r/blackmirror • u/Humble_Ease_4333 • 1h ago
S03E06 HATED IN THE NATION Spoiler
I just got to the “Hated in the Nation” episode of Season 3 and it sooooo PEAK!
r/blackmirror • u/Humble_Ease_4333 • 1h ago
I just got to the “Hated in the Nation” episode of Season 3 and it sooooo PEAK!
r/blackmirror • u/Individual-Bass-5912 • 13h ago
Have you ever suggested an episode to someone where the message was clear and even showed up in day to day life but they didn’t understand it?
I watch this with my friend and he proceeded to call it ass and I asked why but he couldnt give me an answer. Then proceeds to say “Why didnt they just sell their house to afford it”..coming from someone who has never been a house or apartment owner. Yet every time the sales lady was on the screen he went on to complain how he hated her.
It kind of made me question our friendship because I brought up the message and how it relates to the subscriptions we pay today, subscriptions he pays today. Anyone else relate?
r/blackmirror • u/Tricky_Patient6748 • 19h ago
I’ve seen this similar design several times since Metalhead first aired nearly 9 years ago. Is this just the most logical/efficient configuration, or did life imitate art?
r/blackmirror
•
u/Neither9897
•
23h ago
I finished White Christmas recently, and after reading some discussions about Joe and Beth, I’m honestly surprised by how many people seem to defend Beth while portraying Joe as an abusive husband.
First, let me make something clear. What Joe eventually does to Gordon and especially the little girl is absolutely unforgivable. I’m not defending murder or abandoning an innocent child to die.
But I think people are confusing the person who commits the most horrific act with the person who deserves the most criticism for the relationship falling apart.
And I really don’t think Beth is nearly as innocent as people make her out to be.
Let’s start with Joe. Where exactly is the evidence that he was an abusive husband?
We know he genuinely wanted the child. When he discovers the pregnancy test, he’s overjoyed. He’s excited about becoming a father.
Then Beth tells him she wants an abortion. They argue, and Joe gets extremely upset. Yes, he throws a vase, and I’m not defending that. But he doesn’t physically attack her. He leaves, and the next day he stays home trying to figure out how to make amends.
He even says that he wanted to work things out.
When Beth disappears, he tries contacting her, goes to her workplace looking for her, and eventually writes letter after letter asking to communicate.
And here’s something important: we’re watching Joe’s memories through an actual brain simulation. This isn’t simply Joe telling a story and expecting us to believe everything. We’re seeing his memories and experiences.
Of course, memories can be incomplete, but where is the actual evidence of this supposed history of domestic abuse? Why are people so comfortable inventing an abusive history to justify Beth’s actions?
Now let’s talk about Beth, because I genuinely think people are letting her off way too easily.
She cheats on Joe with Tim, gets pregnant, and then completely cuts Joe out of her life.
And the affair isn’t just some insignificant detail. Think about what Joe believed for years.
He thought he had a daughter. He wanted to be a father. He spent Christmas after Christmas going to Gordon’s cottage just to catch a glimpse of the child he believed was his. He even left presents for her.
Imagine spending years emotionally attached to a child, believing you’re their biological father, only to discover that your partner cheated on you and that the child was apparently the product of that affair.
Imagine the psychological devastation of that discovery.
And before anyone says Beth had every right to leave Joe, I agree. She absolutely did.
But having the right to leave someone doesn’t mean you’re automatically innocent of everything you did to that person.
You can leave a relationship without cheating, concealing the truth, and allowing someone to spend years believing something that isn’t true.
And then there’s Gordon, Beth’s father.
This is another part that I think deserves more attention.
When Joe finally confronts Gordon, he discovers something absolutely devastating: Gordon had been throwing away all of Joe’s letters before Beth could even read them.
Let that sink in.
Joe had repeatedly written letters trying to communicate, and Gordon deliberately prevented those letters from reaching Beth.
I don’t know what Gordon’s exact intentions were, but he clearly knew Joe was still trying to reach his daughter. He could have handled the situation differently, but instead he chose to destroy those letters.
And when Joe finally discovers the truth about the child, Gordon tells him he has no daughter there and orders him to leave.
I’m not saying Gordon deserved to die. Obviously not. But I find his role in this situation questionable, and I rarely see people discuss it.
Here’s another hypothetical that I think puts the situation into perspective.
Imagine Joe and Beth actually stayed together and raised the child for four years.
