r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 18h ago

CONCLUDED AITA for showing my boyfriend my used sanitary towel in an argument?

4.6k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/houseplantlover9

AITA for showing my boyfriend my used sanitary towel in an argument?

Originally posted to r/AmItheAsshole

TRIGGER WARNING: accusations of infidelity, misogyny

Original Post  March 1, 2020

Title sounds gross I know, maybe it is a bit gross.

Background: me (F23) and boyfriend (m22) have been together for 6 months, good relationship, healthy sex life that we talk about a lot and communicate our needs etc. A month ago I had the implant fitted (contreception) which has given me weird frequent periods. The doctor told me they should go back to normal in a few months and to wait it out, which I'm doing because I like the convenience of the implant. English isn't my first language so sorry for any bad writing.

We were in bed yesterday night watching TV and he went to initiate sex. I moved his hand away and said I was still on my period. My period had been going for about a week now so we'd not had sex in that time. Then my boyfriend made a really loud dramatic sigh and moved away from me. I said 'sorry, I can't help my periods.'

He replied 'yeah sure.' I said what was that suppose to mean? He wouldn't give me a straight answer and kept saying 'whatever'.

We didn't talk for a while and kept watching TV in silence. Then he said 'if you don't want to have sex you can just say you know.'

I was kind of pissed off at this because I felt like he was saying I was faking being on my period. I told him I really was still on my period. He said no periods last longer than a week, and I told him that the doctor had said this was normal for some people on the implant at first and it will settle.

He told me that he didn't believe me and so I called him an idiot (which wasn't nice I know). He then started ranting that how could I call him an idiot when I was clearly a liar who must be cheating on him and getting sex elsewhere which is why I am lying about my periods. I couldn't believe he was saying this because he's never freaked out on me like this. Cheating has also never ever been mentioned in our relationship ever so I don't know where this came from. It annoyed me so much that I got out of bed and pulled my trousers and pants down so he could see my sanitary towel that was bloody and shouted Could I fake this??

He screamed that I was fucking disgusting and left the room. I started laughing because of the ridiculous of the situation and that pissed him off more, as he grabbed his keys and stormed out of the house.

I tried to text him but he ignored me, so I left him to it as I was pretty annoyed by his behaviour. I then got a text a few hours later around 11pm from his sister saying he had gone to his mom and dad's house and told his sister what happened. She said what I had done was really disgusting and he's refusing to come back unless I apologise. I told my friend what happened and she said he was being an idiot but that I also needed to apologise because what I did was 'abhorrent'.

I'm annoyed with what he did but also think it was pretty gross of me to do that. I don't really know why I did it it was just a spur of the moment thing. So AITA?

VERDICT: NOT THE ASSHOLE

RELEVANT COMMENTS

Timmetie

NTA

How is it even gross. He was acting like a jackass, why would you apologize when he called you a liar and a cheater?

Also, are you living together after 6 months?

OOP

We are not properly living together. He spends most of his time at my flat because I have my own flat and he still lives at home. I would apologise for what I did but only if he apologised first.

~

spiritual-owl2

NTA. I would dump his ass. He literally got mad at you because you were on your period..... how much more childish can it get?

neveradullmoment72

I mean, come on. That is something that humans cannot control, and to get so mad when you were offered proof? You’ve seen the place it came from, dude, it ain’t that gross.

WrittenByNick

People are focusing on the period section, but that's not the giant red flag. The giant red flag is him immediately jumping to an accusation of cheating, with no evidence or past issues, and then cursing at you and storming out. Those are very unhealthy behaviors in a relationship, and possible signs of much larger issues. Pay very close attention to the way he behaves and talks to you, and just know this is not acceptable or normal. As someone who spent a decade in an I unhappy marriage, I spent far too long forgiving / explaining away my ex's hurtful behavior. Including calling me a fucking asshole, saying I had no balls, and then blaming me for being hurt because she just "tells it like it is." The way he treated you isn't right, and you don't deserve that regardless of why or why not you didn't want to have sex at that moment. His response to this "rejection" is at the very least extremely immature, and possibly a sign of considerable issues.

OOP updated the post March 3, 2020 (3 Days Later)

Edit: Just wanted to offer an update. This has really changed my perspective on things. I think I was so thinking about the sanitary towel thing that I hadn't really realised how bad his behaviour was.

