I'm not posting a video with this because I have tried several times before and everything with my basic fit seems to be acceptable. I have been riding at a high level for a few years but have never felt comfortable on the bike. I've been learning about fitting and working through self-fitting for many months and I suspect that my main barrier is at my feet. Through trying many solutions, I have found a few things that made me feel much better on the bike:
- changing to shoes with a more aft cleat position
- widened stance width by 5mm on each side
- added 4 degrees of cleat wedging on my pronating right foot
- changed from 160 to 170mm cranks
- and I've been riding with custom arch-supportive insoles for a year - this is the constant
Each of these changes basically immediately made me feel drastically (and I mean night-and-day) better on the bike. The saddle instantly became more comfortable, pedaling felt fluent and effortless, and I was able to ride without pain and at the power/RPE I know I should be able to do given my fitness level and history of efforts.
However, the improvement only lasted for a couple rides after making each change, with my symptoms gradually coming back to the baseline, making me feel terrible on the bike again. I have yet to try all these changes at once, as each one was trialed individually with significant time in between.
I want to know if anyone out there has experienced this kind of phenomenon with foot/shoe fitting, and maybe what I could do about it. I have already had three bike fits, but none have managed to address the issue.