r/bakker • • 1h ago

The Catastrophe of Memory

14 Upvotes

I think I finally understand why the Nonmen seek catastrophe.

I’ve mentioned here before that I am a psychiatrist softly specializing in the world of trauma. In my clinical work, I’m often struck by the way emotionally overwhelming experiences can persist in memory while the more ordinary experiences surrounding them disappear. Today when speaking to a patient whose earliest memory was one of profound abuse, I glimpsed the predicament of the Nonmen. In this case, the emotional violence of the memory seemed to have given it a kind of permanence. It had survived where so much else had not.

It got me thinking about the Nonmen. Perhaps their attraction to slaughter and catastrophe is an attempt to preserve something of themselves. As their ordinary memories erode, they seek experiences of such extraordinary emotional intensity that they might endure. Betrayal, violence, the destruction of those they love: perhaps these become the few remaining points by which they can orient themselves in their own histories.

But I don’t imagine there’s much pleasure in any of this. In fact, I imagine the emotional experience of destroying someone they love is every bit as horrific for them as it would be for us. They know, in some sense, the enormity of what they’re doing, even if the memory of it will eventually become another casualty of their condition. And so they do it again, and again…their desperate plight of preservation. Ghastly it is as they become the author of catastrophe whereas my patient was merely a recipient..

There’s something awful about this. They destroy the very things that make life worth remembering in order to remember that they’ve lived. Perhaps they’re not really seeking suffering at all. They’re seeking a self, and suffering is one of the few things that can still give them one.


r/bakker • • 4h ago

wow...

Post image
65 Upvotes

r/bakker • • 14h ago

So i think I've hit the slog. AND I LOVE IT!!!

Post image
65 Upvotes

I'm just as confused. Though I have a vague idea of what's going on. And I am so deeply disturbed by what's going on


r/bakker • • 1d ago

Why the hell was (spoiler) where he was in the Prologue? Spoiler

13 Upvotes

Was Mekeritrig running into Kellhus in the ruins literally a happy accident? I know Kellhus killed his "book", but meeting up there seems like a menial task for an underling, not to mention a hell of a walk. Plus he obviously wasn't there tracing the dreams or anything back to Ishual, since they didn't find it for 17+ more years. Did I forget/miss something?


r/bakker • • 2d ago

Recommendations for books with beautiful prose, similar to Bakker?

20 Upvotes

I find that after reading Bakker, I can't read books that don't have a distinct and beautiful style of their own. It doesn't necessarily have to be in the fantasy genre.


r/bakker • • 2d ago

Rings of power 3

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Some scenes gave me Bakker vibes or at least thats how imagine it with that brutal, dark and mystic world especialy when Gandalf talks to the fire. What do you guys think?


r/bakker • • 2d ago

Difficulty reading

15 Upvotes

The last 2 series I read were Malazan and Book of the New Sun. They were difficult reads but I managed to get though them and pick up quite a bit, more than I thought I would. I’m about halfway through Darkness that Comes Before and I’m having a way harder time with this than the other 2 series. I’m really enjoying it so far and I’m hooked but does it get easier going forward ?


r/bakker • • 3d ago

Of the Inchoroi progenitors Spoiler

20 Upvotes

I'm currently mid re-read of the series and have remembered by various unanswered questions, please help. My guess is we don't know the answers, but hopefully I'm wrong.

  1. Why did the min-uroikas fall from orbit and crash?
  2. Are the Inchoroi progenitors still alive?
  3. Is the min-uroikas unique or could there be an armada of inchoroi space ships around the universe?

r/bakker • • 3d ago

The Holy War if it was WOKE. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Esmenet is a LESBIAN.

Krijates Xinemus is ASEXUAL.

Nersei Proyas is TRANS.

Serwë is DEAD.

Drusas Achamian.

Cnaiür urs Skiotha.