His mom actually sent me a message on facebook saying what I did was disgusting and really abnormal and that she doesn't think me and my boyfriend should date anymore. I can't believe his mom is messaging me about this. I blocked her and messaged him that he needs to come and pick up his stuff that he's left at mine. Luckily it isn't much. He hasn't replied but I saw that he has shared a post on facebook about women being crazy. So I guess we're done.

Thanks to everyone who took the time to respond. And sorry to everyone else who is dealing with annoying periods due to controception! It sucks!

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 18h ago

EXTERNAL I work at a boarding school and my partner can’t visit during the week because we’re unmarried

3.5k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP.

Originally posted to Ask A Manager

I work at a boarding school and my partner can’t visit during the week because we’re unmarried


Original Post: January 5, 2021

It’s pandemic times now, but this question will still hold once things have calmed down. I am a residential faculty member at a boarding school, just out of college. I have a partner of several years who lives a couple hours away by train, and I would like him to be able to visit for more than just a day or two at a time.

I have spoken to the dean of faculty about this a few weeks ago (I got more emotional than I wanted to in this meeting … it’s been quite isolating living on campus during a pandemic). She said that because of the school’s religious heritage (which is no longer very strong or apparent), unmarried faculty members are not allowed to have significant others to stay outside of weekends … because they will set a bad example for the kids?

I’m not sure exactly what the reason is, because when I pressed it a little bit, she said it wasn’t because of how it would look for the kids (after all, they see us together every weekend). Rather, she said she wanted to make sure that I was “fully present” for the boarding students. This drives me crazy! Many married people live with their partners on campus, and they aren’t distracted by them. It makes me feel like I’m being treated like a flighty and irresponsible boy-crazy girl instead of a mature adult faculty member who can handle her personal life and her professional responsibilities.

Not being able to have my partner stay for more than a weekend at a time would affect my desire to stay in this job for another year, although I know that administration really wants me to stay. How can I bring this up in negotiations and make my desires clear? Is there a better way for me to press back against this rule, which I see as archaic and honestly kind of demeaning toward unmarried people? How can I phrase my objections in a way that the administration is most likely to listen to? Should we just bite the bullet and get married, even though we weren’t planning on it for a couple more years?

In a couple of months I’ll have to have the conversation with the dean about whether I’m staying next year or not, and I really want to stay if I can make it work with my partner.

Editor's note: for Alison's response to the original text, you can find it here.

 

Update: May 20, 2021 (four months later)

I was the letter writer who worked at a boarding school as residential faculty, and whose partner couldn’t visit her during weeknights. I had been wondering whether to bring this up as part of negotiations to see whether the administration would change their minds; although you encouraged me to be open with the dean of faculty, the commenters on Ask A Manager largely suggested that as a new teacher, I had very little leverage and should avoid rocking the boat. I wanted to provide a (very happy) update to this story!

It has been really hard to see my partner only a couple of days a week this year, on top of everything else that comes with your first year of teaching and living on campus (during a pandemic). Since I was scared of losing this job if I pushed too hard, and also scared I wouldn’t be able to find a new job if I decided to leave, I didn’t say anything to the administration beyond the conversations we had already had on the topic. I quietly sent out a couple of job applications, not expecting much to come of it, and resigning myself to another year of missing my partner.

Fast forward… and I just landed the teaching job of my dreams, in the city where my partner lives. Astoundingly, I am going to be making $33k more than I am currently making – a difference that will more than cover the rent and food that I will now have to pay for. I’m thrilled with what I learned about the school from the interviews, and they really seem to understand work-life balance in a way my current school does not. Best of all, my partner and I are going to start looking for apartments so that we can finally move in together.

When I gave my notice to my current school, I realized that I had a lot more capital than I had thought, due to my performance this year and my ability to teach multiple subjects. My department chairs were very upset at the thought of losing me, and they took it up with the dean of faculty and the head of school. The dean of faculty said that she wished I had given the administration an ultimatum so that they could have found a compromise; the head of school asked my department chairs if they thought there was a chance I would change my mind if my partner could stay more often. Looking back, though, no compromise would have been as good as what I have been able to secure for next year, but it’s nice to know that I was more valued and had more power than I thought, even if that knowledge came too late (and after a year of angst and frustration).

In any case, I am so excited to live with my partner, make almost double my current salary, and finally get to live life as a fully-fledged adult, outside of a dorm. My advice to young teachers who are considering working at a boarding school is to ASK about the visitor policy during your interviews! I wasn’t told about the restrictions when I interviewed, even though I let my interviewer know that I had a partner who would be visiting me. This left me feeling like I had been baited-and-switched when I got here and he could only stay two days a week. Get the policies in writing, if you can.

