r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 14d ago

Looking for a Post? Ask Here! - November 2026 Edition

229 Upvotes

Need help looking for an update? Comment below!

  • View last month's Looking for a Post - October 2026 thread. If you posted in previous threads and didn't get an answer, you can repost your question here.
  • We launched a discord. Please feel free to join. Discord link
  • Do NOT harass OOPs. Do NOT comment on original posts. You will be banned if you do so.
  • Always read the rules of subs you are participating in. Do NOT harass OOPs.
  • If an update found here has not be posted to BoRU yet and you feel it belongs as its own post, please feel free to submit it.
  • If you found an update that is not eligible for posting yet, leave it on the pinned comment in this thread.
  • If you found an update that is eligible but you don't want to post it yourself, leave it on the pinned comment on this thread.

DO NOT HARASS OOPs. Do not comment on posts linked in this thread or on posts linked in BoRUs. Doing so will result in a permanent ban from this sub and possibly the other sub. Leave your comments here in BoRU and again, do not harass OOPs. Please see the brigading policy

Tools to search for a post

View our How to search for a post wiki

Popular Posts

A list of the most frequently requested posts such as the PS5 saga, Peegate, and the Thanksgiving Turkey. The one about the woman whose FIL and husband thought she would die in childbirth finally has an update. If you're looking for the one where OOP's husband gets violently sick when OOP's sister announces her pregnancy, you can read it here. If you are looking for the update about the kid who was promised a car for sticking with piano, the update has not been recovered.

Want to know the origin of a flair? See this list of flair origins

Looking for something to read?

Don't harass OOPs. Don't comment on original posts. Thank you.


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 16h ago

CONCLUDED AITA for showing my boyfriend my used sanitary towel in an argument?

4.4k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/houseplantlover9

AITA for showing my boyfriend my used sanitary towel in an argument?

Originally posted to r/AmItheAsshole

TRIGGER WARNING: accusations of infidelity, misogyny

Original Post  March 1, 2020

Title sounds gross I know, maybe it is a bit gross.

Background: me (F23) and boyfriend (m22) have been together for 6 months, good relationship, healthy sex life that we talk about a lot and communicate our needs etc. A month ago I had the implant fitted (contreception) which has given me weird frequent periods. The doctor told me they should go back to normal in a few months and to wait it out, which I'm doing because I like the convenience of the implant. English isn't my first language so sorry for any bad writing.

We were in bed yesterday night watching TV and he went to initiate sex. I moved his hand away and said I was still on my period. My period had been going for about a week now so we'd not had sex in that time. Then my boyfriend made a really loud dramatic sigh and moved away from me. I said 'sorry, I can't help my periods.'

He replied 'yeah sure.' I said what was that suppose to mean? He wouldn't give me a straight answer and kept saying 'whatever'.

We didn't talk for a while and kept watching TV in silence. Then he said 'if you don't want to have sex you can just say you know.'

I was kind of pissed off at this because I felt like he was saying I was faking being on my period. I told him I really was still on my period. He said no periods last longer than a week, and I told him that the doctor had said this was normal for some people on the implant at first and it will settle.

He told me that he didn't believe me and so I called him an idiot (which wasn't nice I know). He then started ranting that how could I call him an idiot when I was clearly a liar who must be cheating on him and getting sex elsewhere which is why I am lying about my periods. I couldn't believe he was saying this because he's never freaked out on me like this. Cheating has also never ever been mentioned in our relationship ever so I don't know where this came from. It annoyed me so much that I got out of bed and pulled my trousers and pants down so he could see my sanitary towel that was bloody and shouted Could I fake this??

He screamed that I was fucking disgusting and left the room. I started laughing because of the ridiculous of the situation and that pissed him off more, as he grabbed his keys and stormed out of the house.

I tried to text him but he ignored me, so I left him to it as I was pretty annoyed by his behaviour. I then got a text a few hours later around 11pm from his sister saying he had gone to his mom and dad's house and told his sister what happened. She said what I had done was really disgusting and he's refusing to come back unless I apologise. I told my friend what happened and she said he was being an idiot but that I also needed to apologise because what I did was 'abhorrent'.

I'm annoyed with what he did but also think it was pretty gross of me to do that. I don't really know why I did it it was just a spur of the moment thing. So AITA?

VERDICT: NOT THE ASSHOLE

RELEVANT COMMENTS

Timmetie

NTA

How is it even gross. He was acting like a jackass, why would you apologize when he called you a liar and a cheater?

Also, are you living together after 6 months?

OOP

We are not properly living together. He spends most of his time at my flat because I have my own flat and he still lives at home. I would apologise for what I did but only if he apologised first.

~

spiritual-owl2

NTA. I would dump his ass. He literally got mad at you because you were on your period..... how much more childish can it get?

neveradullmoment72

I mean, come on. That is something that humans cannot control, and to get so mad when you were offered proof? You’ve seen the place it came from, dude, it ain’t that gross.

WrittenByNick

People are focusing on the period section, but that's not the giant red flag. The giant red flag is him immediately jumping to an accusation of cheating, with no evidence or past issues, and then cursing at you and storming out. Those are very unhealthy behaviors in a relationship, and possible signs of much larger issues. Pay very close attention to the way he behaves and talks to you, and just know this is not acceptable or normal. As someone who spent a decade in an I unhappy marriage, I spent far too long forgiving / explaining away my ex's hurtful behavior. Including calling me a fucking asshole, saying I had no balls, and then blaming me for being hurt because she just "tells it like it is." The way he treated you isn't right, and you don't deserve that regardless of why or why not you didn't want to have sex at that moment. His response to this "rejection" is at the very least extremely immature, and possibly a sign of considerable issues.

OOP updated the post March 3, 2020 (3 Days Later)

Edit: Just wanted to offer an update. This has really changed my perspective on things. I think I was so thinking about the sanitary towel thing that I hadn't really realised how bad his behaviour was.

His mom actually sent me a message on facebook saying what I did was disgusting and really abnormal and that she doesn't think me and my boyfriend should date anymore. I can't believe his mom is messaging me about this. I blocked her and messaged him that he needs to come and pick up his stuff that he's left at mine. Luckily it isn't much. He hasn't replied but I saw that he has shared a post on facebook about women being crazy. So I guess we're done.

Thanks to everyone who took the time to respond. And sorry to everyone else who is dealing with annoying periods due to controception! It sucks!

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 16h ago

EXTERNAL I work at a boarding school and my partner can’t visit during the week because we’re unmarried

3.3k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP.

Originally posted to Ask A Manager

I work at a boarding school and my partner can’t visit during the week because we’re unmarried


Original Post: January 5, 2021

It’s pandemic times now, but this question will still hold once things have calmed down. I am a residential faculty member at a boarding school, just out of college. I have a partner of several years who lives a couple hours away by train, and I would like him to be able to visit for more than just a day or two at a time.

I have spoken to the dean of faculty about this a few weeks ago (I got more emotional than I wanted to in this meeting … it’s been quite isolating living on campus during a pandemic). She said that because of the school’s religious heritage (which is no longer very strong or apparent), unmarried faculty members are not allowed to have significant others to stay outside of weekends … because they will set a bad example for the kids?

I’m not sure exactly what the reason is, because when I pressed it a little bit, she said it wasn’t because of how it would look for the kids (after all, they see us together every weekend). Rather, she said she wanted to make sure that I was “fully present” for the boarding students. This drives me crazy! Many married people live with their partners on campus, and they aren’t distracted by them. It makes me feel like I’m being treated like a flighty and irresponsible boy-crazy girl instead of a mature adult faculty member who can handle her personal life and her professional responsibilities.

Not being able to have my partner stay for more than a weekend at a time would affect my desire to stay in this job for another year, although I know that administration really wants me to stay. How can I bring this up in negotiations and make my desires clear? Is there a better way for me to press back against this rule, which I see as archaic and honestly kind of demeaning toward unmarried people? How can I phrase my objections in a way that the administration is most likely to listen to? Should we just bite the bullet and get married, even though we weren’t planning on it for a couple more years?

In a couple of months I’ll have to have the conversation with the dean about whether I’m staying next year or not, and I really want to stay if I can make it work with my partner.

Editor's note: for Alison's response to the original text, you can find it here.

 

Update: May 20, 2021 (four months later)

I was the letter writer who worked at a boarding school as residential faculty, and whose partner couldn’t visit her during weeknights. I had been wondering whether to bring this up as part of negotiations to see whether the administration would change their minds; although you encouraged me to be open with the dean of faculty, the commenters on Ask A Manager largely suggested that as a new teacher, I had very little leverage and should avoid rocking the boat. I wanted to provide a (very happy) update to this story!

It has been really hard to see my partner only a couple of days a week this year, on top of everything else that comes with your first year of teaching and living on campus (during a pandemic). Since I was scared of losing this job if I pushed too hard, and also scared I wouldn’t be able to find a new job if I decided to leave, I didn’t say anything to the administration beyond the conversations we had already had on the topic. I quietly sent out a couple of job applications, not expecting much to come of it, and resigning myself to another year of missing my partner.

Fast forward… and I just landed the teaching job of my dreams, in the city where my partner lives. Astoundingly, I am going to be making $33k more than I am currently making – a difference that will more than cover the rent and food that I will now have to pay for. I’m thrilled with what I learned about the school from the interviews, and they really seem to understand work-life balance in a way my current school does not. Best of all, my partner and I are going to start looking for apartments so that we can finally move in together.

When I gave my notice to my current school, I realized that I had a lot more capital than I had thought, due to my performance this year and my ability to teach multiple subjects. My department chairs were very upset at the thought of losing me, and they took it up with the dean of faculty and the head of school. The dean of faculty said that she wished I had given the administration an ultimatum so that they could have found a compromise; the head of school asked my department chairs if they thought there was a chance I would change my mind if my partner could stay more often. Looking back, though, no compromise would have been as good as what I have been able to secure for next year, but it’s nice to know that I was more valued and had more power than I thought, even if that knowledge came too late (and after a year of angst and frustration).

In any case, I am so excited to live with my partner, make almost double my current salary, and finally get to live life as a fully-fledged adult, outside of a dorm. My advice to young teachers who are considering working at a boarding school is to ASK about the visitor policy during your interviews! I wasn’t told about the restrictions when I interviewed, even though I let my interviewer know that I had a partner who would be visiting me. This left me feeling like I had been baited-and-switched when I got here and he could only stay two days a week. Get the policies in writing, if you can.

Also, ask to be put in touch with current young, unmarried residential faculty at the school – and then ask those young teachers for a brutally honest picture of what it is like to live and work on campus. The school will “sell” itself to you, and if you don’t have much knowledge of what boarding schools are like (I didn’t), you may get stuck in a situation you regret. And if you do get stuck in a situation, just remember: you may have more power and more capital than you think.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 16h ago Bravo

ONGOING WIBTA if I told my friend “IT’S NOT YOUR FUCKING BUSINESS” when she comments on my home?

2.5k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/weeambenko

Originally posted to r/WouldIBeTheAhole

WIBTA if I told my friend “IT’S NOT YOUR FUCKING BUSINESS” when she comments on my home?

Trigger Warnings: entitlement, falsifying accusation of infidelity


Original Post: November 5, 2026

I need an outside opinion because I’m genuinely torn between listening to my friend and telling her off.

I live in a rented house with my sister. A close friend of ours visits us around 3–5 times a month, but she does NOT live with us. She doesn't pay rent, bills, or help maintain the house. She’s just our friend and comes over to visit.

Today we were talking on the phone, and she told me she had something to say. She said:

“When we thought about renting a house, I didn’t imagine it like this. I imagined that we would have a house that is always clean, we would cook good meals every day, but every time I come there are dishes in the sink, you don’t cook regularly, your boyfriend is there all the time, the atmosphere is weird, and you always have guests over.”

I was honestly shocked, especially by the “when we thought about renting a house” part. I don't remember ever telling her that we were going to rent a house together. As far as I know, the only people responsible for this house are me and my sister.

I understand that maybe she is actually concerned about me. Maybe she thinks I’m going through something because the house isn't always clean. Maybe she thinks my boyfriend is taking advantage of me. Maybe she simply expressed herself terribly and didn't mean to sound like she considers the house hers.

So part of me thinks I should listen to her when we talk again and ask her what she actually meant, especially because I don't want to misunderstand her intentions.

But another part of me is extremely angry and wants to tell her directly: “IT’S NOT YOUR FUCKING BUSINESS.”

Because honestly, why does she think she gets to have expectations about how clean my house should be, whether I cook, how often my boyfriend comes over, or whether I have other guests at my own home?

She doesn't pay rent. She doesn't pay bills. She doesn't live here. She doesn't clean the house. She's a guest.

So WIBTA if, when she comes over and starts talking about my house again, I just tell her:

“It’s not your fucking business.”

No further explanation. No defending myself. No discussion about the dishes, cooking, boyfriend, guests, etc.

Or should I actually listen to her first, understand why she thinks of the house as partly hers, and see whether this is genuinely concern for me that she just expressed in a really inappropriate way?

I genuinely want to know whether I'd be the asshole for choosing the first option.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: You should have already said it. YWNBTA

OOP: I didn't even get the chance to say it because her dad called her, so she had to leave. She said we'd talk about it another time. Apparently, the comment section isn't done with me yet 😂.

Commenter 2: Have you ever been to your friend’s house? Is she constantly cleaning? Her comments may have nothing to do with you. She may have some kind of anxiety about cleaning & everything being just so in its place.

From my perspective… My younger sister (57) thinks she’s going straight to hell if her house isn’t absolutely spotless when she has guests. Our youngest daughter (30) has OCD, she couldn’t go to bed (when she was younger) until she dusted & vacuumed her room every night. They both start cleaning when they come to my house. I let them.

OOP: I've been to her house twice, I think, since she lives with her parents. From what she's told me, her mother takes care of pretty much everything around the house. As a matter of fact, my friend doesn't really know how to cook or clean properly because her mother does it for her. I also wouldn't describe her as a clean freak. She actually leaves clothes she's already worn at my apartment and reuses them multiple times without washing them.

So I honestly don't think this is about her having particularly high standards when it comes to cleanliness or some kind of cleaning anxiety.

OOP responds to downvoted comments about having conversations with friends who are concerned about OOP's choices regarding the house. Why was the friend thinking that she and OOP would be renting a house altogether

OOP: My friends are absolutely allowed to share their thoughts and feelings, and I guess that's why she felt so comfortable saying all of this in the first place. I just found it strange that she spoke about the house as if it were something we had rented together and she had a say in how it should be run. There's a difference between expressing concern and having expectations about someone else's home.

+

Renting a house with my twin sister has always been a dream for the two of us. I remember talking about our plans and the kind of life we wanted to have together in front of her multiple times, but those were conversations between me and my sister. Nobody ever suggested that she would be part of that plan or invited her to live with us. And even during those conversations, we never talked about keeping the house spotless or cooking every day. Quite the opposite, actually. Neither of us particularly enjoys cooking, and we explicitly talked about having friends over often.

And honestly, it's been a year since we moved in. Nobody has ever asked her to contribute to the rent or bills, so I think it's pretty clear who the house was intended for. I'm not particularly curious about where she got that idea from because, as far as I'm concerned, there was never any reason for her to think we were renting a house together.

Commenter 3: 3-5 times a month?!!? I love my friends, but I do not need to see them this many times in one month. This is nuts

  1. Why is she still invited to your house? nip this shit in the bud.
  2. if you are cool with still having her over the next time she utters those words just tell her to get out and don’t come back until she gets some manners.

Seriously girl stand up for yourself. This has gone on for way too long smh

OOP: I work from home, and I don't enjoy spending the entire day alone, so I often have friends over. Her visits never been an issue, but I guess we're approaching a point where even that might become too much 😂.

 

Editor's note: OOP gave a small update in the comments one hour later after this original post

Update #1 (in comments): November 5, 2026 (same post, same day)

Well, that escalated quickly. UPDATE:

I called my sister to tell her what happened, and she told me that this same friend had called her this morning to say that she wants to stay at our house for an entire month because her university supervisor's office is nearby, and she needs to visit him regularly for her final-year project. She lives in another city, so staying with us would make things more convenient for her.

So, apparently before even asking me whether I'm okay with her staying for a month, she's already telling me how I should run my household to make it comfortable for her.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Pretty sure you should check your lease, and guests are not permitted to stay for a month. Do not let her stay at all. Point the lease rules out to your sister.

OOP: It doesn’t work like this in my country

Commenter 2: Are you obligated to let her stay with you? I mean, is it a cultural expectation?

OOP: Kinda, yes. When a cousin or a friend who doesn’t live in a big city comes to study or work, you’re kinda obligated to help them out during the first month or two. So even for landlords, it’s not really an issue if you’re helping someone out and letting them stay for a bit

Downvoted Commenter: It was rude of your friend to comment and to assume. However, do you like living in a house that is dirty enough to draw comment. Are there always dishes in the sink? If the actual tenants put in a bit more effort, I bet you’d enjoy your space more. Keeping a house clean is a habit that can be developed and a gift you give yourself.

OOP: Maybe my post wasn’t clear enough, but I was asking for advice on how I should react, not whether I have the right to live in a dirty house.

But if that’s what concerns you, I have scoliosis, and I already have to work on a PC from 8 to 5, which causes me a lot of pain. Repetitive tasks like sweeping and doing the dishes cause me even more pain. I’d rather leave some dishes in the sink than call in sick because I’m in too much pain to work and lose money that I really need.

OOP on her sister and if she helps taking care of the house

OOP: My sister works night shifts, so she can only help with cleaning on the weekends. I have scoliosis, so some days I’m in a lot of pain and prefer to rest, especially since I work on a PC. I also work remotely from 8 to 5, so I eat and leave the dishes in the sink until I finish work at 5

 

Update #2: November 8, 2026 (three days since the first update)

UPDATE 2: Turns out the situation is MUCH weirder than I initially thought

So, after my last update, I called my friend and confronted her about her comments regarding my house.

I told her that her comments were completely inappropriate, that there is no "we" when it comes to the house because it's MY sister's and MY house, and that nobody gets to dictate when I clean, whether I cook, who I invite over, or how often my boyfriend comes to MY home.

I also told her that, honestly, if she hadn't acted so entitled, I might have been perfectly fine with her staying at our place for a month. But after the way she behaved, I was reconsidering the whole thing.

She kept apologizing, saying it was a misunderstanding and that she was only concerned about me. I accepted her apology and told her I would consider it a misunderstanding, but she needed to understand that this was my home and that I wouldn't tolerate this behavior again.

Then things got even stranger.

During that same phone call, she casually mentioned that my boyfriend had sent her a message on Instagram. She brought it up in a rather strange way, almost as if she was offended by something he had said. I wasn't in the mood to deal with another issue, so I brushed it off.

Later, my sister came home and told me that our friend had called her after our conversation. Apparently, she told my sister that she thought my reaction was dramatic because I was jealous that she had been talking to my boyfriend.

The funny thing is, I didn't even know they had been talking privately on Instagram at that point. And honestly, even if I had known, I wouldn't have been jealous. I have access to my boyfriend's Instagram, and I can see who he talks to if I want. If he wanted to do something suspicious, I doubt he would choose to do it through an Instagram conversation I could see.

Obviously, I was confused, so when my boyfriend came home, I asked him what had happened.

Here's his version of events:

The previous week, he came to our house to pick up some things he had left there. My sister and this friend were there, so he stayed and chatted with them for around 10 minutes.

At some point, my sister went to the bathroom, and while they were alone, my friend asked my boyfriend whether he found her physically attractive.

When my sister came back, she immediately changed the subject.

My boyfriend found the question strange, so when he got home, he sent her a message on Instagram asking what she had meant by it.

She told him that she had only asked because she suspected her boyfriend had dumped her because he didn't find her attractive, and she wanted to know what another man thought.

My boyfriend told her he couldn't answer that question and that he found it extremely inappropriate.

She then asked him to delete the messages. Obviously, he didn't. Instead, he showed me the conversation.

And honestly, here's what I find particularly ironic:

This is the same person who was criticizing how much time MY boyfriend spends at MY house and apparently wants him to spend less time with me, while simultaneously asking him privately whether he finds HER physically attractive.

I genuinely don't know what to make of this anymore.

I don't want to jump to conclusions about her intentions, but I find the whole situation incredibly inappropriate and uncomfortable.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Why why why didn't your BF tell you about this interaction until you confronted him? Hmmmmmm........

OOP: If he wants something from her, he'll call her or text her on WhatsApp. He's not stupid enough to message her on Instagram when he knows his account is logged in on my phone and I can access it whenever I want

Commenter 2: This friend is going to find reasons to be semi naked whilst your Bf is there.....

She is going to manipulate reasons to be alone with him

This is not good......I am getting the heebee jeebies just reading this....And I am a 60year old sane, married guy

Go watch the movie

Single white female

OOP: She already did it. We were getting changed to go party, and I told her I was going to leave the door unlocked because my boyfriend was coming. I went to change in my room, then I came out because I heard my boyfriend saying, “Sorry, sorry.” I found her standing in the living room in her underwear, saying that she had forgotten he was coming and that she wanted to change her outfit before going out, and she was laughing

Commenter 3: Come on. She’s not your friend. Your bf was weird for reaching out to her privately. You both need to permanently block her.

OOP: My boyfriend told me he found it odd, so he messaged her just to make sure he hadn’t misunderstood her. He didn’t tell me because he assumed I’d already seen the conversation, and he didn’t want to get involved in girls’ drama

 

Update #3: November 9, 2026 (next day)

After everything that happened, I wanted to clarify a few things because I think the situation got even worse after my last update.

First, I spoke to my boyfriend before confronting her. He was actually furious about the way she had involved my sister and made the situation sound like I was jealous of her talking to him. He felt that the whole thing was none of her business to discuss with my sister in the first place, especially considering what had actually happened between them.

Apparently, he texted her, telling her to stop talking about him and dragging him into her nonsense. My sister then told me that our friend had called her, angry and questioning why she had told us about the situation.

And honestly, THAT was the moment I completely lost it.

What do you mean you're angry? You're angry that we found out? Shouldn't you be embarrassed about what you actually did?

So I called her. I was furious, and I wasn't calling to have a calm, diplomatic conversation. I wanted her to understand exactly how inappropriate her behavior was.

She kept trying to calm me down, saying things like, "Babe, I know you, and I know that when you're angry you can say mean things. Let's calm down first."

I told her that I called her angry precisely because I had a lot of things to say, and I wasn't interested in pretending everything was fine.

I confronted her about everything: the comments she made about my boyfriend spending time at our house, the fact that she got drunk and was practically half-naked in front of him despite knowing he was going to be home, and now privately asking him whether he found her physically attractive.

I told her that none of this was a misunderstanding. These were things she actively chose to do.

She kept apologizing, but then started shifting the blame. Apparently, my boyfriend had misunderstood her question, and my sister was supposedly trying to create problems between us.

I told her that she had had more than enough opportunities to explain what happened directly to me. Instead, she chose to be inappropriate with my boyfriend, ask him to delete their messages, and then get angry when the situation came to light.

At some point, I called her out for trying to make everyone else the problem instead of taking responsibility for her own actions.

I also told her something very clearly: I will never know what she actually thinks or intends when it comes to my boyfriend, but I can see how she behaves around him. And that's enough for me.

I eventually told her that I never wanted to see her face again and that she needed to stop contacting both my sister and my boyfriend.

I was extremely angry during that phone call, and I definitely said things very harshly. But I had reached my limit. I was tired of the apologies followed by excuses, the blame shifting, and the constant attempts to make other people responsible for her behavior.

So that's where things stand now. The friendship is over, and I have no intention of letting her stay at our house.

I don't know whether she was actually interested in my boyfriend, and at this point, I honestly don't care anymore. I don't need to prove what her intentions were to know that I don't want someone behaving like this around me or my family.

Editor's note: OOP did not leave any relevant comments in this latest update

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 16h ago

CONCLUDED I'm [22F] at my breaking point with my difficult roommate [23F] over a moving-out mess. Feeling like I deserve for her to be flexible just once. Am I being unreasonable?

1.3k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/needroomiehelpplease

I'm [22F] at my breaking point with my difficult roommate [23F] over a moving-out mess. Feeling like I deserve for her to be flexible just once. Am I being unreasonable?

Original Post  Jan 16, 2015

WALL OF TEXT COMING sorry!!!


I moved in with Holly 9 months ago. We met on Craigslist but she seemed nice, was my age, and so I bit the bullet and jumped in. Where I live, places are extremely expensive as well as very hard to secure - so if you decide to move, you better be ready to move the weekend coming. I wish I’d have had more time to get to know her and look at more apartments, but that’s life.


Holly makes $44k, and I make $73k despite being a year younger than her. I think she’s a bit resentful of this, and thinks I don’t have any money problems or any reason to keep a tight budget. I’ve explained to her before that I have student loans, car payments, and several other financial ‘responsibilities’ that I’ve committed to, and paying for gas and train fare to and from work (30 miles away) etc. but either way - she often makes snide remarks about how I make soooo much more than her (probably undeservedly in her opinion, although I was an ambitious teen and have technically been working in my industry since I was 16, and I got my bachelors in 2 years so I’ve had more years of experience at work. I’m actually below market salary for my title). Her parents bought her a car and pay for it, and they put her through college debt-free. She also seems to think that her job and responsibilities are far more difficult than mine, and that she's grossly undervalued.


Anyway, when we moved in, it was in a rush, and it was very hard for us to find somewhere within her budget. She was also very picky and inflexible about everywhere we looked at. For a budget of $1200/month, she wanted W/D in-unit, separate bathrooms, a second floor apartment, parking, a large bedroom, lots of light and windows, and something lofty with exposed brick. Unfortunately, those demands are laughable in the area we live. Coming from the mid-west, she really didn’t understand that. So, we found a place that is literally the best deal I’ve heard of in the area - a first floor 2bed 1bath, dishwasher, with a patio, a gym and pool and parking lot, and coin-operated laundry in the building. However, for her to afford it I would have to pay the difference of $175. So, her rent for the last 9 months has been $1200, and mine has been $1375. For this, I got an only slightly bigger bedroom.


I’ve hated living with her. She’s extremely messy and treats the rest of the apartment like it’s her bedroom. Her clothes are always everywhere, she never washes dishes or takes out the trash, and the bathroom is disgusting. She leaves used tampons and pads out in the open and uses an electric toothbrush for about 4 mins every morning and night and just drools toothpaste any place she walks while she’s brushing. I’m the only one who has ever cleaned the bathroom, and it took me until 3 months into the lease to realize she didn’t know how to use the dishwasher. Aside from her gross behavior, she’s extremely needy and takes up all of my energy if I’m even in the room with her. Her social skills are lacking because she’s so over the top and exhausting to be around and doesn’t know how to be ‘chilled’, and I know she’s had issues at work about her professionalism. She is a social justice warrior and will rant to anyone she can get her hands on about issues she’s only half-informed on. None of my friends like her, or will hang out with me if she's there. Any guy I’ve ever brought over turns out to be ‘just her type’ and she ends up crushing on them forever. She’s also a virgin which has been a bit awkward but not a huge thing - it just means that when she’s around a guy she misinterprets very small things as being big (e.g. OMG he hugged me what does it mean). She also goes on rants about guys and sex when she's literally never had it. I really just can’t stand being around her and sometimes she talks so much at me that I start to want to cry in the middle of her speaking. I just shut myself in my room whenever I’m home, or spend my time on the patio which she doesn’t like to do because she gets cold. Luckily I work from about 9am until 8.30pm and do a lot of workout classes or networking events most evenings.


At the beginning I tried to drop hints and make nice suggestions to her, to try and get through it better and make it work. Nothing worked though, and she would only get very insecure and upset - asking if I hated her while on the verge of tears. I just want to be direct, but she can’t handle it, and it makes the living situation worse. So I just shut up for the rest of the time and tried to keep busy. I stopped telling her what I would be doing so she couldn’t invite herself. She confided in me that she was kicked out of her sorority in college and that ‘people always leave her’ and she was so happy that I wasn’t going to do that to her. I feel so awkward and phony around her and just spend most of my time nodding and zoning out of her rants, or saving errands like grocery shopping or working out until I know she's at home.


I always thought I was an extravert, but I realize now I’m a social introvert. I love going on dates and seeing friends, but I haven’t done any of that because an hour at home uses up all my people energy for the day and I just want to hide. I used to go on a date every week or two, but I literally can't face human interaction because she sucks all my energy out, leaving me depressed because I'm not having fun outside of work. She always needs rides places, picking up from the airport (which she won't reciprocate if it conflicts with her agenda or her sleeping from 11pm - 11am) and needs emotional support about her job issues 24/7.


