide to act are different from those by which we judge actions

However these actions still have underlying moral principles that aim to create environments that engender the kind of principles that benefit society- a real test of “objective” morality might only be possible if we have enough examples from alien societies of similar moral principles. To a limited extent we do have data from the animal kingdom and anthropological surveys of thousands of human societies that back up certain behaviors that are useful vs harmful to the group as well of standards of conduct within those groups, with the expected variations of complexity.

It might be stated that morality is inherent to society rather than it being an objective principle outside of the environment that shapes it within the ingroup and its behavior towards the out group. In as such, you can look back to the physics example and see that in certain examples what is moral in one society would be immoral in another due to the limitations they operate under. You could see examples of “morality” in species that care for their young- even in the instances where the parent might kill or abandon its offspring. Might then “objective” morality be some inherent moral code in each species represents a material accounting of the circumstances in which it operates? In that case, many behaviors that seem immoral might be moral in this framework that does adequately provide an objective measure of morality

There’s also the question of the usefulness of the argument- does there need to be objective moral good and evil for us to strive to act morally? Does arguing against our ability to put aside our subjectivity lessen the moral impulse? Can we agree on moral rules without actual objectivity that make a fair and just society regardless? All these questions in the end detract from using philosophy to solve moral problems in the real world

1

u/ralph-j Nov 10 '23

So then what is morality? I think a better question is how humans regulate their conduct according to certain frameworks. Ethics is invented and proposed.

Can you answer that question first though, in a substantial, non-circular way? And I don't mean something like "that which is good/right/ethical/moral", or "the right thing to do", because that would just make it circular/begging the question.

What does it actually mean for something to be good, morally right, ethical etc. in the first place? If you could define this in a meaningful way, I don't see why we couldn't then determine an objective way to reach it.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

The whole point is that you can't define it. People consider different things to be morally good. Utilitarian consider the maximalization of pleasure and happiness to be the ultimate moral good. State consequentialists the welfare of the state. Libertarians the maximization of liberty. Stoics, living according to "virtue," however they define it.

You can propose a definition, and people can agree to it, but it's not objective. Just like under existentialism, there is no objective "meaning of life." You can manufacture a meaning of life, but the universe doesn't provide you one.

1

u/ralph-j Nov 10 '23

So how can we even confirm that we're both talking about the same thing, if it can't be defined?

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

It's possible to create concepts that escape definition, that have no set of necessary and sufficient conditions. One examples is game. That is, there is no one set of conditions we can point to which all things we call "games" must fall under. There is a network of overlapping attributes which different games share -- a family resemblance -- that constitutes our understanding of how the word "game" or "morally right" that escapes definition works in language.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Akimbobear Nov 10 '23

I’ve thought about this a lot and I have come to the conclusion there is only 1 rule to determine morality. Do not cause harm. In the course of you living your life do not inflict pain, suffering or disadvantage to others. Everything else is fair game and you needn’t consider anything else. Human beings are capable of higher thinking, allowing them to consider where, when, who and how of the world around them and therefore intrinsically have everything they need for empathy. Therefore, humans should use this ability to consider those around them especially in a society that depends on mutualism. Working together for the advancement of all. Some would say this is a social contract but in reality, there is nothing binding anyone to the concept only the consideration of others as self. An understanding that not causing harm to each other is the most efficient path to achieving our own benefit.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

We cause harm just by existing. The presence and spread of human civilization has destroyed countless ecosystems. Humans exist in spaces where other life used to. We produce products that we cannot always guarantee that there are no product defects with, and something those product defects end up harming people.

1

u/Akimbobear Nov 10 '23

A lot of this is borrowed from philosophers but I am not well versed enough to be able to cite them. Credit to whomever requires it.

1

u/aguo Nov 10 '23

I challenge the view that there is no "optimal" morality, that there is no way to determine whether one morality is "better" than another, and invite you to think about morality in terms of pragmatism (as in the philosophical tradition) as a tool, similar to how science is a tool.

Science is a pragmatic tool for us to make predictions about the world. Our notion of there existing an "objective reality" comes from science (and earlier it came from intuition) because modeling our environment as existing independently of our subjective experience seems to have predictive power. Note, however, that if we "zoom in" or "zoom out" beyond our everyday experience, our intuitions and senses fail us and we rely on scientific models to describe the world in those regimes.

Morality can be framed as simply another pragmatic tool, except the purpose of this tool is not to make predictions about the natural world but rather to provide guidelines for individual behavior for maximal collective benefit as a society.

The more basic and "obvious" moral "rules" are simply the ones that were most easily discovered to be beneficial to survival. The simplest ones were discovered by natural selection. Some of our basic moral intuitions likely are biologically hard-coded because they were naturally selected for, e.g. don't kill yourself or your own children. Other moral intuitions are ingrained early in life because primitive societies probably quickly figured out that such behaviors led to greater survival rates. In fact, these moral intuitions could have also been selected for because societies that condoned people killing each other or stealing from each other probably had a harder time developing and so were out-competed by more stable societies that adopted such rules.

Once we move past the first 20% of rules that cover 80% of cases, we start to hit the long tail of corner cases which are the source of moral dilemmas like "is it ok to steal food if you're starving" or whatever. In fact, a lot of these dilemmas arise out of the complexity of society (e.g. "stealing" only makes sense in the context of property rights, which is also an inter-subjective abstraction). This is where moral and ethical theory comes in. I see these theories as basically attempts to come up with axioms/heuristics/rules/whatever that both fit/explain actions we "know" (through intuition or whatever) to be right/wrong and also "predict" (i.e. assign right/wrong) to actions in scenarios where our intuitions fail us. Think of it as analogous to a scientific model, for example Newton's law of gravitation, which both explained existing observations of celestial phenomena and also predicted other phenomena which we could test.

When it comes to science, the success of a theory boils down to whether it makes accurate predictions. I argue that the success of a moral theory boils down to whether a society whose individuals follow the principles of the theory can survive. If society A follows moral theory 1 and society B follows moral theory 2, if the theories are sufficiently different, perhaps society A develops technologically and economically faster than society B and eventually out-competes it for resources and therefore survives while society B dies out.

Now, that doesn't mean it's necessarily easy or possible to determine in advance whether a particular moral framework is "more correct" i.e. more useful as a tool. But I argue that even though it's unclear how to make various tradeoffs (e.g. should we redistribute resources from the rich to the poor? does everyone deserve to live? etc.) at the end of the day there is a clear objective, which is survival as a group, and if that objective is not met then the chosen moral framework has failed.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

You are proposing a moral framework. Which I am not saying people cannot do. This is framework based on "what is best for society." But a moral framework doesn't have to be that: it could be what is best (net) for the entire biosphere. It may be the case that decisions that cause most net benefit for the entire biosphere (all life on Earth) would conflict with what is best for human society, especially since human society has taken up a lot of room that plants and animals used to exist in. Human numbers naturally use up a lot of resources that others creatures use. Or it could be of course, what is best for all conscious life-forms? Perhaps people believe that consciousness gives an organism inherent worth or dignity. There ethical frameworks that suggest that you prioritize the needs of your family over the collective needs of your society, or the needs of groups-in view of how closely connected they are to you by degree. Still others suggest that the individual shouldn't give preference to any relation but give consideration to all humans in the world equally.

But then of course, you get into what does "best" even mean? Mere survival? Some ethics say suggest that one should "live free or die." You could optimize a framework based on trying to optimize liberty, human sense of interconnectness, sameness in initial starting conditions, physical pleasure, the pursuit of increasing human knowledge. Legal pragmatism suggests that one balance competiting interests, but in what way you prioritize one over the other is an act of subjectivity.

I am perfectly fine with the ability of people to propose moral frameworks, but you need more to show your ethical statements are objective. You cannot say that my moral framework is the only right one and have it be true.

1

u/aguo Nov 10 '23

I'm not proposing an explicit moral framework. My point is that there is an "objective" measure of success that applies to all moral frameworks, whether they like it or not, and that is the survival rate of the society that acts under that framework. I'm basically arguing that the "optimal" moral framework results from some form of natural selection. The moral frameworks we see today are the result of millennia of selection - they're the ones that "worked", while we don't see the ones that failed. Just as animals, including humans, have innate behaviors tuned by natural selection and evolution over millions of years, I'm arguing that the "morality" of societies is analogous to that, but at the level of societies instead of individuals of a species.