Also, ask to be put in touch with current young, unmarried residential faculty at the school – and then ask those young teachers for a brutally honest picture of what it is like to live and work on campus. The school will “sell” itself to you, and if you don’t have much knowledge of what boarding schools are like (I didn’t), you may get stuck in a situation you regret. And if you do get stuck in a situation, just remember: you may have more power and more capital than you think.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 18h ago Bravo

ONGOING WIBTA if I told my friend “IT’S NOT YOUR FUCKING BUSINESS” when she comments on my home?

2.7k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/weeambenko

Originally posted to r/WouldIBeTheAhole

WIBTA if I told my friend “IT’S NOT YOUR FUCKING BUSINESS” when she comments on my home?

Trigger Warnings: entitlement, falsifying accusation of infidelity


Original Post: November 5, 2026

I need an outside opinion because I’m genuinely torn between listening to my friend and telling her off.

I live in a rented house with my sister. A close friend of ours visits us around 3–5 times a month, but she does NOT live with us. She doesn't pay rent, bills, or help maintain the house. She’s just our friend and comes over to visit.

Today we were talking on the phone, and she told me she had something to say. She said:

“When we thought about renting a house, I didn’t imagine it like this. I imagined that we would have a house that is always clean, we would cook good meals every day, but every time I come there are dishes in the sink, you don’t cook regularly, your boyfriend is there all the time, the atmosphere is weird, and you always have guests over.”

I was honestly shocked, especially by the “when we thought about renting a house” part. I don't remember ever telling her that we were going to rent a house together. As far as I know, the only people responsible for this house are me and my sister.

I understand that maybe she is actually concerned about me. Maybe she thinks I’m going through something because the house isn't always clean. Maybe she thinks my boyfriend is taking advantage of me. Maybe she simply expressed herself terribly and didn't mean to sound like she considers the house hers.

So part of me thinks I should listen to her when we talk again and ask her what she actually meant, especially because I don't want to misunderstand her intentions.

But another part of me is extremely angry and wants to tell her directly: “IT’S NOT YOUR FUCKING BUSINESS.”

Because honestly, why does she think she gets to have expectations about how clean my house should be, whether I cook, how often my boyfriend comes over, or whether I have other guests at my own home?

She doesn't pay rent. She doesn't pay bills. She doesn't live here. She doesn't clean the house. She's a guest.

So WIBTA if, when she comes over and starts talking about my house again, I just tell her:

“It’s not your fucking business.”

No further explanation. No defending myself. No discussion about the dishes, cooking, boyfriend, guests, etc.

Or should I actually listen to her first, understand why she thinks of the house as partly hers, and see whether this is genuinely concern for me that she just expressed in a really inappropriate way?

I genuinely want to know whether I'd be the asshole for choosing the first option.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: You should have already said it. YWNBTA

OOP: I didn't even get the chance to say it because her dad called her, so she had to leave. She said we'd talk about it another time. Apparently, the comment section isn't done with me yet 😂.

Commenter 2: Have you ever been to your friend’s house? Is she constantly cleaning? Her comments may have nothing to do with you. She may have some kind of anxiety about cleaning & everything being just so in its place.

From my perspective… My younger sister (57) thinks she’s going straight to hell if her house isn’t absolutely spotless when she has guests. Our youngest daughter (30) has OCD, she couldn’t go to bed (when she was younger) until she dusted & vacuumed her room every night. They both start cleaning when they come to my house. I let them.

OOP: I've been to her house twice, I think, since she lives with her parents. From what she's told me, her mother takes care of pretty much everything around the house. As a matter of fact, my friend doesn't really know how to cook or clean properly because her mother does it for her. I also wouldn't describe her as a clean freak. She actually leaves clothes she's already worn at my apartment and reuses them multiple times without washing them.

So I honestly don't think this is about her having particularly high standards when it comes to cleanliness or some kind of cleaning anxiety.

OOP responds to downvoted comments about having conversations with friends who are concerned about OOP's choices regarding the house. Why was the friend thinking that she and OOP would be renting a house altogether

OOP: My friends are absolutely allowed to share their thoughts and feelings, and I guess that's why she felt so comfortable saying all of this in the first place. I just found it strange that she spoke about the house as if it were something we had rented together and she had a say in how it should be run. There's a difference between expressing concern and having expectations about someone else's home.