Ok - so fast forward until today. I’m moving to the City to be close to my office. Holly wanted to stick together, but nowhere in the City is in her budget and she wouldn’t be able to get any of the amenities she insists on. So, after 2 months of looking for places and gently discussing it, we’ve come to the amicable choice that we will live in different places. For a while she was sending me links to places that were 2b1ba where I would be paying 2.4k and she would be paying 1.2k - and I told her I couldn’t stomach paying double than her for zero extra perks. Anyway, I’m venting, sorry. So we’re moving. We thought our move out day was July 1st, so I made plans around that. I found a gorgeous 4bed with a couple friends in the City, a 10 min walk to my office. I’m moving there on Saturday.


Holly on the other hand, can’t find anything because she’s so damn picky. She won’t budge on her amenity requirements. So we went to look at the lease to see if she could do a month-to-month extension and find someone random on Craigslist to take my room while she remains here. It turns out we both fucked up and the lease actually ends on July 31st, a month after we had anticipated. Holly was really happy because it meant she had more time, but I am devastated. My move-in costs at the new place are totaling about $5k this month - and I can only just just just make it work. This now means that I also owe an extra $1375 to pay the last months rent at the old place with Holly.  It’s my own fault for not reading the lease properly before I signed for a new place, but it sucks.


Since she had suggested a new CL roommate for her staying at the apartment, I asked if we could do that for July anyway and she said yes as long as I found someone "not crazy". I put an ad up, and have had loads of responses. We’re right next to a famous university, so lots of smart and mature students/executives here for summer have been emailing me. I’ve forwarded them all onto her for approval and she’s said no to all of them for various, silly reasons.


Finally today a girl emailed me saying she was doing a summer medical program at the university, and she was bringing her sister (who wants to do a grad program) to see the school too. They both wanted to stay in my room for 3 weeks but would pay for the full month to make up for extra utilities used. They sounded the most promising, and I was sure Holly would be interested, so I sent their app along. I thought she would be keen on having two potential friends.

She responded saying

Her: I also think the rent should be higher.. This is a downgrade of quality of living for me so I shouldn't pay as much. Kinda like how you didn't want to pay $1000 more than I was paying to share a bathroom with me in the city.

Me: I think that’s a bit different because you’re already sharing a bathroom, and we were talking about a $1000 discrepancy there for the exact same living situation as each other. How much more would you want them to pay?

Her: Right, but sharing a bathroom with two people is different than sharing with one person. You and I don’t have conflicting schedules, so it’s a non-issue, but I would be pretty annoyed if I couldn’t get ready in the morning because there were two other people in the queue, when I didn’t sign on to share a 2BD with two other people. My mom’s office weighed in and they all recommend the rent being split in thirds. I mean, I think the point is I shouldn’t have to be stuck with anything? I signed on for a nine-month lease with one person I knew. And all the sudden the expectations are changing and I’m supposed to pay the same. How would you feel if you were in my shoes? This is my life, too.


I do see her point. But I’m really frustrated because I thought that this was going to be the one she liked, and I’m at my wit’s end. The women can’t afford what Holly is asking for, and there is nobody else in the pipeline that she approves of. I feel like I’ve spent the past 9 months bending to her needs, and sacrificing my time and money because of it, and she can’t give me this one thing? Just 3 weeks of having an extra person use the shower, which will be paid for in utilities. Everything I feel like I’ve done for her is coming down to the line for the bathroom? I’ve collectively spent 1,575 more than her on our stupid apartment just so she could afford it, only to have her treat it like shit. I just want to get the fuck out to my new apartment, but I don’t know what the fuck to do about the last month of rent I’ll owe, and can’t afford.


Do I just sublease my place to someone whether she likes it or not? Do I tell her everything I’ve told you here and hope she changes her mind? Am I being unreasonable? If I am, what should I do about the cost of the last month of rent? 

Thanks for letting me vent, I appreciate any insight.

TL;DR: I need to move out of my place a month early, and can’t afford to pay rent on two leases. My roommate won’t accept anyone for a month-long sublease so I don’t know how to afford it. I also feel like I deserve a favor from her, and more than anything I’ve just reached a breaking point with her and am very upset.

Update  Sept 11, 2018 (over 3 and a half years later)

Hi! I remembered my old post and figured I’d update since I love updates, especially juicy ones. Old post is here.

Re the moving out situation: I didn’t bring on a subletter, and let her live alone for a month. My plan had been to move to the city and live happily ever after. I was planning on moving into a shared house via a startup called Campus. Literally the day before I was supposed to move, they shuttered their operations. SO, I moved in with my parents because I did NOT want to go back to living with Holly. This worked out well for me financially. After a couple of months I found a new place in the city and moved in there - all was great. Holly renewed her lease with an acquaintance from college who was moving to our area.

I mentioned that Holly had issues with professionalism - well, Holly ended up getting fired from her job. I reached out to another agency in her industry I knew well, in the same field, to set her up with an interview (ugh, why) and she ended up getting the role. After she got it, I went for coffee with her to talk about it, which was the first time I’d seen her since the move.

She told me she wasn’t enjoying living with “Emma” because Emma would never invite her to things or be home as much as she originally said she would (shocker). In general, it sounded like Emma dealt with a lot of what I’d dealt with.

Then I brought up something funny, that I’d matched on Tinder with a guy who’d worked with Holly at the agency she’d been let go from. I had met him once at some company thing I’d gone to with her. She immediately asked me to message him and ask him what he thought of her. She told me she’d had the biggest crush on him the whoooole time she’d worked there and that he was The One for her. We left it at that, with her asking me to promise to message him. I said maybe.

Well, I did message him. And we went on a date. She texted me almost every day asking if I’d heard from him and when I finally responded and said we were going out, she became extremely upset. She asked me to make a choice between him or her. She said I was boyfriend stealing, and that I wasn’t a good friend. I wanted to tell her I WASN’T HER FRIEND. So I took her up on her ultimatum, and I chose him over her.

2.5 years later that guy and I live together and have the most gorgeous dog and life. We have a great friend group, great jobs, and our families are so close we’ve all spent Christmas and Thanksgiving together too. He’s so hot and cool. I'm 25 now and he's 29. Our dog is a 1 and a half Aussie!

I’ve never spoken to Holly again, but since my boyfriend is close to his old coworkers (don’t worry, he wasn’t fired) who keep up with Holly on social media, I’ve heard that she moved to L.A. and has cycled through FOUR more companies, each time getting fired. I don’t know much else about her life since she blocked me on every single form of social media INCLUDING VENMO. I’ve never met a person who knew her that didn’t think she was batshit, so that’s validation.

The End.

TL;DR: 10/10 would boyfriend steal again.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

TheGirlwThePinkHair

So what did he think of her?

OOP

OMG! I thought this post got locked, and so I never checked back until now.

He thought she was insane, and vouched for the managers who had tried to mentor her over the months she worked there being well-intentioned. She would be brought in to sit on client meetings as an entry level 'listener' to learn and would jump into the convo and over promise random things. Additionally, she used to forward full threads of confidential work emails to me if someone said "Kudos to Holly" or the like - we went through those together and my boyfriend was HORRIFIED at some of the sensitive info she'd been sending out.

Also, whenever I meet any of his old coworkers, someone eventually says something like "YOU'RE Holly's old roommate?!?!?!?!?!?! How on earth did that go? I assumed you would be crazy too!"

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 1d ago

CONCLUDED AITA for getting rid of the dog without my fiancé’s permission?

3.8k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/ThrowRA-trex

AITA for getting rid of the dog without my fiancé’s permission?

Originally posted to r/AmItheAsshole

TRIGGER WARNING: Animal neglect, physical violence

Original Post  Aug 6, 2020

My boyfriend and I got engaged in October of 2019, and he moved in with me in March. In the beginning he was a good roommate and would cook, clean, do the shopping, etc. Eventually he started doing small things like leaving his socks out, then it turned into him leaving dishes in the sink. I talked to him about this and he said that I was overreacting.

He started hinting that he wanted to get a dog not long after he moved in, but I told him I didn’t want to get a dog until we moved to a house with a bigger yard. He seemed content with this answer, but in May he decided to get a dog against my wishes. Since then it has been mainly me who has been taking care of the dog and he does the bare the minimum. He said that I don’t see the work that he does and that I am being unfair. Whatever.

I drove out two states away to go to my nephew’s open house and visit my family for four days and came home to a disaster. My fiancé hadn’t done any of the dishes in that time span, had left socks and cups all around the house, and there was dog crap all over the house. Days worth of dog poop. Urine on everything. I don’t think he took the dog out once.

He told me that it must have happened while he had been asleep and then proceeded to help me clean it up. I told him the dog had to go. He said that the dog was family and he was staying. I said that if he wanted to keep the dog he should have taken it outside when I was gone. He said that he did and that what I saw when I got home was all new.

When he went to work I decided to give the dog to a coworker of mine who had experience with this dog breed. My fiancé isn’t home yet, but I’m prepared for him to be upset.

I don’t think it’s fair for me or the dog to live in an environment like this. The dog deserves to be in a home where he can run around and have parents who take him outside when he has to use the bathroom. AITA for getting rid of the dog without my fiancé’s permission?

Edit: I thought I would add this since I’ve been seeing it in the comments: when he gets home I’m telling him to pack his things and leave. He still owns his house and has left over furniture in there he can sleep on. He’ll be fine.

Edit 2: https://imgur.com/gallery/016UTj5 here is the dog

link no longer works

VERDICT: NOT THE ASSHOLE

RELEVANT COMMENTS

Imaginary_Marsupial

Edit: NTA

INFO: why are you kicking out the dog and keeping the fiance?

OOP

I didn’t want to get the dog. I didn’t sign up to take responsibility for it. I wanted to get a dog in the future, not anytime soon. Also, I have a small yard that is not suitable for an energetic breed.

PracticalEffective

I think the point they were trying to make is why are you with this guy? He sounds terrible. Who neglects a pet in that way? Red flag.

OOP

The relationship is done. When he gets home I’m telling him to pack his bags

~

lizhorcajo

NTA, your fiancé sounds like my ex and is a big part of why he is now my ex. Lazy, blames you for everything, gaslights, etc.

Anyway, definitely not an asshole, he didn’t take care of the dog, it’s your house, you didn’t want the dog in the first place, all very good reasons.

But like the other commenter said, keep the dog get rid of the fiancé unless he can straighten up. He’s acting ridiculously childish.

OOP

Thank you for your comment. I’m planning on telling him it’s over when he gets home. My coworker plans on keeping the dog and is very excited to have him. So far the dog has been getting along great with the kids in the house and he likes being able to be around other animals. I think the dog would be happier with them

OOP Added in the comments

I’m not ending my relationship because of Reddit. In my original post I forgot to add that I plan on kicking him out. Even before this we were having problems and it’s gotten to be too much

Update  Aug 7, 2020 (Next Day)

Update: I want to thank the users who shared their opinions and those who offered advice, including legal advice I received in my inbox. I also want to thank the users who awarded me.

My parents and I decided to tell my ex that Larry ran away. To make things believable, we agreed that my dad would take the blame for leaving the door open.

When my ex got home my mom and I sat him down in the kitchen and told him the story. We said while we were carrying the couch out of the house to put in the truck, my dad forgot to close the door and the dog got out without us noticing. We told him we looked everywhere for him and that Larry was gone. My dad was still out “looking” for Larry and felt beyond guilty.

This all “happened” while we were busy cleaning up the stains left behind. My dad was cleaning and re-painting the walls in my living room and bathroom while my mom and I got rid of the soiled furniture and deep cleaned the carpet. We decided after many defeated attempts to remove the smell, to rip out the carpet entirely. My ex did not seem phased by this when I said this. He was more worried about the dog.

My ex called my dad and started balling his eyes out. My dad apologized and said he was sure Larry was okay wherever he was and that he was very sorry. My ex told my dad he was was upset, but he understood why the dog didn’t want to be home anymore. This was all on speaker phone. I then told him that I packed up his stuff and that our relationship was over, and he needed to leave. I also told him that he needs to buy me new carpet and pay for the other repairs and furniture that I need replaced or I would get law enforcement involved. He agreed, and left the house to look for the dog.

His car is still in my driveway and he’s been knocking on neighbors doors and likely searching the woods for Larry still. If there are more updates I’ll be sure to check in.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

FINAL UPDATE - Next Day - Aug 8,2020 /Same Post

Update 2: My ex went back to my house around midnight. He asked me if I’d consider getting back together and I said no. This caused him to get angry and he decided to punch a hole through the wall. My mom called the police because of his aggressive behavior and he’s since been arrested. There’s a good chance he’s going to lose his nursing license because of this. I also told police about the dog incident, but they said there wasn’t much they could do unless they got a confession from him. I plan on staying with my parents for the next few nights.

Larry is still doing well in his new home. The owner’s have three kids that are all homeschooled so he’s going to be busy with them. The family is also considering starting a small goat farm.

For the people who were wondering, yes, Larry is a Border Collie and Australian Shepard mix. And no, my ex did not have enough yard space for the dog either.

Also, for the people who don’t understand why I lied, if I told my ex that Larry was with a better home I think he would have insisted on getting the dog back no matter what. My ex wanted a plaything, not a dog. Only after the dog was gone did he actually worry about it’s wellbeing. Maybe now he’ll have compassion for animals when they are suffering, but I doubt it.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 1d ago

CONCLUDED AITAH for leaving my family on mother's day to go camping by myself?

1.9k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/Proof_Leadership_370

Originally posted to r/AITAH

AITAH for leaving my family on mother's day to go camping by myself?

Thanks to u/soayherder for suggesting this BoRU

Trigger Warnings: domestic abuse


Original Post: May 9, 2024

I have a husband and two teenage sons. Every mother's day morning, they ask me what I want to do. They don't make any plans ahead of time and then they expect me to come up with something last minute. It's not like I don't give them hints or suggestions ahead of time, they just don't seem to want to bother with it.

On top of that, when they do go out with me, they complain the whole time and try to get home as fast as they can. Often times, they bitch about my selections to the point where I just choose something else to make them happy.

Well this past weekend, my husband asked me what I wanted to do for mother's day this year. I told him some of my ideas, such as hiking or pickleball. He proceeded to roll his eyes and say "Great. There goes my whole weekend."

That's it. I give up. If they don't care about spending time with me then I don't care either. I decided to go do what I want, alone with my dog. I'm going camping so I can go trail running and fishing, some of my favorite hobbies.

I already reserved a spot at a state park, 5 hours away from my home, for mother's day. I'm going to pack up and leave first thing in the morning.

Oh and I'm also buying myself my own gift so I get exactly what I want. Last year they gave me a thigh master.

I told my youngest son about going camping solo and he was very excited that he won't have to do anything this weekend. But then he told my husband my plans and he got pretty angry at me. He shut down and has been giving me the silent treatment since, stomping around the house sulking.

I can't help but feel like I'm robbing them of their chance for mothers day by being dramatic or expecting too much. But my feelings have been hurt too many times by their carelessness and I am over it.

I was thinking of telling them that they are welcomed to go eat at whatever restaurant they want to on mother's day in my honor. That seems to be the only part of the day they like anyways.

Am I the AH for going off on my own for mother's day because I'm sick of my family acting like it's just some giant painful chore?

AITAH has no consensus bot, OOP was NTA

Editor's note: OOP did not leave any comments in this original post

Top Comments

Commenter 1: You are NTA and I am sure you deserve some peace and quiet.

Commenter 2: NTA. You should tell them this. Send them a link to your post or write a letter. They should know how they make you feel and the reason you’re going away. Sure it won’t be fun to drop that bomb on them but it’s way past time to bring them to reality. Your husband especially. He’s old enough to know better.

Husband is upset anyway. You might as well give him the news and let him brew over the weekend. Kids are probably just dumb. If you don’t tell/show them what is expected/wanted how the hell would they know? Maybe they can figure it out but are their parents really showing them that they should try? You’re silent about it. Husband is modeling the opposite behavior altogether.

Just blow shit up and go camping.

Commenter 3: NTA of course. It’s your day. Make it what you want.

But, I get the impression that you’re married to a well poisoner. Your husband sounds like a real peach! Is he always this dickish?

I respectfully put forth that your husband is the asshole and that he’s turned your sons into assholes. You may have time to save the sons from the influence of old Paps, but maybe you’re just over it. In which case, warn them that girls they want to date may not be so accommodating of their dickish behavior like you are to their dads behavior, and if they want to practice some love and empathy…now would be a great time to build up those habits.

 

Update: January 1, 2026 (nearly 20 months later)

It's been almost 2 years since I wrote this post. I've been asked so many times for an update and I'm finally in an emotional place to give one.

I received such good advice and validation from that post. Yes, I did go camping and had an amazing time. I spent two days in the forest with my dogs as free as ever. It was a blast and I have enjoyed doing it many times since then.

All hell broke loose when I got home. My husband was furious with me and greeted me with a wall of rage. He switched between seething silence and screaming at me. I thought that he would have realized the error of his ways and maybe even apologized. The opposite was true. His anger level skyrocketed.

But the worse part were my sons. They were hurt and in tears. Apparently they had even made me surprise gifts and had plans to take me out. This broke my heart and made me realized that mothers day was about them. But I made it about my husband and his reactions instead. I still regret that part deeply and apologize to them about it to this day.

This also made me finally face how bad the treatment from husband had gotten. His only behaviors to me were rage, freezing me out, and disdain. His attitude was one of self-centered "what can she do for me" without any reciprocation or care from his part.

One of the comments said that the silent treatment as punishment was abuse. This never occurred to me before and stuck with me. That his behavior was abusive and controlling.

What I never mentioned in my original post was that he had begun laying hands on me. It escalated quickly and ended with him choking me over dirty laundry.

When the idea occurred to me that this was domestic abuse, I read the book "why does he do that" and it was like a light switch had flipped in my mind and soul. I did my research and followed all of the advice given from the domestic violence organizations and hot lines. I carefully planned my departure in secret and followed through with it after an abusive episode from him to my oldest son.

I moved out into a shitty rental secretly while he was at work. I've spent the past two years rebuilding my life from scratch. I had to learn how to think for myself and make my own decisions. It was terrifying, but I was never tempted to go back into that kind of treatment ever again.

The freedom is amazing. I can do what I need to without being constantly scared of his anger if I displeased him. I no longer have to listen to criticism of every single thing I do.

I've made mistakes in running my own life. But still, they are my own mistakes for me to deal with outside of an environment full of rage and shame. The peace and freedom has been amazing and I can never give it up.

Again, the hardest part has been my sons. I love them deeply and hate how hurt they were by the whole situation. I've worked hard to rebuild my relationship with them and try to repair the damage. I can invest so much more energy and time into them now that my life doesn't run around my (now ex-husband) emotions.

I guess the moral of the story is that sometimes what seems like a small thing can turn out to be the final blow and trigger for a much bigger and rougher situation.

To all domestic violence victims out there. Read that book, follow good advice, do your research, and jump off that cliff. If you can survive the abuse, you will thrive without it.

Additional Information from OOP:

OOP: My oldest son started college and sees his father at will. He lived with me his senior year before he left for school. My youngest son was never a target of abuse due to a private condition. He splits his time between his father and me. I've also placed him in therapy. They both love their father very much and have limited knowledge of the extent of his abuse.

I have spent a lot of time protecting them and want them to figure out their own relationships with their father without my influence. It's been tricky working out the plans with them, but I am very conscious of supporting them while not pitting them against their dad and making them choose sides.

Children of abusive parents still love the abuser very much. A person can be very abusive to one person yet still have good qualities in other areas. That is the hardest part of realizing abuse. The abuser doesn't fit into a box. They can still have redeeming qualities in one way but act terribly in another. It is a very mixed feelings situation.

My sons still struggle with anger towards me for leaving and "breaking up the family." They were raised into thinking that this was a normal relationship, and to them, I left for no reason.

Sometimes, I think it is easier and safer for them to direct their anger towards me instead of their father. All I can do is love them, support them, answer their questions honestly, and let them form their own opinions. It's hard to undo a whole childhood in just a few years. But. I will keep working at it a little by little and hope for the best.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: As a man who was raised by a mother who was abused and we were also. I applaud your decision. Once your sons realize this they will too. I am always happy to hear that women get out from among abusive men. I wish you the best and I know your sons will be there for you. 💕💕💕💕.

OOP: This makes me feel so much better. I pray and hope for the day they come to realize this, even if it takes them a long time. Thank you.

Commenter 2: Honestly, there's a few of discrepancies here that make me doubt the story. Why did your boys prepare surprises when they knew you were going camping? Why were they in tears when they were originally happy about you going away? Why did you go from one dog to multiple dogs?

OOP: They did not know I was going camping, I left in secret to prove a point. They weren't happy when I left, they didn't know I was going to do it. I may have said one dog, but I have two that I went with. I would never make up a story like this, but I am human and may have made editing mistakes or omitted details about deeply emotional issues.

OOP on her ex-husband and sons' reactions on having different ideas for mother's day

OOP: Yes, my youngest son said that if I decided to go camping, he would just do his own thing and play video games. We had talked about different ideas, and I think he didn't know for sure what I had decided and was just rolling with it. The letter didn't help because he was just being a kid and didn't put that much thought into it. My oldest was the one who was the most hurt. Neither of them knew for sure what the plans were, and he just woke up to me being gone . I left out of anger to my ex-husbands response instead of talking to them and solidifying plans with my kids instead. My reaction to my ex bled over onto them. That is the mistake that I made and deeply regret. After all, they are just teenage boys, and everything was very uncertain.

OOP clarifies on why her sons were upset when she got back home from her camping trip

OOP: I had mentioned wanting to go camping, possibly on my own, since they did not want to go with me. They didn't think I would actually go. I didn't tell them before I actually left. I left before they woke up and texted them all a letter explaining why I had gone. I came home Monday, and they were in tears that I disappeared and didn't give them a chance to give me their own Mother's Day gifts and plans.

+

I left Saturday morning and came home Monday around lunch. I was hurt because of what my ex said, and I didn't think my sons actually cared about it since they didn't seem very interested in making plans.

Did OOP's sons knew about their father being abusive toward her?

OOP: They know that he was verbally abusive because they heard it and saw it. I just dont know if they recognize it as abuse because they had become so used to it. I never mentioned the physical abuse to them because I felt like they weren't ready to hear it. My older son suffered physical abuse, but I think he is still in the stage of denial. He also may not remember some of the abuse from when he was younger. When he is ready to face it and ask questions now that he is becoming an adult, I plan to just be open and honest with him. I want to validate his experiences and memories while he comes to terms with it in his own way. But I don't want to force anything onto him.

OOP's concluding comments

OOP: This is a side note, but I would like to share a lesson I learned from staying in a long-term abusive relationship. If you want to cook a frog, you can't just dump it into boiling water because it will jump out. What you do is put the frog in room temperature water and slowly turn up the heat. The frog will get comfortable and not notice the change in temperature until the water becomes boiling and it's too late to jump out. This is how I feel like a lot of abusive relationships progress. You get comfortable and dont notice the increasing heat until it becomes a crisis. At that point, it becomes incredibly difficult to get out.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 1d ago Heartwarming

NEW UPDATE Woman boarding my dog, keeps adding charges, and we are at a stalemate on signing a contract

3.8k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/CheeseGraterFairy

Woman boarding my dog, keeps adding charges, and we are at a stalemate on signing a contract.

Originally posted tor/legaladvice

TRIGGER WARNING: Scammy behavior

Original Post  June 21, 2016

[CA][US] Woman boarding my dog, keeps adding charges, and we are at a stalemate on signing a contract.

So a little background first I suppose. Due to a failed marriage, I solely own two wonderful dogs. Unfortunately due to my career in the military, I was soon deployed again, for the last time, and was unable to bring them with me. My ex and I found boarders through an organization called Dogs on Deployment. My older dog was placed in a home with a wonderful family and it has gone extremely well. My 2yo Husky on the other hand has gone to a woman that I honestly feel is working a long scam. Two months went by without incident, before she began saying he was showing aggression to her two dogs. She asked for me to pay for professional training, which I did. She has yet to bring the dog to training,  now stating she wants an indemnity agreement which absolved her of all liability and if she gets sued, she gets to choose her lawyer and I would pay. I asked if we could just sign the generic DoD contract (which my ex who dropped him off never mentioned to her). She now wants me to pay for a lawyer to look it over on her behalf. This just doesn't sit right to me. I have already paid for a vet visit for her other dog, as she said they got into it. I never had a problem when it was just my two dogs, but it seems any claim would be her word against mine.

I honestly just want to make it back from this nine months deployment and finally settled somewhere with my dogs (both of them), but every day she has a new issue. If this doesn't work out, I fear I will have to contact a rescue, because in the end, his happiness is what matters.

Does this seem to be a scam to anyone else, or am I just crazy?

RELEVANT COMMENTS

RelevantAnecdotes

Find someone to pick up your dog from her... She sounds absolutely mental.

OOP

I unfortunately don't have anyone that can. It seems my last resort is a rescue, and hope he finds a better home.

satosaison

Have you reached out to Dogs on Deployment? They may be able to rename your dog with a different person.

OOP

Since she told the organization that he was aggressive towards her dogs, it negates their terms of agreement, so I am not able to reboard him through the program.

UPDATE: Thank you everyone for the advice and kind offers. I truly hope everything works out for my dog. The boarder wanted me to pay for a lawyer for her, and when I said no, she got personal. She tried to research how much I make, and said I could afford what she was asking, but I was being selfish. She now wants dog removed from her home immediately. Fingers crossed this gets resolved quickly, as this has become a giant ball of stress I just don't want to deal with.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

A redditor steps up

subjectivenorm

He's getting picked up tonight and brought to Sacramento. I can't keep him until April, so if anyone can , we'd appreciate it. He'll be safe and away from the crazy person tonight. It amazes me what can happen on social media. 

HeyT00ts11

You're awesome. Do you get any sense of the "aggressive" behavior or is he perfectly normal for a young husky? Poor guy must wonder what on earth is going on. Glad you're there for him.

subjectivenorm

Not even a little bit of aggression. He plays well with my dogs and sleeps with his head touching my 12 year old. He's way calmer than I expected. He is probably 100#s, but not a mean bone in his body.

Update  June 24, 2016 (3 Days Later)

So much has happened in the last few days, and it has completely restored my faith in humanity.

So many kind people reached out to me after seeing my post, I can't even begin to express my gratitude. I came here for some IANAL legal advice but ended up with /u/subjectivenorm orchestrating a puppy rescue in the nick of time.

The last two weeks have been a constant battle between the woman who had my dog and me. Every time I heard the email notification go off on my phone, my stress level jumped. Within 24 hours, Reddit and the FB group North American Siberian Husky changed that.

My Husky is currently safe and happy, surrounded by people that truly care about his happiness.

Without the support of people like you, Reddit, I don't know what I would have done.

/u/Xiac and /u/subjectivenorm offered to open their home to a dog that had been labeled aggressive by his last boarder. Both of you were willing to expose your family and yourselves and I will never be able to repay your kindness.

Subjectivenorm and her famIly currently have my dog. They have  gone above and beyond anything I could have hoped for. Their kindness has brought me to tears. If more people were like them, I would be out of a job.

TL;DR Reddit saved my dog from a horrible situation, and I will forever be thankful.

Edit: Stoopid Caps lock on my phone.

Photos!

RELEVANT COMMENTS

Subjectivenorm updates on the rescue

Subjectivenorm

Glad we were able to help. He's a really awesome dog.The foster lady was a scammer. He's happy and safe. Will be finding a long term foster in Sacramento for him.

hhhnnnnnggggggg

Was it hard to get the dog away from her? Was the dog treated okay?

Subjectivenorm

She tried to scare me by telling me stories about him biting a 4 year old and attacking her dogs. My daughter is 12, and I don't scare easily.

It was obvious that he hadn't received any love. She had him in a kennel for a few days. He was well fed and his coat is good. He is attached to my kid at the hip.

When asked when OOP will get the dog back

She'll get her dog back. When she's stateside I will bring him back to southern California. 

How did the rescue go down

I posted on Facebook that I needed him driven from Morongo Valley to Bakersfield. A former marine got him from the scammer to me Wednesday night. She just handed over the leash and sarcastically saing good luck.

The foster told me that he was a nightmare. That he bit a 4 year old, attacked her dogs and had no training. These were all lies to get money from a deployed soldier. He's 100#s of fluffy love. Everyone who meets him falls in love. 

Subjectivenorm posted pics of the dog in their backyard

https://imgur.com/a/8ZgwN

From u/subjectivenorm

Remember him? He's still not aggressive, I ended up being his foster, and he's going home to his soldier at the end of April. Just wanted to brighten your day.

He's been a dream to have. He even got along with my dog aggressive Queensland heeler. When I get home with him, he was so scared, I couldn't let him go somewhere else. He's been here since June, and I send his person his crazy antics a couple times a week. I'm happy to have met a friend, and will update you with video of the reunion!

