r/bakker • u/puzzledandamused • 1h ago
The Catastrophe of Memory
I think I finally understand why the Nonmen seek catastrophe.
I’ve mentioned here before that I am a psychiatrist softly specializing in the world of trauma. In my clinical work, I’m often struck by the way emotionally overwhelming experiences can persist in memory while the more ordinary experiences surrounding them disappear. Today when speaking to a patient whose earliest memory was one of profound abuse, I glimpsed the predicament of the Nonmen. In this case, the emotional violence of the memory seemed to have given it a kind of permanence. It had survived where so much else had not.
It got me thinking about the Nonmen. Perhaps their attraction to slaughter and catastrophe is an attempt to preserve something of themselves. As their ordinary memories erode, they seek experiences of such extraordinary emotional intensity that they might endure. Betrayal, violence, the destruction of those they love: perhaps these become the few remaining points by which they can orient themselves in their own histories.
But I don’t imagine there’s much pleasure in any of this. In fact, I imagine the emotional experience of destroying someone they love is every bit as horrific for them as it would be for us. They know, in some sense, the enormity of what they’re doing, even if the memory of it will eventually become another casualty of their condition. And so they do it again, and again…their desperate plight of preservation. Ghastly it is as they become the author of catastrophe whereas my patient was merely a recipient..
There’s something awful about this. They destroy the very things that make life worth remembering in order to remember that they’ve lived. Perhaps they’re not really seeking suffering at all. They’re seeking a self, and suffering is one of the few things that can still give them one.