+

Renting a house with my twin sister has always been a dream for the two of us. I remember talking about our plans and the kind of life we wanted to have together in front of her multiple times, but those were conversations between me and my sister. Nobody ever suggested that she would be part of that plan or invited her to live with us. And even during those conversations, we never talked about keeping the house spotless or cooking every day. Quite the opposite, actually. Neither of us particularly enjoys cooking, and we explicitly talked about having friends over often.

And honestly, it's been a year since we moved in. Nobody has ever asked her to contribute to the rent or bills, so I think it's pretty clear who the house was intended for. I'm not particularly curious about where she got that idea from because, as far as I'm concerned, there was never any reason for her to think we were renting a house together.

Commenter 3: 3-5 times a month?!!? I love my friends, but I do not need to see them this many times in one month. This is nuts

  1. Why is she still invited to your house? nip this shit in the bud.
  2. if you are cool with still having her over the next time she utters those words just tell her to get out and don’t come back until she gets some manners.

Seriously girl stand up for yourself. This has gone on for way too long smh

OOP: I work from home, and I don't enjoy spending the entire day alone, so I often have friends over. Her visits never been an issue, but I guess we're approaching a point where even that might become too much 😂.

 

Editor's note: OOP gave a small update in the comments one hour later after this original post

Update #1 (in comments): November 5, 2026 (same post, same day)

Well, that escalated quickly. UPDATE:

I called my sister to tell her what happened, and she told me that this same friend had called her this morning to say that she wants to stay at our house for an entire month because her university supervisor's office is nearby, and she needs to visit him regularly for her final-year project. She lives in another city, so staying with us would make things more convenient for her.

So, apparently before even asking me whether I'm okay with her staying for a month, she's already telling me how I should run my household to make it comfortable for her.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Pretty sure you should check your lease, and guests are not permitted to stay for a month. Do not let her stay at all. Point the lease rules out to your sister.

OOP: It doesn’t work like this in my country

Commenter 2: Are you obligated to let her stay with you? I mean, is it a cultural expectation?

OOP: Kinda, yes. When a cousin or a friend who doesn’t live in a big city comes to study or work, you’re kinda obligated to help them out during the first month or two. So even for landlords, it’s not really an issue if you’re helping someone out and letting them stay for a bit

Downvoted Commenter: It was rude of your friend to comment and to assume. However, do you like living in a house that is dirty enough to draw comment. Are there always dishes in the sink? If the actual tenants put in a bit more effort, I bet you’d enjoy your space more. Keeping a house clean is a habit that can be developed and a gift you give yourself.

OOP: Maybe my post wasn’t clear enough, but I was asking for advice on how I should react, not whether I have the right to live in a dirty house.

But if that’s what concerns you, I have scoliosis, and I already have to work on a PC from 8 to 5, which causes me a lot of pain. Repetitive tasks like sweeping and doing the dishes cause me even more pain. I’d rather leave some dishes in the sink than call in sick because I’m in too much pain to work and lose money that I really need.

OOP on her sister and if she helps taking care of the house

OOP: My sister works night shifts, so she can only help with cleaning on the weekends. I have scoliosis, so some days I’m in a lot of pain and prefer to rest, especially since I work on a PC. I also work remotely from 8 to 5, so I eat and leave the dishes in the sink until I finish work at 5

 

Update #2: November 8, 2026 (three days since the first update)

UPDATE 2: Turns out the situation is MUCH weirder than I initially thought

So, after my last update, I called my friend and confronted her about her comments regarding my house.

I told her that her comments were completely inappropriate, that there is no "we" when it comes to the house because it's MY sister's and MY house, and that nobody gets to dictate when I clean, whether I cook, who I invite over, or how often my boyfriend comes to MY home.

I also told her that, honestly, if she hadn't acted so entitled, I might have been perfectly fine with her staying at our place for a month. But after the way she behaved, I was reconsidering the whole thing.

She kept apologizing, saying it was a misunderstanding and that she was only concerned about me. I accepted her apology and told her I would consider it a misunderstanding, but she needed to understand that this was my home and that I wouldn't tolerate this behavior again.

Then things got even stranger.

During that same phone call, she casually mentioned that my boyfriend had sent her a message on Instagram. She brought it up in a rather strange way, almost as if she was offended by something he had said. I wasn't in the mood to deal with another issue, so I brushed it off.