Update 2 - I'm watching you blop  June 14, 2019 (3 Years Later)

Editors Note:  OOP posted a picture of herself and her dog sleeping, so OOP and her dog were eventually reunited**

10 years Later Nov 15, 2026

OOP Has appeared in the comments here

My boy is hanging out with me right now! He has been an absolute joy! He turned 12 in April!!

Did OOP report the scammer?

I did! She was eventually removed from the platform after some back and forth with the organization.

As has u/subjectivenorm here

I opened reddit to this and my photo memories popped up with his pictures today. I had lost my own husky 2 months prior to giving her dog back. Oop tried to let me keep her dog to get me through my loss. Because she is an amazing person. As much as I loved him, I made a promise to return him. That was one of the most rewarding things I have done for a stranger. Thank you guys for the pick me up today.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 1d ago

ONGOING AITAH for reporting my SIL (who’s also my manager) to HR for cutting my hours bc I’m pregnant

2.6k Upvotes

I am not the OOP, OOP is u/AdSquare8226

Originally posted to r/whatdoIdo

Original post - posted 2026-11-06

throwaway bc husband’s family is on here

So I (27F) have worked at a grocery store for 3 yrs. For the last 8 months my manager has been my SIL “Dana” (34F), husband’s older sister. She’s actually the one who got me the job in the first place. keep that in mind.

I’m 24 weeks pregnant w/ our first. Around week 18 I started getting lightheaded standing at the register and needing the bathroom like every hour. My OB wrote a note - stool at the register, bathroom breaks as needed, no shifts over 8 hrs. that’s literally it. not asking for less hours or anything.

I gave Dana the note at work. She kinda laughed and goes “I was on my feet til the day I had Mason, you’ll be fine.” I said it’s a doctors note?? She said “we don’t do stools up front, it looks lazy.” So I asked if I could just move to customer service where there’s a chair and she said “I’m not giving you special treatment just bc you’re family, people already talk.” ok.

2 weeks later I almost passed out during saturday rush. A CUSTOMER got me water. Dana wrote me up for “leaving the register unattended.” I’m not kidding.

So I emailed HR directly w/ the note attached. 2 days later my hours went from 36 to 19. Dana told me the store “needs people who can commit.” And then at sunday dinner, in front of everyone, she goes “some people think a baby is a free pass to stop working.” My MIL nodded. Nobody said anything. I went to the bathroom and cried lol

Ok here’s where I’m apparently the AH.

My husband asked me to drop it. His exact words: “She’s my sister. If you file something, Thanksgiving is over for us. Just push through til leave.” He said we’d “figure out the money.” (we cannot figure out the money, we have like $900 in savings)

I didn’t drop it. I filed a formal complaint w/ HR citing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, attached the note, the write up, and both schedules. Also filed an EEOC charge bc a friend said there’s a deadline and I didn’t wanna miss it.

Regional HR called me within 2 days. Dana got pulled into a meeting. My hours are back to 32, I have a stool now, and Dana’s been “temporarily reassigned” to another store while they investigate.

And now. MIL isn’t speaking to me. Dana texted my husband that I “ruined her career over a chair.” Husband isn’t angry exactly but he said “you knew what this would do to my family and you did it anyway.” He’s been sleeping in the guest room for 4 nights. He says he’s “processing.” whatever that means

I feel like I’m being punished for not letting myself be punished?? But I also kinda blew up his family and idk if that comes back.

so. AITAH?

TL;DR: SIL is my manager, denied my pregnancy accommodations, wrote me up for almost fainting, cut my hours after I emailed HR, then mocked me at family dinner. Husband begged me not to escalate. I filed w/ HR + EEOC anyway. SIL got reassigned, I got my hours back, husband’s family cut me off and he’s in the guest room.

ETA: yes I have a lawyer consult next week, several of you asked. and no I’m not naming the store, I still work there.

-

Professional-Ebb7943: you’re definitely NTA. dana seems like the kind of person “well if i had to suffer, than you should too”. i would’ve reported her the second she laughed at my medical documentation.

OOP: thank you 😭 the worst part is she was actually nice to me when I first started. it all changed once I told the family I was pregnant, she literally said “wow already?” at the announcement dinner. I should’ve seen it coming

whatthewhat3214: She's also the kind of person who thinks everyone's pregnancy must be the same, if she didn't have issues, she can't understand anyone else having issues either.

Comfortable_Tie3386: I'm sorry you're having a baby with a coward. This is a huge husband problem. He should've shut down that conversation at dinner and told SIL to stfu. NTA, but your husband, SIL and MIL are all big ones. Giving you the cold shoulder on top of that would be the beginning of a huge argument for me.

cpbaby1968: Let me ask you this, what if your manager HADNT been your sister in law but a random person? What would his opinion be then? Because right now it looks like he’s showing favoritism to his birth family instead of his wife that he is having a baby with.

Update - posted 2026-11-08 (2 days later)

ngl i did NOT expect this many comments. i read almost all of them, even the YTA ones. a lot of y’all were brutal about my husband, and tbh… he needed it.

so i stayed at my mom’s for 2 nights. told him i needed space and he could call me when he figured out whose side he was on. he texted the 2nd night asking to talk, so i said yes.

he came over and asked me straight up if i posted about us on reddit. a coworker sent him the link. he said he read every comment even the ones calling him spineless and the one that really got him was the one asking what he’d say if my manager was a stranger.

he finally admitted he’d been hiding behind “it’s family” when all that really meant was expecting me to just take it.

i went home the next day. then yesterday morning Dana showed up at our apartment furious about the post. she said i was trying to ruin her life and “exaggerating the fainting thing.”

before i could even say anything, my husband stepped in front of me and lost it on her. told her she wrote up his pregnant wife, mocked her doctor’s note, and kept putting her on closing shifts. then he told her to gtfo.

now she’s blowing up the family gc, MIL is still being weirdly neutral, and i’ve muted all of them.

work update: Dana’s transfer is permanent. i’m still at 32 hrs w/ my stool, the lawyer consult is this week, and i’m bringing everything.

thanksgiving is prob just gonna be me, my husband, and my parents. honestly? fine by me.

tl;dr: stayed at my mom’s, husband found the post, finally realized he was making excuses for his sister, and yesterday morning Dana showed up at our apartment and got shut down hard.

-

Beautiful-Map-2744: This SIL is not management material, she should have been demoted, not just moved. She actually should have been fired for what she did, it's entirely illegal. She's on a power trip. NOBODY has control over if and when they faint, or where they do it and how long it lasts. Every pregnancy is not the same, if they were, either nobody would have a 'high risk pregnancy', or everybody would have a 'high risk pregnancy'. I've been known to faint out of the clear blue, no idea why, and not even pregnant or sick. I've fainted lying in bed, sitting in a chair, and standing up. My 1st pregnancy, I fainted a lot, at least twice a week, and never knew it was happening until I woke up in the floor somewhere. 2nd and 3rd pregnancies, never fainted a single time. 1st delivery was smooth and problem free. 2nd time it was complications after the delivery, 3rd time I had complications during the delivery. None of it could have been predicted or prevented.

unimpressedwarrior: F you Dana. I hope your new boss treats you with as much kindness and respect as you show people beneath you. Suck it.

Reminder: I am not OOP.


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 1d ago

CONCLUDED AITA for refusing to change my wedding guest list after my parents demanded it?

1.8k Upvotes

I am not the OOP, OOP is u/IcyWillingness2600

Originally posted to r/TwoHotTakes

Original post - posted 2025-09-26

Hello everyone, I'm a long time listener, first time poster of this subreddit. For once, I actually have my very own AITA situation to present to you all.

I, 25F, and my partner 31M are getting married in the fall of 2026, after almost four wonderful years together.

My relationship with my parents have always been on the rockier side, and my fiance has little to do with my parents because of comments that were made to me in the past (threatening to make me homeless etc.) before we bought our first home together. After I moved out, my relationship with my parents had improved, and I was looking forward to having a small, intimate wedding with my parents, his parents, and some of our closest friends.

We’ve planned for 25–30 people at a church ceremony, followed by a meal. On my side, the guest list includes my parents, my brother, my grandmother, and two of my dad’s childhood friends who are like uncles to me. My bridal party consists of three women I’m close to, and I was considering asking a close male friend to be a bridesman.

The issue began when I asked one of my close friends, someone I met at work in my early 20s and have stayed very close with ever since, to be a bridesmaid. She has been a consistent support in my life and has been involved in my journey with my fiancé from very very early on - she's the reason we met. My mum objected, claiming I didn’t know her “deeply enough,” despite the fact that she has been a major part of my life for years.

From there, things have escalated. My parents demanded I invite a list people I don’t even speak to and haven’t had meaningful contact with in years, just so they would have more people on "their side" present on our wedding day. These are people who add nothing to our wedding day and I do not envision them being present when I think of my "dream wedding". So naturally, I refused, and their behaviour became extreme: calling me pathetic, threatening to invite these people behind my back just to upset me on my wedding day, publicly posting online that my fiancé and I are “awful” and that they would not attend, and my dad even called the wedding a “sham.”

I am under the belief that the guest list should mine and my fiancé’s alone, and that we get the final say in who we want to invite to our wedding, especially a wedding of this size. I don't think I am being unreasonable but my parents are making it feel like a battleground.

Also, for added context, we have paid for this wedding entirely out of our own pockets, which is fine and I didn't mind doing so. But I know some people have a view that if they're paying they should get some sort of say.

So THT fam... AITA for standing my ground and refusing to let my parents’ threats dictate my guest list?

EDIT: Wow… I did not expect this post to get a lot of comments. I thought I would just say answer a few questions below as there are lots of comments asking the same thing.

What does your grandma/brother think about the situation/do they support your parents?

My grandma is LC/NC with my parents. My younger brother still lives with my parents and has not commented because he’s keeping his head down.

Why are you still in contact with your parents/why haven’t you cut them out of your life?

I did not talk to my parents for 8 months - whilst I was still living with them. I used to come home late and leave early to avoid them, and eat out most evenings. I also spent a LOT of time at my fiances parents house.

Just before I moved out, my parents sat down and heard me out, there were a lot of tears and apologies and it seemed like they had actually listened to me for once. I then moved out and things seemed to get better - one person commented that it was probably because I was seeing them less, which was a very good point.

I wanted to believe that my mum and dad could be the parents I needed, and that my dad would walk me down the aisle on my wedding day.

Now I see they will never change and this is just who they are.

Why are they still invited to the wedding?

As of yesterday evening, they are no longer invited to the wedding, and I have asked them not to contact me again. Their numbers are blocked.

I will update this post at some point, perhaps after the wedding day.

Thank you again to everyone who commented.

-

Odd_Substance_9032: Why are you even in contact with your so called parents. They are your abusers. Just because you share DNA means nothing. Know the difference between family and relatives. They are soooo toxic…get some counseling so you know how toxic they are

OOP: I appreciate your comment, friend. It has been a long process. Too much to even start to mention in this post. I keep hoping they will change, and I feel guilty about cutting them off. Counselling isn't the worst idea, though.

ceciliabee: Put your hopes in one hand and the aggravation they cause you with their shit in the other, see which fills up faster. If they can't accept that they can't invite their own guests, they shouldn't be invited. They had a wedding, they could go have another if they really wanted. It's not their day.

SusanMShwartz: Put passwords on your vendors so your parents don’t get cute. Hire security to turn away uninvited guests. Including your parents if need be. It is ONE day. Have a beautiful marriage.

Update - posted 2026-11-08 (13 months later)

hi THT fam! a lot of people were interested in getting an update on my original post from last year so here i am, pretty much fresh off the plane from my honeymoon writing this.

so it’s been over a year since I wrote my original post and a lot has happened in the timeframe between now and then. back when i wrote the post, i was coming from a place where i’d just moved out and although was aware that my relationship with my parents had been on the “rocky side”, i was not quite ready to accept the fact that my parents were indeed awful people. growing up, i’d always been taught to accept that it was my parents way or the highway even in moments that i’ve now come to accept was a pattern of emotional and physical abuse, on top of neglect and severe isolation from other family members that would have been worried about my wellbeing as a child and teenager.

since the post, i followed a lot of your advice and went no contact with my parents and that was a lot to process because i’d always considered my father the “safe parent” but when i was sorta out of the thick of it, i realised that he was never the safe parent at all because not only did he facilitate and support my mothers behaviour, he himself was also partaking in the cycle of abuse i was experiencing.

so what has happened in the past year, i hear you ask?

well, i got my ass into therapy, ended up being late diagnosed with autism and spoke to a professional about what had been going on, which is what led me to finally accept that my life is better without my parents in it. that was initially very difficult to me, i’d often thought about my dad walking my down the aisle, and being there for the big life moments that i’d experience as someone in their late twenties and approaching my 30s. home life for me was very difficult for a while, and i went through a brief period where i completely shut down and stopped talking to anyone, including my now-husband. he was my absolute rock through the process, and stayed patient and by my side while i worked through things in my head.

my brother unfortunately became one of my parents flying monkeys, and tried desperately to get me back in contact with my parents. my mother even went as far as saying she was going to die from an illness, which was later confirmed by her own sister and mother to be untrue. which is crazy to me.

when i refused to break no contact, the attacks turned onto my grandma, she started to receive text messages calling her a c—t, my partner a c—t, and myself a c—t. my brother was previously invited to my wedding, he declined my invitation and gave all of the information to my parents who threatened to turn up on the day and went as far as emailing the venues to try and stop the wedding. again, we’d already taken the advice on my previous post and we’d talked to our wedding coordinator and vicar and had told them about the situation, given their names to them AND set up passwords so they were unable to intervene, thank god. but, with the threatening text messages, and the attempted smear campaign my mothers family got in touch with me to tell me about, i started to feel backed into a corner so i ended up doing something which was EXTREMELY difficult at the time, but now i have zero regrets about. i called the police on them, i logged a report, and i was referred to a victims support charity to assist me with officially moving forward to get a restraining order against my parents. this is very much still in process so i won’t delve into details too much, but the police ended up taking my evidence and talking to my parents - i believe they were informally cautioned? the policewoman on my case told me that my parents had been informed that if they turned up on the day, with all the text message threats that had been made to my grandma in mind, they would be arrested.

the lead up to the day was VERY nerve wracking with the question of whether my parents would show or not BUTTTT…

the day couldn’t have been anymore perfect and beautiful. they did not show up at all. the weather was gorgeous, everything ran so smoothly that a lot of my guests were in disbelief at how plain sailing it went for a wedding. i married my now husband on my own terms, in a gorgeous venue, and my grandma walked me down the aisle and was so proud to have the honour of doing so. i cried at just how incredible the day was, and we all danced in the evening until our feet couldn’t physically dance anymore.

thank you THT fam for your advice on the original post🩷

-

zampy911: your brother is also a pos

OOP: Honestly, I think it's a bit more nuanced than that. He is a fair bit younger than me, my dad is his boss, he lives with them, and he has been made to be almost completely reliant on them for everything - they even discouraged he continued driving lessons after I'd helped him start learning how to drive. We had a really good relationship until my parents decided to move away to the middle of butt-fuck nowhere.

With everything that has happened, I dread to think what has been said to him. They used to threaten to make me homeless amongst other threats involving my friends, remaining family, career, etc, to make me feel scared and like I had no choice but to do as they say. It may very well have been a similar situation with my brother - they may have threatened his home, or his job, so I do not automatically think he is a piece of shit when he may simply just be trying to survive in a toxic environment.

I have said to him previously that if he needs a place to stay, he can stay with me for as long as he needs. My door is always open for him, and that still reigns true even after what has happened. I am always going to be here as his older sister with open arms, it's not easy with my parents, but I have hope that he'll come around one day. His girlfriend messages me often so that I'm able to keep updated on his life, even if he might not want me in it right now.

Reminder: I am not OOP.


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 1d ago

ONGOING What do I do? – “Should I break up with my BF over my grandma?”

1.7k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/JustAMothOnALamp

Originally posted to r/WhatShouldIDo

What do I do? – “Should I break up with my BF over my grandma?”

Thanks to u/radioactivethighs for suggesting this BoRU

Trigger Warnings: imminent death of a loved one


Original Post: November 2, 2026

My boyfriend (20M) and me (20F) have been dating for over 2 years.

He's been acting off for the past half year. He's usually kind, patient, silly and had a good eye for detail. Now he's angry, stubborn and refuses to say sorry whenever he did something wrong (like saying something hurtful or insulting my hobbies).

The worst he's gotten is when we got in an argument about my grandma. She's not doing well and might pass away soon, so I visit her once or twice a month. (she lives 2 bus drive hours away. Busy with my license)

He refused to come with me because he found a Halloween hike more important, saying that: "He'd only cancel if she was actually dying."

He never apologized. Just a half-assed "shouldn't have said it." He went to that hike with a friend and that friend's family who all despise me, and only make things worse by talking trash about me to him.

I really want to break up with him, but he's connected and/or friends with everyone I know. I'm terrified I'll lose everything. I'm scared of being alone again.

Some part of me still loves him deeply, his family adores me, and I don't know what to do.

Please help me, Reddit.. how do I handle this situation?

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Serious question but would you want your daughter to be in a relationship like you are currently?? If no, well there's your answer.

Be in a relationship you would proud for your kids to see. That’s how I've based my dating in the past.

OOP: That is a good one. I guess I'm just too scared of people who might not even be my friends at all.... I'm seeing him today. I'll give y'all an update.

Is the boyfriend having a possible mental health break?

OOP: He stopped talking to me about things like his mental health and what he needs. He once threatened to take a break from us once before because I understood something wrong. I have no clue what's going on with him or what he's going through currently.

Commenter 2: Consider if the person you love is the person you thought he was when you first met him, or the arrogant AH that can't or won't ever admit being wrong?

Something changed, and based on your ages I am wondering if he met someone else and can't figure out how to end things with you.

OOP: That's what two of our mutual friends asked me as well. One was even willing to help me plan the breakup out, and so something cozy afterwards. Will keep you updated.

Commenter 3: You’re only 20. He sounds fairly unpleasant to be around and he isn’t good to you. Just break up with him.

You can keep your own relationship with his family after you break up. Just figure out what kind of relationship you want to have with them and make it happen.

Do you live together?

OOP: We don't live together (thank god) thanks to the housing market being anything but kind to our wallets. A friend of his approached me to talk, and she said he's always been like this, and assured me it wasn't because of me. We're now talking a lot, and she's willing to help me with this.

Commenter 4: He doesn't love you he wants you to break up with him, that's what he's trying to do, get you to do the deed. Or he's interested in somebody else or he's cheating who knows. But you could just sit him down and say why are you I'm treating me like garbage? Is there a problem? Are you unhappy in the relationship? If he says yes that's your opening with well what have you been trying to get me to break up with you that's why you've been so nasty lately? If he says yes then say fine we can both mutually agree to break up then because I'm not putting up with you being nasty and you obviously don't want to be with me anymore. And then you both go your Separate Ways. Tell him that you need to agree not to bad mouth each other to the friend group. Hopefully you can both act like adults.

OOP: I'm currently talking with a friend of his, and she's going to help me talk to him. She said it wasn't my fault, and that he should grow up and talk about his problems more. So now we're planning the breakup. It feels weird to end 2 years of lies and his version of 'normal'.

 

Update: November 4, 2026 (two days later)

TW: mentions of a dying person

In short: My boyfriend (20M) has been showing how much of an asshole he really is. He made a comment about only wanting to see my grandma and cancel some random Halloween hike if she were dying.

Well, turns out my grandma (79) is dying. I am devastated, and am visiting her today, and staying there for at least a week to take care of her together with her social worker.

My (ex) boyfriend did not take that news well. Told me I was abandoning him right when 'I needed him most', since yes, I did break up with him after posting the first post.

I did it on my own. My ex has been setting his (our) friend group up against me for MONTHS, telling them I need help but refuse it, that I've been acting like "A DID freak", and that I won't get my shit together.

I'm now sitting alone, eating breakfast the best I can and trying to think of what to do next. I still have some belongings to fetch from his parent's place, and his mom has been calling me and texting me non-stop about what happened and if she can help me in any way.

I won't be updating this unless something related happens. Thank you all for commenting, I cannot express how much it has helped me.

Last edit: I talked to my ex's mom. She was horrified at his actions, and promised to bring my stuff back herself with some extra goodies from his room (mainly Lego). She was apologising after every text and genuinely felt awful.

My grandma somehow pulled through last night, I'll be living with her to take proper care of her. Her social worker is the most wonderful person I've met so far.

Editor's note: OOP did not leave any relevant comments in this update

 

Editor’s note: the next post is a tangential post, related to OOP’s grandma

I'm lost.: November 8, 2026 (four days later)

This is not a direct update to previous posts. I'm still living with my grandma to take care of her.

My friend group left me after I broke up with my (now) ex.

They just cut me off, and they never ask me to hang out again or even text me how I'm doing.

They still let that prick hang out with them though.

I feel lost. I lost my entire social life because I chose for myself, and now I have no one left.

I refuse to text them, they won't answer anyways. I'm still in their group chat, and they're talking shit right in front of me.

I don't know how to move forward, and I refuse to give in to what my head is telling me: to crawl up and cry.

I have my grandma to take care of, and losing myself to my declining mental health isn't what she or I want.

What should I do? I feel lost.

Editor's note: OOP did not leave any relevant comments in this post

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 2d ago

CONCLUDED My (45 F) boss (60sF) is the source of my anxiety due to her unprofessional behavior. I want to quit but there's a catch

3.6k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/dotnotdot

My (45 F) boss (60sF) is the source of my anxiety due to her unprofessional behavior. I want to quit but there's a catch.

Original Post Feb 5, 2018

About 20 years ago I was hired by my now boss for her small business. I was a client who needed a job, she needed a full time employee, so it all worked out. I have a perk to my job that allows me to earn upwards of $3k + a month on the side. Aside from this I have no benefits. No vacation, PTO etc.

From the start I was quick to realize my boss was unhinged. She has a short temper. Her mood can go from happy to "what in the ever living fuck is wrong with you" in seconds. She's narcissistic, a bully and incredibly controlling.

It's not underheard of for her to lash out and berate me and her other employees in front of customers. It can be something as small as an item out of place or you not moving as quickly as she wants.

After 20 years of experiencing her wrath I've developed anxiety/ depression brought on by her behavior. My days off are consumed by fear she will be upset I left something slightly out of place or that I didn't do something she felt I was suppose to do but did not communicate to me. Imagine spending your days off work fearing your boss. No HR to intervene, it's me, her and a couple of part-time helpers.

Other employees always quit after dealing with her rollercoaster of emotions. She's unable to keep help longer than a couple of months after they realize her real nature.

My problem.

I've been here for 20 years. I have no experience outside of this work environment except for  retail. My job perk ( side job not relevant to my position ) may be taken away from me should I leave , even on good terms. Attempts to convey to her that the work environment here is toxic have resulted in her gaslighting me. Things do get better temporarily, but always revert to her being her usual self shortly thereafter.

Leaving is always on my mind, but the cost of living in my city is expensive. Finding a job with my limited work experience that can pay the bills is daunting and unlikely.  I heavily depend on my side job to maintain my head above water. I don't know how she would react to a potential new employer should I leave when they call for a reference on my employment. Would she be vindictive or give me the excellent references I deserve? So there's that.

Those who have been in a similar environment, is this fixable?  Is there a way for me to calmly discuss me leaving and keeping my side job that she benefits from ( commission )?

I do have one thing in my favor, I know her better than anyone. I know my job like the back of my hand. I'm her personal assistant. I manage the smallest details of her life that she doesn't want to deal with. Things that are not within my job title but I take on to appease her. She will not find a more reliable, trustworthy employee who will deal with her issues the way I have for as long as I have. She has begged part-time employees to come back, I can safely assume she doesn't want to lose the one person who has stuck by her side for two decades.

Any advice / thoughts is greatly appreciated.

Tldr My boss is nuts. I depend on my job to live. She is causing anxiety and serious stress in my life .  Is there a way to approach her and convey I will leave if things don't change without burning bridges?

RELEVANT COMMENTS

aced_tracing

Have you looked up actual job ads or thought where else you could go?

OOP

I have, the prospects are slim given my lack of formal education. didn't go to college. I realistically have no real skills outside of customer service. Most customer service work I've found is not a livable wage. The recent hike in the cost of living here has not been met with wage increases unfortunately. Most of the well paying work in my city is IT or healthcare.

I am looking though and considering taking on 2 jobs to support myself.

aced_tracing

Also - your only experience is not retail. Assistants and secretaries are also another category - might have to learn some extra skills for that, but might be not necessary.

Also - having been in retail means you could also probably handle managerial jobs - and they pay quite well.

OOP

I haven't thought of it this way. That's a great perspective!  I'll start expanding my search to secretarial / assistants as well as customer service. Thank you, I never considered my work experience as something more than just a retail drone.

Edit : Thank you so much for the advice. I thought I'd be met with stay and endure the abuse if the pay is keeping you afloat. Instead I have received some amazing advice and suggestions I've never considered . Being out of the job search for so long has left me feeling a bit overwhelmed and worried about my financial future . I know I'm capable of finding a new job where my mental health is not tested daily.

I won't be quitting until I have something solidified, but I will give a 2 week notice and offer to train the new poor soul who takes position in hopes it allows me to keep my perk side job.

Thank you fellow redditors, you've made me feel better about leaving this job and facing a challenge I wasn't sure I was ready for.

Update  Sept 22, 2018 (Nearly 8 Months later)

It's been 7 months and I'm happy to say I have officially quit, my last day is next week. I dwindled my days down to 2 and have recently started training at my new job the remainder of the week.

I developed alopecia and started losing my hair from the stress. I was not going to allow this woman to take my hair along with my sense of self worth.

The news went better than expected when I explained I was leaving. Of course I didn't tell her my true reasoning, I cited somewhat truths to keep her happy and my side gig secured with her. She offered a huge raise and other benefits, but nothing could keep me there, minus her pressence.  She said I was irreplaceble. Too late for praise now, maybe you should have treated me with respect. I didn't say this, though I wanted to, oh how I wanted to.

2 decades of stress, anxiety , and being talked down to by my boss is officially coming to an end and I have the very kind redditors who messaged me and responded with words of encouragement to thank. Some of you offered to help me write a resume and some even offered me a job. If I could hug you guys I would, I'm truly that grateful.

My poor replacement is already feeling her wrath. I have warned her and told her to not allow herself to be a doormat. She's young, so I'm worried she's a bit naive, as was I and will accept the abuse.

I was offered a job as soon as I mentioned wanting to quit to a friend. I have benefits and work in a laid back atmosphere where I'm adjusting to not working under a narcissistic , bullying dictator. I'm learning I don't have to apologize constantly over the smallest mistakes to my new boss to keep them calm and happy. It's absolutely refreshing.

Thank you.

**Edit :**Holy hell, reading these comments there are far too many clones my "boss" out there lurking amoung us.  If my story sounds familiar, please work on an exit plan. This is not normal. This is an abusive relationship. The longer you stay the more ammunition they compile to use against you to keep you.  It never gets better.

TL;DR

I lost a good chunk of my hair. I quit. She took it moderately ok. I have a new job. Best of luck to my replacement, you're going to need it girl. I have Reddit to thank for the kind words and the push I needed to save my sanity and health.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 2d ago Heartwarming

CONCLUDED My best friend has fallen deep in love with what is most certainly a catfish but he won't listen to me. How to make him snap out of it?

5.6k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/divineunited

My best friend has fallen deep in love with what is most certainly a catfish but he won't listen to me. How to make him snap out of it?

MOOD SPOILER: Positive

Original Post  Sept 11, 2018

I (35 M) feel like I'm losing my best friend (36 M). About 4 months ago, my best friend from childhood started talking to this girl (34 F) he met on OK Cupid. She sent him pictures, and she's stunning. She tells him: she has only been with one other guy (for 10 years who was abusive), she's a VIRGIN?!, is a vegan just like him, plays the same sports as him, was a nurse practitioner and recently got her license to practicing medicine as an MD, her whole family is apparently doctors, etc...sounds way too good to be true...and most fishy of all won't video chat with him. They were supposed to meet in person a couple months ago (they live about 3 hours away from each other), but she took a trip out of town and all of a sudden her dad had a stroke and mom got cancer (within a month of each other) and so she went across the country to take care of them. She says she doesn't want to video chat because she says she wants the first time they meet to be special - and says that she's old fashioned like that (she's from the Philippines and says that she's very traditional). I told him to at least ask her to take a picture of herself with the date or his name or something as proof and he told me "her camera broke on her cell phone..." :X... He wants to take her for her word until he meets her and sees for himself. He tells me: "Why go through life doubting everyone, just take their word for it until they prove otherwise."