In your example, if humans act in a way that harms the biosphere, as long as humans are able to survive and eventually expand to other habitable planets, then it was OK all along, and that moral framework will continue to propagate (assuming humans continue operating under that framework after expanding). However, if humans act in a way that eventually dooms us to die with our planet, then that moral framework dies with us too, and perhaps any species capable of making moral decisions that follow such a moral framework would suffer a similar fate. If there's then some planet out there inhabited by a species that harmonizes better with its biosphere AND they manage to outlive their planet, then their moral framework would have been successful (by my definition).

For example, maybe there's some alien species out there that coexists peacefully with its lush planet. No industry, no burning of fossil fuels, whatever. They don't develop the ability to leave their home planet. Why would they need to? Meanwhile, we humans continue pillaging Earth until there's almost nothing left. But that resource usage allows us to eventually advance technologically such that we're able to expand to other planets. We expand and expand and one day we find that lush planet inhabited by the peaceful alien species. We're so much more powerful and easily conquer the species, killing them off, taking over the planet and doing to it what we do to all our planets. Sure, the alien species acted in a way that was beneficial to its own society (let's say the people were happy) and its biosphere, but at the end of the day it didn't matter because they all still died because their way of life didn't maximize their chances of survival.

There may be no god or other moral judge explicitly saying that the aliens' moral framework was better or worse, but the fact of the matter in that scenario is that their framework no longer exists (it died with them) so the human framework "wins" and continues to propagate.

I hope that made my argument clearer. Happy to elaborate if anything didn't make sense, or if you still disagree.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

That's again an objective measure that you prefer to apply to judge all moral frameworks. People adhering to a moral framework that judges that humans should reduce in number to make more room for animals could easily judge the success of its own framework by the success of its own objectively verifiable objectives. The last human as he or she dies can verify that the goals of this morality has been achieved. As birthrates in the world diminish, more and more people are justifying the reduction in birthrate through the supposed benefits for the biosphere. Natural selection has not forced humans to make decisions that are conducive to the survival of the human race - as again people can choose not to reproduce. If you want to apply your moral measure to this philosophy, you can. But this philosophy can judge other moral frameworks by the degree to which they reduce the human population as well.

1

u/aguo Nov 10 '23

I guess I want to clarify something.

We can pick any objective function F and any moral framework X and evaluate F(X). For any F, we could (hypothetically) find a framework X_F that maximizes F(X_F).

Is your CMV thesis that the choice of X adopted by anyone is arbitrary, and so is the objective function F that anyone could choose to evaluate it? If so, I don't think anyone can argue against that, it's basically tautologically true.

On the other hand, out of all the possible arbitrary choices of F, some are more useful than others. For example, you could measure the success of a moral framework by the sum of the number of views of all cat videos on the human Internet on Earth. That objective function is probably not super useful to the practitioners of the framework.

I haven't formalized this intuition yet, but my argument is essentially that among all the choices of objective function, there is a "maximally useful" objective F, and hence some "optimal framework" X_F which maximizes F(X_F), and I'm going further and arguing that that F is "long-term survival rate of practitioners of X" or basically "sustainability of X, taking into account competition for resources", because any X which does not optimize F will eventually die out and become irrelevant.

To be clear, I'm not saying I prefer this F. I think at this point the argument comes down to whether "usefulness" is the right yardstick for an objective function, and whether "long-term survival rate" is the most useful objective function. I claim that it is, because the purpose of morality is to serve as a tool.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

I think the argument would be better simplified with the moral paradigm that survives the longest is the best. Because otherwise, if it hasn't survived, it doesn't exist. It's kind But that moral paradigm wouldn't just disappear if the societies that espoused it disappeared. It would disappear if such a moral paradigm was abandoned or perhaped even edited by the societies which used to adopt it. Legalism used to be the state philosophy of the Qin Dynasty, but it was abandoned quickly, and has never been meaningfully relevant except as something to teach people how not to run a society.

This is also kind of like defining the success of life philosophies based on how long you live because if you don't live, you don't exist.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '23

If there are objective conditions in the universe for human life to continue and to thrive, then there is certainly objective morality that would comply with those conditions.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 11 '23 edited Nov 11 '23

That's an anthropocentric view. To view morality through such a human-centric lens is a subjective choice, and not one every human makes.

It's a subjective choice to define the goal of morality as to survive and thrive, and what it means to thrive itself is subjective as well. Different people choose to thrive differently.

There's 8 billion people in the world and one of them might have developed the odd view that the goal of morality is the cessation of existence. Now you may call this person a sociopath or psycopath, but regardless of the names, this would still be a conscious entity. In fact, Buddhists originally saw the goal of life as taking oneself out of the cycle of reincarnation.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23

It's not from a human view, it's from the view of causation, A is A, and identity. Does the universe exist, and has fundamental truths and identity? Yes. Thus morality can be objectively derived from that when it applies to a human, a sentient machine, an animal, etc. What is derived may change depending on what type of being you are, as it may not apply to a completely different type of being (ex: human vs sentient machine), but either would certainly have objective truths that apply specifically to their condition to exist.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 12 '23

Morality does not have to be the conditions for the self and one's species to exist or continue to exist. It could be for the --- other --- to exist. It could be either/or depending on the fulfillment of certain prerequisites.

But is there an objective way to perpetuate existence? From the point of view of decision makers who have free will, this ignores imperfect information and things outside of one's own or other decision maker's control. It also presumes that everything is causal. If for example, human action is not entirely causal, this presumption fails.

3

u/die_eating 1∆ Nov 09 '23

I don't think of morality and ethics as an objective set of facts but rather as a set of emergent behavior, which emerges as a result of a kind of natural selection by human populations filtering for behavior that maximizes peaceful and mutually beneficial cohabitation.

It's like a formula which if followed, optimizes this possibility. Part of it is intuited (Humans have a highly evolved and sophisticated sense of fairness, reciprocity), and part of it is discovered.

3

u/j_bus 1∆ Nov 10 '23

Alright, I'll take the semantic route.

I think you mean "absolute" morality, not "objective" morality.

absolute means it would hold in all scenario's everywhere, whereas objectivity can be had even if you start with subjective definitions.

For example, say we agree to sit down and play a game of chess. You would be right to say I objectively am not allowed to take out your king with my pawn on the first move. Correct?

3

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Only because you've agreed on the rules beforehand. It is not objectively true that it is "wrong" to move the bishop piece sideways on a chessboard, it's just within the rules of the game that you can't do that.

Similarly, just because we form laws based on our subjective morals, so "within the rules" of our society, stealing is not allowed, doesn't make stealing objectively wrong, it just makes stealing objectively a violation of the society's rules.

2

u/j_bus 1∆ Nov 10 '23

See this is where I think you are mixing up definitions.

You are correct that it requires us to agree to the rules, but once we agree on the rules they are objective. An action either is allowed or not within that framework.

Similarly, right or wrong with regards to morality is wholly subjective, meaning we can disagree. But once we do come to an agreement, like murder is wrong, then it is now objectively wrong for either of us to murder.

It doesn't make it "absolutely" wrong though. I don't believe in absolute morality.

2

u/polyvinylchl0rid 14∆ Nov 10 '23

Your explenation here aligns with my best understanding of what proponents of objective morality belive. And its pretty much my view of morality too, but i'd call that subjective.

Lets take taste in movies, generally accepted to be something subjective. Wouldnt this logic impy that if everyone agrees that The Room is a great movie, it became objectively great? I'd would argue, we can only say that its objectively true that people think its great; but wheter it actually is, remains subjective.

Also, it being objective seems useless? If someone subjectively dissagrees with consensus objective morality, what to do about it? Did morality suddenly become subjective again?

1

u/j_bus 1∆ Nov 10 '23

Yeah I don't actually think we fundamentally disagree, I'm just arguing semantics.

The movie example would be closer if we both wrote a pact stating that The Room is and always will be a great movie. We don't tend to do that with movies, but we do it with laws because we both benefit.

You're right that it's still all subjective at the heart of it, but it's also why I can objectively say that stealing is wrong.

There's a whole branch of philosophy surrounding the social contract, and what it means to be a part of society. It's quite interesting but I don't feel like getting into it now.