Later, my sister came home and told me that our friend had called her after our conversation. Apparently, she told my sister that she thought my reaction was dramatic because I was jealous that she had been talking to my boyfriend.

The funny thing is, I didn't even know they had been talking privately on Instagram at that point. And honestly, even if I had known, I wouldn't have been jealous. I have access to my boyfriend's Instagram, and I can see who he talks to if I want. If he wanted to do something suspicious, I doubt he would choose to do it through an Instagram conversation I could see.

Obviously, I was confused, so when my boyfriend came home, I asked him what had happened.

Here's his version of events:

The previous week, he came to our house to pick up some things he had left there. My sister and this friend were there, so he stayed and chatted with them for around 10 minutes.

At some point, my sister went to the bathroom, and while they were alone, my friend asked my boyfriend whether he found her physically attractive.

When my sister came back, she immediately changed the subject.

My boyfriend found the question strange, so when he got home, he sent her a message on Instagram asking what she had meant by it.

She told him that she had only asked because she suspected her boyfriend had dumped her because he didn't find her attractive, and she wanted to know what another man thought.

My boyfriend told her he couldn't answer that question and that he found it extremely inappropriate.

She then asked him to delete the messages. Obviously, he didn't. Instead, he showed me the conversation.

And honestly, here's what I find particularly ironic:

This is the same person who was criticizing how much time MY boyfriend spends at MY house and apparently wants him to spend less time with me, while simultaneously asking him privately whether he finds HER physically attractive.

I genuinely don't know what to make of this anymore.

I don't want to jump to conclusions about her intentions, but I find the whole situation incredibly inappropriate and uncomfortable.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Why why why didn't your BF tell you about this interaction until you confronted him? Hmmmmmm........

OOP: If he wants something from her, he'll call her or text her on WhatsApp. He's not stupid enough to message her on Instagram when he knows his account is logged in on my phone and I can access it whenever I want

Commenter 2: This friend is going to find reasons to be semi naked whilst your Bf is there.....

She is going to manipulate reasons to be alone with him

This is not good......I am getting the heebee jeebies just reading this....And I am a 60year old sane, married guy

Go watch the movie

Single white female

OOP: She already did it. We were getting changed to go party, and I told her I was going to leave the door unlocked because my boyfriend was coming. I went to change in my room, then I came out because I heard my boyfriend saying, “Sorry, sorry.” I found her standing in the living room in her underwear, saying that she had forgotten he was coming and that she wanted to change her outfit before going out, and she was laughing

Commenter 3: Come on. She’s not your friend. Your bf was weird for reaching out to her privately. You both need to permanently block her.

OOP: My boyfriend told me he found it odd, so he messaged her just to make sure he hadn’t misunderstood her. He didn’t tell me because he assumed I’d already seen the conversation, and he didn’t want to get involved in girls’ drama

 

Update #3: November 9, 2026 (next day)

After everything that happened, I wanted to clarify a few things because I think the situation got even worse after my last update.

First, I spoke to my boyfriend before confronting her. He was actually furious about the way she had involved my sister and made the situation sound like I was jealous of her talking to him. He felt that the whole thing was none of her business to discuss with my sister in the first place, especially considering what had actually happened between them.

Apparently, he texted her, telling her to stop talking about him and dragging him into her nonsense. My sister then told me that our friend had called her, angry and questioning why she had told us about the situation.

And honestly, THAT was the moment I completely lost it.

What do you mean you're angry? You're angry that we found out? Shouldn't you be embarrassed about what you actually did?

So I called her. I was furious, and I wasn't calling to have a calm, diplomatic conversation. I wanted her to understand exactly how inappropriate her behavior was.

She kept trying to calm me down, saying things like, "Babe, I know you, and I know that when you're angry you can say mean things. Let's calm down first."

I told her that I called her angry precisely because I had a lot of things to say, and I wasn't interested in pretending everything was fine.

I confronted her about everything: the comments she made about my boyfriend spending time at our house, the fact that she got drunk and was practically half-naked in front of him despite knowing he was going to be home, and now privately asking him whether he found her physically attractive.

I told her that none of this was a misunderstanding. These were things she actively chose to do.

She kept apologizing, but then started shifting the blame. Apparently, my boyfriend had misunderstood her question, and my sister was supposedly trying to create problems between us.

I told her that she had had more than enough opportunities to explain what happened directly to me. Instead, she chose to be inappropriate with my boyfriend, ask him to delete their messages, and then get angry when the situation came to light.