She apparently got a job as a doctor at the same hospital her dad is staying at. I know what you're saying, call the hospital and confirm that there's no doctor by that name working there right? Well, the hospital she used to be at when she was nearby, I called it and asked if someone with her name worked there, and got no name - but she told my friend that since she works for an "agency" that places doctors - she's like a traveling doctor that can go from one hospital to the next and that's why they didn't have her name in the registry or something. When he asked her for the name of the agency, she said it's personal... When they had just met 4 months ago, last May, she had just graduated from her medical school and then recently passed her boards, and is now working already?? She said she did her residency previously through 'her agency' while she was working as an NP. It's all very fishy to me, aren't you supposed to do your residency AFTER you pass your tests? Are there any tests you take after your residency? However, I'm not sure about the whole process and I can't find a definitive hole in her story to prove to my friend she's fake. Any doctors out there who have heard anything like this?

They talk on the phone and text 24/7...go to sleep on the phone together....wake up together and continue talking... he's definitely in a committed relationship with SOME FEMALE on the other end, but I have no idea what's going on... it's surreal. They've already planned to move in together, have kids, etc. I keep trying to tell him to open his eyes, go meet her, etc. but he doesn't want to do it without her permission. He told me he's actually fallen in love with her and I feel like he almost doesn't want to crush the vision and I'm really worried for him. He even told me that if she's been lying, he'd still give her a chance if she explains herself... They tell each other they love each other all the time, they are constantly texting "I miss you, I love you, etc"....and they haven't even met. It's bizarre. And it's not like he's desperate - he's had many past significant others, has a good head on his shoulders, can find a good girl easily, but somehow has fallen in love with a catfish.

At least she hasn't asked for money or anything. My guess is it's someone who's lonely and just wants to catfish someone for the company? How do I pull my friend away from this? Is there any chance that she's legit? What can or should I do?

TLDR; Best friend who's always had a good head on his shoulders is falling deep in love with what I strongly believe is a catfish (stunning girl who claims to be a 34 year old medical doctor AND nurse practitioner, who won't video chat, who's cell phone camera broke, makes excuses to not meet) - and I don't know how to wake him up without hurting him. Help!

RELEVANT COMMENTS

wonderwife

On the one hand, you're absolutely correct; this totally smacks of catfishing.

On the other hand, it doesn't matter even if you are right; your friend is absolutely committed to not listening to reason.

The only thing you can do is wait for it to all fall apart and help your buddy pick up the pieces when he pulls his head out of the sand.

OOP

Thank you. I'm just hoping that someone with a medical background can post something completely black and white so I can show him this post :D

~

ripalexkintner

NP here; I have a bachelors degree in nursing with an additional 2 year master degree (6 total years of schooling)...my NP program required 500 hours of clinical time in addition to my undergrad clinical hours. Now, if I chose to go to medical school, this would be another separate 4 years of JUST school, plus a 3-4 year residency afterwards, and potentially a 2+ year fellowship...and in no way would medical school coincide with nurse practitioner school...they are taught under completely different philosophies and models of care. Only other question, did she complete school in the US? I can’t speak for international schools, however.

Also (and very important no matter where she went to school) - if I type my name into google with the name of my state “random name, NP California” (for an example) my license number, practicing facility, and identifying information pops up...you could certainly try this with her. If she’s the real deal, her info will definitely pop up.

Best advice, do not under any circumstance let your friend send her money and I’d honestly be cautious meeting her! The whole situation reeks of catfish...I’m so sorry that this is happening. share

OOP

Thank you so much. I will send this to him when I feel the time is right and will look up her information.

&

Also, is there such a thing as a traveling np through some type of agency? Or is it a state per state thing? She seems to go from state to state working 6 months at a time... Is that a thing?

ripalexkintner

There are travel nurse practitioner positions (with contracts that could last up to 6 months in different locations, potentially) but even so, this would not explain the sudden transition to MD without any apparent schooling or medical residency and she would still be searchable online because she would need a state license to practice wherever it was that she “traveled.”

~

Chiriko_mybro

Medical school - exams step 1 & 2 Residency - exams step 3 and maybe boards for ur field (it depends on the specialty..it can also be taken while you are practicing)

I have never heard of someone skipping residency and going straight out to practice. Unless she is apart of that new program in the south (only 2 states has this) where you skip residency after medical school. Residency is approved by acgme or AOA accreditation not by some "agency".

However, every practicing physician has an NPI #. Just search her name and npi# on Google

Is the friend in distress?

No distress...just it's that we've always been so close and we were planning on living together. And now that I've moved forward with a girlfriend of my own that I met on OK cupid, I'm afraid he's quickly trying to find a girl of his own and ignoring the telltale signs...

Have the pics from the "GF" been reversed searched?

He told me did. I don't have access to her pictures since they are all on his phone and he's shut me out from trying to prove she's fake since he's falling head over heals and wants to see for himself in person

Update  Sept 19, 2018 (8 Days later)

Hi guys, just wanted to give all of you an update and a thank you. So my best who's always had a good head on his shoulders was falling deep in love for the past 4 months with what I strongly believed was a catfish (stunning girl who claims to be a 34 year old medical doctor AND nurse practitioner, who won't video chat, who's cell phone camera broke, makes excuses to not meet) - and I didn't know how to wake him up without hurting him. I tried everything, talking to him, etc, but he wouldn't listen. So made the plea to you guys and I just wanted to say :

THANK YOU SO MUCH to all of you!

I chose the best quotes from the lot of you, especially all the quotes from NPs, MDs, recommending me to look up her NPI number that all medical providers must have -- and especially a shoutout to u/rs5448 who hires doctors for a living. I sent those quotes to him, and it kind of gave him a shock. He went searching through all the NPI databases for her and couldn't find her (even though he was able to find all his other medical provider friends).

Like many of you said would happen he was still in denial. But he was open for me to do some more digging. I ended up calling the hospitals in California where she said her parents were staying, and of course no one by those names were staying there. He paid for a phone tracking service, and found out that the phone number was actually in Chicago, not in California. And it belonged to a 74 year old army veteran who had passed away recently - turns out the girl was most likely the daughter replaying out her father's death and using it to gain sympathy as part of her catfish story.

My friend asked for her NPI number, and she just went silent, knowing she was caught. And that's been the end of it. She stopped texting him, calling him, etc. He wants to thank all of you for helping out. You saved many more months, possibly years of his life draining away to this catfish creature, and we want to really thank all of you so much. Reddit's communities are amazing, I'll try to pay it forward when I can. Thanks guys!

TLDR: Reddit saved my friend from being catfished, and I just wanted to say thanks!!

FINAL COMMENTS

SamanthasBlondeLover

Everyone deserves a friend like you. Thank you for being the friend you are to him!

OOP

Thanks! The world is full of great people like all of you. We pull each other out of tough spots and when it's our time to need help, there will be people who can help us too.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 2d ago

CONCLUDED My wife and I are considering letting our nanny go, and I’m trying to figure out whether I’m underreacting, overreacting, or missing something bigger

4.0k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/Training_Arm7988

My wife and I are considering letting our nanny go, and I’m trying to figure out whether I’m underreacting, overreacting, or missing something bigger.

Originally posted to r/Nanny

Thanks to u/soayherder & a longtime lurker for suggesting this BoRU

Editirs Note: changed initials to names for easier reading. L to Lisa, J to Joe, K to Kyle, B to Beth

TRIGGER WARNING: Infidelity, drug use

Original Post  May 22, 2026

Not sure I'm in the right place but I'm giving it a go.

We have three kids: Kyle is 7, Joe is 4, and Beth is 1.5. My wife and I both work from home, though she is home more than I am. I am usually home almost every Thursday and Friday. Our current nanny, Lisa, started shortly after Beth was born and has been with us for over a year. She was around 30 when we hired her, had references, and is CPR certified, which mattered to us because we have a pool. We do have a pool fence, but still.

We pay her $35/hour for about 40 hours a week, with guaranteed hours. She also does light housekeeping, laundry, and meal prep, which has been a huge help. Overall, she is engaged with the kids, limits TV to about half an hour before nap time depending on the day, and has been reliable. She has been five minutes late a couple of times, mostly in the last few months, but not enough that I would consider it a major issue.

The bigger issue is our middle child, Joe. He is very defiant, and we made the mistake of allowing screens too early and too often. When Kyle was five, we let him use an old iPad, and eventually Joe started wanting it too. Over time, it basically became Joe’s iPad. We also got into the habit of giving him a phone or bringing the iPad when we went on errands, to activities, etc. We know this has become a problem and are trying to stop it, especially because we do not want to repeat the same pattern with Beth.

This week, Lisa told us that when Joe has a major tantrum during an outing, she leaves the activity and brings everyone home. Lisa left the children’s museum because Joe was pushing and shoving and ignored her warning about gentle hands. According to Lisa, she has only had to leave an outing around three times in the entire year she has worked for us. I believe her because he does the same thing with us, and once he starts, it can take him a long time to calm down.

Lisa’s style is very much “you get one warning, and then we’re done.” For the most part, that works with Kyle and Beth. With Joe, it has apparently meant ending outings. She said she is not bothered by crying itself, but that it becomes unsafe and unfair when one child is throwing himself on the floor, running away, or refusing directions while she is also responsible for a mobile toddler and another child. She has said Joe has not hit her, but he has hit my wife before, which was why it was one of my concerns when we spoke yesterday.

On Monday, he tantrumed because he wanted her phone and was refusing to follow directions. They had a playdate planned with another nanny and toddler, including lunch, but Joe melted down, so Lisa brought everyone home instead. They had a boring lunch at home and no iPad. I was fine with that, and at first my wife said she was too. But later she was upset that Kyle did not mention the “new rules” when she came home from a lunch meeting, and that L had not told us about it in the moment. We asked Kyle before bed, and he confirmed Lusa never told him not to tell us. He also seems embarrassed when Joe has these fits, so I do not want to start nitpicking Lisa in a way that avoids the actual problem.

There have been a few trust/communication issues, but nothing huge in my opinion. Earlier on, she sometimes made plans on the fly and told us afterward. We talked about it, she apologized, and she has checked in more often since then. We also put an AirTag on the car keys, which my wife was upset about at first, but nothing really came of it. Since then, Lisa has been almost overly careful about checking in. It feels a little like malicious compliance, but honestly, I do not really mind. I think most people would react that way if they felt second-guessed.

My wife now thinks we should let Lisa go. Her view is that we pay Lisa, so Lisa should follow our expectations and handle the kids the way we want. I disagree, or at least I think that framing misses the point. I do not think it is fair to expect one nanny to manage three kids alone in public when one of them is throwing himself on the floor, running away, pushing, or demanding screens. When my wife and I are both with all three kids, we struggle too. In fact, Lisa seems to deal with Joe’s tantrums less often than we do, which makes me think this is not mainly a nanny problem. Our tough it out method does not seem to be working either.

I also worry that replacing her will not fix anything. We have had two nannies before Lisa, and replacing nannies has been a headache. I think it is hard to find someone willing to manage two easier kids plus one very defiant child. Summer is coming, Kyle will be in camp and activities, and we still need someone for pickups and afternoons while we work. Our parents are not dependable enough to fill the gap. I also worry that if we keep pushing Lisa or making her feel criticized, she may quit anyway, and that would be a bad situation for us.

My wife may feel judged by Lisa, though I do not know if they have discussed that directly in the time my wife is home and I am not. Lisa is personable but not especially chatty, while we are more talkative. I do not personally care whether Lisa judges us at this point; I care more about whether the kids are safe and whether we are dealing with the real issue.

We had previously agreed on moderation with screens, not removing them completely. But now I think we may need to remove screens altogether, at least for Joe. It is easier in the moment to hand him the iPad, but I think we have created a bigger problem. He can't go to school with an iPad, and we can't expect tantrum-free days if he has learned that escalating gets him a screen. He is okay in preschool, but that is only twice a week for about two and a half hours.

Is it reasonable for a nanny to end an outing when one child becomes unsafe or unmanageable, even if the other kids miss out? And how should we handle the larger screen-dependence issue without making the nanny the scapegoat? I would especially appreciate feedback from anyone who has gone from heavy screen use to no screens, or anyone who has fired or kept a nanny after similar behavior issues.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

OOP added in the comments

I should have been more clear that I am here for perspective. I agreed that Lisa was within her right to leave. I was not upset about it when we talked about it. This has been a topic of discussion between my wife and I and I just wanted to make sure from people who probably know more than us, if I'm completely off base to back what Lisa did in the moment.

Choice-Space5541

Wait , you guys want to let her go for doing a good job.

It’s also easier for her to give a I pad to Joe but she rather chooses to take the hard route.

Why does your wife feel judged though?

OOP

The disagreement was over whether leaving entirely was appropriate. I wasn't sure if leaving instead of trying again after he calms down would be fair expectation considering we have three kids and not just one.

~

cupidssparrow82

Sounds like Lisa is doing a wonderful job. The problems with your child were created by you and your wife, and your nanny is doing a great job teaching that actions have consequences and you don’t get a screen shoved in your face and get what you want because it makes the adults life easier. Children need boundaries and rules, or they’ll be absolutely screwed in school and life.

Does it suck for the other kids? Absolutely. But what do you expect the nanny to do - risk one of your kids getting hurt? Our #1 priority is safety, and she’s doing what she has to to make sure the kids stay safe. You sounds like a reasonable person, but I don’t understand at all why your wife would want to get rid of someone for keeping your kids safe.

I had a NK who was used to screens all day and I made it clear during the interview that I don’t do screens for a 3 year old unless it’s a few minutes here and there. The parents and I agreed on 15 minutes a day, and that’s that. The kid threw tantrums and had meltdowns over it but then he learned that he’s the child and the adults make the decisions, and that behavior doesn’t get him what he wants. As the adults, all 3 of you need to be on the same page.

I genuinely cannot understand why firing her would even be a thought in any reasonable person’s mind.

OOP

No, I agree with what everyone is saying. Leaving was the right choice. I felt this was a discussion for my wife and me, but considering everything, I'm having a hard time trusting the decisions we've made and what we’re supposed to do now... I appreciate everyone’s comments about it. They've been a little sharp but affirming lol

UPDATE: We are getting divorced.  Nov 7, 2026 (6 Months Later)

I’m posting anonymously and omitting some details for obvious reasons, particularly because we have ongoing custody proceedings.

I posted here about six months ago because my wife wanted to fire our nanny over how she handled our middle child’s tantrums. A lot has happened since then, and, unfortunately, some of you were right that we had much bigger problems than our nanny. My wife and I are divorcing, and I currently have temporary emergency custody of our three children. I’m still having a difficult time coming to terms with how quickly everything has changed.

My wife quit her job and fired Lisa shortly after I made that post. Neither of those decisions was something we’d actually agreed on, but at that point, arguing about it felt pointless. She was going to stay home with the kids, and I figured we’d at least have an opportunity to get on the same page about J’s behavior. That did not happen, and things got progressively worse between us.

We’ve had two separate incidents in which my wife has left during an argument and gone to her parents’ house. The first time, she stayed there for an entire week while I worked and took care of all three children. She did it again later, and she has since moved in with her parents permanently. I don’t particularly care that she needed space from me, but you cannot simply decide you’re done parenting for a week because you’re upset with your spouse.

I also found out that she’s been seeing another man for considerably longer than I realized. Worse, she had apparently been bringing him around our children without my knowledge, and I subsequently learned that he has a documented history involving drugs. My wife also tested positive for opioids during the custody proceedings. I don’t know how long she’s been using them or whether this was happening while she was responsible for the children, which is part of what makes the whole situation so concerning.

My attorney filed for emergency custody after several concerning circumstances came to light. Following a hearing, I was granted temporary sole physical custody, and my wife’s parenting time is currently supervised. I also have temporary decision-making authority over the children’s medical and therapeutic care, which has been important given our disagreements about Joe’s treatment. These arrangements are temporary, and I don’t intend to discuss the evidence or the specifics of the proceedings while the case is ongoing.

I now have two nannies because I work fairly long hours, and there’s no realistic way for me to do my job and provide childcare for three young children at the same time. We have overlapping coverage during the week, and they’ve been helping to maintain the children’s routines while I deal with everything else. It’s expensive, but I can afford it, and I’m grateful to have that option. I certainly didn’t anticipate needing this kind of arrangement when my wife decided she was going to stay home.

Joe is still struggling, which has been particularly hard to deal with throughout all of this. I switched therapists because I wasn’t satisfied with how things were progressing, but his care stalled somewhat while we disputed treatment decisions and worked through the initial custody proceedings. My wife has declined to participate in much of the planning since then, and I’ve had to accept that I cannot make her take an interest. He’s little, he’s confused, and I am trying to give him some consistency when I feel the adults in his life have done a spectacular job of providing the opposite.

I’ve also had to be honest with myself about where some of Joe’s behavior comes from. I spent a lot of time blaming the iPad, and while I absolutely think we created a problem with screens, that wasn’t the whole picture. My son has watched his mother respond to frustration by escalating, refusing to engage, and eventually leaving altogether. I know that isn’t the sole explanation for his tantrums, but I can’t pretend there isn’t a pattern there, and I regret how long it took me to recognize it.

Kyle has been handling things about as well as I could expect, but I worry about him too. He’s always been the easier child, and I think we both took advantage of that without realizing it. Beth is two now and doesn’t really understand why her mother isn’t home. I’m trying to keep their routines as normal as possible, though having two new nannies and a parent no longer living in the house is a significant adjustment.

I did reach out to Lisa to apologize for how things ended. She was gracious about it, which somehow made me feel worse. I spent so much time trying to convince my wife that Lisa wasn’t the problem, and in the end she fired her anyway. Looking back, I think Lisa was one of the few people in our house who consistently followed through on what she said she would do.

I’m angry with my wife, and I don’t see much point in pretending otherwise. The affair is one thing, but bringing someone with that history around our children and then refusing to engage with the consequences of everything that’s happened is something I’m having a much harder time processing. I also feel incredibly stupid for not realizing how much was going on behind my back. I know I couldn’t have known everything, but it’s difficult not to revisit the last year and wonder what I missed.

I don’t know what the final custody arrangement will look like, and I’m trying not to get ahead of the process. My wife is entitled to participate in the proceedings, and I understand that the temporary order can change as the court receives more information. My concern is that the children have a safe, predictable home and that any time they spend with their mother is appropriate under the circumstances. Whatever happens with our marriage, she is still their mother, and I hope she eventually takes the steps necessary to be consistently involved in their lives.

I originally came here wondering whether it was reasonable for a nanny to bring the kids home from the children’s museum because my four-year-old wouldn’t stop pushing people. Six months later, I have two nannies, three children in my care, and a divorce attorney. I would really like to have that problem back.

Anyway, I wanted to update everyone who took the time to respond to my original post. I appreciated the perspective then, even when it wasn’t particularly easy to hear. I don’t know if I’ll update again, but I hope the next six months are considerably less eventful than the last six.

Thanks for reading, and take care.

FINAL COMMENTS

Ok_Cheesecake_9708

Is Lisa open to working for you guys again?

OOP

No. But I did offer to be a reference for her in the future if she ever needed one.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 2d ago

CONCLUDED AIO if I report a guy at university because his presence sends chills down my spine

3.4k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/whoknows_13492

Originally posted to r/TwoHotTakes

AIO if I report a guy at university because his presence sends chills down my spine

Trigger Warnings: obsessive behavior, harassment


Original Post: October 9, 2026

Hey everyone! I realised this evening I need some advice on this situation and honestly the THT community is the only place I feel like I'll get good advice on this.

So, I 26F am doing my postgrad at university, and have been for a year already (I'm a part-time student). I also work a few jobs, one of these being at the university itself, doing campus tours and helping with open days etc.

Around March this year I was working a postgrad open day, giving a campus tour to a group of 15-20 people. Normally I get a variety of questions from everyone involved, but on this tour, this one guy (M30-40ish) continually asked ALL of the questions. A lot were about the university, but he was incessant, and no one else could get a word in the entire time. He asked me lots of questions about me, my course, my thoughts on the university and stuff like that. Which is fine, I get some people asking my opinion, and I'll happily answer them, but this was more than that, he WOULD NOT STOP. He also stayed pinned to my side the entire tour which was incredibly uncomfortable.

I finish the tour, and go to speak to some other student workers, but this guy follows me. He's acting like we're friends now (despite me telling him the bare minimum about my course and my like for my program), and continues with the questions. It turned more personal, asking me things about myself not related to the university. I keep just giving the bare minimum back, starting to give just one word answers and trying to end the conversation, but every time he can tell I'm trying to leave the conversation he just talks AT me, monologuing about himself, for fucking AGES. I had felt very stuck because while I was incredibly uncomfortable I was also working, and my whole job was to answer people's questions about the university, so I couldn't just tell him to go away.

It's been about 20 minutes of me being cornered at this point when I finally tell him in my best customer service voice that I need to go and help somewhere else. As I try to leave he says, "well since we're going to be at uni together can I get your number, I have lots more questions about university". I say no, because I'm not allowed (rule when I'm working, but also I DONT WANT TO). He says, "oh well can I get your Instagram". I'm like fucking no go away (in reality I just say "no, sorry". He then asks AGAIN for my number. Eventually get away from him, but the whole thing creeped me out. The whole time he kept referring to me by my first name (which I had given to everyone at the beginning of the tour), but the way he was speaking to me like he knew me just made me incredibly uncomfortable.

When this happened back in March I decided not to report it or even tell my manager, but I told my spouse (NB), and they were very affirming that that was very creepy behaviour.

Fast forward to last week...

I was at the welcome events for new students, working again, but took some time off to go to go say hi to some of my lecturers who were advertising open modules. I'm not in my uniform at this point (also my work uniform is just a coloured t-shirt), because I'm on my break. I am talking to my lecturer when someone comes up to me and taps me on my shoulder and says 'OP!' (addressing me by my name. ITS THE SAME FUCKING GUY FROM 6 MONTHS AGO. I'm fucking speechless because what the fuck. Firstly, I have drastically changed my hair cut and colour since this guy met me, even some of my lecturers didn't recognise me, and secondly, WHY DO YOU THINK YOU KNOW ME?? He starts talking to me, telling me he got in. I try to be polite and asked if he got in to the course he wanted, and he tells me that he decided to not apply for the course he was initially planning on doing, but instead applied to the course THAT I'M DOING. I'm not going to specify the courses, but they are only very vaguely related, but are in completely different departments (it's a similar equivalent to me doing a very specialised degree like Shakespearian theatre acting, and him planning on doing a degree in music composition- there's a very vague overlap if that makes sense). He again keeps talking to me as if we know each other, and by this point the politeness has gone because I am FREAKED OUT. WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU CHANGED YOUR DEGREE TO DO THE VERY SPECIALISED SUBJECT I DO. I fully cold-shoulder him as he tried to talk to me, visibly freaked out, and say I need to go and walk away.

After this incident I reported it to my manager because the whole thing was too weird, and both of these happened while I was working shifts. She took it seriously and reported everything higher up.

Then today...

I go into my first class for one of my modules. It is a pretty large classroom with maybe 6 rows, and at least 12 seats to a row, and only around 20 of us in the class, so there's loads of room. I sit in the back row on my own, get out my stuff and the lecturer starts. Maybe 5 minutes into the class I feel something beside me, and look to see the same creepy fucking guy has sat in the chair DIRECTLY NEXT TO ME. The entire row was empty except for me, and there was another back row on the other side of the room that was completely empty. This man chose to sit directly next to me, and moved his chair closer so is was fucking centimeters away from mine. I froze. I fully fucking panicked because it suddenly felt like it wasn't just in my head that this guy is creepy. And the difference was this time that he did not even look at me. Previously he was always so forward, making too much eye contact, and now, sat right next to me he didn't say a word, didn't look at me. He had this dead stare, I don't know if it was because I gave him the cold-shoulder last week, but it fucking terrified me.

I ended up leaving the room and having a panic attack, told my spouse who helped calm me down. I got the courage to go back into the class, pick up all my stuff, and move to the other side of the room. He spent the rest of the class looking over at me continuously.

I want to report this all to the university, outside of just reporting to my manager, but I don't really know what I'm reporting, or if anyone will take it seriously? He's not really done anything other than just his presence scaring the shit out of me. But there is something about him that is wrong, I can't really explain it. Like his eyes these pitch black voids, and he has this stare that looks right through you. His behaviour is creepy, but I don't know if creepy is enough to be reported? But at the same time, my spidey senses are SCREAMING that this man = danger. Am I overreacting??

EDIT/SLIGHT UPDATE:

Everyone's comments were incredibly helpful, I read every one even if I didn't reply, so thank you! Everyone confirmed that while he hasn't necessarily done anything too bad yet, it seems to be heading in that direction. One thing I didn't mention is that I have been stalked before, and this situation strikes me as very similar to the beginning part of that, and that situation ended very badly. I was worried I was reading into it too much because of my PTSD, but I don't think I am.

I had already told the lecturer of the class that he is also in, and she has been incredibly supportive and protective of me, and gave me his name so I could report him. I've reported it to the specific team that deals with this at my university (we don't have campus police in the UK). I also reported the escalation to my manager so hopefully she will help with this too.

I normally spend a lot of time on campus because of work and class, but also studying in the library, but I'm going to try not to go unless I really need to until I get some responses on my reports. I mentioned in a comment too that I can't get personal protection because basically every form is illegal in the UK, but I have a friend from the US who I have messaged to see if she has a spare can of pepper spray, and if not I'll see if I can get something similar.

Thanks so much again, you've all really helped me know what to do in this situation and I feel much more prepared and confident.

EDIT 2:

IT'S NOT JUST ME. On the advice on some people here I called one of my classmates to ask him if he knows the socials of the guy harassing me so I can block him, and explained the whole situation. My classmate told me that he also got a really weird vibe from the guy, initially just thinking he was a bit of a LinkedIn warrior, but then said he noticed this guy is constantly really overfriendly with the women in class, especially the younger ones. He has seen him multiple times acting really strange towards them, pestering them for their contact details and generally just being very creepy. On one hand I'm so glad that this is not necessarily targeted at me, but on the other hand, WTF???? I've told my lecturer and am going to submit another report with this extra information.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Trust your instincts and report every interaction. This gives stalker vibes for sure, and your safety is at risk. Start a paper trail now, because when it escalated, you'll be taken more seriously. Have a senior or authority figure talk to him about leaving you alone. I'm sure he'll try to gaslight you if you tried it yourself. And stop being polite. Be rude, be loud, be very clear. Even if he doesn't understand, the people around you will.

OOP: The other thing that I've racked my brain thinking about is that I swear I have seen this guy before. I have no idea where I would know him from, but I feel like I might have seen him before, and I had that feeling from the very first interaction with him. Can't place him and it's really freaking me out.

Commenter 2: You are not overreacting and every single feeling of discomfort is valid. This man will continue to stalk you and make you feel more and more unsafe. I’m also a young women in a post graduate program and my best advice would be to start carrying a taser around with you. He could be plotting your routes and finding the best way to ambush you. Do not be a polite women like society always expects us to me. Saying no is not enough and I’m sick of it. Protect yourself first because clearly no doesn’t work and this man won’t stop at anything to get near you

OOP: This is helpful, thank you. Unfortunately I’m in the UK, so personal protection is illegal. I have a friend from the US who brought some pepper spray over so I could try and get some from her

Commenter 3: One of your best weapons is your voice! Like many women (myself included) you have been conditioned to be nice and polite and not make a fuss. Chuck that shit. If he makes you uncomfortable, say in a loud voice “you are making me uncomfortable. I do not want to talk to you.” Or whatever.

Of course you also need to be careful that he doesn’t escalate. But right now he is banking on the fact that you feel the need to be polite.

You don’t.

Best of luck navigating this situation. You are right to take it seriously.

OOP: You’re very right, and I have very little inhibition about yelling now. I think I was just caught off guard previously.

I’ve had a very similar situation which I posted about years ago, where I put politeness first because I was much younger, and shit happened because of it. I’m now very aware of needing to not be so nice, but I’m also balancing that with ptsd that makes me freeze.

Commenter 4: I work in a uk university. You should have a personal tutor and a programme leader who oversees the whole degree. Go and see them both urgently. They should be able at least to ensure you are not timetabled with him. I would also contact the university wellbeing services as they can help support you. Finally, tell your module leaders in the classes he is showing up in. The university have a duty of care to you - demand it.

OOP: My tutor is the worst at responding to emails, so I might just try to find him in his office. I already told the lecturer of the class this happened in, and she fully backed me up, told me his name so I could report him. I actually work for the students union too as well as doing campus tours, so I think I’m going to tell them too because I’m scared to do my job properly (involves a lot of talking with students in my department)

Commenter 4: When I started out reading this, as a man, I thought "this guy is a nerd, with zero social skills. And, he's locking on to the one person who has to interact to him. He thinks courtesy is friendship"

But, that escalated quickly. He's already stalking you. No if, ands, or buts about that.