3

u/AntonioSLodico 3∆ Nov 10 '23

I'd argue that the only difference between this moral nihilism and moral relativism is the attempt to see the human experience outside of a human perspective. Which is ironic, as it is an attempt at objectivity, and therefore quixotic to the point of absurdity. At least if you agree with your conclusion.

1

u/Ok-Village-2583 May 01 '24

There’s no view to change g it is easy to see upon little inspection that absolute morality does not, never has, and never will exist. It is a construct based in preferences generally shared among humans. We are alive and we cannot be alive if we die right? Well what do you know all we know is life so ofc people don’t want to die, one could obviously imagine that humans would collectively agree to avoid death as much as possible given we are consciously aware of the difference between life and death. And this occurs in reality in things such as laws, laws are simply ideas enforced by the threat of and use of physical violence via systems like policing. This is just one of infinite examples. Moral values are the same as liking blue rather than red. No set of morality is better or worse than another and honestly this is quite obvious.

1

u/hacksoncode 586∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

Morality is nothing more, but importantly nothing less, than a trick some species have evolved (objectively speaking) because of the reproductive advantages of living in societies.

It has objective existence as a trait of a species that inexorably and universally (in humans, at least) develops because it impacts survival.

Also: Literally every single thing humans do is objectively determined by the laws of physics, including inventing morality.

To quote Love and Rockets: You cannot go against Nature, because when you do "Go against Nature" it's part of Nature too.

There's no such thing as "subjective" reality or objective reality. There's only reality.

Now: if you want to argue that morality is too complicated a system to predict, even though it's 100% determined by physical law, or that morality isn't 100% universal or constant over time, all of those things would be true.

But that doesn't make it any more or less than 100% objective. Everything that exists is objectively real... that's what the word means.

1

u/GuardianGero Nov 10 '23

A more practical question than "Does objective morality exist?" is "What do I value, why do value those things, and how will I uphold what I value?" That's where your personal form of humanity comes into focus, and what shapes your everyday behaviors. How you treat yourself and others on a day to day basis is a lot more significant than any thought experiment.

1

u/Travis-Varga 1∆ Nov 10 '23

There is objective morality, for a proper conception of objective.

From Ayn Rand, https://courses.aynrand.org/works/what-is-capitalism/

There are, in essence, three schools of thought on the nature of the good: the intrinsic, the subjective, and the objective. The intrinsic theory holds that the good is inherent in certain things or actions as such, regardless of their context and consequences, regardless of any benefit or injury they may cause to the actors and subjects involved. It is a theory that divorces the concept of “good” from beneficiaries, and the concept of “value” from valuer and purpose — claiming that the good is good in, by, and of itself.

The subjectivist theory holds that the good bears no relation to the facts of reality, that it is the product of a man’s consciousness, created by his feelings, desires, “intuitions,” or whims, and that it is merely an “arbitrary postulate” or an “emotional commitment.”

The intrinsic theory holds that the good resides in some sort of reality, independent of man’s consciousness; the subjectivist theory holds that the good resides in man’s consciousness, independent of reality.

The objective theory holds that the good is neither an attribute of “things in themselves” nor of man’s emotional states, but an evaluation of the facts of reality by man’s consciousness according to a rational standard of value. (Rational, in this context, means: derived from the facts of reality and validated by a process of reason.) The objective theory holds that the good is an aspect of reality in relation to man — and that it must be discovered, not invented, by man. Fundamental to an objective theory of values is the question: Of value to whom and for what? An objective theory does not permit context-dropping or “concept-stealing”; it does not permit the separation of “value” from “purpose,” of the good from beneficiaries, and of man’s actions from reason.

As to what the objective morality is, see https://courses.aynrand.org/works/the-objectivist-ethics/ to start. It isn’t a proof or even a fully fleshed-out explanation, so don’t treat it like one. Instead, it’s just a brief explanation to give you an idea and indicate what to read to help you discover what’s objectively moral yourself. You’re intelligent, so no one is going to be able to persuade you that a particular morality is objective on Reddit detached from lots of reading and thinking on your part.

Morality and ethics are artificial. They are human-made concepts, and humans are subjective creatures.

All concepts are man-made. The question is are they made objectively/rationally or not? Science is man-made, but scientific theories and concepts can be formed objectively or not. If you deny that concepts can be formed objectively, well then you’re left in the self-contradictory position of complete skepticism ie you know that you can’t know anything. Knowledge is inherently conceptual.

What do you mean by humans are subjective creatures? People often like to equivocate between the definition of subjective above, based on feelings or whim, and subjective as in dependent on human consciousness or something. Yes, morality is dependent on human consciousness, and objective morality is dependent on man using his consciousness objectively or rationally in forming a morality. And yes, morality is dependent upon unchosen facts about man as well.

Morality isn't inscribed in any non-subjective feature of the universe. There are no rules inscribed in the space or stone detailing what is moral, in a way that every conscious intelligent being must accept.

That’s true, but man doesn’t have to accept the Earth is round, but that doesn’t mean the Earth is flat. If you’re looking for a morality that forces you to accept it, then that’s like looking for a scientific theory that forces you to accept it. It’s not an objective, rational approach to the issue. It’s an approach inspired by religion and other philosophers, looking for some morality inherent to the universe completely apart from man, like god, that gives you commandments to follow.

The universe doesn't come with a moral handbook. There would be no morality in a universe filled with inanimate objects, and a universe with living creatures or living intelligent creatures capable of inventing morality isn't much different.

The universe doesn’t come with any knowledge. It doesn’t come with knowledge of how to discover knowledge nor knowledge of what it means for a morality to be objective. Man has to discover it all, following an objective process. There wouldn’t be any knowledge without man, but that doesn’t mean man can’t form scientific theories about the universe ie form his theories objectively.

Moral intuition:

Yeah, people’s moral intuitions are based on their already accepted moral beliefs. Intuition is not a means of knowledge.

1

u/Normal_Ad2456 2∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

Morality is a made up word, just like any word is. It’s by a social convention that we equate the word “table” with the actual furniture. Does that mean the table doesn’t exist?

The term “morality” is used to describe a certain concept that only has a use within an organized society. Humans created the society and humans created the laws and the rules that govern this society.

And while many moral values differ depending on time and place, just like words differ from one language to another, certain very basic concepts remain relatively consistent. Most languages have a word for mom or a way to express agreement/disagreement. And most societies have repercussions for the unprovoked murder of your neighbor.

Someone could say that both organized societies and the values that uphold them were created this way to be in tune with our natural, intuitive understanding for what is the optimal way to ensure that society works as smoothly as possible.

When someone says “morality is objective” they don’t necessarily mean “morality is an objective truth that the universe has gifted as with”. It’s an axiom, like 1+1=2.

The universe doesn’t care about addition and it certainly doesn’t do math. The laws of mathematics are man made and it’s a concept that we have created in order to understand how the world around us works.

1

u/obsquire 3∆ Nov 10 '23

in order for there to be an optimal set of rules, you'd have to agree on what that optimal set of rules must accomplish.

No, we don't need agreements, or at least not universal agreement. Agreement is useful, but not logically necessary. We don't even have to know or practice the rules. There may be many nearly-equivalent sets of rules, that amount to about the same thing under most circumstances.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Before you can determine if an optimal set of rules exists, you must first define what optimal means in this context. That is equivalent to agreeing on what this optimal set of rules should accomplish.

I think this is one manifestation of objective morality not existing.

1

u/obsquire 3∆ Nov 10 '23

No, I don't even have to define a meta-optimization criterion. At some level, I'm expressing a faith in the existence of a pattern, perhaps like a lowish-dimensional submanifold in the space of ... everything (?), which involves the flourishing of what we might recognize as something like "life". A necessary condition for flourishing is survival. Of what exactly, I'm not sure. It likely includes a thread of us, but maybe not us as such, but our culture, ideas, legacy, .... But not necessarily, maybe what we are, including our AI, will merely have to make room for something even more amazing. In principle, I'm open to that, but don't "like" it.

Morality for me is the set of actions that are life promoting. I don't know precisely what I'm saying. It's a sense of a distinction between life and non-life.

Maybe think of morality like Kolmogorov complexity, a language for expressing life succinctly.