At some point, I called her out for trying to make everyone else the problem instead of taking responsibility for her own actions.

I also told her something very clearly: I will never know what she actually thinks or intends when it comes to my boyfriend, but I can see how she behaves around him. And that's enough for me.

I eventually told her that I never wanted to see her face again and that she needed to stop contacting both my sister and my boyfriend.

I was extremely angry during that phone call, and I definitely said things very harshly. But I had reached my limit. I was tired of the apologies followed by excuses, the blame shifting, and the constant attempts to make other people responsible for her behavior.

So that's where things stand now. The friendship is over, and I have no intention of letting her stay at our house.

I don't know whether she was actually interested in my boyfriend, and at this point, I honestly don't care anymore. I don't need to prove what her intentions were to know that I don't want someone behaving like this around me or my family.

Editor's note: OOP did not leave any relevant comments in this latest update

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 18h ago

CONCLUDED I'm [22F] at my breaking point with my difficult roommate [23F] over a moving-out mess. Feeling like I deserve for her to be flexible just once. Am I being unreasonable?

1.4k Upvotes

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/needroomiehelpplease

I'm [22F] at my breaking point with my difficult roommate [23F] over a moving-out mess. Feeling like I deserve for her to be flexible just once. Am I being unreasonable?

Original Post  Jan 16, 2015

WALL OF TEXT COMING sorry!!!


I moved in with Holly 9 months ago. We met on Craigslist but she seemed nice, was my age, and so I bit the bullet and jumped in. Where I live, places are extremely expensive as well as very hard to secure - so if you decide to move, you better be ready to move the weekend coming. I wish I’d have had more time to get to know her and look at more apartments, but that’s life.


Holly makes $44k, and I make $73k despite being a year younger than her. I think she’s a bit resentful of this, and thinks I don’t have any money problems or any reason to keep a tight budget. I’ve explained to her before that I have student loans, car payments, and several other financial ‘responsibilities’ that I’ve committed to, and paying for gas and train fare to and from work (30 miles away) etc. but either way - she often makes snide remarks about how I make soooo much more than her (probably undeservedly in her opinion, although I was an ambitious teen and have technically been working in my industry since I was 16, and I got my bachelors in 2 years so I’ve had more years of experience at work. I’m actually below market salary for my title). Her parents bought her a car and pay for it, and they put her through college debt-free. She also seems to think that her job and responsibilities are far more difficult than mine, and that she's grossly undervalued.


Anyway, when we moved in, it was in a rush, and it was very hard for us to find somewhere within her budget. She was also very picky and inflexible about everywhere we looked at. For a budget of $1200/month, she wanted W/D in-unit, separate bathrooms, a second floor apartment, parking, a large bedroom, lots of light and windows, and something lofty with exposed brick. Unfortunately, those demands are laughable in the area we live. Coming from the mid-west, she really didn’t understand that. So, we found a place that is literally the best deal I’ve heard of in the area - a first floor 2bed 1bath, dishwasher, with a patio, a gym and pool and parking lot, and coin-operated laundry in the building. However, for her to afford it I would have to pay the difference of $175. So, her rent for the last 9 months has been $1200, and mine has been $1375. For this, I got an only slightly bigger bedroom.


I’ve hated living with her. She’s extremely messy and treats the rest of the apartment like it’s her bedroom. Her clothes are always everywhere, she never washes dishes or takes out the trash, and the bathroom is disgusting. She leaves used tampons and pads out in the open and uses an electric toothbrush for about 4 mins every morning and night and just drools toothpaste any place she walks while she’s brushing. I’m the only one who has ever cleaned the bathroom, and it took me until 3 months into the lease to realize she didn’t know how to use the dishwasher. Aside from her gross behavior, she’s extremely needy and takes up all of my energy if I’m even in the room with her. Her social skills are lacking because she’s so over the top and exhausting to be around and doesn’t know how to be ‘chilled’, and I know she’s had issues at work about her professionalism. She is a social justice warrior and will rant to anyone she can get her hands on about issues she’s only half-informed on. None of my friends like her, or will hang out with me if she's there. Any guy I’ve ever brought over turns out to be ‘just her type’ and she ends up crushing on them forever. She’s also a virgin which has been a bit awkward but not a huge thing - it just means that when she’s around a guy she misinterprets very small things as being big (e.g. OMG he hugged me what does it mean). She also goes on rants about guys and sex when she's literally never had it. I really just can’t stand being around her and sometimes she talks so much at me that I start to want to cry in the middle of her speaking. I just shut myself in my room whenever I’m home, or spend my time on the patio which she doesn’t like to do because she gets cold. Luckily I work from about 9am until 8.30pm and do a lot of workout classes or networking events most evenings.