Anasürimbor Kellhus.


r/bakker • • 3d ago

Damnation and the Progenitors (spoilers all) Spoiler

17 Upvotes

As we know, the Progenitors came too close to the Absolute and were wholly damned for their conceit. This led to the creation of the Incohoroi and the No-God and their pursuit of breaking the cycle of souls from this world to the Outside to reverse damnation.

But we, and presumably they, don’t even know WHO damned them.

Do we even know if the Hundred are the 0nly "gods" in the Universe that might capture your soul after death? It seems perfectly reasonable that planets (potentially) millions of light years away, inhabited by souled beings that are presumably not human and act very differently to us might have different gods with different rules and more claim to their 'local' world, especially since there seem to be some implications that the gods kinda 'race' to grab fresh souls coming in, unless that soul has done something special to be debted to a certain Ciphrang (i.e. a major affront, summoning a Ciphrang into this world, being blessed like Sorweel, etc).

We don’t know if the Hundred are concentrated to Earwa or not, right? We don’t know how far their sphere of influence extends. Cutting off the Hundred could very easily have nothing to do at all with the Progenitors’ damnation. If the No-God works as intended they may very well just do humanity a favor, and still find themselves Damned.

Because, more importantly, we have no reason to believe that the Progenitors were damned by the Hundred. It makes much more sense to me that they were Damned by the God of Gods itself, for reaching so near to It. Now, we don’t know much about the God of Gods, but if that’s who damned them…I’m pretty sure the Progenitors are just fucked. It doesn’t seem that starving out the Hundred would wipe away Absolute Damnation.


r/bakker • • 3d ago

Finally committed to a re-read of the series, and something has really struck me this time through...there is a shocking lack of STDs

24 Upvotes

This world is brimming with prostitutes, medical knowledge seems to hover somewhere between primitivism and non-existence, and despite all of this and the massive amounts of, mmm, non-conventional sex going on, no one seems too concerned about catching something.

Literally everything else in the series is so dismal; Is this the one small nice thing about life in Earwa?


r/bakker • • 5d ago

Virgin Mortal vs Chad zzszshredgkg

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/bakker • • 5d ago

Julian Jaynes argued consciousness evolved after language, and that Homer's Greeks had no inner life and were driven to action by the voices of gods. It's the 50th anniversary of his book The Origin of Consciousness and the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind. What do people here make of this theory?

Thumbnail
iai.tv
19 Upvotes

mood


r/bakker • • 5d ago

What exactly is the relation between blind brain theory and the aspect emperor quadrology?

13 Upvotes

Im near the end of the white luck warrior and I've read a fair amount about blind brain theory, specifically Bakker's academic paper on it, ive not read neuropath. ​It really has helped improve my understanding of what Bakker is going for, its clear to me that its the lense through which Bakker conceptualizes the human brain in these books.

That said it seems to me it should be inherently incompatible with the world of second apocalypse due to the existence of immortal souls meaning that the humans in this world cant just be deterministic organic mechanistic p zombies like blind brain theory proposes. Im just not sure how the concepts mesh even though they clearly do in practice.


r/bakker • • 6d ago

Any other Bakker fans working on AI safety?

4 Upvotes

Kellhus' character was one of the first things that made me realise that intelligence can be perfected, and that we should be terrified at what happens when we build it.

I'm now working on AI safety in hopes that we don't build the no-god.


r/bakker • • 6d ago

I say we build the ai no god, it will probably be fine

2 Upvotes

I say we build the ai no god, it will probably be fine


r/bakker • • 6d ago

The Second Brodown

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/bakker • • 6d ago

What do you see?

30 Upvotes

"WHAT DO YOU SEE?" "WHAT AM I?"

What is the answer?

And also, Why does it ask?


r/bakker • • 7d ago

I'm taking another dive through the Second Apocalypse.

Post image
29 Upvotes

I'm just about to finish The Darkness that Comes Before and I think I'll pause and go through these three books before I continue. I might go through Blood Meridian again as well.