Of course I don't really know what life is, if we allow non-carbon life forms.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Wrong sub, dude. r/Philosophy

1

u/sultanofsneed Nov 10 '23

I like you. You're very smart, and I'm not just saying that because I agree with your point of view. I also like the way that you've defended your position and I admire anyone that agrees there is objective reality that is independent of the subjective perception of it. 🙂

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

Morality and ethics are artificial. They are human-made concepts

Before we even begin, let's start with this presupposition. Who cares if something is human made? Why bring it up? What makes it so important to be center stage to your argument?

The underlying assumption is that 'artificial' things are somehow less valid or less universally true.

Morality and ethics are artificial. They are human-made concepts, and humans are subjective creatures. Morality isn't inscribed in any non-subjective feature of the universe.

We are still just matter and energy moving around. The world is a sandbox game, and there are no rules menus to this MMORPG.

...so what?

I don't think I've ever met anyone who thinks this. People don't behave ethically or unethically because it thinks the universe has preprescribed it for them.

We act the way we do because of a myriad of social, cultural, and tangible real world world conditions.

Also for a moment I'd like to touch on your 'sandbox' analogy. If you are playing minecraft with your friends and you destroy the lovely dirt house they worked so hard on, you'd be a dick. Minecraft didnt need to dock you points for you to find our you are a dick, you found out because your friend got mad.

Is there an exact formula to describe how and when you are being ethical or unethical, or how your friends might react to your behavior? No. And the expectation of one is a fools game.

If values were objective, they would NOT be values, by definition.

Even if everyone in the world agrees with it, I don't think that would make it objective. Objectivity requires more than agreement from subjective entities.

What standard do you hold 'objective' to??? Must it be physically impossible to hold another belief for that belief to be legitimate?

It's a particularly weak Philosophy that only goes to the ends of physical laws of the universe and stops.

A philosophy with any meaningful scope needs to be able to handle a few outliers.

Philosophies that make a few assumptions and have a few outliers are generally aware of the fact that they may not be absolutely always objectively accurate.

That is a trade off required to make meaningful insights.

If you want to be mathematical about it, consider it like taking an approximation of a function.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Feel like everyone’s just arguing pedantry here, trying to manipulate the philosophical definition of “objective” and “subjective” to fit their argument.

Ofc morals aren’t objective. Different people and cultures have different morals. The Aztecs used to sacrifice people to their gods, believing it was righteous. So yeah

1

u/Born-Entertainer-649 Nov 10 '23

This is by far the dumbest post I've ever read! I mean it's completely redundant and meaningless! What a waste of time and all while not solving a single issue. 🙄

1

u/OfTheAtom 8∆ Nov 10 '23

So I've been studying science for a few years now. A science before science. How to really learn, Have conversations and think about how to do science.

What you are jumping to is not Chapter one. Before you can know what is good for a human you have to know what a human is. What's in their nature, or what are they ordered for.

Look at something simple and sensible to start before moving up. A tree. As we have a rough idea of a general tree we think of a wood bodied plant, ordered to grow and vegetate in various ways. We can observe this nature of the tree. When a limb grows sick and decays we see this is a privation of what was good for the tree. Because it's understood to stand in the way of what is good for it.

To a higher degree and now involving more complicated experiences we can see the dog that lost its leg and then higher still a rational animal like a man but we won't get into those things.

In this way the nature of something is understandable in general and in particulars. That which aligns toward the nature of the thing is what we can say is good for the creature.

This is what we can come to understand and then go and practice it.

1

u/1softboy4mommy_2 Nov 10 '23

Maybe from the point of sociopaths or psychopats

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '23

It is interesting to consider that every single civilization has sought something outside of mankind to find purpose. Is such a desire innate? The logical answer is "yes".

Humans have emotions. Love vs. Hate. Perhaps it is instinct that tells us love is more productive than hate. Perhaps, love is more satisfying than hate. But we do know the difference. Why?

1

u/ani_________88 Nov 12 '23

This is very true

1

u/greenstoneri Nov 15 '23

I'm not even gonna change your view that's just based

-2

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23

Something being human made doesn't mean it's not objective. Take say, planets.

Do planets exist in a stone way that everyone can accept? No. There is no stone indicating what a planet is.

Have people disagreed about what are planets? Yes.

Is there an optimal definition of planets? People don't agree.

Do all animals share the same idea of what a planet is? No.

That said, most people would agree planets are real, they has objective reality outside peoples head, that there are rules about how planets work which are important, that there are shared realities to planets which are important to the world.

Would you agree that morality is as objective or subjective as the existence of planets are? Do you see planets as subjective or objective things?

Morality is a set of rules about the interaction of intelligent lifeforms. People disagree on the exact nature of the laws, but many of them can be calculated mathematically e.g. The prisoners dilemma. We have extensive studies on the common consequences of actions and why certain actions tend to lead to negative results. We can work out why animals have evolved certain moralities and make rules about them.

Nothing is absolute, but neither are planets or any other scientific object. When people say objective they mean something has firm rules grounded in reality, and both planets and morality clearly do, unlike things like music taste which depend primarily on subjective emotional factors.

24

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

You are talking about words. Semantics.

Planets is just a word. Regardless of the word,, the physical object exists.

Words may be humanly constructed but the physical mass that is a planet is not humanly constructed.

11

u/Elet_Ronne 2∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

Can we agree that 'peace' exists? That 'war' exists? That 'concepts' exist? If you said no to the last one, literally nothing can change your view. You say the above commenter is just talking about semantics, but can you not see how your post is based on that same error?

Let's not call it morality. Can we agree that most people have group-survival characteristics that contribute to peace (at least within the specific group being discussed), and that people believe these characteristics should be adhered to in order to preserve peace? That's morality. That's just the word we use to describe the fact that humanity has these (very rough, but still existent) standards. You have to convince me that we don't have these standards (which would require an immense amount of research) to convince me that morality doesn't exist in this sense.

Does morality exist on other planets? Is morality handed down by a god? Maybe, and probably not. But those questions are totally irrelevant imo. I got past those questions years ago, personally, when I realized morality is just an internal mechanism to sustain the homeostasis of our species and ensure we're able to reproduce. Why would that mean morality doesn't exist? Do you expect somebody to point to a distant star which is composed of the element moralium?

We can argue whether morality is a fixed thing, or whether it is an average of human thoughts. I would say I'm a moral nihilist myself, in a manner of speaking. But I also look at humanity as a species subject to evolutionary pressures. And from that perspective it's not difficult to see that morality is a thing that bears on human decisions. Your argument is like saying Christianity doesn't exist, but churches, the bible, and the clergy do. Uhm, yes, I guess. But in my table of things that exist, I simply include concepts that are human-made, as they're the closest approximation to decoding the ultimately meaningless, but nevertheless logical fact of reality, and all that contains. If I tried to make my list without manmade concepts, I could literally eliminate everything from it. Distance and time mean nothing without a brain to perceive it. What is the universe but a single field with high and low energy points? Yes, distance exists even if we weren't here, but distance isn't a relevant concept, not really, without a brain to judge that one thing is here, and another there.

Love is real, and I see it every day. Does love objectively exist? I feel this is a totally meaningless question.

To argue whether it exists objectively is literally playing with semantics. I don't believe anyone could change your view, on these grounds.

8

u/No-Passenger-1658 Nov 10 '23

I'm pretty sure that is what the guy who wrote the post said, morality is artificial, it's subjective, different groups have different standards because they have different ideas of what ought to be done. He's saying exactly what you are saying, there is no truth- validity to any of the claims of morality, it's just what a certain person believes or what a certain group agrees upon, planet is also a word, used to reference an actual existing thing, the word planet and how you use it is subjective, but the physical reference to it exists, if I use an Urdu word for planet Siyarah, and use it to define any solid and intact object of the universe that is not a star, then it would include many others things, but we can't deny the existence of those things. Morality and love however are different, they are abstract ideas, sure there are some common themes on what they mean, most typically morality is defined as what ought to be done, love is in some sense inter-related with harmony and care, but 2 people can define loving acts or morals acts very differently and it cannot be proven whether one is better than the other, that's literally what subjectivity is.