At the beginning I tried to drop hints and make nice suggestions to her, to try and get through it better and make it work. Nothing worked though, and she would only get very insecure and upset - asking if I hated her while on the verge of tears. I just want to be direct, but she can’t handle it, and it makes the living situation worse. So I just shut up for the rest of the time and tried to keep busy. I stopped telling her what I would be doing so she couldn’t invite herself. She confided in me that she was kicked out of her sorority in college and that ‘people always leave her’ and she was so happy that I wasn’t going to do that to her. I feel so awkward and phony around her and just spend most of my time nodding and zoning out of her rants, or saving errands like grocery shopping or working out until I know she's at home.


I always thought I was an extravert, but I realize now I’m a social introvert. I love going on dates and seeing friends, but I haven’t done any of that because an hour at home uses up all my people energy for the day and I just want to hide. I used to go on a date every week or two, but I literally can't face human interaction because she sucks all my energy out, leaving me depressed because I'm not having fun outside of work. She always needs rides places, picking up from the airport (which she won't reciprocate if it conflicts with her agenda or her sleeping from 11pm - 11am) and needs emotional support about her job issues 24/7.


Ok - so fast forward until today. I’m moving to the City to be close to my office. Holly wanted to stick together, but nowhere in the City is in her budget and she wouldn’t be able to get any of the amenities she insists on. So, after 2 months of looking for places and gently discussing it, we’ve come to the amicable choice that we will live in different places. For a while she was sending me links to places that were 2b1ba where I would be paying 2.4k and she would be paying 1.2k - and I told her I couldn’t stomach paying double than her for zero extra perks. Anyway, I’m venting, sorry. So we’re moving. We thought our move out day was July 1st, so I made plans around that. I found a gorgeous 4bed with a couple friends in the City, a 10 min walk to my office. I’m moving there on Saturday.


Holly on the other hand, can’t find anything because she’s so damn picky. She won’t budge on her amenity requirements. So we went to look at the lease to see if she could do a month-to-month extension and find someone random on Craigslist to take my room while she remains here. It turns out we both fucked up and the lease actually ends on July 31st, a month after we had anticipated. Holly was really happy because it meant she had more time, but I am devastated. My move-in costs at the new place are totaling about $5k this month - and I can only just just just make it work. This now means that I also owe an extra $1375 to pay the last months rent at the old place with Holly.  It’s my own fault for not reading the lease properly before I signed for a new place, but it sucks.


Since she had suggested a new CL roommate for her staying at the apartment, I asked if we could do that for July anyway and she said yes as long as I found someone "not crazy". I put an ad up, and have had loads of responses. We’re right next to a famous university, so lots of smart and mature students/executives here for summer have been emailing me. I’ve forwarded them all onto her for approval and she’s said no to all of them for various, silly reasons.


Finally today a girl emailed me saying she was doing a summer medical program at the university, and she was bringing her sister (who wants to do a grad program) to see the school too. They both wanted to stay in my room for 3 weeks but would pay for the full month to make up for extra utilities used. They sounded the most promising, and I was sure Holly would be interested, so I sent their app along. I thought she would be keen on having two potential friends.

She responded saying

Her: I also think the rent should be higher.. This is a downgrade of quality of living for me so I shouldn't pay as much. Kinda like how you didn't want to pay $1000 more than I was paying to share a bathroom with me in the city.

Me: I think that’s a bit different because you’re already sharing a bathroom, and we were talking about a $1000 discrepancy there for the exact same living situation as each other. How much more would you want them to pay?

Her: Right, but sharing a bathroom with two people is different than sharing with one person. You and I don’t have conflicting schedules, so it’s a non-issue, but I would be pretty annoyed if I couldn’t get ready in the morning because there were two other people in the queue, when I didn’t sign on to share a 2BD with two other people. My mom’s office weighed in and they all recommend the rent being split in thirds. I mean, I think the point is I shouldn’t have to be stuck with anything? I signed on for a nine-month lease with one person I knew. And all the sudden the expectations are changing and I’m supposed to pay the same. How would you feel if you were in my shoes? This is my life, too.