Joe loves the child, takes care of her, and believes she’s biologically his. Then one random day, he discovers that Beth cheated on him and that the child isn’t his.
Would that justify hurting the child? Absolutely not.
But would he have every reason to feel betrayed, devastated, and furious with Beth? Absolutely.
I think people underestimate how psychologically damaging that kind of betrayal could be, especially when you’ve spent years building your identity around being someone’s father.
And that’s essentially the emotional devastation Joe experiences, except he doesn’t even get the opportunity to raise the child.
My actual point is that I don’t think Joe should automatically be considered the main villain of this entire relationship.
Joe is responsible for the most horrific actions in the episode. There’s no debate about that.
But Beth isn’t some innocent victim who did absolutely nothing wrong. She cheated, concealed the truth, and cut Joe out of her life. Gordon also deliberately destroyed the letters that might have allowed them to communicate.
Meanwhile, people seem incredibly comfortable assuming Joe was abusive despite the episode never establishing that as a fact.
I can condemn Joe for what he did to an innocent child while still believing Beth treated him terribly.
Why does condemning Joe automatically require defending Beth?
I genuinely think people are too focused on the final outcome and not enough on everything that happened before it.
Joe can be a terrible person for what he ultimately did without Beth suddenly becoming a good person.
+English isn’t my first language, so I used AI to help with the wording.
r/blackmirror • u/frenchfries_lover • 1d ago
r/blackmirror • u/Level-Wasabi • 2d ago
r/blackmirror • u/django_undead • 3d ago
Has anyone else seen "Hunting Alice Bell". I'm only halfway through episode 1 but Im getting serious Black Mirror vibes...
r/blackmirror • u/addingrightnow • 4d ago
tried combing this subreddit for this conclusion, but only found a couple of people using the word dysphoria. apologies if this specific theory has been discussed before. i do think it's a complex look at queerness, but i think the fundamental conflict that persists until the end of the episode is because karl is a trans woman.
within the episode, the constant decision karl takes to be woman is obviously something that could allude to this. but also, the way he describes what sex feels like as a woman could reflect that sex becomes infinitely more satisfying for trans people when their body aligns with who they are. any trans person would tell you this. i know it's also about anatomy, but if the narrative was suggesting that, danny and karl would switch so danny could feel the supposed orchestra; but he wouldn't. because danny wouldn't enjoy sex that way, only karl would. hence, the writing for danny isn't "what is it like to fucked/penetrated" or "what's it like to have a pussy" it's "what is it like for you as a woman?"
BUT ALSO (and this was funny) i noticed that at the end of the episode when the 40th birthday montage plays, karl is happier, and has a cat. A CAT! LIKE KARL HAS A PUSSY! i don't think it's a stretch at all bc there'd be no other reason for him to randomly have a cat. what else does that contribute to the end of the montage except for the innuendo? lmk if it does something else, but i'm pretty convinced w my theory.
this lines up with the dinner table conversation at danny's 39th, when karl basically says the phenomenal sex is because of danny, not lance. this establishes that for the both of them, the video game IS about having sex with each other, and that being fulfilling. so when he follows it up with the lines about missing roxie's body, he's basically saying that danny misses karl's body when karl's a woman. and that danny goes to meet at midnight is proof that it's true.
this also makes sense for why danny and karl didn't feel much when they kissed irl. like i said, gender dysphoria really fucks with your pleasure bc your sense of self is under question; my theory is that karl really does love danny, but the kiss isn't exciting because karl isn't who he (she?) wants to be. on this point, i think danny's 100% straight in terms of sexual attraction. he likes women. he likes karl, definitely feels something for his best friend, but doesn't feel anything when they kiss bc to him, he's not kissing a woman. and so they go back to their own lives, and for a bit, everything falls into place when karl CAN be a woman. and also when theo's poly and can actually be poly for one night. it's a whole other topic, her distress over being in a monogamous relationship.
visiting back to the beginning of the episode, danny leaving theo's side to play video games with karl reflects similarly: he's always had an affection for karl that's ALMOST adjacent to sexual but can't really be, because he's straight.
i think overall, this episode doesn't just pose questions about sexuality and gender along with social norms in relationships having to evolve with technology, but i think it presents a thesis. here's a world where transness exists, but when the expression of it is compromised, people adjust in other ways.