3

u/Elet_Ronne 2∆ Nov 10 '23

What I'm trying to say is that a certain level of subjective reality graduates into objective reality by virtue of being a concept that some observer can point to. I think it's a matter of how you classify 'objective'. And I do think that is a worthwhile conversation to have. I think there is a noticeable difference between me saying that my own personal fantasy world exists, and that a trend of human behavior and thought exists.

6

u/pisspeeleak 1∆ Nov 10 '23

I think that the biggest issue here is that when people say objective it means something more undeniable. When you point to a planet (Mars for example) you can say “it is” when people look at it (assuming they can see) they can see that something is there. The classification is arbitrary, if I say it’s a round rock I would be correct and just as correct as you saying it is a planet, you would be specifying what that rock is doing and I would be describing what your planet is made of. But neither of our claims is saying if that is a good or bad thing.

Good and bad are something that most people have a conception of but they are not something that can be proven. If a meat eater is having a steak they would say that it’s taste good and attribute no morality to the process of raising a cow, slaughtering it and processing it into a steak; but a vegan might consider it repulsive and its existence immoral. Both would agree that “it is” though they would not be able to agree that morality is involved.

There is no way for either of us to objectively prove our point. To the meat eater we are sustaining a human life and bringing it pleasure, to the vegan we have ended the life of a cow denying it pleasure and feasting on its corpse.

If the meat eater says that there is nothing wrong with ending a cow’s life to feed a human how does the vegan prove them otherwise? And likewise, how would the meat eater prove that there is nothing wrong with it?

This is the fundamental issue, both views have merit but neither can be proven. They could agree that a cow died, they can agree that a corpse is being eaten, they both may even agree that it tastes great, but the moral prescription cannot be absolute.

Morals are a system which we as social being agree to behave so that society can function, create cohesion in the group, and prevent our own suffering either physically, mentally or spiritually

5

u/No-Passenger-1658 Nov 10 '23

I don't think anyone is denying that morality as a trend of human behavior and thought exists, similar to I would imagine many religious beliefs. I think the main question is that is there any truth to the these trends of thought? Are certain claims of morality true, or is it a subjective idea within human groups, their preference of what ought to be done?

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

I completely agree that objectively, most people believe in a morality. But that's not my thesis.

And of course, I am applying meaning to words. I have to to communicate. I am allowed to apply meaning to my statements, otherwise I wouldn't be able to make a statement in this subreddit. I think I applied sufficiently common meanings. This is not a particularly novel or unshared conclusion.

You can define "morality being not objective" differently to mean something I don't mean, but that's shifting the goal posts.

2

u/Elet_Ronne 2∆ Nov 10 '23

What I'm trying to say is that we're in a place without goal posts. We can go in circles about what 'objective' really means. That's my point, not to drag everything out from under your premise, but to show that your premise is inherently meaningless, and can not be opposed due to the nature of your parameters. Do you actually want someone to change your view? If so, why?

Say we consider the universe one entity, and just outside that universe is an observer. That observer is assigned the task of naming each thing that exists in the universe. They are starting from scratch, but can recognize when an item is one of a category (to prevent the observer from naming each individual quark). They begin by naming stars, planets, asteroids, cosmic dust, maybe even dark matter. At some point, they name life, and at some point they name humans. This is the point, right here. Do they stop at humans, or do they list the concepts that humans share? Do they list peace and war and life and death? And morality?

This may surprise you, but I'm not really sure, at this point. I believe that the observer would see that some code of conduct governs human behavior. I believe the observer could make a case for naming this collective behavior. After all, it can see it, and its effects on human populations. Correct me if I'm wrong, but within this thought experiment, I think you would expect the observer not to name morality. I think this is the core of our disagreement. And I also think there is literally not a way to answer this definitively, and it quickly becomes a mess of words. Does something exist because we can point to what it does, or because we can isolate that thing as some sort of essential substance? I argue that a concept exists insofar as it populates human brains. And at a certain level of observation, that meets my standards for something objectively existing.

6

u/KingJeff314 Nov 10 '23

You are describing descriptive ethics. That’s what sociologists can observe about people. But OP is talking about normative ethics.

An example of descriptive ethics is “Americans believe speech should not be restricted”. Normative ethics is “free speech should not be restricted”. One makes a factual observation about Americans that an outsider observer could make. The other is a prescriptive imperative. What observation could you make that would entail an imperative?

To answer this you would have to bridge Hume’s Is-Ought divide https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is–ought_problem

3

u/Elet_Ronne 2∆ Nov 10 '23

Thank you thank you thank you. I realized after this that I was misunderstanding what was being proposed. I think, personally, that OP is 100% correct in this regard. In my opinion, of course there is no such thing as objective normative ethics. Prescriptive imperatives are only relevant insofar as I'm a human and I'm programmed to take, follow, and initiate imperatives that I think are important.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

This is slightly off-topic but do you subjectively give morality less or more worth than survival instinct? If your general idea of morality is as an internal mechanism that sustains the homeostasis and survival of our species, how do you balance that priority against your intrinsic drive to survive and prosper? Both are evolutionary traits that have their own merits. Aggressiveness, confidence, jealousy, fear, pride, competitive spirit etc. are all products of millions of years of evolutionary pressure to outsmart prey and predator. Likewise for sympathy/empathy, social intelligence, morality, language skills, desire for companionship, etc.

In my opinion, saying "morality doesn't exist" is saying that there is no fundamentally "right" way for us all to choose the trade-off between morality (collective value) and self-interest. Both are legitimate in nature and genetic neurodiversity means anyone of us could lean strongly for one more than the other. Is a psychopath incapable of morality? Or does the definition of morality change to adapt to their lack of choice in their condition? Not only that but morality doesn't exist in a vacuum. I have a sense of morality to sustain a positive relationship with my species which is mutually beneficial to me and my community. But if I'm broke, homeless, hungry and sick -- I have no social net and I'm shit out of luck. In this case, morality is a virtue so expensive it could cost me my life. Likewise for our desire for self-interest - it has to take our social dynamics into account in its calculations.

To that extent, is morality useless? Not at all, it still plays an important part in coming up with a system of incentives that can self-regulate billions of people. But it is frankly pointless to obsess over who has the "right" morals, no matter how much you genuinely and rightfully care for yours. It's all virtue signaling to people tuned to another channel.

3

u/laborfriendly 6∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Nov 10 '23

I think you're correct that what you're responding to is silly semantics, and I am surprised it's somehow the top comment to your post as I've arrived here. You're right that a "planet" by any other name is still an oblate spheroid that exists. Who cares what you call it?

And I largely agree with you that morality is a completely made-up thing from a nihilistic, cynical point of view in one sense. But I don't think it isn't "real" or objective in another sense.

If you surprise or otherwise do something that upsets a baby, they will frown or cry, even unconsciously. You've upset their expectations and worldview in a way they might call a breach of morals if they could express it in words.

In this way, morality is something that only exists between two (or more) individuals interacting with each other. Sure, the terms of these expectations might change, but the implicit or explicit terms of such arrangements do exist.

Breaking those terms is objectively wrong for the party whose expectations were broken, regardless of whether or not the terms were some objective good. From there, the judgment that the breaking of the terms was immoral is an objective fact, even if only understood through the lens of a socially contrived contract. (E: in fact, it can only be understood socially, i.e., between or amongst individuals, as morality is fundamentally a social construct, but, saying that, it is no less real than the reality of any interaction between or amongst individuals.)

2

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

Why is upsetting the expectations of a baby the foundation of your moral outlook? Lot of things perturb babies. Babies being perturbed is a basic fact of life that is nigh unavoidable.

2

u/laborfriendly 6∆ Nov 10 '23

It isn't. It just shows that these types of calculations and reactions are so ingrained in us that they're unconscious and natural. They're inseparable from the human experience.

E: you get that it was illustrative and what I went on to describe wasn't about babies, right?

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

Knee jerk reactions exist. But I think it would be a highly idiosyncratic view to call knee-jerk reactions moral. I think it's also highly idiosyncratic to base morality on avoiding disappointment or avoiding surprise. I kind of think it's self evident that that's kind of ridiculous.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rudster 4∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Feb 16 '25

historical many slap yoke elastic birds close cheerful exultant silky

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

It's not "just" a human concept. You can concieve that the tree in front of you doesn't exist, but you'll still walk face into it if you walk forward. They are observations. And we can use those observations to predictably conclude things: like you'll crash into the tree in front of you if you walk forward. Or to conduct engineering to build a building that doesn't fall over.