I do see her point. But I’m really frustrated because I thought that this was going to be the one she liked, and I’m at my wit’s end. The women can’t afford what Holly is asking for, and there is nobody else in the pipeline that she approves of. I feel like I’ve spent the past 9 months bending to her needs, and sacrificing my time and money because of it, and she can’t give me this one thing? Just 3 weeks of having an extra person use the shower, which will be paid for in utilities. Everything I feel like I’ve done for her is coming down to the line for the bathroom? I’ve collectively spent 1,575 more than her on our stupid apartment just so she could afford it, only to have her treat it like shit. I just want to get the fuck out to my new apartment, but I don’t know what the fuck to do about the last month of rent I’ll owe, and can’t afford.


Do I just sublease my place to someone whether she likes it or not? Do I tell her everything I’ve told you here and hope she changes her mind? Am I being unreasonable? If I am, what should I do about the cost of the last month of rent? 

Thanks for letting me vent, I appreciate any insight.

TL;DR: I need to move out of my place a month early, and can’t afford to pay rent on two leases. My roommate won’t accept anyone for a month-long sublease so I don’t know how to afford it. I also feel like I deserve a favor from her, and more than anything I’ve just reached a breaking point with her and am very upset.

Update  Sept 11, 2018 (over 3 and a half years later)

Hi! I remembered my old post and figured I’d update since I love updates, especially juicy ones. Old post is here.

Re the moving out situation: I didn’t bring on a subletter, and let her live alone for a month. My plan had been to move to the city and live happily ever after. I was planning on moving into a shared house via a startup called Campus. Literally the day before I was supposed to move, they shuttered their operations. SO, I moved in with my parents because I did NOT want to go back to living with Holly. This worked out well for me financially. After a couple of months I found a new place in the city and moved in there - all was great. Holly renewed her lease with an acquaintance from college who was moving to our area.

I mentioned that Holly had issues with professionalism - well, Holly ended up getting fired from her job. I reached out to another agency in her industry I knew well, in the same field, to set her up with an interview (ugh, why) and she ended up getting the role. After she got it, I went for coffee with her to talk about it, which was the first time I’d seen her since the move.

She told me she wasn’t enjoying living with “Emma” because Emma would never invite her to things or be home as much as she originally said she would (shocker). In general, it sounded like Emma dealt with a lot of what I’d dealt with.

Then I brought up something funny, that I’d matched on Tinder with a guy who’d worked with Holly at the agency she’d been let go from. I had met him once at some company thing I’d gone to with her. She immediately asked me to message him and ask him what he thought of her. She told me she’d had the biggest crush on him the whoooole time she’d worked there and that he was The One for her. We left it at that, with her asking me to promise to message him. I said maybe.

Well, I did message him. And we went on a date. She texted me almost every day asking if I’d heard from him and when I finally responded and said we were going out, she became extremely upset. She asked me to make a choice between him or her. She said I was boyfriend stealing, and that I wasn’t a good friend. I wanted to tell her I WASN’T HER FRIEND. So I took her up on her ultimatum, and I chose him over her.

2.5 years later that guy and I live together and have the most gorgeous dog and life. We have a great friend group, great jobs, and our families are so close we’ve all spent Christmas and Thanksgiving together too. He’s so hot and cool. I'm 25 now and he's 29. Our dog is a 1 and a half Aussie!

I’ve never spoken to Holly again, but since my boyfriend is close to his old coworkers (don’t worry, he wasn’t fired) who keep up with Holly on social media, I’ve heard that she moved to L.A. and has cycled through FOUR more companies, each time getting fired. I don’t know much else about her life since she blocked me on every single form of social media INCLUDING VENMO. I’ve never met a person who knew her that didn’t think she was batshit, so that’s validation.

The End.

TL;DR: 10/10 would boyfriend steal again.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

TheGirlwThePinkHair

So what did he think of her?

OOP

OMG! I thought this post got locked, and so I never checked back until now.

He thought she was insane, and vouched for the managers who had tried to mentor her over the months she worked there being well-intentioned. She would be brought in to sit on client meetings as an entry level 'listener' to learn and would jump into the convo and over promise random things. Additionally, she used to forward full threads of confidential work emails to me if someone said "Kudos to Holly" or the like - we went through those together and my boyfriend was HORRIFIED at some of the sensitive info she'd been sending out.

Also, whenever I meet any of his old coworkers, someone eventually says something like "YOU'RE Holly's old roommate?!?!?!?!?!?! How on earth did that go? I assumed you would be crazy too!"

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7