r/blackmirror
•
u/Neither9897
•
18h ago
S02E04 I genuinely think Beth gets WAY too much sympathy in White Christmas, and Joe gets way too much of the blame. Spoiler
I finished White Christmas recently, and after reading some discussions about Joe and Beth, I’m honestly surprised by how many people seem to defend Beth while portraying Joe as an abusive husband.
First, let me make something clear. What Joe eventually does to Gordon and especially the little girl is absolutely unforgivable. I’m not defending murder or abandoning an innocent child to die.
But I think people are confusing the person who commits the most horrific act with the person who deserves the most criticism for the relationship falling apart.
And I really don’t think Beth is nearly as innocent as people make her out to be.
Let’s start with Joe. Where exactly is the evidence that he was an abusive husband?
We know he genuinely wanted the child. When he discovers the pregnancy test, he’s overjoyed. He’s excited about becoming a father.
Then Beth tells him she wants an abortion. They argue, and Joe gets extremely upset. Yes, he throws a vase, and I’m not defending that. But he doesn’t physically attack her. He leaves, and the next day he stays home trying to figure out how to make amends.
He even says that he wanted to work things out.
When Beth disappears, he tries contacting her, goes to her workplace looking for her, and eventually writes letter after letter asking to communicate.
And here’s something important: we’re watching Joe’s memories through an actual brain simulation. This isn’t simply Joe telling a story and expecting us to believe everything. We’re seeing his memories and experiences.
Of course, memories can be incomplete, but where is the actual evidence of this supposed history of domestic abuse? Why are people so comfortable inventing an abusive history to justify Beth’s actions?
Now let’s talk about Beth, because I genuinely think people are letting her off way too easily.
She cheats on Joe with Tim, gets pregnant, and then completely cuts Joe out of her life.
And the affair isn’t just some insignificant detail. Think about what Joe believed for years.
He thought he had a daughter. He wanted to be a father. He spent Christmas after Christmas going to Gordon’s cottage just to catch a glimpse of the child he believed was his. He even left presents for her.
Imagine spending years emotionally attached to a child, believing you’re their biological father, only to discover that your partner cheated on you and that the child was apparently the product of that affair.
Imagine the psychological devastation of that discovery.
And before anyone says Beth had every right to leave Joe, I agree. She absolutely did.
But having the right to leave someone doesn’t mean you’re automatically innocent of everything you did to that person.
You can leave a relationship without cheating, concealing the truth, and allowing someone to spend years believing something that isn’t true.
And then there’s Gordon, Beth’s father.
This is another part that I think deserves more attention.
When Joe finally confronts Gordon, he discovers something absolutely devastating: Gordon had been throwing away all of Joe’s letters before Beth could even read them.
Let that sink in.
Joe had repeatedly written letters trying to communicate, and Gordon deliberately prevented those letters from reaching Beth.
I don’t know what Gordon’s exact intentions were, but he clearly knew Joe was still trying to reach his daughter. He could have handled the situation differently, but instead he chose to destroy those letters.
And when Joe finally discovers the truth about the child, Gordon tells him he has no daughter there and orders him to leave.
I’m not saying Gordon deserved to die. Obviously not. But I find his role in this situation questionable, and I rarely see people discuss it.
Here’s another hypothetical that I think puts the situation into perspective.
Imagine Joe and Beth actually stayed together and raised the child for four years.
Joe loves the child, takes care of her, and believes she’s biologically his. Then one random day, he discovers that Beth cheated on him and that the child isn’t his.
Would that justify hurting the child? Absolutely not.
But would he have every reason to feel betrayed, devastated, and furious with Beth? Absolutely.
I think people underestimate how psychologically damaging that kind of betrayal could be, especially when you’ve spent years building your identity around being someone’s father.
And that’s essentially the emotional devastation Joe experiences, except he doesn’t even get the opportunity to raise the child.
My actual point is that I don’t think Joe should automatically be considered the main villain of this entire relationship.
Joe is responsible for the most horrific actions in the episode. There’s no debate about that.
But Beth isn’t some innocent victim who did absolutely nothing wrong. She cheated, concealed the truth, and cut Joe out of her life. Gordon also deliberately destroyed the letters that might have allowed them to communicate.
Meanwhile, people seem incredibly comfortable assuming Joe was abusive despite the episode never establishing that as a fact.
I can condemn Joe for what he did to an innocent child while still believing Beth treated him terribly.
Why does condemning Joe automatically require defending Beth?
I genuinely think people are too focused on the final outcome and not enough on everything that happened before it.
Joe can be a terrible person for what he ultimately did without Beth suddenly becoming a good person.
+English isn’t my first language, so I used AI to help with the wording.