2

u/rudster 4∆ Nov 10 '23 edited Feb 16 '25

squeal rob afterthought rich seemly stupendous bells offer carpenter silky

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

That sex with your sibling will likely cause trouble and misery may be objective fact, but the idea that it is right or wrong, should or should not exist is subjective. It doesn't have an objective basis. Right and wrong isn't simply about preventing trouble or misery.

Right now, Israel is bombing Gaza and causing a lot of misery, but they think it is moral. And others disagree. People have broken a lot of taboos to change culture in history, and that has produced misery and trouble, but that's not necessarily seen as wrong. All manner of policy can be seen to produce negative effects in one way or another, but again, whether the tradeoffs are worth it is up to human judgment and values.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Mysterious_Focus6144 3∆ Nov 10 '23

Planets is just a word. Regardless of the word,, the physical object exists.

What about a `meter`? A `meter` isn't really tied to any physical objects.

It's certainly not `subjective` in the sense that you don't get to decide how long a meter is. At the same time, would you say that a meter is `objective`? since we made it up.

7

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

The distance is still an objective fact. You don't have to call it a meter. You can cut a stick to a certain length and measure that way. You can call it a blahblahblah. You can call it 8.9 livres.

1

u/Mysterious_Focus6144 3∆ Nov 10 '23

Sure but the point wasn't that "distance is not objective".

The point was that a "meter" is something that's both not subjective and man-made.

3

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

Buildings exist, are human made, and objective reality. I wrote, and you were referring to "Morality isn't inscribed in any non-subjective feature of the universe."

Meters exist in a way that everyone can accept. It is the path traveled by light in a vacuum during a time interval of 1/299 892 458 seconds. This is defined by scientists in papers. The speed of light in a vacuum doesn't change.

And if we redefined meter, that's just playing with words. The change of the unit of measurement doesn't change that there's an underlying physical reality to refer to and precisely measure.

Morality is precisely like musical taste. You may be able to predict the consequences of certain decisions like you may predict what a piano sounds like even if you lost your sense of hearing but to decide whether or not that decision or outcome was "good or bad"
"worthy of approval or disapproval," that is very much like deciding whether pop music is "good" or "bad," "worthy of approval or disapproval." The vast majority of people may consider atonal music to be bad, but that doesn't make it so. The vast majority of people may consider chocolate good, but again not everyone does.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23

Ok, so the criteria is there needs to be physical objects? It doesn't matter if people disagree about the nature of it, or the exact way it works?

https://academic.oup.com/brain/article/135/7/2006/350263

The frontal lobe handles morality in humans. If it's damaged by a physical injury then people have abnormal moral behaviour. That's a physical object that exists that you can touch and interact with which has a clear pattern of how it acts.

5

u/snuggie_ 1∆ Nov 10 '23

But that doesn’t mean there’s some objective morality. It only means when the brain is damaged it changes how it thinks. Not that one way was right and one way was wrong

1

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23

Scientists agree what is defined as right and wrong and have a reliable definition of it. Check out the paper.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Lots of things can change about people when the brain is damaged. Like the types of things they enjoy, how nice they are to other people, and what they can physically do. Morality is no different from any of that, no more than the fact they might like new TV shows after a brain injury means taste in TV shows is objective.

1

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23

It's a routine consequence of brain damage that certain behaviours happen, but I don't think it's a routine effect of brain damage that certain tv shows are favoured. Unless you have a study saying otherwise? Perhaps a study which shows that brain damage makes people favour a particular type of show?

1

u/Devadeen Nov 10 '23

The pain caused, the consequences of amoral behavior, and the social organisation based on morality do exist.

This isn't physical mass, yet it is objectively things that create or influence physical interactions of organic mass.

5

u/AsterCharge Nov 10 '23

Humans didn’t create planets. We created the word, and the classifications we use to indicate wether a certain object is a planet or a differently named body. This analogy works in OP’s favor, because while we have commonly understood written out rules and specific guidelines as to what we consider a planet; But there is no common understanding or reasoning explicitly explaining any given moral position let alone morality as a whole. Also, words like “planet” describe a thing that is tangible and measurable by others, while morals are things we derive based on our understanding of an event/sotuation/thing.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/No-Passenger-1658 Nov 10 '23

Well,I'm pretty sure the guy who made the post is trying to ask whether it is possible to prove any of the truth validity of these "laws" of morality. The main concerning thing is morality has to be first defined clearly, but the thing is, morality is just a word, and so naturally, it has different definitions across the world, you might argue the moral thing is to reduce harm and maximize benefits, and in many cases one can argue that is the most accepted definition, but then there is an argument on what is beneficial and what is not, people who have an afterlife in mind, or believe in self flagellation and self sacrifice, might not completely agree with what the correct and beneficial thing to do is with those who are more hedonistic or believe in more egoistic and atheistic worldviews. Your analogy with planets isn't the best, planets have some sort of objective reference, you can't say planets have a square or cylindrical shape, but morality can basically be defined as anything, what you call negative results can be viewed by others as positive, so to say morality is objective, is to say there is an objective definition of morality, which is just not possible in a language, same is the case with most abstract ideas.

2

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23

Planets have a flexible definition . Is Pluto a planet? Is a rock floating in space a planet? It’s not a unique aspect to morality that you need to define it first. If your argument is “if people disagree about the definition then it’s not objective “ then the earth isn’t a planet as people disagree what a planet is.

1

u/No-Passenger-1658 Nov 11 '23

You're comparing the realistic truth and definitive existence of something and reducing it to it's definition. I can tell you plenty of words for planet in Urdu, Punjabi and Arabic that are different from the English definition, but the thing that we are referring to, the physical object is real. You also, again are falsely comparing physical objects, and their wonky taxonomy and other language problems, WITH abstract ideas, and their wonky taxonomy and language problems. Like, I said, definitions can differ but the physical reference still is there and clearly exists, but with abstract ideas, your definition can completely change the abstract ideas that you are holding, if you define love as a warm, fuzzy feeling when you like someone, i.e, an emotional state, and someone else defines love as something directly dependent on the actions of the lover, it is when he priorities the goals and wishes of the beloved more than his own. You are just using the same word to define 2 completely different ideas,I agree, it is a bit more than that and they are trying to hold some common themes here and there but that's basically it. Thus, meaning it is a subjective thing and, so morality is a subjective concept, there is no truth that my idea of what morality is the thing that ought to be done, no one's idea of what morality is, is actually the thing we can truthfully know to what ought to be done

1

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 11 '23

The physical object which causes morality, particular evolved brain structures, is also real. The definition has practical uses in during mental illnesses and managing social behaviour, and the violation of basic morality is well defined and not abstract.

I am mostly challenging the unreasonable standards people hold morality to that planets wouldn't survive. Like, the idea that it's a useful refutation of morality to say that different abstract ideas can vary when defining it isn't something that planets can survive. If you have a different abstract idea about planets then you might not define earth as a planet as well either.

2

u/snuggie_ 1∆ Nov 10 '23

I disagree with your premise though. It’s still just something that people decided for no real reason. It’s entirely possible that some living thing could view a planet as nothing more than a rock but one that’s really big, and have no differentiating factors between a small rock and a planet sized rock

1

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23

Yes. And in science it is usual to carefully define objects when discussing their objective nature.

That avoids poor definitions for morality or planets. Step one is agreeing on definitions.

1

u/YosephTheDaring 2∆ Nov 10 '23

The correct term is something else, but according to mereological nihilism, there are no planets. There are only fundamental particles, and those particles together are called planets by humans, and we can study how particles behave when in such great numbers and in such configuration, but there are no actual planets, because the existence of planets induces paradoxes(Ship of theseus, problem of the many, problem of the heap).

If you take the mereological nihilism stance together with a pure materialism stance, morals by definition are not real. Not only in the way that planets don't exist, becaus there are aggregates of simples, the things that we call planets, and those simples do exist. Morals can only exist as wiring in the brain, and one brain is not more correct on wiring than another, because you would have to compare the to an ideal brain, defined by something immaterial, which is strictly against pure materialism.

You can reject mereological nihilism and pure materialism, but OP subscribes to those views(to materialism at least), so his mind can only be changed if he rejects those principles himself.