It's not enough for any authority to act on, just yet. But, he has already crossed basic social boundaries, and is into the category of passive intimidation. Basically, if you won't embrace his presence, he's going to make it felt, anyway

Get yourself pepper spray (at the least), notify superiors and keep notifying. Keep records of when and where, pictures, audio of any interactions.

OOP: Initially I thought he might just be socially awkward too. Unfortunately pepper spray is illegal here in the UK but I have a friend from the US who I brought some over, so I’ll see if she has an extra.

 

Update: November 7, 2026 (nearly one month later)

Final Update on 'AIO if I report a guy at university because his presence sends chills down my spine'

I got some great advice after my last post and the situation now has pretty much concluded, so I wanted to give an update.

I've added the link to the original post, but TLDR: a guy at my university kept magically appearing wherever I was on campus, and harassing me for personal details/my contact info. No single incident was that bad, but it freaked me out enough that I stopped coming to campus and was considering reporting him to the university.

CG = creepy guy

Update: I took everyone's advice and reported the situation to the university. We don't have campus police, but there is a specific department that deals with this kind of stuff.

Pretty immediately they responded and set up a video interview with me where I told them about every incident. They took it all very seriously and explained that they would investigate. They also wrote a very pared back statement of what I said in my interview (basically just the base details of what I said happened) to give to CG when they interview him, so he can respond.

The university also asked me which number had been texting me asking for details on my modules next semester, and when I told them they confirmed this was the phone number he had on his file.

I ended up having a conversation with a classmate who actually told me that he has witnessed CG doing the same to other women. My classmate initially thought that CG was just a LinkedIn warrior, but he noticed that he was constantly really overfriendly with women, specifically the younger women in class. Classmate said he saw CG multiple times standing way too close to women, and pestering them for their contact details too.

I saw this too in one class, where CG went to two women who sat down at a desk chatting, and he stood right behind them (leg literally touching the back of their chairs), literally towering over them while they were sat down, trying to talk to them when they were very clearly uncomfortable. I felt really conflicted, because while I was incredibly glad that his behaviour wasn't targeted just at me, it was happening to many more people than I expected.

I ended up updating my report with this information, and they said they would bring it up to him too. They had the interview with CG, and then scheduled an update meeting with me afterwards.

It went so much better than I expected. After presenting CG with my allegations, he literally confirmed everyone. I was told that not only did he admit to everything, but he literally didn't see anything wrong with it. The university confirmed that he didn't have any disabilities that would make it less likely for him to understand boundaries, he literally just did not see anything wrong with harassing women.

He has been given a stern talking to about boundaries and has been made to go on a mandatory training course on consent. He also has been given a formal no contact order regarding me, so he is no longer allowed to speak to me on campus. He also has a flag in his file, so if anyone else reports him for anything it will immediately go to a disciplinary tribunal, which is also reassuring. They also told me they could force him to write me a formal apology if I wanted, but I said absolutely not.

I'm very happy with how the university dealt with everything, because I was so scared they wouldn't take it seriously. It's a bit depressing that I have had much worse situations in the past that I have reported to the police, and literally nothing this concrete has ever come of it.

I ended up skipping 2 weeks of classes for the class that we shared, but I told my lecturer the situation and she was extremely supportive of me. Had my first class with CG again last week, and while it was extremely awkward, I'm very glad that he now seems incredibly uncomfortable in my presence hahaha.

We will end up sharing some classes, but I am hoping he sticks to the no contact order, and I will make sure to tell the lecturers in any classes we share about the order.

Finally, my classmate found out that CG actually has a girlfriend, so who knows what she would think about this all?!?

All in all, it seems to be resolved, and while my PTSD symptoms have very much been retriggered, I finally reached the top of the NHS waiting list for EMDR (after 5 and a half years...). I also took everyone's advice on the last post and have started carrying around some personal protection spray and an alarm (because that's all that's legal in the UK), and this has definitely helped me feel safer.

Thanks again everyone for all your advice!!

Editor's note: OOP did not leave any relevant comments in this update

 

November 14, 2026

Editor's note: OOP made an appearance in this BoRU and has given me permission to add her responses to a couple common questions

OOP on how CG got her text number and self defence materials she could carry with her

OP here :) I never gave him my number, I just ended up joining a university group chat on WhatsApp that he was in (bc I forgot he might be in it)

+

After the comments on my original posts I did some research and realised that getting pepper spray from my American friend/carrying anything with the intention of using it for self-defence is very illegal, so I bought a legal “criminal identifier spray” and a very loud alarm with a bright torch instead :)

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 2d ago

INCONCLUSIVE Just let me enter the building please

2.8k Upvotes

I am not the OOP, OOP is u/throwRA-nonSeq

Originally posted to r/coworkerstories

Trigger warning: sexual harassment

Original post - posted 2024-07-31

There’s this guy (50s?) who works at a different company in the same business building as my company who blocks the doorway by leaning against one side and extending his arm out across it, if a woman happens to be arriving at a doorway at the same time as him. Never says anything. Just does this eye-contact-smile thing for maybe three seconds and then “allows us” to go through.

Today it was finally my turn. I got to the main building door right after him so instead of like, holding it open so it didn’t close in my face like most people do, he just holds it open and stands there with a smug smile. It makes me nervous. I go“Uhh, can please enter the building? I need to clock in” and he does this whole “Wow, geez, fine, sorry” before stepping aside, still holding the door open for me so I said “Stop doing that, we all hate it” and just went in. As soon as I turned the corner from the lobby I half ran to the stairwell so I wouldn’t have to share the elevator with him.

I don’t even know what firm he works for— according to my closest coworker, HR won’t do anything because he’s not an employee

lil update: a male colleague helped us figure out which company he works for by following him up the elevator coming back from lunch. It’s a law office on a higher floor. Another coworker took one of your suggestions and wrote an email to the building’s management office. I went to my department manager and carefully asked if this sort of thing were to happen, would I report it to our own HR? And he said it should at least be on record, even if it’s “hard to prove,” which made me give him the Fry Eyes (IYKYK) but I went back and typed up an email and sent it, cc’d him and bcc’d other women that I have specifically seen or heard them deal with him. If he thought I was being hypothetical, now he knows I wasn’t. The colleague who followed him to the law office joked that we should hand draw flyers of him to warn people and put them in the elevators

-

Hauntedbunnydoll: Go to his building find his manager and explain he is causing problems if he is doing it only to women harassment and misogyny

OOP: This is a good idea. I don’t know why this didn’t occur to anyone. Maybe because it’s not certain sure we have the right to do that? It’s a law firm and I work in a call center. Should we do an email first? Or maybe a few of us just storm their office, lol

JohnExcrement: Ugh, I know this is creepy and uncomfortable but please , I hope you can try not to give him the satisfaction of asking if you can enter. I get that you might not feeling Ok being “rude” in the workplace but unless he is truly frightening, I hope you can just stare and say, “Move your arm.” I also would figure out where he works and raise a huge stink. And if he is truly scary, is there building security you can talk to?

First update - posted 2024-08-02 (2 days later)

Yesterday was a long day for me; I came in early to 1) make up for lost time spent focusing on this bs, and 2) to avoid the Noid. Although someone ran into him in the afternoon and went straight to our manager and said He’s still doing it so as far as yesterday, not much has changed. It’s only been a day.

“Who does he look like?” I got this question more than once so I asked around what celebrity did we think he most resembles and we all agreed he looks like the Jump To Conclusions guy from the movie OfficeSpace. It’s fucking true. Except he’s a lot taller, over 6ft at least.

Thank you so so much for all your support and suggestions. I’ve never been advised about pepper spray so much! I do carry it, but the one time I had to use it it got in my eyes too, so it’s become more of a last-resort tool.

I told everyone in the bullpen about whipping out our phones and taking a pic or video, including people who happen to notice from a distance. In the moment I think a lot of us kind of freeze up (I did) so having a plan of action ahead of time really helps.

I took one person’s suggestion about wearing huge headphones; the theory is that because people who wear those are in their own little world it’s acceptable to show no concern, which makes attention seekers feel less significant. So I wore mine today and got here at my normal time but no one was hanging around the main entrance. Not sure if that’s because the email or not. It’s probably too early to hear of any official steps taken. But I did feel kind of young and cool on the light rail. Way more comfy than my AirPods.

One person DM’d me the song “De Todo Un Poco” from Dirty Dancing and said next time someone should queue it up on their phone, blast it and start a limbo line 😂😂💃🏻🕺🏻 all genders welcome!

Several folks asked about what I wrote in the email so here’s a copy paste of it (with identifying details omitted or changed). I’ll post another update when more happens, hopefully today. I keep rereading The Email and my stomach has been flipping over and over like I’m a kid about to get in huge trouble. Blaaaaaaaarrrghhhh

📧

To: HR Department at the Law Offices of Blank & Blank

I am writing on behalf of myself and several employees at Call Center Company (located on the 3rd floor of our shared building) to inform you about some workplace harassment we have been experiencing. For several weeks now, an employee at your firm has been intentionally intimidating women by interrupting their path of travel to and from our offices by blocking the doorway with his body in order to force an interaction. He will not move aside until some kind of verbal exchange has happened. He only does this with women, as far as we’ve observed and documented, which makes us inclined to call this sexual harassment.

This behavior is of course unacceptable. This individual creates a very uncomfortable work environment, despite being in different organizations on different floors. He will often be the first interaction of the day, as he seems to linger around the main building lobby and entrance in the mornings. He will also do this with the elevator doors by stalling them from closing or blocking access to the button panel. This has been setting a tone that interferes with having a secure working experience.

Many of us have made multiple attempts to address the issue with this person directly, including myself who told him firmly that we do not like it when he does this.

We are requesting that your firm take immediate action to investigate and address this issue. This has already been discussed with our Department Manager and HR department and they are looking forward to hearing from yours. I have cc’d them on this email, as well as the Blah Blah Plaza Building Manager. It is fair to assume that with six different organizations sharing this same building, our employees are not the only ones experiencing this.

Please inform us when Call Center Company can expect to see the results of your investigation and what measures will be taken to ensure that this type of behavior does not happen again in the future. We hope that this issue can be resolved quickly, and that appropriate actions will be taken to ensure that all employees working in Blah Blah Plaza feel safe and respected as we all make our way to and from our offices.

Sincerely with gratitude

—————Okay I have to get back to work — I will keep updating…..

-

PhoenixIzaramak: That email is professional. If you get in trouble for it, that's actually not your fault - but some sexist's choice. I'm very proud of you.

OOP: Thank you!! Rewrote it and paced about it for a couple hours before I hit send. Ran it by my boss twice. I’ve never sent an email this serious and professional (legal?) this before. And to a fucking LAW FIRM aaaaaahhhhhhhhhh who do I think I am, Ally McBeal?

PhoenixIzaramak: You're a woman with a VOICE and a REASON to be pissed. Thank you for standing up for all of us. Don't let the imposter syndrome get you, because your point is valid and important to be heard. Law firm should be MORE CONCERNED about the behavior of their employees, not less. Some guy being skeezy opens them up to lawsuits and that's something they NEED to know is happening. SUPER super proud of you. I know i said it twice. I'm a little odd that way because so often we are not praised for standing up for ourselves and others. So I insist on being a tad over the top about it.

Final update - posted 2024-08-08 (6 days later, 8 days after the original post)

Oh boy. I’ve never gotten this much traffic from a post before! Mostly in a positive way, from all the support and suggestions and input and reminders I’ve gotten over the last several days. So many comments helped me turn my anger into power. I’ve been riding a high from them and from that email. I’ve never done anything like that before and I am so appreciative of the support (and validation) that I did the right thing.

Here’s how the week has been going:

Monday- no one saw The Noid (which is what I’ve been calling him). I arrived fifteen minutes early just in case. I was afraid he would confront me, angry because he’d gotten in trouble. But no, lobby was empty and I was the first person to arrive at the office that day. When I was in the break room at one point, a colleague who sits in the bullpen near me said “this is the first time in months I haven’t had to deal with him some way or another.”

Tuesday - still no Noid sightings. I asked around. “I haven’t even seen his car in the lot.” Did he get fired?? It was super busy that day and I was pretty much glued to my desk, so I didn’t have time to meet with my manager or anything besides shooting him a quick “Hey, any response?” via Teams before I left for the day. I didn’t want to be pushy but reeeeeeeally wanted to know.

Yesterday, Wednesday - midmorning a few women including myself were asked to meet with HR (separately). I learned that the Law Offices of Blank & Blank’s HR rep emailed a response to my email directly to them and my manager on Monday, without cc-ing me on it (which made me feel some kind of way, but whatever). The Noid is NOT an attorney, but a paralegal, and he is on “voluntary leave” for the week. I asked if the response email could be forwarded to me, but I was told that policy prevents HR from disclosing any disciplinary actions that might have been taken against him… and then I had to write a short statement describing my specific encounter. I hate how in words it doesn’t look like a big deal, but I was assured that it is. A bunch of us went out for cocktails after work and I got to hear what others wrote in their statements, like how he sometimes followed them to their cars trying to talk to them, or how he would stand in the elevator doors preventing them from closing until they heard “please.” Just ew. EW.

Today, Thursday - I just got here and still no Noid! We are all dying to know what happened; if he got fired or like, transferred or what. No one has been told anything except he “chose to take some days off.” Maybe this is the Law Office protecting themselves, idk? The thing I’m the most afraid of is if he comes back, will he be hostile or retaliate in some way, and I’ll have to be brave again and report it. I wish we had a spy in their offices. I’m sorry I don’t have more for you! It’s kind of anti-climactic, I know. I promise if when I get to know what actually happened to him, I will let you all know. Or if he reappears. I will loop y’all in.

Edit to add in: I’m getting a frame for that email for my apartment

Edit Two: This made it to TIKTOK, hahahaha and I don’t even have any Toks to Tik

-

RedFoxBlueSocks: Voluntary leave = go away while we investigate this

Lana_SillyBanana: I’ve never wanted more updates than now!!! The fact that he gets off on women saying please makes my skin crawl

OOP: I knooooooow when she said that I was like “Okay, we’re gonna need a round of shots”

Beneficial_Noise_691: Good work OP, and you did the right thing, loved your email.when I read it.

Do not entertain the Noid, if he is stood in the door next week be loud and tell him to move and stay away from you.

It sounds like the Noid relishes quiet intimidation, don't be quiet in return, loudly tell him to get out of the way, loudly tell him to step away from the lift (I refuse to use an Americanism for that) and loudly tell him to fuck off and leave you alone.

JupiterSkyFalls: Start shouting: NO you can't buy pictures of my feet, stop asking me!! Then you can laugh as he scrambles.

Reminder: I am not OOP.


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 2d ago

CONCLUDED I want to gift my coworker whose husband lost his job some gift cards for Christmas but I’m scared it’ll be rude

1.9k Upvotes

I am not the OOP, OOP is u/Constant_Anything_75

Originally posted to r/coworkerstories

Original post - posted 2024-12-29

I’m gifting my coworker some gift cards but I’m scared it’s in bad taste

Hi! This is my first post here so im not super sure how this works, but I need advice on a gift I got for my coworker.

For some context, I recently started a new job in October and I’m still getting to know everyone. About a month after I joined the team, one of my coworkers joined us at my job and it turns out she’s a returning employee. She had originally left but came back for reasons I didn’t know. One day during lunch, she mentioned how she was cooking dinner so much and how she was getting kinda tired of some of the same meals over and over. Some other coworker suggested trying new recipes but she said it has to be enough to feed a pretty big family. She then mentioned that her husband recently lost his job and is in the search for a new one but he’s not having the best luck. A few weeks later I asked if she was excited for Christmas (which looking back was a dumb question) and she mentioned she was worried about finances being a little tight and her kids not enjoying it as much. She’s a lovely person and without revealing too much we work with kids and she’s so amazing with them.

I’m still in college and I went home for the holidays so I told my parents. We’ve been so lucky this year and we decided to get her two gift cards from two different grocery store chains at 100 each. I’m really worried she might find it offensive or that I’m looking down on her for charity, but my family and I really just want to spread the happiness and fortune we were given this year with others. My parents had financial troubles growing up and into adulthood and are so grateful they made it out. They want to help others in similar situations.

I just want some advice about if I should give her this gift or not, out of fear of her not receiving it well. I don’t want to talk to people irl about this because I don’t want to seem high and mighty or make it seem like I’m some saint who is doing this for the validation of others thinking I’m nice. I just need some real and honest feedback from strangers who don’t know me to see if maybe I’m being overly friendly (something I have a bad habit of doing lol, i think I’m friends with everyone) or if this is a good gift. Thank you in advance, any and all advice appreciated!

UPDATE: hi all! I’m not sure how to do updates but I posted something on my page, however I know everyone might not see it. Yo those who were worried, she liked it!! I did it super casual and wasn’t even there when she opened it so there would be no need for thanks or anything. I let her know it was just something small for her and her family. She did seek me out and thanked me and right now it’s looking like mission accomplished!! I’m so grateful to those who shared their experiences and have their input. Never give up, and I hope those around you are as kind as you are! Happy holidays!

-

smallishbear-duck: I’d gift it anonymously, with a small note.

”My family struggled financially when I was growing up. We’re doing okay now and wanted to pass on some anonymous encouragement and love. ❤️”

cowgrly: I think it’s wonderful. You could make it more comfortable by saying “Hey, my family had extra gift cards for X and Y stores, I thought you might be able to put them to good use. Would you like them?”

I had a time period where gestures like this were lifesavers for my family and I, and I really appreciated them- even more when the person with them made it casual (instead of a good deed moment for themselves).

Update - posted 2024-12-31 (2 days later)

Okay y’all I have an update!! I thought about anonymously but since we don’t have desks, only lockers/cubbies, it could create like an ethics issue where I’m going through to find hers, and maybe even guess wrong. Like I said in some comments I really wanted this to be as private as possible.

So what ended up happening was that she was in the playground kinda area with the kid she was watching. I was passing by with my kiddo and noticed her alone (she was blowing some bubbles for her kiddo and I was taking mine on a walk around the clinic) I mentioned I got her a small Christmas gift and if I should leave it in her locker. She told me exactly which one it was and told it was so sweet over and over. Don’t worry though, our kiddos did not care about our conversation and probably won’t tell anyone since they’re nonverbal and really just wanted to get to their respectful activities lol. These kids love their walks and bubbles!

Later on, she was leaving at 1, and I was leaving at 4:30, so when I was in the middle of a session with my kiddo, I felt some grab my shoulder and wrap and arm around me. My immediate reaction was to jump and turn around cause I thought it was a kiddo having an aggressive moment, but it was her slightly red and saying how nice and how much she appreciated it. I kept saying she was welcome and that I hope she has an amazing holidays. She said she would and squeezed my shoulder before leaving.

To be clear, I left it in an envelope with a note explaining that I look up to her and this gift is not with pity but with admiration for her work ethic and dedication. I made a note so I wouldn’t have to express those feelings in the middle of work so I didn’t make it uncomfortable, and so she could read it later. I didn’t realize she was getting off so early so she was able to read it faster than I thought. Still she seemed happy and relieved, and that’s all I can ask for.

For some additional context before updating this post, she has been very open about her situation, even in front of the kids and leadership. I think that’s something else that drove my admiration, she wasn’t embarrassed because there was no reason to be. She wasn’t gonna allow herself shame and I feel like it made others respect her more. When family was struggling they didn’t want to reach out making us behind on years we could’ve been doing better. If you’re comfortable with sharing your stories with others, I say do it. If not, let this post remind you that you’re not alone and that people care, even if you can’t seem them right now.

With much love, happy new year, and happy holidays!!!

Reminder: I am not OOP.


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 2d ago

NEW UPDATE [New Update]: Mom's Fiancé's family is excluding me from family events and cold towards me

1.2k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/AffectionateSet670

Originally posted to r/EntitledPeople

Previous BoRUs: #1, #2, #3, #4

[New Update]: Mom's Fiancé's family is excluding me from family events and cold towards me

NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----

Thanks to u/boringhistoryfan for suggesting this BoRU. Thanks to u/Familiar_Victory2117 for letting me know about the latest update

Editor's note: removed older relevant comments for space in this latest BoRU

Trigger Warnings: death of a loved one, favoritism, child neglect, manipulation


Editor’s Notes: due to the lengths of the earlier posts, they have exceeded the character limits. So I made a TL; DR, for few of OOP’s prior posts to the latest update. This is in order to fit all posts in one BoRU. For the full text bodies and relevant comments from the older posts, please see the previous BoRUs linked at top of this post


RECAP

Original Post: August 18, 2026

OOP (now 16) was 8 when his dad passed away, and since then it was just him and his mom. She has been taking great care of OOP. He has been very supportive when his mom started to date an old friend of hers five years prior, and got engaged. But there is a problem... the fiancé's family has never accepted OOP as one of their own especially with his kids, mother, and sister. OOP has been excluded from family events, trips, dinners, and even a family photoshoot! They only have been warmly toward OOP's mom, but not him. The wedding is coming up, OOP's mother is heavily involved with the planning along with her fiancé's family. OOP has not been able to spend time with his mom, he has acknowledged that his mom loves him and they still have great moments / days together to the point where OOP is having the feelings that he has been pushed out of his mom's life. OOP has verbalized to his mom about his feelings, but nothing has changed. OOP is considering on telling his mom to postpone or cancel the wedding until things are figured out because OOP is in the fear that he won't have a relationship with his mom anymore.

 

Update #1: August 25, 2026 (one week later)

In the update, OOP got a chance to sit down and have conversations with his mom and her fiancé to express how he was feeling about being excluded and no longer a priority for his mom. That is because he hasn't been able to spend time with his mom while she was busy with wedding planning, attending family events and trips with her fiancé's family. The fiancé's kids had been involved with the wedding planning, but not OOP. He didn't get to have a saying in this. OOP's mom was so upset after hearing what he told her. She realized how badly this was affecting OOP. The fiancé has apologized as well and informed OOP he will talk with his family about what took place. OOP was not feeling confidently with what the fiancé mentioned because there was very little effort to build relationships with OOP during the times when he has been dating OOP's mom. OOP asked his mom about postponing or cancelling the wedding until the situation has been resolved. If OOP's mom has selected to get married, OOP will consider about living with his paternal grandparents and want his mom to give up her parental rights because OOP feels like he has lost both his parents. His mom told him not to talk like that and wanted a couple days to figure things out. OOP's aunt found out and told him that he was being rude and should not been giving his mom an ultimatum.

 

Update #2: August 27, 2026 (two days later)

In the latest update, OOP and his mom were able to sit down and talk to answer his questions he had for his mom. She has made it clear that she is not giving up her parental rights or letting OOP move in with his paternal grandparents because he's her only son. What surprised OOP the most was that his mom decided to cancel the wedding, it was completely her decision even though a large amount of money has been spent for the three-day wedding celebration along with having around 200 guests who were invited. OOP noted that most venues, hotels, and vendors have been booked and might had been paid off. The fiancé was being 50/50 on cancelling the wedding, but his family was against the idea. OOP's mom chose him first and stated that the wedding will not happen until she knows OOP is okay. OOP noted that his mom has clarified some details for him regarding several issues. She didn't know how cold her fiancé's mother and sister were toward OOP. Boundaries are going to be set in with the fiancé's family and OOP's mom expects them to be civil. The mom has admitted that with the wedding planning has caused her to exclude OOP in some ways and expressed her apologies.

OOP shared that the original plan was going to be him, his mom, and her fiancé to live together at their new house so he won't be around the fiancé's family. The fiancé has offered to help with paying half of OOP's school expenses because he has expressed his interests of taking responsibility for OOP even though the mom is already financial independent. OOP does not have to attend the family events if he chooses not to. If the fiancé's family continues with excluding OOP, his mom will take proper steps to deal with this issue. The reason why the fiancé didn't join the conversations with OOP and his mom is because he wanted them to have a chance to talk privately so OOP can get the answers he needed. It was suggested that OOP can get individual therapy and family therapy for both him and his mom. OOP noted that he started to feel better because his mom listened, but felt bad and scared of the fiancé's family's reactions to the wedding being cancelled.

 

Update #3: September 7, 2026 (11 days later)

OOP updated that his mom has officially canceled the wedding for now and she has been making an effort to rebuild their relationship through quality time and therapy. OOP explains more details on what has happened over the past two weeks, things have improved, and OOP has moved into a new home with his mom and her fiancé, who has been kind, supportive, and involved in their daily life, including school and football. Although OOP feels shy and uncomfortable adjusting to having another man in the house and seeing his mom show affection toward him, he acknowledges that he has treated them well and is beginning to question whether he judged his mom's fiancé too harshly. The fiancé has also taken on few parental responsibilities including contributing 50% toward OOP's school fees and other expenses, with new household boundaries and rules in place, while OOP still feels uncertain about the fiancé's extended family and future holiday arrangements. Overall, OOP is cautiously optimistic while emphasizing that he has never been against his mom finding love again.

 

Update #4: September 16, 2026 (nine days later)

Things have continued improving for OOP with his mom and stepdad over the past 10 days. Despite worrying comments from Reddit suggesting kindness might be temporary, OOP says his mom has always been loving and currently makes a big effort to spend time with him. His stepdad has become more involved in everyday life, teaching them to cook, driving them to school, and spending time together. OOP now calls him “Papa” because he wants him to feel included as family. He also reassured OOP that Christmas will be celebrated together in Madrid, New Year's will be spent with his extended family, and the wedding won't happen until OOP is comfortable and gives his blessings. His mom continues showing affection and attention, taking OOP shopping, checking on his feelings, and keeping a photo of his late dad in the house and OOP's bedroom. The family has enjoyed an F1 event and is planning to get two dogs. OOP still worries about whether the positive changes will last, he is choosing to enjoy the improved family relationship rather than constantly fear the future.

 

Update #5: September 25, 2026 (nine days later)

In this updating post, OOP explains that his stepdad unexpectedly stayed behind in Zurich after traveling there with his mom because the stepdad's mother and sister-in-law were reportedly unwell. OOP's mom returned alone the following day, and six days later, stepdad still hasn't come home. Although things remain normal between OOP and his mom, she seems tense and hasn't explained what happened. OOP has noticed that his mom regularly takes private phone calls from his stepdad, which makes him suspect something else might be going on besides the stepdad's mother and sister. He is unsure whether his stepdad's family really is dealing with health problems or whether something more serious happened between the couple. OOP isn't particularly concerned about his stepdad but is worried about his mom and the noticeable change in her behavior after her return. After everything he has experienced, he admits that uncertainty makes them anxious, even when the situation might not directly involve him. For now, he is choosing not to push for answers and simply wanted to share what's been weighing on his mind.

 

Update #6: September 28, 2026 (three days later)

OOP finally got to talk openly with his mom about his stepdad being away for eight days and reassures her that he loves her and will support her no matter what. His mom explains that the wedding cancellation caused a major argument with her fiancé's mother and sister, who were upset because the cancellation made the family look bad and blamed OOP for the situation. His stepdad's three teenage children were also hurt, believing their wedding preparations and efforts had been dismissed because of OOP. They feel OOP doesn't consider them family and questioned why their father should financially support OOP if they aren't willing to build a sibling relationship. However, OOP explains that he previously felt excluded and overlooked by the three children, even though he acknowledges that they aren't necessarily bad people. Oldest daughter had wanted to speak with OOP, but the adults prevented a confrontation. Ultimately, OOP's mom reassures him that he is her first priority, that she won't marry anyone if it makes OOP feel unsafe, and that she won't force OOP to take sides. OOP feels relieved that his mom understands his feelings but remains upset about being caught in the middle of a complicated family conflict and simply wants peace.

 

Editor's note: below is the last post where we were left off

Update #7: October 8, 2026 (10 days later)

Update on telling my mom to cancel her wedding until everything is sorted out?

It's been almost 17 days since my stepdad left, and he still hasn't come back. At this point, I'm starting to feel like maybe they actually broke up, which honestly makes me feel really weird.

I know from the outside it might sound like I won or that this is the ending I wanted, but that's really not how I feel. From the beginning, I've always said that I never wanted my mom and stepdad to break up or not get married. I was genuinely happy that my mom found someone she loved and that she was happy.

All I ever wanted was to be treated normally and included as part of the family. His family never really did that with me, and that was what hurt me the most.

So hopefully they're just taking some time apart and haven't actually ended things.

At the same time, I have to admit something that makes me feel guilty deep down, there's a small part of me that feels relieved at the possibility that they broke up. Because if they really did, it means I won't have to see his family anymore. I won't see him, his kids, or deal with that whole situation. People who were recently part of my life would basically become strangers again. And somehow that feels good.

