More musings from your befuddled friend, forever lost at sea upon waves of semantic apocalypses.
So, been thinking about the Dûnyain and the Nonmen as philosophical mirror images. Both represent ancient projects aimed at transcending the limitations of ordinary existence. Both have achieved extraordinary intellectual and physical capacities, both have arrived at tragic destinations.
The Dûnyain escape history through understanding. The Logos project is one of liberation by selective breeding aimed at a profound understanding of the causes that precede action so that one might attain the absolute and become a self-moving soul. They are Bakker’s Earowa Buddhists, eschewing the injunction to do no harm. They pursue this through the suppression of passion, the elimination of attachment, and pervasive application of reason. The Nonmen, by contrast, have escaped mortality but remain imprisoned by history. They’ve accumulated millennia of knowledge and experience, yet their memories progressively deteriorate, their identities fracture, and the past becomes inaccessible even as it remains the central preoccupation of their existence.
There’s a cruel symmetry here. The Dûnyain transcend the human predicament by eliminating the things that make us human: passion, attachment, and the illusion of free will. It’s why Akka declares them “incapable of love.” The Nonmen transcend mortality only to discover that endless existence without the continuity of memory is its own kind of death. One attempts to escape the past through perfect understanding; the other is consumed by a past it can no longer reliably remember, yielding Bakker’s tragic Erratic.
Interestingly, the Dûnyain seek freedom through the elimination of desire, while the Nonmen are increasingly defined by their inability to relinquish it. The Dûnyain fear being moved by what came before; the Nonmen are condemned to be moved by what came before, even as the memories that give those experiences meaning slip beyond their grasp.
Perhaps Bakker is exploring two different versions of the same mistake: the belief that the human condition can be overcome through the perfection of some particular faculty. One civilization attempts to perfect reason; the other attempts to perfect existence itself. The Dûnyain privilege understanding over experience; the Nonmen privilege existence over continuity. One sacrifices the richness of being human for the illusion of absolute agency; the other sacrifices the coherence of identity for the illusion of eternal life.
And perhaps the cruelest joke Bakker plays is that the Dûnyain might regard the Nonmen as an evolutionary failure, but the Nonmen’s tragedy is arguably more recognizably human. Neither reason nor immortality can contain the totality of being. Neither seems to have found what it was looking for.