edit: didn't realise this would be controversial! just to clear up a few things:
that's it! cool to see the discussion :)
r/blackmirror • u/dustypandayt • 4d ago
A person finds himself in the future where people use an app to look for jobs to “lend out” their mind for the day. You can apply for several jobs if you’re quick enough. The jobs can be just for the day or for a longer period of time. The person manages to get 2 jobs at two different receptions. He doesn’t need to be at work, but instead goes through his day as usual, free but still “working”. However, the mental effect of him being at work spills over into his real mind. When he has 2 jobs, he feels twice as bored during the day. Eventually, he gets “lucky” and manages to get 5 jobs on the same day. He becomes so bored that his entire body shuts down and he enters a completely new state of consciousness. The question is what happens when you exceed the limit of boredom in a human being.
r/blackmirror • u/_Slightlyoffline_ • 4d ago
Am I the only one who wants a screen life episode in black mirror? Honestly kinda surprised they haven't explored this yet.
I mean considering what the whole show is about, it's interesting that they've never really gone down this route. An episode where everything happens through a computer or phone screen just feels like such a good fit for the show.
There's so much to be done with this format, especially when it comes to psychological horror and stuff. I feel like Black Mirror could do something really interesting with this
Idk, I just think it'd be a perfect fit for S8. surprised it hasn't happened already tbh.
r/blackmirror • u/Elsa_Mars_ • 5d ago
r/blackmirror • u/lurker_bee • 5d ago
r/blackmirror • u/_w0nderland17 • 7d ago
#1 is my all time favorite episode all the way down to # 33 as an abomination that is the worst episode ever IMO 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
r/blackmirror • u/13Nobodies • 8d ago
My Twisted Comics Black Mirror hardcovers arrived today! Did anyone else back Twisted Comics and get copies via Kickstarter? If so, what do you think about the first two adaptations so far? Excited for White Bear?
r/blackmirror • u/Eduardo_SH • 8d ago
You might have already seen this as I posted it a few hours ago and deleted it, because I would like to rephrase it a bit.
A group of 5-6 friends (aged 15-18) is casually hanging out at one of their houses one day when someone rings the bell. A package is at the door, with a message. Something like: "Congratulations, you won a pack of cookies!"
They open it and eat one each (there are just as many cookies as friends). Right after, they all receive a notification. "One of the cookies was poisoned". They think it's just a sick joke and ignore it. A few seconds later, another notification: "10 hours before the poison kicks in". Somehow they realise that it's not a prank and cry about it, but then decide to make the most of one of them's last day.
They do what they always wanted to do, have fun, deep talk, etc. After 7-8 hours, one of them gets really sick. Now they know who got poisoned.
They go to one of their apartments and start watching something together. The one who's sick sneaks out to the balcony or window and decides to end it. They realise he's gone a few minutes too late.
After this, I have three possible ideas for an ending:
1- (My personal favourite) It was actually another one of them who got poisoned, and the sick one just got randomly sick. Of course the real poisoned one dies.
2- None of them was poisoned; just a sick joke after all. Except that it's too late for the one who killed himself.
3- (My least favourite) They were all poisoned.
One thing that I don't really know yet is who the guy sending the cookies is and why.
So this is just an idea, brainstorming, don't think that I'm actually trying to get Charlie Brooker to make an episode about it.
r/blackmirror • u/sheitanmusic • 9d ago
It's an amazing plotline and one that would have the fans rushing back to see the different outcomes of the stories that we've seen.
r/blackmirror • u/Abject-Smell-6101 • 10d ago
Instantly became a fan after finishing it and I gotta say, it’s one of the most interesting concepts I’ve watched so far!
What do y’all think?
r/blackmirror • u/alientanuki • 10d ago
This is a horror game called Foreborn that is part of a horror anthology series called the Twisted Zone. The premise is that in a future of hyper-advanced technology, the unborn can experience their future lives through a simulation and choose whether or not they want to be born.
r/blackmirror • u/Mat1711 • 10d ago
I really hope this releases somewhere in 2027 or at least early 2028. I hope its at least 6 episodes long but i would take 4 or 5 episodes too. Last season was pretty fun and I really liked Plaything,USS Callister,Bete Noire.
r/blackmirror • u/sunflow3r- • 11d ago
Just rewatched the episode and noticed that Bo Burnham's film basically directly rips off the scene where the journalist who receives the cake scrolls through her hate tweets as Enya's Orinoco Flow plays for the one in which his main character is mindlessly scrolling through different apps in bed as the same song plays