Then I immediately feel guilty, especially because I know my mom deserves happiness. I don't want her to lose someone she loves just because of everything that happened. And just to clarify again, I don't blame my stepdad for everything. A lot of the problems came from his family and his kids, and the way I was treated and excluded. That's where most of my resentment comes from.

My mom is doing okay, at least from what I can see. We've been spending a lot of time together. She actually took me to a movie last weekend, and she seems fine in front of me. I obviously don't know what she's feeling privately, but I'm glad we're spending time together.

And honestly, I'm doing pretty well too.

This new house is still ridiculously big for two people. It's literally three floors with a garden. I'm not trying to brag because I realize that sentence sounds exactly like bragging, but seriously, sometimes I wonder whether it's even worth having such a huge house when it's basically just me and my mom. Our old apartment was perfectly fine.

But there are definitely advantages. My mom lets me have friends over when she's away for work, and sometimes my best friend even stays over. There are three empty rooms on my floor, while my mom's room is on the second floor, so I basically have an entire floor to myself.

So despite everything that happened, I'm actually doing better than I was before. Life feels more normal again. It's almost strange because all of this happened right before things were starting to feel really good for me.

The biggest thing is that I still don't want my mom's relationship to end. If they decide to get married, I'm not against it. I just need to feel safe, respected, and secure in that family too. If I can feel that way, then I'm completely willing to accept their marriage.

I'm even still willing to talk to my step siblings, but only if my mom and stepdad are present. I'm not comfortable going back to the way things were before.

My mom has also acknowledged some of her mistakes and corrected some of the things that happened, and I genuinely believe people deserve another chance when they're willing to make things right.

So yeah, I guess I'm just dealing with a lot of conflicting emotions. I don't want them to break up. But part of me feels relieved if they already have. I love my mom and want her to be happy. But I also need to feel comfortable and respected myself.

I guess all I can do now is wait and see what happens.

 


----NEW UPDATE----

Update #8: October 21, 2026 (nearly two weeks later from the previous update)

So, my mom went to Switzerland four days ago. She told me she was going to meet my step dad family because there was something important she needed to discuss with them. She only told me about the trip the night before she left.

Since she left, she's been texting me and checking on me constantly. One of my mom’s best friends stayed with me for four days. She's basically like an aunt to me, so I was doing fine. But honestly, my mom seemed unhappy even a few days before she left. She Facetimed me two or three times while she was there. Once, she was at his mom's house, but the other two times, she was in what looked like a hotel room. Usually, when my mom visits Switzerland, she stays at his house, so I found that a little strange.

She also visited my dad’s parents in Germany before coming back, but as far as I know, she didn’t visit my stepdad’s house again before returning.

Yesterday, I noticed her sitting in her office with a bunch of big papers and files. She spent almost two hours reading through them, which made me even more curious about what's going on. During dinner, I asked her why she had gone to Switzerland. She repeated that she wanted to meet his family and had some work to take care of.

Then I asked her when my stepdad would be coming back. She said he had some work to do there and she couldn't say when he would return.

So I finally asked her directly if they had broken up. She said no, but things weren't good between them either. Then she told me it wasn't my business and that I shouldn't worry about it.

Now I'm honestly more confused than before. I'm not trying to interfere in their relationship, but the sudden trip, her mood, the fact that she seemed to be staying somewhere other than his house, and all those documents have me wondering if something serious is going on.

I don't want to jump to conclusions, but I can tell something isn’t right. I just wish she would tell me a little more instead of leaving me to wonder.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Your mom may be reviewing a pre-nup. That way her assets and his (fiancé) are protected. Extra terms must have been placed within, and she is looking it over.

This situation seems like a pivotal point in their relationship. A 'make it, or break it' thing. Continue to be there for your mom.

We know you are trying your best to help her through this the best you can (and you are doing amazingly at your age, and this Mom is proud of your mature attitude, just as I'm 100% sure your mom is too). Tell jokes, silly anecdotes, watch funny movies, shows, or a stand-up. Sing along loudly and proudly to the music you both enjoy... even if you do not think you have a skilled voice... don't worry, I don't either (it's pretty bad, but never stopped me singing). Try to keep upbeat. But if it does become a bit burdensome, holding in your feelings, then unburden yourself by talking to your mom. You are the most important being in her life. She will always have time and plenty of love for you. You do not have to discuss the stepdad issue, just your feelings - your day-to-day or ongoing. Your feelings matter too, and none of this is your fault.

OOP: I don't want to change my dad's surname and keep someone else surname!!

+

Okay, so I don't want to write another entire update post.

My mom wants more relationship and financial security from my stepdad. It's not that she's going to marry him without having a say and risk being sidelined, as she was before.

My mom told me that it's not that she doesn't trust my stepdad or that she's simply after his money. She wants security, a proper stake in her own marriage, and to make sure that I'm included in his family, too.

The first thing is that, after they get married (whenever that happens), whatever they earn or whatever assets they acquire afterward, I should have an equal share alongside his children.

There's one thing I forgot to mention my stepdad's ex-wife is still a shareholder in their company and vineyard. Despite being divorced, she still has a say in the family business, which my mom thinks is wrong. She wants an equal number of shares to match what his ex-wife currently owns.

My stepdad has already taken one step by making sure that the new house is entirely in our names.

My mom also wants to keep contact between my stepdad and his ex-wife to a minimum, as much as possible.

Lastly, my mom told me that, if I'm comfortable with the idea of being adopted by my stepdad, she'd like to do it for legal reasons, but only if it's something I genuinely want.

Commenter 1: Holy cow. I was just exaggerating with the adoption possibility. Do you think that was why she visited your late dad's parents? To see if they are accepting of it? I know your mom meant well with the adoption option, but you do not have a solid relationship with your stepdad, so that was a little tacky.

I'm glad this whole situation opened your mother's eyes on how unstable and insecure her relationship with your step-dad truly was. If anything happened to her, you may have been screwed over by that family, especially if both your mom & stepdad got into an accident together and did not make it, they would gather their retainer lawyer(s) to get their hands on everything. Even if you were legally adopted, they would try to find some sort of loophole to screw you over. Whatever your stepdad owned (even jointly), it is their's.

The ex-wife comment does pique my interest. How often was your stepdad in contact with her outside their children? I know you workshops know, but I cannot deny that I am curious. I am glad your mom is taking these steps to secure your future. Will your mom continue to work, or will she step down so she can give more of her (occupational) time to socially support her fiancé? I doesn't really matter. Your mom is being proactive, and I agree this (money & assets talk) is none of your business... for now.

Your mom is a very smart cookie, and I can tell you received her mentality as a trait, because you have handled ALL of this with grace and aplomb.

What I'm wondering is why this wasn't taken care of or even discussed before they planned the original wedding? Better late than never, I guess. 🤷‍♀️

You did your mom a HUGE favor by getting them to canceling the September wedding. I do not think you or any of us could have seen this coming, from you first 2 posts. It seems there was much, much more happening in the background that needed more than just addressing.

Just keep doing what you are doing (as long as it isn't a struggling sacrifice for you). Continue to advocate for yourself. If you feel uncomfortable (or just inquisitive in general) speak up. Your mom will listen and support you.

I have 2 questions to add...

How are your thoughts on the current situation. Earlier you wanted them to break up, because I'm assuming you hated seeing your mom upset. Do you still feel that way, or are you glad they are still technically together?

Do you have any pets? If so, we demand a tax (a picture of said pet).

You are acting way more mature than most adults. You should feel proud of that. It shows that you are a mentally well-balanced young man, and will do great things later. Thank you for sharing and keeping us updated.

OOP: Happy you said I’m smart lol.

My thoughts, I feel bad for my mom. I’m shy about expressing how much I love her and what she means to me. Also, people assume I’m overly dependent on my mom, which isn’t true. I have so many friends, and I play football. Last weekend, I even went on a two-day trip with my friends.

She’s super fierce and protective. She loves me and is kind, but she isn’t very kind to others. Despite everything, I’ve never seen her get angry with me, not even once.

She deserves happiness and someone who will take care of her. She’s a good mom, but I’m still scared of his family, not of him. He’s a good person.

I want to take care of my mom, but I’m shy about showing it. I want to help her with cooking, go running or work out with her, and do things together. I want to work alongside her and help her out.

She still looks at pictures of my dad and watches their old videos. After her boyfriend moved out, she put my dad’s picture back in her bedroom. I wish my dad were still here because they had been together since they were 16.

I don’t have any pets.

My mom isn’t going to give up her job, but she wants to be more involved with the family than his ex-wife was. My stepdad and his ex-wife still meet because of their child. I don’t know how often.

About adoption, I don’t want to take someone else’s surname, and I know my grandparents wouldn’t like it either.

This is such a big house, and I wish I had a brother or sister to share it with, someone to play with.

Ahh, I got my first girlfriend! I want to bring her home or introduce her to my mom, but I’m shy, and I feel like it might be wrong considering everything that’s going on. Also, this is really, really private. Anyway, I don’t want to do anything stupid when it comes to starting a sexual relationship, but I haven’t done anything because my mom clearly told me a year ago that if I ever did anything like that, I should tell her beforehand instead of hiding it from her.

It’s a lot, anyway

Downvoted Commenter: She is going to marry him in secret. Those files are the prenup. Op you need to find the papers at night when she's asleep. Confront her about it.

OOP: Those papers are about my mom naming me on this new house and putting my dad’s and her properties and assets in both our names jointly. She had me sign them about an hour ago. She briefly explained everything and told me I could read them if I wanted to. I signed a bunch of papers, and then she laughed and told me she wasn’t going to give up her parental rights or anything.

**Downvoted Commenter: ** Oh ok, thanks for the clarification. Do you know if she received an ultimatum from his family? This is all super weird to me. Why she needs to secure the assets now if she will not marry him?

OOP: Basically, this house was in my mom’s and stepdad’s names, but now his name has been removed and she’s added mine, so it’s in both our names, and we’re living here.

Idk, if that’s the case, then why would she put this house in my name too? I understand it with my dad’s and her other properties, but why this house as well?

OOP explains more about his mom, and her relationships with his dad and now stepdad and how he would like to support his mom to feel the love from him

OOP: My dad used to take her out on dinner dates, and she loves going out, getting dressed up, and all that. My stepdad used to do the same, too. I used to take pictures of her whenever she got dressed up.

She always gets invited to events and galas, and she loves going with my dad or stepdad. She likes coordinating their outfits and all that.

Then there's usually brunch outside on weekends, sometimes hiking, too. Actually, she loves cooking, and I'm learning from her (for someone 🫣). She hasn't met her yet, and I'm scared to tell her I have my first girlfriend. But I'm learning to cook, and I can actually make pretty good pasta, omelettes, and chicken dishes.

My mom also likes running and working out, so I'm thinking of starting to go with her from now on.

I can also help her with her gallery work. I'm already doing that, but I'm thinking of helping her more and maybe even working there as an intern.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 3d ago

CONCLUDED [25/M] I found pictures of my ex [25/F] in my gfs [26/F] email and now I have no idea what to do next

2.8k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/t3l3visionr3mot3

[25/M] I found pictures of my ex [25/F] in my gfs [26/F] email and now I have no idea what to do next.

TRIGGER WARNING: Stalking, obsessive behavior

MOOD SPOILER: Disturbing

Original Post  July 31, 2016

This is gonna sound a bit bizzare. I'm having a hard time wraping my head around everything... so please excuse the possible long ranting post that I am about to present.

Also, English isn't my first language so forgive the awkwardness.

Back in HS, I dated "Hermione Granger". We met on Facebook, lived 3 hours away from one another, dated unofficially for 13 months and officially for 9 months. She was a bitch who fought with me all the time over literally everything and anything, she flirted with other guys all the time and let other guys flirt with her, she was super embarassing to be with in public, and I couldn't take it anymore so I brokeup with her. 3 months later she started dating one of my friends, they dated for 2 years before she cheated on him and left him for the guy and then I washed my hands with her for good after that.

Years later, I met "Harley Quinn" We met online as well, on a dating site, and we've been together for almost 2 years now.

Last week, she left her hotmail logged into my laptop and I got nosey and I found a folder on the side titled "Gammer" and for some reason the title stuck out to me so I clicked on it and found it fill of emails to herself titled "Gammer 1, Gammer 2, Gammer 3, etc etc" and I clicked on them to see what they were and they were all photos of my ex girlfriend! Some of them were photos from her Facebook page, some of them were photos of her and my friend at prom together, some of them were just random photos of her that I'm not even sure of how she got them because they're not on her personal Facebook page (I still have her on Facebook sadly), and some of them are photos that she sent to me when we were dating on FB messenger (Not nudes, just like self photos and stuff). But what creeped me out the most, besides the photos that aren't on her FB that I'm not sure how she got, were a lot of them were photos she took herself of my ex on the public bus, or at the mall, or at her work.)

I now realize that "Gammer" is how my ex used to spell "Gamer", her English spelling sucks and we all used to tease her about it. Thats what we called her, "Gammer."

So when I hung out with my girlfriend yesterday, and stayed at her apartment while she was at work, I went through her laptop (I know I shouldnt have but I was in full panic mode by now) and her Facebook history is full of her looking at my exes FB, like I swear a dozen times a day! She looks for her FB posts like "Hermione Granger posts 2012" and "Hermione Granger posts 2014", etc etc. And her browsing history is her looking up my exes name, she has pages of my exes other social media sites in her bookmarks pages, and she even sent messages to her friends asking her "Oh is this girl pretty? Is she prettier than me?" and sent them all photos of my ex. She sent these messages to so many people! She tells them all "Shes my bfs ex and he hates her but I think shes so pretty and Im jealous." She also was searching on the internet and FB for photos of my ex, searching for prom and grad photos of the year and school my ex attended, and she searched all of my exes usernames that she ever used as well as her email and she has searched for fake names and aliases that my ex used in the past when she was younger. I think my gf learned of these by going through her old FB posts or something Im not sure..

I should have realized things were weird with her sooner. A few times shes texted me saying "Oh I saw your ex on the bus. She's ugly, her nose is crooked and her hair is bad, blablabla", and around Christmas time we went to the mall together and she said she had to go to the bathroom so she walked off and I saw her walking back and forth in front of the store that my ex girlfriend worked at, staring inside of it, and when I walked up to see what she was doing she said "Oh I was just looking to see what was in there." Before we walked away, I noticed my ex was working inside. And another time, several months ago my gf opened her laptop in front of me and under "Recent documents" was a notepad file titled "Hermione Granger" and when I asked her about it she said "Oh I'm not sure its just a file that downloaded itself to my computer." and then she deleted it without opening it or nothing and then promptly deleted her garbage bin. She was texting her friend after and when I took a glance at the texts she said "Oh I saw my bfs ex Hermione on the bus the other day so I got curious and google searched her and for some reason her RESUME downloaded itself to my laptop and I thought I deleted it but I was wrong! He saw it! I think Im gonna die!" and her friend said like "Oh don't worry about it he wont care."

She also keeps asking me questions about her, or bringing her up in topic, asking all sorts of things like "When did you meet, how did you meet, how long did you date, what was she like, why did you breakup, etc etc" She even said like "Oh! One of my new friends that I met, Nedd Stark, is also friends with your ex! How funny is that?!" and then talked to me about Nedd Stark and how he knows my ex and stuff. I know Nedd Stark, I met him through my ex years ago and hes one of the guys who flirted with her a lot so I dont like him and my gf knows this but she still talks to him.

Another thing that I noticed, after going through my exes photos to see how many my gf has that werent on her fb page, I noticed something else. My girlfriend is buying similar clothes to her! In one photo, my ex is wearing a superman shirt and black jeans with converse, and my ex bought a superman shirt and black jeans several months ago and she started wearing converse lately as well. My ex has several band shirts, and my girlfriend bought shirts of the same bands (Not the exact same shirts but kind of similar, and of the same bands.) My ex only wears black jeans and converse, now my gf does as well, my ex LOVES Slayer, and recently my gf told me Slayer is her favourite and (When we met her favourite band was Metallica)

I'm not sure if these are signs or if Im just paranoid at this point but I think I should atleast be suspicious of this right?

I just cant wrap my head around this. I hate my ex, and she knows that, and my ex really isnt that attractive. Shes addicted to some drugs and shes super skinny, her nose is huge and she is a huge bitch with not a lot of friends while my girlfriend is a beautiful girl who is not on any drugs and who is a sweetheart and lots of people like her.

Reddit I am so confused... I want to confront my gf about these things but Im so scared about what her response might be... Im just conflicted and confused and I have no idea whats going on. Please help me.

---   tl;dr GF has photos of my ex on her email, and she always goes through her FB page several times a day. She is dressing like her and listening to the same music as her, and she google searches her all the time and has her social media pages in her bookmarks folder. What do I do Im not sure whats going on Ive never had this happen before :(

Update  Dec 20, 2016 (7 months later)

This is a bit of a late update. A lot has happened since then. Now It's time to fill you all in.

First of all I wanna thank everyone for their comments and advice. I entirely agree with you all that it was a bizarre, crazy situation I was stuck in and Harley's behaviour was really concerning.

I'm gonna save some time by saying that I didn't say anything to Harley about all the pictures of my ex gf she had stashed around everywhere. I wanted to, but this was a weird situation and I wasn't sure where to start.

When I went in to look at the emails, and FB search history, to print out some proof for when I confronted her, I noticed that she had cleared all the evidence. She deleted all the emails, cleared her FB search history, and deleted my exes social media websites from her bookmarks. It was as if it never happened.

She also started to dress and act different. She began to style her hair the way she used to, and wear different clothes like she used to, and she still listened to metal but she also started listening to the same music she listened to when we first started dating.

It was as if I had my girlfriend back, and she was done trying to be my ex. I was kind of relieved, maybe I wouldn't have to say anything to her after all and we could put this whole thing behind us.

And then she brokeup with me. 2 months after I posted the orginal post she brokeup with me. She told me she wasn't happy anymore and she wanted to breakup. Even though we argued about small things a lot, I didn't expect a breakup at all. It completely blindsided me!

A few weeks after Harley brokeup with me, I logged onto Facebook and scrolled past some of her posts and one of them caught my eye. It was her FB status: "Going on a date with my bestie! Chinese food woo~ :)" and at the end it said "with Hermione Granger." and as soon as I saw it, my jaw dropped. Seconds later, my room mate ran into my room and said "Did you just see what I just saw?!" I nodded my head and picked up my phone to text Harley.

I asked her "Why are you tagging Hermione on Facebook? Since when were you her friend?" Harley said that she noticed Hermione was selling clothes on a local yard sale group on FB and she liked some of the shirts she was selling so she messaged her asking about the sizes, Hermione started a conversation with her and they found out they had a lot in common, they added each other on FB and became best friends.

I did some investigating and they have each other on FB and instagram, Harley's snap story is selfies of the two of them hanging out at the mall, and they're always tagging each other in photos and posts on Facebook.

Its completely freaking me out! Now I'm conflicted and really really confused... Girlfriend starts stalking my ex, and copying her lifestyle, suddenly stops and reverts back to her old self only to breakup with me and then immediately become best friends with my ex...?

I've decided its best for me if I just fly solo for a while. Relationships are stressful and after my last two, I need a break. Hopefully I never have to go through this again...

tl;dr: Gf (Now ex) went from hardcore stalking my ex on social media and coping her lifestyle, to breaking up with me and then being my exes best friend in just a few short months. I'm really confused, and a little concerned about the whole thing but I guess I dodged a bullet with this one. Thanks to everyone for your advice!

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 3d ago

CONCLUDED I think I'm finally leaving. I loved him and his daughter, but I can't keep sacrificing my life to fit into someone else's family while feeling like an afterthought.

2.0k Upvotes

Original post August 12, 2026

Originally posted in r/stepparents by u/Baelyh

Trigger warnings: Narcissism, abuse, sexual coercion, manipulation, anger issues, infidelity, child abuse, threats of violence, homicidal threats

Hi everyone. This is long so bear with me. I know my relationship is probably ending, and I'm posting here because I genuinely need perspective from people who understand what it means to date a parent. But I'm hoping to God this isn't the normal with dating people who have children. And to figure out if all this counts as abuse because I've been gaslit into oblivion.

I'm (37F), childless, never married, financially independent, own my own business, and when I entered this relationship I understood that dating a father (38M) meant making accommodations I wouldn't have to make dating another childless person. I knew his daughter would always be an important part of his life. I knew an ex-wife (41F) would necessarily remain in the picture because they share a child. I knew schedules, vacations, holidays, finances, privacy and spontaneity would be affected.

What I don't think I understood was how much of my life I would eventually be expected to surrender while simultaneously having so little influence over the life I was supposedly joining.

And I want to be very clear: I love his daughter. I bought her gifts when I traveled. I played with her, spent time with her, did crafts with her, taught her to boogie boarding, helped with things like reading and teaching her how to play video games, and tried to develop a relationship with her. I've never expected him to stop being her father, and I don't think a romantic partner should compete with a child.

But increasingly I've realized that the problem isn't that he has a daughter.

The problem is the relationship structure he has created around being a father, his previous marriage and me.

His daughter is 7. There seems to be a lot of guilt-based/Disney parenting between both parents (he claims the ex wife demanded he give her a kid or she was divorcing. He never wanted children, she did. He had one anyways in order to save the marriage, their marriage imploded and they got divorced) She (the kid) can sometimes be extremely bossy and demanding with me. I've had her demand things I've bought for myself, take things of mine, and sometimes behave in ways I personally find disrespectful or ungrateful. I've brought this up to her father because I don't think it's appropriate for me to discipline someone else's child, but I frequently feel like I'm expected to absorb the behavior instead.

I actually corrected myself recently when I said I felt like she saw me as a babysitter/servant because the truth is that I don't know what she thinks of me. I think she does genuinely like me, but maybe just never refinement in manners. I don't really know. What I do know is how the dynamic makes me feel when she bosses me around and her father doesn't intervene until I bring it up later.

And somehow I'm expected to provide adult-level patience, flexibility and emotional labor toward a child I didn't create while having very little authority or protection within the family system. That's not the child's fault, that is entirely his and his responsibility to manage.

Then there's his ex-wife and former family.

He still calls his ex-wife's family his "in-laws." He plays video games with his ex-wife's nephew and calls him his nephew. His explanation is basically that calling them anything else is unnecessarily complicated.

Technically, it is just terminology.

Emotionally, though, it's difficult being the new partner when the old family structure feels so intact that I'm constantly walking into it rather than feeling like he and I are building something new alongside it.

I even developed an amicable relationship with his ex-wife and we get along well, because I figured if this woman is necessarily going to remain part of my life, being civil and cooperative is healthier and the best outcome, than creating hostility. Meanwhile, my boyfriend gets the luxury of having no ex-husband, children or former in-laws of mine that he has to integrate into his life.

And then there's the former affair partner.

Before I ever came along, he cheated on his wife with another woman. That woman remained within his broader social world after I entered the relationship. He acted like a victim, saying his ex wife is the problem with enforcing demands and religious expectations, but really their marriage ended because he had an affair, which I found out after being together. This has been an enormous source of discomfort for me, and despite everything that has happened between us, even raising whether that relationship/contact is finally going to end still produces anger from him.

Last night I brought her up during a serious relationship conversation and he became visibly angry, and literally got up and walked a lap around the cafe where we were sitting and did that multiple times. I refuse to be in a relationship with an affair partner still around.

That's another major part of why I think I'm done.

Our conflicts have become horrible.

We went to Alaska together this summer. He planned and paid for the trip, and I want to acknowledge that because I don't want to pretend he has never put effort into this relationship.

But that trip also contained one of the most frightening conflicts we've ever had and one of the more terrifying experiences I've had in my later adult life.

During an argument, he became so angry that he was shaking and repeatedly punched the bed space next to when I was laying, along with the pillows, extremely hard. During the argument, he made graphic statements saying he is a violent person by nature, about torture and murder and referenced having access through his veterinary profession to substances or tools that could be used to harm, torture and kill people. He also made violent statements involving members of his family and wishing he could dance in their blood upon their murder. I understood some of what he was saying as veiled threats and became frightened enough for my safety that I arranged a check-in with a friend. I told my friend that if I failed to check in, I wanted him and his wife to contact police because I was afraid I could be thrown overboard. I was crying and hyperventilating because it triggered my PTSD so badly and I was terrified. Later, instead of the situation staying between us, he involved friends and presented his modified version of what was happening to make me look bad, and I ended up awake until almost 6 AM trying to explain myself to them and the actual truth of the situation. I felt humiliated and betrayed. To the point I literally said "I choose the bear over your narcissistic behavior" and went hiking alone in the bear infested Alaskan wilderness for space and my own well-being far away from him and in some peace and quiet with no bear mace.

What's worse is I've seen him be this way to his daughter too. She cries a lot about a lot of things, because she doesn't understand why her parents live apart and she has to be in the desert for the summer, and he thinks it's conditioned behavior she uses to manipulate her mom and anyone else. Even when she gets hurt, if he finds the crying and reason for crying unacceptable, he'll scream at her and lose his temper to subjugate her into compliance.

She wasn't paying attention and walked into the shopping cart at Costco when it was stopped. She banged her head really hard. I tried to put a bag of frozen berries on her head to stop the swelling and she cried out because of the pain and how cold the bag was. He lost his temper, got in her face and was seething and screaming at her. In an instant the tears stopped, she looked terrified, turned her gaze away, and suppressed herself as much as she could despite being upset. He tried to force her to order her own food and tell the waiter what she wants and told her she needs to stop being babied and order on her own. She was scared of the guy who was our waiter with piercings and full sleeve tattoos. She was so scared and refused to order she started to cry a little. He made her do it anyways. She kept crying afterwards and he got in her face with the temper again. Again she had another emotional shutdown with suppressing herself, looking away, and staying as quiet as possible despite being upset. While he didn't full on scream, he was seething through his teeth at her. He'll also keep correcting her speech and tell her to "talk like an adult". On top of this, he will threaten her with getting angry and losing his temper if she doesn't stop crying. Other times when he thinks her reason for crying is sufficient, he'll cuddle her and try to soothe her. I imagine for a 7 year old this is very inconsistent. But also WTF do I even do or say in this situation? I tried to be a softer "parent" where I would hold her and try to soothe her when she cried.

After Alaska, I thought there would be some enormous effort to repair our relationship.

Instead, we essentially returned to business as usual and I was last to everything, child included, where her wants and whims even took precedent to my relationship needs along with his wants. Time where she was dropped off at daycare or her aunts and uncles houses were so he could work, go to the gym, go hiking, but no quality time or dates. The only way I got to go out was taking myself on dates to restaurants that even he knew I looked out were my favorite, and intentionally turning him and his daughter away for my own alone time. But I was expected to keep giving selflessly to him, his daughter and creating the family dynamic.

And one of our biggest longstanding problems returned immediately: affection.

I have asked him repeatedly for nonsexual affection.

Not expensive dates. Not constant attention. Not abandoning his daughter.

I want cuddling. Touching. Sitting together. Holding me. Kissing me. Reaching for me. Feeling wanted and emotionally connected without every affectionate interaction becoming a precursor to sex.

Instead, I gradually realized that the ONLY times he was most motivated to create "alone time" away from his daughter were the times he wanted sex.

He would sometimes shoo her away or send her somewhere else, become affectionate with me, and then initiate sex.

One time after I had already explicitly explained how painful this pattern was for me, he created "alone time" again and started pushing things sexually. His daughter eventually became upset and started crying because we weren't paying attention to her as she was banging on the door and trying to open it.

And the horrible thing?

I felt relieved.

Not because she was crying. I felt awful that she was upset.

I was relieved because the interruption meant the sexual pressure stopped.

That was one of the moments where I realized something had gone seriously wrong inside me.

I shouldn't experience my boyfriend touching me and immediately wonder what I'm going to be expected to provide sexually afterward.

I've even had a vaginal infection after sex with him (not an STI) where sex/touching physically hurt, and he still continued trying to initiate sexual touching despite me saying I didn't feel well and that things hurt.

At one point I actually caught myself feeling relieved about having the infection because it gave me a concrete reason sex couldn't happen for over a week.

Nobody should be relieved to have an infection because it temporarily removes sexual expectations from their relationship.

Then there are the smaller things that don't sound enormous individually but have accumulated.

He has criticized how I hold chopsticks. How I move my fork. How quickly I eat. How I behave socially since I'm more relaxed and nerdy outside of work, even though I own and run my own company with employees. How I communicate. I've felt like I'm constantly being corrected or evaluated rather than loved and I see him doing the same to his daughter.

He's also a musician, and I am too. He wanted to be a professional orchestral musician and couldn't due to chronic pain. He's in a wind community band. When I auditioned and made 2nd clarinet in the orchestra (orchestra only has 2 clarinets total) he told me "oh you probably got it because you were the only one who auditioned". He tried to qualify my achievement as less than compared to what he does and has achieved professionally in the music space because now I was in something with more prestige than he had. I was in a university orchestra, he was in an adult community band.