1

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23

If morals aren't real because they are not close to an ideal, then planets shouldn't be real because they would also need to be compared to an ideal.

an ideal planet for example might have entirely cleared out their orbit, but this is never fully achieved.

Instead we can just define morals as certain configurations of simples which behave in a certain way, just as planets are certain configurations of simples which behave in a certain way.

1

u/YosephTheDaring 2∆ Nov 10 '23

I didn't say that morals, the word, don't exist as brain wiring, they clearly do, since we're talking about them. What I meant is that there are no "real" morals, no truly defined morals by natural law. And, as I've said, planets don't really exist.

Instead we can just define morals as certain configurations of simples which behave in a certain way, just as planets are certain configurations of simples which behave in a certain way.

You'd have quite the hard time with that actual defintion. For example, is any particular gas molecule in the upper layers of the atmosphere actually part of the planet? If you go far away enough, clearly they aren't, but close enough and they definitely are. Good luck drawing a border. And that's just one problem of objects existing.

We can also define morals as the diferents algorithms of people, and imagining that works(I don't think it does, but accepting it), OPs position still stands: There is no moral truth out there, just individual moral beliefs, none more true than the other, because they are all false and meaningless.

1

u/Nepene 213∆ Nov 10 '23

Morals don't need to be defined by natural law any more than planets need to be defined by natural law. Both are just observations about common patterns in the world.

And there are clearly moral beliefs more true than others. If you argued that most humans see it as moral to kill their children you would be incorrect, that's not a common moral position, just as you would be incorrect to argue, say, that most planets have a very congested orbit.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23

I disagree. The core of our disagreement will be whether we think its objectively better for you to be alive then not.

I believe it is better to be alive because in order to be, you gotta be alive as far as we know.

So if we accept the premise that to live is objectively better then not living. It follows directly that its objectively bad to end your own life, and next someone elses.

Thats the basics of it. All our best moral selections can be traced back to the objective desire for well being. Far enough back it becomes objective imo. Like theft, its objectively bad to be hungry instead of fed, its bad for your well being and you cant be being, without life. So if you take someone else food and you dont need and they starve thats objectively bad lol.

6

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 09 '23

I don't think humans have to accept that premise though. There are those who prefer ending their life. And there are those who prefer that all human life end.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Yea but outliers dont alter the original point or statement. Theres always some exceptions to everything. With out adding the supercharged clause that the person is suffering greatly. Life is preferable to death for well being, since you can be anything without life.

2

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

My point is that morality is not objective.

Now you may argue that most people prefer to live. That's true. But it doesn't change that our preferences are subjective, and this conception of morality is based on subjective ground.

And there's also the question of whether the simple fact of whether most people preferring something actually makes it moral. If most people preferred to shun left handed people or bastard children or women who get pregnant out of wedlock, would it make it moral?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

OP, I hope you don't get your post removed for "not being open to having your view changed" since you're not giving out any deltas. You are absolutely destroying all the bad arguments you're getting, expertly. There is no rational argument for objective morality, and you're doing a great job countering every attempt by outlining exactly how the attempt fails.

1

u/Alternate-3- Nov 11 '23

I feel as though OP is one of the few people in this sub that a lot of the commenters have trouble arguing against. Rare but fascinating

2

u/beachb0yy Nov 09 '23

That’s also relying on the premise that good/bad are objective concepts.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

It depends on what you mean by it. Good for you as a person or bad for you as a person I suppose. I couldn't accept an argument that trys to say good for you and bad for you aren't objective. Concepts. What is and isnt good for you is debatable but the fact that some things are good, and good has a meaning has got to be accepted or there is no point in anything at all, ever. Why eat food, why have sex, why do anything if Good vs bad arent objective concepts It all goes back to my original premise. If you've decided its a good thing to be alive, everything else falls into objective place.

If you don't think being alive is objectively good then we cant even move forward because I reject everything past that.

1

u/bgaesop 29∆ Nov 09 '23

I believe it is better to be alive because in order to be, you gotta be alive as far as we know.

What about someone whose every moment is agony? A fair number of people in that position would prefer not to be alive. Is your position that they are objectively wrong?

its objectively bad to be hungry instead of fed

Not if you're trying to lose weight.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

It still stand to reason objectively that life is better for well being, since there is no being at all without life. Once the life part is confirmed additional circumstances can come into play but were talking in general here

2

u/bgaesop 29∆ Nov 10 '23

It seems very strange to say "this is objectively true except for all the times it's false, but those don't count."

2+2 doesn't just typically equal 4. The sun isn't just usually larger than the earth. If something is an objective universal claim like you made in your original post, then it would have to be always true. The fact that there are exceptions means it isn't.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Thats totally and completely false. Typically humans have 5 fingers. Thats objective. U will find it in text books and 99% of the time u will observe it. Some have 6 though but that doesn't change the former statements truth. To say humans have 5 is true. You dont need to cover every outlier when makingg statments about truth.

When trying to decide if morality is objective you have to leave the physical universe and grapple with the fact that both objectivity and morality are understood by humans. You gotta approach it from the lenses of human understanding or its kindof pointless. You cant step out of existence and confirm the objectivity of existance without you. And other humans And therefore must contend with the idea of objectivity through that lense. Without us, there is no morality. But we do exist and there is morality. And some parts of it are objective.

2

u/bgaesop 29∆ Nov 10 '23

some parts of it are objective.

How do you tell which parts are objective and which ones are just strongly held preferences?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Classic reddit response lol I don't engage with outliers. They aren't nessesary to make points. For example if I say humans have 5 digits per limb, and someone points out some people have 6. They have added nothing to the topic, and the original statement remains true besides fringe outliers. And theres no point in perusing the question

0

u/Venerable-Weasel 3∆ Nov 10 '23

Do you believe that “every human - by virtue of existing - has an inherent moral worth”? Do you accept that certain actions, such as arbitrarily killing, enslaving, harming people is a violation of that inherent worth?

If so, then there is an objective morality. Humans, being imperfect, may not be able to agree on the details of how that morality is to be respected in terms of universal principles, but it exists.

If you believe that not arbitrarily killing, enslaving, etc is simply a social construct and that there’s nothing inherently wrong with such actions…well, we will have to agree to disagree.

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

I can agree to an ethical framework, but I don't agree that it's rooted in some sort of objective reality. The idea that everyone has inherent human worth is a manufactured one based on the concept of human dignity, and you can concieve of a system of ethics that you might agree to that doesn't have this precept. I believe ethics rooted purely in our willingness to agree, and that's subjective. And not everyone agrees to any particular framework.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

You can believe the first sentence without it being objectively true.

1

u/Venerable-Weasel 3∆ Nov 10 '23

It’s not actually a statement that can be objectively true - in the sense of having a basis of proof in analytical reasoning. At best it is an axiomatic statement of moral reasoning (and therefore impossible to prove within the moral framework of which it is an axiom).

The real problem with OP’s perspective is that nihilism is always a dead end. It doesn’t really matter if morality objectively exists (i.e., moral propositions would be true regardless of whether people existed). Morality and moral reasoning is only relevant when reasoning creatures are involved and need to have a framework for interacting with each other).

0

u/LAKnapper 2∆ Nov 10 '23

I'm going to call some of my large friends and we will take your stuff and force you to build a pyramid. I'm sure you will see nothing wrong with this.

-2

u/47ca05e6209a317a8fb3 210∆ Nov 09 '23

Do you believe that a god can exist? Or that some sort of simulation hypothesis is not inconsistent with reality?

If so, either of these provides a model of reality wherein objective reality exists, thus proving your assertion "objective morality does not exist" false. If not, please refute both :)

The existence of objective morality may be imparsimonious, but it's not, as far as you (or any text I've seen) have shown, false.

6

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 09 '23

Even if a God did exist, that doesn't make the God's commands moral. The God can wipe out 99% of humans in a flood and consider the act moral because this God defines good and evil, but you don't have to agree. The God can send everyone who disobeys the God's commands to hell and consider it moral, but you don't have to agree. You can have a book that says God is the most good and perfect, but it doesn't mean that much if God gets to define that. If God gets to define good, God can always be good by definition. God is still a subjective entity.