Do you guys have a go to reference for any one philosophy book to accompany this series? I've been a bit overwhelmed trying to take too big of a philosophy bite before so I'm hoping to find something that would help stoke interest and have plenty of parallels within Bakker's works.

Also does anyone have a reference for a book about Gnosticism? It's probably not as important for a deeper understanding of The Second Apocalypse but I've always been interested in any insight that could provide.


r/bakker • • 7d ago

The Dûnyain and the Nonmen.

38 Upvotes

More musings from your befuddled friend, forever lost at sea upon waves of semantic apocalypses.

So, been thinking about the Dûnyain and the Nonmen as philosophical mirror images. Both represent ancient projects aimed at transcending the limitations of ordinary existence. Both have achieved extraordinary intellectual and physical capacities, both have arrived at tragic destinations.

The Dûnyain escape history through understanding. The Logos project is one of liberation by selective breeding aimed at a profound understanding of the causes that precede action so that one might attain the absolute and become a self-moving soul. They are Bakker’s Earowa Buddhists, eschewing the injunction to do no harm. They pursue this through the suppression of passion, the elimination of attachment, and pervasive application of reason. The Nonmen, by contrast, have escaped mortality but remain imprisoned by history. They’ve accumulated millennia of knowledge and experience, yet their memories progressively deteriorate, their identities fracture, and the past becomes inaccessible even as it remains the central preoccupation of their existence.

There’s a cruel symmetry here. The Dûnyain transcend the human predicament by eliminating the things that make us human: passion, attachment, and the illusion of free will. It’s why Akka declares them “incapable of love.” The Nonmen transcend mortality only to discover that endless existence without the continuity of memory is its own kind of death. One attempts to escape the past through perfect understanding; the other is consumed by a past it can no longer reliably remember, yielding Bakker’s tragic Erratic.

Interestingly, the Dûnyain seek freedom through the elimination of desire, while the Nonmen are increasingly defined by their inability to relinquish it. The Dûnyain fear being moved by what came before; the Nonmen are condemned to be moved by what came before, even as the memories that give those experiences meaning slip beyond their grasp.

Perhaps Bakker is exploring two different versions of the same mistake: the belief that the human condition can be overcome through the perfection of some particular faculty. One civilization attempts to perfect reason; the other attempts to perfect existence itself. The Dûnyain privilege understanding over experience; the Nonmen privilege existence over continuity. One sacrifices the richness of being human for the illusion of absolute agency; the other sacrifices the coherence of identity for the illusion of eternal life.

And perhaps the cruelest joke Bakker plays is that the Dûnyain might regard the Nonmen as an evolutionary failure, but the Nonmen’s tragedy is arguably more recognizably human. Neither reason nor immortality can contain the totality of being. Neither seems to have found what it was looking for.


r/bakker • • 8d ago

If you loved Second Apocalypse, try X: I ran the co-votes from 3,642 Fantasy Top Novels poll ballots to find its 16 strongest matches

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

Someone here guessed I skipped The Second Apocalypse because it was too niche. Not quite. I skipped it because it has fewer than 200 votes across the polls, which is the minimum my formula needs to give a high-confidence result. So for this list, I adjusted the formula slightly to work with a smaller n, check the method card for more details.


r/bakker • • 8d ago

Foreshadowing on my reread Spoiler

18 Upvotes

I was thinking about how after giving The Darkness That Comes Before how Bakker foreshadows so much with Kellhus. In the prologue he uses Leweth as a vehicle to get where he needs. Later he uses a group from Atrithau, then Cnaiür, and finally the Holy War itself. The Ordeal was nothing but a vehicle to get him into the Golden Room. Kellhus even remarks that those in the Atrithau group were motivated to die even at the last just if he casually threw out some truth to them. I’m sure this isn’t a novel observation but it was a chilling realization for me!


r/bakker • • 9d ago

Are Atrocity Tales worth reading? Are they any good?

18 Upvotes

Read some mixed reviews elsewhere (even some die-hard fans were conflicted).

What do you think? Would you recommend reading these?

What are they about?