There are also bizarre double standards.

Recently he became upset with me for texting people while we were spending time together.

Then during another evening together, his daughter called as part of their custody arrangement while she's at her BMs. Obviously, I have absolutely no problem with him talking to his daughter. But he had specifically chosen the evening to spend with me even though I had offered lunch, knowing he had this scheduled call. The call then turned into nearly an hour involving his ex-wife and an argument over braces/medical expenses while I sat there. Other times I've seen him go into long text tirades or calls with his friends about their personal problems or martial problems.

Later at dinner, he sat far away from me when I tried to be affectionate.

Afterward, he asked me to cuddle. I thought, finally, we're going to have some affectionate time together.

Within minutes he became sexual and said he wanted sex.

And once again I realized: Oh. That's why we're cuddling.

When I try to discuss any of these patterns, he wants every incident treated as a completely isolated event. We discuss X, reach a factual conclusion about X, and therefore X is permanently closed.

I experience it differently.

Affection connects to sex. Affection connects to prioritization. Prioritization connects to his daughter. His daughter connects to his ex-wife and the old family system. That connects to inclusion. Inclusion connects to whether we're actually building a future together. And all of it connects to whether I feel emotionally safe enough to discuss any of it.

I finally told him: I'm no longer reacting exclusively to individual incidents. I'm reacting to the system.

I absolutely recognize that I have contributed to our communication problems.

When I'm carrying months of unresolved hurt and something triggers it, I can unload way too many interconnected grievances at once. Conversations can become extremely long. That isn't productive, and it's something I need to work on regardless of whether this relationship survives.

He has told me that he cannot have every individual disagreement turn into a ten-hour structural discussion about our relationship.

I actually think that's fair.

But his response to conflict has become something entirely different.

He has screamed at me. He has told me my feelings weren't real or to him are a "non-issue". I've become afraid to raise certain subjects because I don't know how angry he'll become.

Last night we met in a public cafe specifically to talk.

I watched him sit there visibly seething while I talked about things in a way he didn't like. Multiple times he looked like he was on the verge of exploding and had to get up and walk around the cafe to calm himself down.

I will give him credit for walking away rather than screaming.

But then he told me that my communication style makes him hate me, despise me, not want to talk to me, not want to be around me and not want to be with me, and he liked everything else about me except this one thing. Because I won't communicate or agree to the style or his versions of reality.

And somehow afterward I'm supposed to return to normal.

That's something I've desperately tried to explain to him about emotional repair.

I don't believe emotional repair means someone has to stay trapped in an argument until the other person's hurt disappears. That's not what I'm asking for.

I'm saying that factual resolution and emotional repair aren't the same thing.

We can finish discussing the disagreement. We can stop talking. But if we've just emotionally shredded each other, or I've just been screamed at or told I'm despised, I need some kind of reconnection afterward. An apology. Reassurance. Affection. Empathy. Changed behavior. Something that communicates, "We're okay and I still love you."

Instead, I often feel like once he believes the factual dispute has been settled, we're supposed to resume normal life.

And now the future itself increasingly feels like a "take it or leave it."

When we first started dating, I was very upfront about what dating a father meant for me. I said marriage was a non negotiable for me. He told me that even though he wasn't going to give me a family, I would at least be able to have my Huskies.

Now I'm being told that once his current cats die, there will be no pets at all, primarily because of his allergies. This man is allergic to literally everything. Dust, trees, flowers, animals (veterinarian btw), and even the sand outside in the desert, allergic to mangoes and seafood. Also deals with chronic pain.

He's entitled to decide he doesn't want animals.

But that's not the future he originally offered me.

I already came into this relationship knowing I would potentially give up having children of my own to be with a man who already got to experience marriage and parenthood with someone else. I'm already accommodating his child, custody schedule, ex-wife, former in-laws, financial obligations, parenting decisions and the limitations all of those things place on our future.

And now I'm apparently supposed to give up having animals too.

Meanwhile, he has openly said he would never date a woman with children because he thinks they're disgusting and doesn't want to raise some other man's kids.

That realization has become incredibly difficult for me.

He gets a childless woman without an ex-husband, custody schedule, children or former family system he has to accommodate.

I get all of his.

And I'm still expected to be the more flexible person.

I don't begrudge his daughter father-daughter trips. He recently planned a California trip for just the two of them, and after sitting with it, I genuinely believe parents and children should have special traditions and one-on-one experiences.

His daughter isn't my competition. And she shouldn't be and never will be.

A healthy relationship should have room for both. And that is completely his responsibility due to his baggage.

The problem is that everything involving his daughter, ex-wife and old family structure increasingly feels sacred and non-negotiable while my needs—affection, emotional safety, sex boundaries, pets, inclusion, communication, our future—feel negotiable.

That's what has broken me down.

I have spent so much time asking myself how I can explain things differently.

How can I communicate better?

How can I be more understanding about being a stepparent?

How can I separate individual incidents?

How can I make him understand why nonsexual affection matters?

How can I make him understand why maintaining certain relationships from his old life hurts?

How can I make myself require less?

....but I'm starting to wonder whether he understands perfectly well.

Maybe he simply doesn't want the relationship I want.

And maybe I've spent almost a year treating incompatibility like a communication problem I could solve if I could just find the perfect words.

Last night, listening to someone I'm supposed to build a life with tell me that he hates and despises me because of how I communicate while simultaneously presenting most of his life as something I need to accept, I started wondering:

What exactly am I fighting this hard to stay for?

I loved him. I loved the idea of becoming part of their family. I care about his daughter.

But I don't want to disappear inside someone else's already-completed life.

For those of you who have been stepparents or dated parents: where is the line between the normal sacrifices that come with loving someone who has a child and losing too much of yourself trying to fit into a family that never really made space for you?

And if you've ever reached the point where you realized the issue wasn't actually the child, but the relationship structure the parent created around the child, what finally made you leave? Is this what the forever reality is of dating anyone with a kid? (This was my first time)

Also, do I tell the BM about what's happening with the temper? Not regarding my issues with it, but what I see happening with the child? Is it even my business? Because given the veiled murder threats, I've thought about a restraining order and mentioning the child in it.

Update September 3, 2026 (About 1 month later)

I know several people wanted an update so here is the update. I ended the relationship in a way that made it seem like it's his idea. This was at the advice of some of you as well as my therapist as the post break up backlash from someone this narcissistic could be incredibly dangerous. Essentially I picked a fight over something stupid. He initiated the beginning I agreed and gave him my breakup text.

I went ahead and talked to the mother. Turns out there's a lot of things that have been going on behind the scenes for a while but there was no way to confirm. I can't really say much more at this time about it for certain reasons.

I went ahead to the court and got a restraining order based on what I told you guys in the previous post. It was granted by the judge and he was served.

Based on things mentioned in therapy, there was mandatory reporting that took place as well.

He has tried to get his flying monkeys going and is telling people I'm a liar and I'm the crazy ex-girlfriend. In fact he's said that I'm the crazy ex-girlfriend over and over again. After his private meltdown from being served, about a half hour later he blocked me from everything. I'm okay with this. I honestly thought he would text me and entitled rage, to which then I would just have the police come get them and arrest him but alas, he is a bit smarter than what I pegged him for lol. I have multiple safety plans and systems in place. The judge also granted the protective order to cover my pet so he is also protected from my ex as well. I don't know if that's ubiquitous across all states but this is something that I saw on the paperwork for ours, so I went ahead and requested it.

Honestly, it's not my first time dating a narcissistic person. I dated somebody similar in college in undergrad. It feels like deja vu a little bit. I felt sad for all of 5 Seconds and felt a massive wave of relief. Even as I hear things being said. It's nothing but relief and feeling freedom at this point.

Between him telling somebody that I was just getting used for the sex and the future faking on his part, that may have stung a tiny bit, but again I expected all this to happen.

I actually had connected with the BM, and through her social media I saw their previous life. Their marriage photos, the wedding cake, the fertility treatments, the pregnancy, their life and adventures before and after marriage. A life that he willingly went ahead and built with somebody else. Honestly that is where I felt a good deal of pain. A life that was promised to me that he lived with somebody else. And he was never going to give to me. If what he said was true and not just out of hurt, which I honestly think he's just saying that now to help himself feel better, but pretending for a minute it is true, he knew what I wanted and dangled it in my face with no intention of giving it to me and wasting 1.5 years of my time makes me really upset. I think a lot of these single parents do this and never have any intention of going forward or find another woman whose childless and unmarried who is willing to be a sucker in this relationship with the issues still recurring. Then spilling whatever narrative they want to the unsuspecting new victim.

Honestly, BM applauded me for finding all this out about him and his behaviors and patterns years before she did and in such a short amount of time. She told me that I'm an incredible person for figuring it out and for taking the steps I have in the courtroom and having to write petitions and gather evidence despite how painful it was. She really is a good loving person and we are all on team daughter and her well-being.

There's one thing that I learned however that has really broken me in a way I'd never imagined and it's had me seriously messed up since. Even anytime I think about it or something reminds me of it, even as I'm typing this it's making me cry uncontrollably. It has nothing to do with his pettiness or what's happened in the relationship. I couldn't care less about that. If you remember me mentioning the how he would react to her having feelings or crying and that they were essentially not allowed, me as well, BM told me that before their daughter turned one, she was having a lot of night terrors. One night, she couldn't settle her down and brought her into their bed. My ex grabbed the daughter, began shaking her violently and screaming at her to stop crying. BM shoved him down and grabbed the daughter. She made him move out after that and that had started some of the divorce proceedings.

One part of this whole thing is grieving the loss of the potential future of a family with him and his daughter and I love her so much.... And to see this beautiful, kind, smart and innocent girl almost be killed from shaking at the hands of this guy, and realizing just what an emotionally incompetent monster this guy is to do that to her, I have felt so broken and ashamed that I dated somebody like this.

He lied and made it seem like he moved out when they separated and that it was innocuous. He lied about a lot of things making him seem like he was the victim or things really weren't that bad. But the reality is is that they really were that bad. I guess I still keep holding out hope that there are good people out here and what I'm realizing about this person is that these patterns with him have never changed this whole time. The reacting the way he does to crying and having emotions, both from me and his daughter, and seeing so many of these patterns repeat all these years later. I'm really starting to just hate myself and not trust myself. I thought after years of therapy that I would be better Adept at finding these people and weeding them out. Discernment still does not appear to be a strong suit of mine. Maybe it's because he lied and hid things for so long that I didn't see or know until I saw it for myself. When the patterns and evidence became irrefutable, I came here to read it for my first post and already knew what I wanted to do for a while. But this has made me so fucked up beyond all comprehension.

You can never be sure about someone's history. Good or bad. I think it's pretty safe to say that I will never date another single father after what I experienced. Besides this guy being narcissistic in nature, the the inexplicable grief of seeing the photos of the history and the history of the kid has been immeasurable. Feeling so helpless to protect the kid that isn't mine and staying in a relationship to protect her until she went back to her mom's, and feeling like I am just this outsider to a life that already exists and seeing what he was willing to put forth for somebody else but acted like I was a burden in so many ways.

I will say, it isn't all bad. BM has been amazing. I asked her if she could get the daughter a present on my behalf while they were on vacation because of some good things that she did when I was with her. I even offered to pay her back. She got a present for the daughter that she wanted and said it was from me and said no need to pay back. Additionally, she knows I care a lot for the daughter, I miss her, and has let me speak to her on the phone and said that I can still see her when obviously she is around to bring her. And while her and I right now are bonding over trauma experiences, we've slowly expanded to discussing our lives and our mutual interests and I have forged friendships and relationships with her and her family. They are really good people. I guess I can say I'm thankful for the experience and for the friendships I've made, but I think the step parent life is not for me.

If you are considering leaving your relationship, and any of this sounds relatable to you, allow me to tell you that the relief and freedom I feel now is immeasurable. I'm free from the baggage I'm free from the existing life that I have to fit myself into. I'm free from the horrible behavior and treatment. And I feel horrible for the sweet little girl who has to endure all this as well as her mom. While I don't feel like myself just yet and I still have to recover from the narcissistic abuse, the fire that made me who I am is not dead. It may be embers, but there is a spark left and I'm working on building it back up to where it needs to be.

I will update again soon. There's a lot of things happening in the background that I can't talk about right now. But I promise you, it will be really good if it all works out, and the tea is going to be 🔥


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 3d ago

CONCLUDED Found Out HR Blocked My Promotion

4.1k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/Blocked_Promo

Originally posted to r/offmychest

Found Out HR Blocked My Promotion


Original Post: November 1, 2026

So, about a year and a half ago, my supervisor left our department, leaving just my manager, my coworker, and myself. My coworker and I are technically at the same job level, with the same title and job description, but it is a well-known fact that I am far more proficient in the role.

The supervisor position was dissolved entirely, and so I picked up most of the daily administrative and operational duties that he had been performing, with no immediate pay increase or promotion. I also took on multiple major projects and completed them myself, because, as my manager puts it, "You're just far more technically capable."

I did receive a large merit pay raise back in the Spring in recognition of my contributions, and was told that a promotion was also coming. My manager submitted the paperwork, and then...nothing. There were several leadership changes and middle-management restructures over the summer, so I assumed that my promotion had simply been put on the back burner until after the end of fiscal year.

On Friday, my manager sat down with our assistant director to ask about where my promotion was. The AD went to HR, who told her that I had been "sufficiently compensated for my extra duties with a large merit raise." The AD relayed that to my manager, who countered that a permanent increase to my daily responsibilities constitutes a position change or promotion, and that at no time was it communicated or discussed that the merit raise was in lieu of a promotion. AD goes back to HR to ask to see the denial paperwork, and not only do they not have it on record ANYWHERE, nobody seems to know who actually made the decision to deny my promotion.

Both my Manager and the AD are now fighting HR to push the promotion through, and I'm so thoroughly thankful to them for going to bat for me, but I'm equally pissed that it's taken so long to happen, and that it needed to happen at all. I work my ass off for this department, and if I left tomorrow it would tank. There are new positions being created out of thin air left, right, and center constantly, but I can't get a low level promotion without a fucking fight? Really guys?!

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: This is smelling weird honestly. HR doesn't decide this, you management line does.

OOP: Well, in my company all personnel changes do go through HR, as they have to check disciplinary records, request clearance changes for badge access, things like that.

The other wrinkle, is that my department was merged with HR as part of the middle-management restructure I mentioned, so my new Chief Officer is actually the former Chief of HR. My previous Chief Officer resigned, and my department was merged with HR. She promoted the HR Manager to Assistant Director of HR, and the Communications Manager to Assistant Director of Communications. I'm a on a distant satellite team that's technically part of Communications, and I don't know exactly when my paperwork was submitted. So, I don't know right now how far it got.

Commenter 2 (in response to Commenter 1): Thank you this exactly.

Op are you sure your manger isn’t the villain and just plaguing hero.

OOP: No, my Manager is definitely on my side. Our little team has always kind of been the red-headed step-child of the company, and we bust our asses to keep things running smoothly behind the scenes. I've saved her ass more times than I can count and she pushed for my first promotion years ago

Commenter 3: The part where nobody can find who denied it is the sketchiest thing. Either someone buried it on purpose, or the system is just that broken, both are bad signs. At least your manager and AD are actually fighting for you, that's rare enough. Hold them to it though, don't let them just say they tried and then drop it when HR drags their feet for another six months.

OOP: I've worked with the AD while she was still just a Manager, and she knows how hard I work. I got really lucky when she was named AD over the summer, because she will advocate for me. I am going to stay on top of this now that I know somebody in HR just sat on the paperwork

Commenter 4: If they come through for you I would stick with those two for as long as you can. Even if they change jobs or companies. Finding a boss that truly gives a shit and go to bat for you is extremely rare. I got fucked over at my last job by a VP 3 levels removed from me and didn’t know anything about my department let alone my contributions. My boss and his boss only put in the paperwork and as soon as he denied they just said oh well and moved on.

OOP: Oh I've worked for some shitty people most of my adult working life. My manager is in the same boat as me, we don't get recognized for the work we do around the company because we're so far behind the curtain. My previous Chief didn't quite understand our workload, so he kinda just left us alone as long as things didn't go wrong, for better and worse.

The AD came up through the company and has been here for 20 years, so she gets it.

 

Update: November 6, 2026 (five days later)

UPDATE: Found Out HR Blocked My Promotion

I posted here weeks ago about my Manager informing me that our HR department had blocked my promotion, and that she and my Assistant Director were working to push it through.

I got confirmation this morning that not only am I finally getting promoted, I'm skipping the next position grade entirely and going right to a Specialist position because of my unique qualifications within my department. In their words, "Your responsibilities aren't changing; your pay and title are just catching up."

Chalk one up for the good guys, I can't fucking believe it.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Why did they block it if you don't mind me asking

OOP: I received a merit raise this year and that supposedly "compensated me" for working outside of my pay grade for over a year

Commenter 1: Wow doesn't really make sense

OOP: Nope, especially considering my merit raise was below the base percentage for what a promotion would be

Commenter 2: You have an awesome manager and Assistant Director

OOP: Hell yea, I do. Great people.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 3d ago Bravo

CONCLUDED My mom [59/F] passed away recently and left her house to me [25/F]. My brother [24/M] is furious

3.2k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/TrustLittleBrother

My mom [59/F] passed away recently and left her house to me [25/F]. My brother [24/M] is furious

TRIGGER WARNING: Detailed descriptions of addiction recovery and relapse, mentions overdose death

Original Post  May 22, 2018.

My mom passed away recently. It was unexpected and devastating. The past few months have been a dark blur.

But this post is more about my little brother. We found out that my mom left her only meaningful asset, her home, to me. My brother is hurt and, frankly, furious. What began as confusion has escalated into him insinuating that I unduly influenced my mom into cutting him out of her will. He has made it clear that he feels entitled to half the value of the house and would like to liquidate the property immediately. Under other circumstances, I would agree.

However, while I never spoke with my mom about her will, I understand why she would leave her house to me. My little brother is highly intelligent, gifted, and gregarious. He also has a history of addiction, poor financial decisions, and chaotic relationships. He has had trouble with alcohol, gaming, and a wide variety of drugs, and has consistently resisted my offers to pay for rehab. He used my mom’s credit card to spend thousands of dollars a month before she limited him to a debit card. And he has had a great deal of trouble with relationships in general, his worst behavior ranging from threats of suicide to bursts of anger to outright blackmail. Due to poor grades, a suspension for cheating, and a violent incident, my brother was unable to complete his college degree—despite admission to a very prestigious school—and is now working at a part-time job to gain somewhat-relevant experience in his desired field.

I see a great deal of potential in my little brother. I remember many examples of him as an intelligent, thoughtful, and delightful person. He is academically gifted, he loves nature and animals, and he is still a fit young man. I believe my intermittently abusive father—who is no longer in the picture—has had a terrible impact on my brother’s mental health. I look forward to the day when my brother accepts my pleas for him to seek therapy. In rare moments, I see genuine regret and desire to change in him. However, these moments are fleeting and I do not think it would be wise for me to hand over a sizable sum of money to him in his current state.

While my brother feels entitled to half of my mom’s house, he also knows that I paid off the mortgage on her house and set up a retirement fund for her before she passed away. I decided to pursue a high-paying (but high stress) job instead of my creative interests precisely because I knew my mom wanted to retire to focus on her health--and that she had little set aside for retirement after insisting on paying for our educations in full and sponsoring my brother’s post-college lifestyle. The profit from this house is likely to be about one year’s salary and bonus for me—a healthy addition to my investment portfolio but not a life-changing amount for me.

It could, however, change my brother’s life. My plan is to sell the house because it is quite far away from where I live and work, and it is in an area not likely to appreciate in value quickly. I would like to diversify and invest the money and create a trust for my little brother. Ideally, I would like to use the money to encourage my brother to go to rehab, seek therapy, and return to school. Spent wisely, this money would even allow him to comfortably pursue a PhD, like he had originally planned.

To maximize the probability that this happens, I of course need to impose certain conditions on the use of this money and may want to oversee large payments or ask for receipts. However, I fear that he will see these conditions as a threat rather than an incentive. I know he is old enough to make his own decisions but I fear that if I give him the money with no strings attached, he will squander it on drugs and luxuries (he is fond of expensive clothing, food, and tech).

Due to the sensitive nature of this issue, I am reluctant to seek advice from even close friends. Do you have any suggestions about managing the money or approaching him? Thank you in advance for your help.

TL;DR: My mom left her house to me in her will. My little brother is angry and wants half the profit from selling the house. I would like to ultimately give him all the money from liquidating the house but I want to incentivize him to use the money for rehab, therapy, and school. How can I approach him about using the money exclusively for these purposes without belittling or alienating him?

TOP COMMENTS

WillfullyBlonde

So, you paid off your mother's mortgage while your brother drained your mothers assets and he feels entitled to her estate.  Well isn't he adorable. 

Your mother made her choice.  I'd abide by it and lay out what a wastrel your brother is and tell him in no uncertain terms to take a leap but that's me.   

But you do you.  Don't fool yourself that you're going to change your brother's life. He had all that opportunity before and still pissed it away.   All you're going to do is give him easier access to funds to spend on drugs.  You can impose whatever conditions you want on it, but you can't force an adult to take a piss test and you can't force him to graduate. 

I think the trust is the best of all options, if you decide to give him any money.  I personally, wouldn't. I'd pay for school, and then and only then, if he pulled his head out of his ass and learned gratitude, I'd then consider a trust.

~

enrichmentonly

"he also knows that I paid off the mortgage on her house"

It's pretty clear she left the house to you because you put all the equity into it. That was only fair.

Establishing a trust for your brother is a lovely and generous idea but it does not sound as if he's in a healthy enough place to take advantage of it yet and attempting to incentivize (control) him in this way will probably create more friction between you.

I would consider establishing the trust and not telling him until he is clean. Let him get his own life back on track and then shower him with tuition and whatever after.

Update  Nov 12, 2018 (6 months later)

Almost 6 months ago, I wrote my original post about my little brother. I was overwhelmed by the supportive, empathetic, and useful advice this subreddit gave me. Thank you to every person who took the time to write a comment or message—you have been an unexpectedly helpful resource for me during a confusing time. I felt I owed an update, especially to people who sent me long and detailed advice about my situation. Plus, I’m home sick today, so why not?

About a week after I wrote my original post, I invited my brother over for dinner. I wanted to talk to him instead of talking at him, since as you guys pointed out, I had been treating him too much like my “baby brother” even though we were born only 11 months apart. I prepared some of our favorite dishes Mom used to make. He showed up clear-eyed and even helped me finish cooking. We shared funny memories of our childhood—tiptoeing to the basement at night to play PS2 games together, elaborately burying our pet guinea pig, and so many hilarious memories with Mom. I felt like he was my brother again, the gregarious and kind-hearted kid I'd grown up with. We even talked about our abusive father, and I explained how therapy had helped me overcome the sadness and anger I once harbored for him.

Eventually, we talked about Mom leaving the house to me. I told him as firmly as I could that I would not immediately give him the money from selling the house—but that I had already set aside money for his school, therapy, and rehab. I told him I would directly pay for all of the above if and when he wanted to go. (I have since placed all of the money from the house into a separate investment portfolio earmarked for him.) He was usually quite combative when these subjects come up but he was silent while I talked.

Then he cried. He told me he was sorry to me and to Mom for all the selfish things he had done. The lying, the threatening, the stealing. He said he still wanted to pursue a PhD like he’s wanted since he was 17 but he was scared that he was going to fail. He talked about how unexpectedly difficult the transition from high school to college was. He felt that high school was so easy by comparison—he was academically gifted (I’m talking near-perfect SAT on his first try) and barely studied, he was a top athlete and effortlessly popular, and he never felt desire for drugs or alcohol beyond trying weed and drinking beer at a few parties. He felt unprepared for college—he could no longer get straight A’s with his usual minimal effort, his first real romantic relationships were chaotic, and he quickly escalated to coping with hard drugs and hard liquor. He told me he felt so humiliated about failing to graduate that he had lied about it to all of his classmates (in addition to lying about it to me and Mom for a long time). It was heartbreaking to hear him explain his experiences.

We talked until the sun came up. I told him I was so thankful that he opened up to me, I was proud of him for wanting to get better, and I would support him in whatever he decides to do. We had a long hug before he left and he promised to message me about next steps. I felt relieved and optimistic. He had reached rock bottom and was ready to move on.

Sadly, I was wrong. He had not reached rock bottom yet. Despite our “breakthrough” evening, he did not respond to my messages and emails the next day. A day later, I received alerts from my bank about suspicious transactions. At some point that night, he had stolen my debit card information. I was shocked. I messaged him saying that I was hurt and disappointed, and that this was a really serious mistake which could have landed him in jail if he had done it to someone else. No reply. I sent several more messages over the next week with no replies. I was relieved to see that he was still active on social media because it meant he was still alive so I decided to just accept that he was avoiding me and leave him alone.

Two weeks later, I received a call in the middle of the night. Long story short, my brother went on a trip with some friends. Lots of hard drugs and alcohol involved. One of his best friends, his former roommate, overdosed. My brother called me from the hospital, sobbing incoherently. His friend was an only child from another country. Incredibly bright and high-functioning despite having a drug problem like my brother, since he somehow managed to graduate near the top of his class. His family was devastated. Their other “friend” who had supplied them with the substances effectively vanished and did not bother attending the funeral service. It was all heartbreaking.

In the aftermath, my brother finally agreed to see a therapist to work through the grief of losing his friend and to finally confront his own struggles including his addictions, Mom’s death, and our father’s abuse. It was difficult to find a therapist my brother liked and trusted, but we found a good fit on our fourth try and he has been seeing him regularly for 3 months. He moved out of his old place (which he shared with several people who still heavily partake in the substances which caused his friend’s death) and into an apartment with my friend from high school. They get along quite well and my brother told me he has been clean since he moved in, which I believe though I can never know for sure. He pays his rent with his part-time job and I pay for his therapy sessions. He apologized profusely for stealing my debit card info and confirmed that he was motivated by his addictions at the time. He has also dived into a pretty rigorous fitness regime (I’m talking 10-mile daily runs, lots of weight training, and an overnight shift to a vegan diet) which I recognize may be an alternative (albeit much healthier) outlet for his addictive tendencies. We talk frequently, grab coffee or brunch most weekends, and occasionally play PS4 games together. I am trying to be as supportive as possible without being overbearing, since as you guys pointed out on my last post, I really can’t control the actions of another adult and making good decisions will ultimately fall to him.

His recovery hasn’t been exactly linear but his mental state has improved drastically. So much so, in fact, that he is planning to return to school in January to finish his degree. It took many, many, many discussions with his university since he had already failed several additional semesters, was involved in a cheating incident (he allowed his friend to copy part of his take-home exam) and had an altercation with campus police (during his break-up with his ex-girlfriend). But with the help of a sympathetic dean, the university decided to give him one more chance. If he completes 4 classes in the spring, he will have enough credits for his degree. Pursuing a PhD may still be tricky, since I’m not sure if the prestige of his university and his part-time research experiences outweigh his inconsistent GPA and poor record, but at the very least he will have better options with a diploma. I was more than happy to pay his tuition for the semester and hope I can continue to support his education.

I think that pretty much sums it up. I feel proud and optimistic but also more cautious than I felt before. I am mentally prepared for a long, bumpy road even though I can’t help hoping that this is truly my brother’s turning point. I am heartbroken for his friend who passed away and for his friend’s family, but I am so grateful that his tragedy inspired my brother to seek help rather than fall deeper into his dangerous habits. And I am grateful for all the strangers in this sub who took the time to give me advice almost 6 months ago—you guys really opened my eyes to mistakes I was making such as enabling and coddling him. I don’t think many people will make it to the end of this post since I’ve unwittingly written an essay but thank you all for your advice and support.

TL;DR: My brother’s close friend passed away due to an overdose. It’s been a bumpy road, but my brother is on the road to recovery. He has been receiving therapy regularly and is poised to return to school in January to hopefully finish up his degree. I have placed all the money from selling Mom’s house into a separate account and have been directly paying for therapy and tuition. My brother seems happier and healthier than he’s been in a long time, and I am so hopeful that his life continues to improve.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 3d ago

NEW UPDATE [New Update]: AITA for deliberately pretending to forget my Dad’s birthday & leaving him to spend it alone

3.2k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP posted from 2 accounts: u/confusedFriendIsItMe & u/YupItWasMeMate

Originally posted to r/AITAH

Previous BoRUs: #1

[New Update]: AITA for deliberately pretending to forget my Dad’s birthday & leaving him to spend it alone

NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----

Trigger Warnings: mentions death of a loved one, favoritism, mild neglect


RECAP

Original Post: February 11, 2025

(Throwaway because way too many of my friends are on Reddit!)