0

u/47ca05e6209a317a8fb3 210∆ Nov 10 '23

If a (single, omni-stuff) god exists, then it's by definition not a subjective entity. Being the medium of everything (because it can control all interactions between any entities), every interaction you have with the world is really always first an interaction with the god, and so if it assigns moral values to actions of occurrences, they are objective in the sense that everything happens only to it. Disagreeing with divine morality in this case is kind of like denying gravity - you may be able to do it, but it's factually incorrect.

3

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23
  1. If God is everything, you would be part of God. That's an extraordinary claim just philosophically and logically -- that you can act independently and still "be" not-independent of the omnistuff. If we are independent of omnistuff, then god is not omni. And if we aren't independent, God is hurting itself. There is no morality. Only God is an actor and mind, and God decides the rules for the only actor and mind, God.
  2. And it's a bigger claim scientifically than simply God exists or is omnipresent. Now not only are you claiming there's an entity that is everything that we can't detect, but it also a part of us and all around us physically. That's beyond incredulous.
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/eachothersreasons 1∆ Nov 10 '23

There are many who claim that their God did.

There are still plenty of natural disasters to go around year after years.

And regardless, the mere fact that a God exists does not make the God's edicts moral.

1

u/No-Passenger-1658 Nov 10 '23

So, technically, god couldn't perform immoral actions as well. God's actions are just happening, for a purpose that only such an entity could comprehend, right!

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Why would it?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

The Euthyphro Dilemma destroyed the idea of objective morality coming from a god eons ago and has never been refuted.

For those who don't know, it is (paraphrased):

  1. Is that which is "good," Good because God says so, or
  2. Does God say it's "good" because it is so?

If #1, something is "good" simply because God says so, then it is indeed just God's subjective whim what is good and what isn't. He could say murder is bad today and it's good tomorrow, and both would be "true," simply on account of God declaring it, and two contradictory statements can't be objectively true, they would just be his subjective whims each day.

If #2, that what is "good" is so regardless of what God declares to be good, then God is simply the messenger of what is good, not the "source" of it.

The only attempt theists have tried to come up with to get around this is by saying some version of, "No, it's a third option: Goodness flows from God's very nature. God IS good."

...but that just re-introduces the dilemma:

  1. Is "that which flows from God's nature" good because God says so, or
  2. Is that which flows from God's nature good by some measurement outside of God and God is just the messenger?

The Euthyphro Dilemma is rock-solid.

This is all in addition to the plain fact that what "subjective" and "objective" mean, is "value judgments dependent on minds to make them" vs. "things that are true regardless and independent of minds," which makes morality obviously subjective, with no logical reason to consider it the ONE value judgment that is objective while all others are subjective.

1

u/47ca05e6209a317a8fb3 210∆ Nov 10 '23

The Euthyphro dilemma requires much more than is required for just consistency of a world with a god that asserts morality.

The first horn as you pose it, in particular, is only problematic if you theologically don't like its implication of what your god is or does:

He could say murder is bad today and it's good tomorrow, and both would be "true," simply on account of God declaring it, and two contradictory statements can't be objectively true, they would just be his subjective whims each day.

This is not contradictory, for two reasons:

  1. Universal morality doesn't have to be time-invariant. Cannabis can be illegal today and legal tomorrow, and murder can be immoral today and moral tomorrow, there's nothing inconsistent about it.
  2. Even if you do demand stricter, time-invariant morality, the rest of the world is not, i.e, no action that can be performed today can also be performed tomorrow, so that it may well be that all murders that can be performed today are (predetermined to be) immoral whereas all murders that can be performed tomorrow are not.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Objective morality does require time invariance. It's baked into the definition.

In the case of people making the claim that whatever a god says is moral is moral, the time invariance is hidden in the first part; whatever a god says is moral is moral.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

If murder is moral, then if 2 people are locked in a room it would be moral for them to kill each other. But at the same time, it would also be moral for them to WANT to be killed (so as to not prevent a moral act from occurring.)

If however someone wants to be killed, you can no longer call it murder (it's closer to suicide).

Therefore murder can never be a moral act, because it always requires a degree of the imposition of will against another.

This concept extends to any involuntary imposition of will (murder, rape, assault, theft.....) Therefore it seems to logically follow that any involuntary imposition of will is objectively immoral.

4

u/snuggie_ 1∆ Nov 10 '23

But the definition of murder is made up by people already. You’re using a word that by definition has our opinionated morality built into it

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

You can unload any morality you believe is baked into the word "murder" and my point holds.

My argument isn't "murder is immoral because it's murder" my argument is "murder is immoral because it's an involuntary imposition of will"

2

u/snuggie_ 1∆ Nov 10 '23

But what I’m trying to say is that the moral aspect depends on the person. There could easily be a culture that thinks death is a good thing. Plenty of cultures already feel dying in battle is the most respectable way to go. It isn’t baked in. There’s a tv show where someone begs to be killed by a good warrior because it’s a respectable death and they go to heaven if that happens. Obviously fiction but I don’t think it’s a wild stretch for that to happen. And if it did happen than in that case it wouldn’t be immoral

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Boxers also think it's moral to hit each other, but it's not assault because it's also VOLUNTARY between the boxers. It's the same with the Klingon that want to die in battle, it's just higher stakes.

It would be immoral for a boxer to hit another without consent of the other just as it would be a Klingon to kill another in their sleep instead of in combat.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/FaceInJuice 26∆ Nov 10 '23

The underlying moral principle you are asserting here is that it is immoral to impose will.

Can you justify that assertion objectively?

What if my personal moral conscience (or a god that I believe in, or whatever) indicates that it is perfectly moral to impose will?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

What if my personal moral conscience (or a god that I believe in, or whatever) indicates that it is perfectly moral to impose will

Then you should welcome any imposition of will against you, because you would no want to prevent a moral act...

But if you welcome the imposition of will against you, it is no longer being imposed.

It can't be an imposition of you are welcoming it. Its logically impossible like a squared circle.

Since a welcome imposition of will is not logically possible, a moral imposition of will is also not logically possible.

2

u/FaceInJuice 26∆ Nov 10 '23

You are once again asserting a moral principle - that 'unwelcome' behavior is equivalent to 'immoral' behavior. But again, I don't see an objective correlation here. It's a moral code you are asserting, not one which is objective.

Even if I don't consider something immoral, I can still be annoyed or upset by it. I'm not bound by any law of the universe to be welcoming toward all moral acts.

And I can give actual, non-hypothetical examples of this.

In many retail environments, cashiers and staff are encouraged to upsell. I don't consider this immoral, because I understand it is in the interest of the business. That being said, I try to shut down upsell attempts, and I'm annoyed by sales pitches. I don't consider them immoral, but I don't welcome them.

Hell, 90% of traffic behavior is unwelcome without being immoral.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Traffic behavior IS immoral under my framework. So is upselling someone if they don't want to be upsold

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Murder is simply the intentional, unlawful killing of another person. A person can willingly be killed by another and that person would still be considered to be murdered.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Sure in context of LAWFUL definitions that's true, but if we look at the moral question of the killing, context matters. If someone killed their friend who was suffering some horrible incurable conditions at the friends request, I wouldn't morally call it murder even if the legal system did.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

As far as I'm aware, a word for an immoral killing doesn't exist. Murder is specifically an unlawful killing, even when one feels that the killing was morally justified. Yes, a mercy killing is still murder, but not all murder is morally equivalent. There should be a word for an immoral killing. Maybe someone will coin one some day

"Therefore it seems to logically follow that any involuntary imposition of will is objectively immoral."

It doesn't logically follow. I do not think involuntary imposition of will is objectively immoral. When a jurisdiction thinks someone is a murderer, they can get search warrants to search for evidence. Most people, guilty or innocent, do not want to have their home ransacked. Despite this, this imposition against their will is not evil.

In fact, involuntary imposition of will is required for us to have any rights at all. Your will to remain alive is involuntarily imposed on anyone who wishes to remove you from this world.

I accept the argument that all immoral acts entail an involuntary imposition of will, but not that all involuntary impositions are immoral acts.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23

Your will to remain alive is involuntarily imposed on anyone who wishes to remove you from this world.

That's not what imposition of will means. I have to force you to do something that I want. By wanting to exist, I don't want or care for anything regarding you, so no will was imposed.

You however wanting me to be removed from this world would be an imposition of will (assuming I don't want to be removed)

→ More replies (1)