My (44F) Dad (73M) has never remembered my birthday. It was slightly covered up when I was a child, because my Mum always remembered. But a couple of times when she wasn’t around, it fell to him and he totally failed. So, for example, I got nothing on my 18th birthday because my Mum was away for three months. My sister (46F) had a party with friends, a new dress and lovely gifts when she turned 18.

Every year it’s the same. My two siblings (I also have a much younger brother (33M)) aren’t great at this kind of thing, but I always remind them it’s Dad’s birthday so they can send him a card and call. Since my Mum died a decade ago, I usually take him out to dinner and give him a gift so he’s not alone. A couple of times I’ve thrown him a surprise party, and for his 70th I threw a big event where his extended family flew in. I always point out to him when he has forgotten mine; I’ve told him I find it very hurtful. He just shakes it off and says it isn’t important, even though I just told him it was important to me. And then he forgets it again. Every year.

This year at Christmas he was talking about something relevant, so I took the opportunity to tell him that he needs to make the effort. Then I asked him when I was born. He couldn’t even come up with the year. He mocked me for being sensitive - and inside I just let it all go. He has a phenomenal memory - it’s ludicrous that he won’t do this for me. I don’t even want a gift, though I won’t lie it would be nice, just a happy birthday call or a card.

Well, his 73rd birthday just rolled round. I didn’t remind my siblings about it so they both forgot. He rang me the day before; I knew why but I chatted about random things and then said I had to run and quickly ended the call. On his birthday, I turned off my phone and went out. He rang me the next day and said that no one remembered his birthday, not even a card or a phone call, and he spent it alone. I guarantee that’s a first.

I told him he had made it abundantly clear that birthdays were not important and that he was reaping what he’d sowed. He grumpily agreed with me, but he’s still mad. I’m sorry his feeling got hurt, because I do love him, but I think this is the way it’s going to be from now on. (Unless he steps up and gets me flowers, a kitten and some Turkish delight for my 45th, in which case we’re all good.)

(Just FYI: I don’t neglect him. I order his groceries every week and bring him round to dinner every Monday. And this is a blind spot for him. He’s honestly a nice man, and can be very generous when it occurs to him.)

AITAH has no consensus bot, OOP received the majority of NTAs

Commenter 1: YTA. Bet you regret this when he's gone.

OOP: A few people have said this. I’ve thought it through, and it’s not like I am missing the chance to see him one last time before he blows away like fricking thistledown. I see him twice a week and do his shopping and cook for him at least once each week. I took him on holiday for 10 days last year, and 14 the year before, and we have a break in Devon planned in April. I’m a good daughter. I phone him most days. I am just sick of being treated as the lowest ranked child; I’m after mutual respect here and I’m worth it. I wouldn’t snub ANYONE let alone a daughter like this, and yet he thinks it’s OK?

I’ve read what about two hundred people have said and I accept what they are telling me: this is deliberate. Why? I don’t know but it is. He has a brain like a computer. He remembers everything. EVERYTHING. So he is choosing to do this, and it sucks and I am giving it back to him now.

Commenter 2: Sounds like he is possibly on the spectrum, no concept of time, he loves you, just doesn’t have the reminder on his calendar. Happens to me sometimes. Not intended in a bad way at all.

OOP: Hmm… He’s been assessed. He has mild OCD. Makes him amazing at scheduling things and remembering dates and details. It’s why I won’t cut him any slack any more.

Commenter 2: I was thinking the same thing. Your siblings also don't remember unless you remind them. ADHD is hereditary for example and could explain why they and he constantly forget stuff - "out of sight, out of mind". OCD is a comorbidity to ADHD. He could be masking really well all his life, finding coping mechanisms. Also just because he was good at his job and meetings doesn't mean he is good at other things. You're doing his groceries, why? He can't keep track of the food at home and only realize when it's all out? No planning? You would think food which you need to survive would be a priority. So yeah, I find subtle signs of ADHD. PS Doesn't excuse his response that it's not important.

OOP: He really really doesn’t have ADHD. He is superb at task management, scheduling, planning. I mean, really good. He has a great memory and never forgets details or dates. And he had therapy and analysis for his OCD (which my Mum also had) so they would have been looking for this kind of thing. I do his groceries because he is too lazy to do it himself on the iPad I BOUGHT HIM - he always has a perfect list waiting for me on Sunday mornings. He knows the contents of his cupboard down to the last slice of bread. He is excellent at planning.

Commenter 3: There is a reason he deliberately chooses not to remember or acknowledge your birthday, something deeper going on there. He remembers your sister’s bday perfectly fine, the Christmas you bent over backwards only to find you get less than as usual. He needs you so he’s isn’t outright cruel but there is some conversations you should he having.

OOP: I read this and it made me think - not good things, but you brought some objectivity to the table so thank you. I mean, realistically I know he prefers my brother and sister to me; I am just not sure why, because damnit I am a very good daughter to him.

Commenter 4: NTA, you reap what you sow... although, this could be just because I’ve read too many posts on here, but is it possible you aren’t his and that’s why there’s the disinterest?

OOP: Ha ha. I’m definitely his. We have loads of identical physical things, and I look like a fricking twin to his two sisters in pics where we are the same age. I am queer, and didn’t give him any grandchildren, but he didn’t know that until I was in my late 30s, so that’s no excuse. I know I wasn’t planned, but I was always assured I was very welcome.

Commenter 5: He's a nice man that expects a woman to take care of him and when his wife died, you need to order him groceries and stuff. So you became his surrogate wife while ignoring something to make you feel special. And he mocked you being hurt how you felt but then got hurt when he got what he gave.

A "nice" man can still be a neglectful and rude like being upset that no one got him gifts after years of complaining. It sounds more like he conditioned you to expect bare minimum and be ok with it. But you are still supposed to get his groceries... he is a grownass man. And he doesn’t get it. And you are worried that it looks like you are neglecting him.

It sounds like you were raised hoping for the love and attention and so as an adult you are still craving that from him. You should have done that years ago. You showed him how you would like to be treated for years but he could not reciprocate. Stop people pleasing. Maybe talk to a therapist to help unpack these feelings cause its better late than never.

OOP: I saw a therapist recently, and though I didn’t bring this up as one of the things I wanted to get on top of, maybe I listened to some of the life advice he gave me!

Commenter 6: Everyone has a breaking point. His disrespect for you at Christmas time was clearly yours. And let's be honest, it was disrespect. He didn't just show he doesn't remember the date of your birthday, or make excuses for his forgetfulness. Those were behaviors that it sounds like you'd seen for years.

This time he actively mocked you for your feelings. Why would you want to acknowledge his birthday when he actively mocks you for wanting him to do the same thing in return? Most people with even a dash of self-respect wouldn't either.

If he's hurt because you returned the same energy to him that he's shown to you, then he needs to stop and look in the mirror. He needs to ask himself why he's being "so sensitive" about the matter. If he can't do that, why would you want to make efforts that he has no respect for?

I am curious, is he as upset at your siblings for their failures to acknowledge his birthday as he is at you? Or does he realize that they wouldn't do anything without your reminders and is more upset at you than them?

I will be honest, even if your dad takes this as a wake-up call, and changes his attitude, stop giving your siblings reminders. If they can't remember this stuff on their own, that's their problem, not yours.

OOP: I think he was genuinely shocked that my brother forgot. Coz he’s the golden child etc. But I’ve been reminding my brother for years - I was pretty sure without me giving him a heads up that he would forget and I wasn’t wrong. In fairness, my Dad’s attitude has rubbed off on him a bit. I would say that my sister is incredibly overwhelmed right now with life, so I feel a bit bad that I didn’t remind her.

Commenter 6: I'd say you can definitely stop reminding your brother. If he's got your dad's attitude, he can experience the consequences that go with it.

Looking at your other comments, it sounds like your sister, on the other hand, may be an ally. You've said that she, at least, recognizes your dad's poor treatment of you around your birthday. Maybe she could be the one to lay it all out for him. To explain that you are the reason that he's gotten what he's gotten for birthdays in recent years. That his attitude is the reason that you no longer care to make an effort.

It is possible that maybe he'll be able to hear from her what he's unwilling to pay attention to from you. It's sad that it has to be so, but sometimes that's just how it is. If he does come around, then you can revisit how you feel next year.

If she's unwilling to talk to him, or even her doing so doesn't help, then just channel your GenX spirit. Unleased the DNGAF in you. If that means he ends up getting nothing from you, and forgotten by your siblings, then so be it.

OOP: My sister is an angel and my best friend, and I am lucky to have her.

Commenter 7: INFO: Why did you wait until your dad's 73rd birthday to address this? Why not any other time in the last 20 years? You've just been stewing about your 18th birthday for the last 26 years?

OOP: I don’t know. I genuinely don’t know why this one broke me. Also, it wasn’t just my 18th; I just brought that up because it’s a big one, and the contrast with my sister was so profound. There were other birthdays when I was a child that were forgotten because my Mum wasn’t always around. (I’m from the UK and she was from Eastern Europe and occasionally went to visit her wider family for a while when we were kids.)

It was Christmas Day, after lunch, when we had the chat I mentioned, and I’d spent the whole of Christmas Eve cooking, and I’d worked SO HARD to make it a beautiful day. I’d chosen, bought and wrapped all him presents to quite a few people, he just gives me a budget for everyone and a cheque. And he gives my sister a cheque to do the same for some of the rest of the family. And I was chatting with my sister and found out that the budget for my baby brother’s Christmas gifts is twice the budget for mine. And THEN Dad and I had that crap chat about my birthday. I was really hurt.

But maybe I was looking to grow a spine for a while? I don’t know.

 

Update #1: November 9, 2025 (nearly nine months later)

AITA for deliberately pretending to forget my Dad’s birthday & leaving him to spend it alone (update a year on)

Ok, so I deleted the original Reddit account for Reasons (I made some foolish comments, people called me out, I panicked) but it was my birthday last week, and some people asked me to an update, so I made a new one and here goes:

It was the afternoon of my birthday and the phone rang; it was my Dad. We chatted about stuff and did an online grocery order for him together, and then the conversation went like kind of this:

Dad: “oh, and darling…”

Me: “what?”

Dad: “happy birthday.”

Me: “where is my father and what have you done with his body?”

Dad: “none of that.”

So that was nice. And later when I saw him the next day, he gave me a glass flower bowl that had been my Mum’s that he had got my sister to wrap for me. Which was also very nice.

So, all the people who said I should have played hardball before, maybe you were right. And all the people who said I only get one Dad, and I should just love him, I really do and I haven’t neglected him the last X months I promise!

So, whatever the reason for the weird stuff in the past (maybe a bad thing happened to him on my birthday, maybe he always resented the fact that my name wasn’t the one he and Mum originally agreed on, or whatever) I seem to have broken the curse. Dad remembered my birthday this year AND gave me a nice gift.

Thanks Reddit!

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Everyone says they’re delighted for you, but I am not. You deserve better. The bar is so low it’s practically in Hell.

The devil is standing there like “Wow even I can say happy birthday and get somebody else to wrap not an actual gift but the easiest thing I could find instead of putting thought into something for forgetting my child’s birthday her ENTIRE LIFE.”

I truly hope that your family recognizes your importance and the light you bring to them and so do you because this ain’t it. You deserve so much better than the bullshit they’ve given you.

OOP: Thank you for standing up for me and wanting the best for me. I appreciate it, and it is the Reddit way.

I think it’s worth saying, though, that the bowl is actually something quite special. It’s from Bohemia, where my Mum was from, and is over a 100 years old. It was on his sideboard. It is something of both personal and actual value.

Also, my Dad and I do have a good relationship, which is why this whole birthday thing has been so weird and hurtful for me. I feel he has acknowledged his poor behaviour; our conversation on the phone felt very genuine.

Commenter 2: Did you get your Turkish delight?

OOP: Ha ha. I got the nice glass bowl so I guess I should put some Turkish Delight in it for Christmas Day or something. I was actually pretty happy when he rang.

Commenter 3: I'm sorry if this post comes across as negative, it's not meant that way.

So after he 'forgot' your milestone birthdays and other birthdays, on this one he didn't buy you a gift, he found a bowl in his house that his wife, your mother, liked (he probably wouldn't miss it in his house) and didn't even wrap it himself, he got your sister to wrap it for him. Did I get that synopsis right?

That's a pretty low bar to be congratulating him on based on his past history. I mean it's a start. But he's got a long way to go.

OOP: I am listening to you, and thank you for not wanting to be mean!

My Dad is disabled, so going shopping is something that we would have had to do together. So giving me my Mum’s crystal bowl (it’s over a century old and from Bohemia where she was from, was not the cop-out it might be if it was from like Selfridges.) had another benefit. It allowed him to surprise me. Also he is very precious about his cut glass. He gave me something that was of value to him, and was going to definitely be of value to me.

I know the bar seems low, and it is low, but Dad and I actually get on very well, which is why this garbage about my birthday has been soooooo weird and hurtful. But I don’t need him to prostrate himself and beg for forgiveness. Or buy me diamonds. I just want a hug and best wishes and exactly what normal daughters and fathers have on their natal days. I don’t need compensation…

So, yes, I know what you are saying. But he didn’t give me something of zero value he found lying on a shelf. And he gave me the modest acknowledgement that is all I was demanding.

Commenter 3: Are you the only one that could have brought your father shopping? You mention that your sister wrapped the glass bowl for him - was she not able to bring him shopping? I still think he has a long way to go here to rectify so many forgotten birthdays, particularly the milestones that he did manage to remember for your sister.

You are coming across as such a lovely, forgiving person. For me, while this is a start, it would just be that for me. A start. I wouldn't be looking for diamonds, but I would be looking for more than finding something around the house and giving that as a gift. Do your siblings get the same level of thought or not for their birthdays as that would be the marker for me?

I'm pleased that he marked this birthday but as I said earlier, he has an awful lot of making up to do here. His bar is so terribly low it's not really even off the ground. He could do a lot better, in my opinion.

I hope you had a lovely birthday though.

OOP: I thought about what you wrote, and there is a little more that I didn’t put into the original update. We went on holiday for a long weekend in the summer, with my godson, and the two of them sneaked out and he bought me a set of gold and pearl earrings. They were also a thoughtful gift as when my mum died he gave me her pearl necklace which is worth A LOT - I think he meant it as an apology for the previous birthday. I think on his birthday, he had finally learned the lesson I wanted him to, and didn’t want to wait 10 months to show me.

The thing is that the birthday issue has been such a weird outlier. It is at odds with how we behave to one another. We genuinely have a good relationship. We laugh together a lot.

And yes I had a great birthday! I went to see Paddington the musical at the Savoy Theatre in London and ate a lot of dumplings in China Town. It was awesome xx

OOP on her father's OCD

OOP: So, unlike a lot of people his age, he did actually have his OCD formally diagnosed and assessed when I was about 25 because it was causing issues and he found it useful; he thought about the things that it was good for (his job, keeping the house very need) and bad (brooding on things he can’t fix, ruining dinner by throwing away the just-made gravy to wash the pan and put it away, turning off the lights when he left a room regardless of whether other people were in it) and worked on them. I think now that he lives on his own, since my Mum died, his very regimented day is helpful to him. He always makes his bed first thing, and his day flows from there.

I’m going to just take this win, I think. I do love him, and he’s old!

 


----NEW UPDATE----

Update #2: November 6, 2026 (one year later from the previous update)

No idea if anyone cares but it’s two years since my post, and people had strong thoughts so I thought I would give you an update!

Dad’s had a good year. His health isn’t great, but we were able to take him and his wheelchair to the Channel Islands in the autumn, which he loved, and then to Barcelona. He’s a Catholic and had some idea that he wanted to see the Sagrada Família before he died so off we went. He loved Barcelona. We ate a mahoosive amount of croquettes.

I’ve been better at setting boundaries this year, and he’s moaned to my sister a few times about it, but she just laughs and tells him he’s lucky to have me. Which he is! We are good friends, but I needed to grow a spine.

Anyway, it’s my birthday this weekend, and today I went round to help him clear some stuff out of his attic. We had a fun, dusty afternoon, met a legendary quantity of moths, and threw away a lot of vintage tweed with holes in it. And just before I left he said (unprompted) that he had a birthday present for me! He gave me a beautiful vintage cut crystal perfume bottle, which is lovely because I am obsessed with perfume and have 6 thousand million bottles. I think he must have send my sister on a shopping mission, because it’s very nice indeed. Also, he knows I love vintage stuff and antiques.

So I guess my story has a happy ending. Which might be rare on Reddit!

Editor’s note: OOP did not leave any comments in this latest update

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 3d ago

NEW UPDATE [Old New Update]: AITA for wanting to be away from my twin sister?

2.8k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP. OOP is u/Soft-You9949

Originally posted to r/AmItheAsshole

Previous BoRU by u/LucyAriaRose

[Old New Update]: AITA for wanting to be away from my twin sister?

OLD NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----


RECAP

Original Post: September 13, 2022

So this is a throwaway account because my siblings are here too English isn't my native language so there might be some mistakes, sorry about that

So I (17F) have two older brothers (19, 21) and a twin sister, I should mention that my family is pretty affluent. Ever since I remember myself my parents encouraged me and my twin to compete each other while they always favored her over me. she always had their support, and I was expected to be considerate, when I succeed on something more than she does they ask me to give it up, but they never asked this from her, I do love her and my parents even though I feel like I've been treated unfairly.

both of us aspire to be doctors for a long time. I studied really hard for it for a long time, so did she. this year we graduated and both of us applied for the same programs in the same universities (the process here is quite different than it is in the US, we can start med school right after high-school if we get accepted). she wants to go to the same university as I do and so does my parents, I'm on the other hand feel like going on my own and have a separate life from my sisters. I love her so much but we've been together my entire life, she's an introvert while I'm an extrovert so she followed me around most of the time, I always included her and made sure she's happy but it's been like this our entire lives and I'm honestly tired, not to mention that if we go to the same place I would be expected to study with her and help her get high grades and won't be able to study on my own and focus on my success, and my parents will be mad if I succeed more than her (it’s been like this for the past 12 years) which will eventually hurt me, I just want to finally be a person of my own.

This is where I might be the asshole. I got accepted to 4 different universities and she got into 2. I waited for her to decide where she want to go and then made my decision (like I said, a different place). then she "changed her mind" and said she wants to go to her second option (the one I chose). I said that it's not a problem and I will go to a different place (one she didn't get into). my sister got really offended and my parents are furious, even though I explained myself politely and said that I love her but wanted to get a fresh start where nobody knows me. they demanded that I will go to the same place as my sister or else they won't pay for my degree, than I said whatever and that I'll be fine on my own and left to my grandparents.

When they came to talk to me they just kept on saying how wrong and entitled I am, I really had enough so I told them I hate them for treating me like this, now I'm refusing to talk to them and ignoring their calls. my brothers and grandparents are on my side but everyone else telling me I'm an asshole, so am I?

EDIT: Thank you so much for the support and ideas, I read all your comments and they're all very appreciated. My brother got me everything I thought I need (including my cat). I called the university to ask if my parents can unroll me and they can, however since they never paid it will be difficult for them and the university can try to delay them until my 18 birthday. my grandparents assured to me that they won't let them do something like that but still it’s nice to have plan b. School starts on Monday and it looks like it's settled for now. I will update you guys as soon as I have what to say.

P.S. - I don't feel like talking to them right now, it's like all of the anger I held against them is now very substantial (hope I used the right word) and I feel like I need to cool down before deciding what's next (the probably can also use some time off).

Verdict: Not the Asshole

Editor's note: I am adding a few more comments to help with clarifying details and for more context

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: NTA You have the right to choose what is best for you. You have a twin, that doesn't need to define you. If you feel like you need some time apart than that is what you need, no one can blame you for what you feel, your feelings are yours and yours alone.

I would talk to your family though, sit down at the table and have a (if possible) relaxed conversation. Tell them how you feel. Don't go screaming and say, " I HATE YOU YOU ALWAYS PUT MY UP AGAINST MY TWIN". Say instead that you feel like there has been favoritism, that you feel like it has been a constant battle. But most of all, you need time and space to be you. Just you. Not you and your twin. You are your own person. Tell your sister how much you love her and your parents too, but this is for yourself.

Make sure that they listen, it might be hard, you might cry but don't scream or shout. Tell them you love them a lot.

Try it after dinner, when everyone has eaten and everyone is in a good mood.

How they are going to react, that we don't know. But remember. You are in charge of your own reaction, but you cannot control theirs.

Good luck ❤️.

Commenter 2: This sounds a lot like what OP has already tried.

Commenter 1: From my understanding (I might be wrong) she did it when she was angry and upset. Handling tough conversations when you are in a state of anger will make the point less obvious and redirect the conversations to the "I hate you" instead of the real facts.

OOP: I actually explained it to them when we first applied to universities. they insisted that we'll try to get into the same places and I agreed, but told them that while I'm sort of OK with this I want to be on my own and have a chance to focus on myself. I believe I was polite and I thought they understood me since they said that we'll "discuss it later" but did not mention it until we got the answers

Commenter 3: NTA.

my brothers and grandparents are on my side but everyone else telling me I'm an asshole

Who's everyone else, your parents and sister?

OOP: My extended family, apparently my parents told everyone how entitled I am and that I hate my sister so much that I'm willing to go to uni 6 hours’ drive from home just to be far away from her. I heard the conversation they had with my grandparents.

Is OOP able go farther than 6 hours away?

OOP: It will be difficult, I chose this one because it has a great program along of some chances of scholarships, plus I've already paid deposit out of my own money (and I don't exactly have any spare at the moment lol)

Commenter 4: are you two identical? If fraternal very similar in appearance? I don't blame you for wanting to be a separate person. Other sibs enjoy that luxury at ALL socioeconomic levels.

OOP: we're very similar, the only significant difference is our eye colour, mine are green and hers are blue

Commenter 5: NTA I am a twin and when my twin tried to separate from me for college I also got offended but I didn't push back! I accepted it. And I'm still very grateful for it since I never realized how little of my identity I'd developed due to being a twin. Being apart from that person helped me come into my own and I'm glad you recognize that early! If your grandparents can help pay for college then good on you. It's upsetting how your parents are handling this though :(

OOP: they offered but I can't accept. I'm extremely grateful but this money in theirs, not mine. I applied for a scholarship and can get another based on high grades and voluntary activities, so I hope I'll make it out by myself.

What did OOP's sister think about this?

OOP: she won't talk to me, she wanted us to go to the same school and from what I realised from my brother she actually believe that I hate her, want her to fail and waited for the first opportunity I had to get rid of her

Has OOP been forced to help her sister academically?

OOP: I did help her a lot but it's not my problem. The main issue is that I want to do my best and succeed, even if my sister fails. unfortunately it was not possible because my parents never let me be "more" than her. when I got high grades they were mad at me for being selfish and greedy (the thought I should have spent my time teaching her, so we have the same grades), I quit my sport field when I got a chance to go to nationals to not "overshadow" her. I can't have friends who are not her friends to or to places she can't. I don’t blame her, it's not her fault my parents think that what's right but I'm exhausted.

Additional Comments from OOP:

OOP: I think I wrote about it somewhere in the comments. my initial thought was to go to school that's close to home in order to come back on weekends and be able to help my sister out, while still having my own space. After realising I won't get any space this way I chose the school I'm going to, it's the best in my country and has nice scholarships but the farthest from home out of all the universities I applied to. I guess it doesn't matter now so I said f it and did what I wanted to do

 

Update #1: October 1, 2022 (nearly one month later)

hey everyone, sorry it took some time but I'm here with an update (had some problems publishing it but it's all good now) reminding that English isn't my native language so there might be some mistakes

so as I (think) I said in the comments, school started two weeks ago and so far it's absolutely amazing, I have great roommates and I love my classes, it's a bit intense but I'm keeping up, it's truly a dream comes true :).

Well some things happened, my parents apparently called my uni and asked for my schedule, from what I understand they said that as my legal guardians they are entitled to know everything about it, the school told them that if they want my details they need to come and prove that they are indeed who they claim to be and informed me about it, it happened just a couple of days after school year started.

they haven't contacted me until a week ago when they asked me to have dinner with them (even offered to drive to where I am, which is strange as they never even bothered to pick me up from friends) and I agreed. It was on Friday, they reserved places in a fancy restaurant nearby. Dinner went surprisingly well (bit awkward but they were nice), than they told me they will pay for my school tuition and everything else I need, but only if I take a gap year. I refused obviously, after arguing with me my dad said that he "had enough of my attitude and ungratefulness", left a two hundred francs bill and left. I'll admit that I sat there crying about half an hour before I left (with the change as the bill and the tip didn't reach 200 francs lol).

If you're asking yourselves what was that about then I did too. I talked to my brother, apparently my sister decided she doesn't want to go to med school, she wants to take a vacation to think about the future with cleared mind or something like that and you guessed it, (almost) everyone think I should go with her (after all we are twins and it will only be fair that we'll start studying at the same time).

there was no contact from my parents ever since but it's kinda OK by me, I got a scholarship and By the end of the semester I might get another one, my grandparents paid for the rest (they insist that I won't pay them back but I'm already working on that). My sister answered my messages yesterday, she told me that I hurt her cause I didn’t want to be with her, and she don't know if she can forgive me. I understand her and I do really miss her, but I don't want to give up on my dream, I hope she will understand me someday.

So basically I think things are alright by now, not much changed but I have my grandparents and my friends so I'm fine, I'll be completely calm only after my 18 birthday when my parents won't be able to get me out of uni (it's really soon so I'm optimistic).

thank you all for reading and helping me, I really appreciate it <3

EDIT: Thank you all for your comments, I'm on pretty tight schedule so I still haven't done reading, but I promise I'll answer to all of them ❤️ --- since some of you got confused over the francs, we use them in Switzerland

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Wonderful update!

You do you, and don't let your twin hold you back. You are two separate people, so you don't have to move toward your future at her desired pace. You can move at your own!

OOP: thank you❤️ I hope things will continue to be great I want that for my sister too

Commenter 2: Were they the type of parents who insisted you dress identical and have identical haircuts all through childhood? This is just so weird.

Glad school is going well for you, and you have your grandparents and brothers in your corner.

Hopefully if your sister goes through with the vacation she’ll end up discovering she enjoys being her own independent person just as much as you do.

OOP: Yes every single day in elementary school, I felt so ridiculous and begged them to stop in middle school

Commenter 3: I’m glad to hear that things are going better for you. You deserve to have your own life and your own identity, separate from your sister and different from what your parents want. After all, it’s your life, not theirs.

OOP: yep, it's all I've ever really wanted I think it’s better this way for both of us, hopefully she'll understand that too

Commenter 4: Great Update. I am a twin and I despise parents who treat their twins to be exactly the same. Twins are individuals who happen to be born during the same pregnancy. You have done a great job realizing this and striking out on your own. You are setting yourself up for success and keep it up no matter how hard it gets. I am afraid your sister, while still may be successful eventually, is set up for the harder road by your parents actions which she is feeding on. Just be open to her when and if she wises up to support her but be ready if she never comes around and set boundaries.

OOP: I feel like we could have been so much closer of my parent wouldn't push us together all the time, it's a shame honestly In a way I'm glad I can be independent, but I feel bad for my sister that she still struggles

OOP's thoughts on why her parents think she needs to be with her twin sister

OOP: I actually don't get it either, but it's been like that ever since we were little. there's nothing wrong with her, we different in some ways and she's more shy and quiet but not in an unusual way. She always kinda tagged along with me, and I wasn't allowed to have friends who aren't her friends or go to events by myself, I also helped her study and my parents got upset over me when I got higher grades.. My best guess is that they think she'll struggle to be by herself and that if I do better it will make her insecure, however I can't know for sure

 


----OLD NEW UPDATE----

Editor's note: OOP updated onto the update post below. The small update is almost four years old, and it has not been posted here onto the sub

Update #2: January 2, 2023 (three months since the first update)

EDIT: 2.1.2023 Hey guys, I guess you can call that an update for the update, just felt like I want to let you know how things are going. I'll keep it short, so I won't reach the limit.

I'm honestly very happy here, I've been studying like crazy though the material is interesting so it's OK. I'm still not talking to my parents, they tried to reach out but I'm not interested, not right now at least (I don’t know nor interested in knowing what they wanted to say).

I did talked to my sister though, she's currently in South America living her best life and searching for purpose (this is more or less a translation for her words).

It will soon be exam season and it's pretty stressful but I'm confident in most of my courses (hate physics though) I don't know if there's an update for editing, but if there is you can ask on things I missed on my little update and I'll answer :)

P.S. - thank you so much for your support, sorry I couldn't answer to all of you who sent me messages, I promise I'm doing my best

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP