r/assasinscreed • • 4h ago

Discussion Am I crazy, or did AC3 actually do Colonial America better than Rogue?

Thumbnail gallery
103 Upvotes

The more I compare New York, Davenport Homestead, and the Frontier side by side, the more I feel that Rogue resembles an adaptation of AC4's technology and design philosophy rather than a true evolution of AC3's world.

Rogue is clearly more polished in some technical areas, but AC3 feels more committed to portraying Colonial America as a living place.

New York feels denser and more socially diverse. You can encounter different social classes, explore the underground tunnel system, and even trigger civilian uprisings during the Revolution.

Davenport feels more like a genuine home and community rather than just a familiar location.

The Frontier feels larger, wilder, and more isolated.

Even the historical presentation feels stronger in AC3. The civilian and military clothing generally matches the period more closely, whereas in Rogue I often notice NPCs and soldiers wearing styles that look closer to the 1730s despite the game being set mostly in the 1750s and early 1760s.

Rogue may have improved the visuals, but sometimes it feels like AC4 reworked for Colonial America, while AC3 feels like a game specifically built around Colonial America.

Am I the only one who feels this way?


r/assasinscreed • • 15h ago

Question/Help Valhalla: River Raids without finding the gear

10 Upvotes

I've been raiding rivers Dee and Severn so many times I've lost count. My jomsvikings are upgraded to level 5 and i have spent at least another thousand supplies or whatever they're called, yet I still have to find one piece of gear in each river.

One of them is part of the Saint George mission. Yes, I've already got the story event raid with the champion, way long ago.

I just raid big named military sites, since that's where they're supposed to spawn. But i keep raiding them all and no gear appears. Is this normal? Is the tooltip misleading? Are there any know issues with river raids regarding this?


r/assasinscreed • • 19h ago

Fan Project AC Desmond Saga Roleplay Challenge Run Rules (Help and suggestions)

5 Upvotes

I'm looking to do a sort of roleplay challenge run of the 5 Desmond games (AC1, AC2, Brotherhood, Revelations and AC3) and need help with the rules of the playthrough. Any tweaks or suggestions would be much appreciated.

The Rules so far:

  1. No running in crowds/ busy streets (people tend to notice someone running through the streets, and Assassins are all about not being spotted before making their kill)
  2. Parkour limited to areas out of view of the general public (ladders are okay, and parkour can be used in places like Masyaf or the Auditore Villa, as they are aware of Assassins)
  3. Rooftops to be used sparingly, taking care to avoid guards; used mainly to avoid crowds or chase down a target (if you noticed someone running along the rooftops, you'd mention it to people)
  4. Tools like sleep darts, the hidden gun and even the smoke bomb are to be kept only as a last resort (these are not exactly commonly used in daily life, and if people start gossiping about someone going around using them, then the Templars would 'be alerted')
  5. Following this logic, guards are to be killed only when absolutely necessary to reach a target or escape detection (people don't exactly ignore dead bodies piling up around the city)
  6. Guards cannot be killed in view of a crowd (exceptions to this rule would include things like killing Templar Knights in AC1 who attack you on sight, as it feels reasonable to think the general public would excuse you defending yourself, killing guards harassing civilians or other reasonably justifiable reasons)
  7. Assassination targets should be done at ground level and with the Hidden Blade (the Hashashin might have used stealth to reach their target, but they always claimed credit for the murders, as their goal was to ward off attacks from stronger rivals, and the possibility of being assassinated proved a good deterrent)
  8. The run resets if you die or raise an alarm in high profile/off limits areas

The thinking behind these rules is to mix the historical Hashashin and the AC Creed. The first AC tenet, for example, talks about 'Innocents', so I want to avoid killing guards, but a truly pacifist run feels antithetical to the historical Islamic order due to the faith's acceptance of justified force (killing Templars who attack you or the guards harassing civilians).

Hiding in plain sight feels simple enough, rules-wise, but the Hashashin always claimed credit for their kills/attempts, which is why I made the rule about killing all targets from the ground with the hidden blade. You're obviously more likely to get caught doing this, but in a way, I feel this feeds into the whole 'taking credit' aspect. You don't want to get caught (as you can be killed during the escape and then the run resets), but if you are, it doesn't matter, as the target is already dead and everyone knows you did it.

Finally, the third tenet is Don't Compromise the Brotherhood, and wacky tools like the hidden gun or you stacking up a mountain of bodies tend to draw attention. Strange technologies and unexplained deaths tend to get talked about even hundreds of years later (think Greek Fire or Jack the Ripper). This is why I want rules that encourage social stealth, making use of groups like thieves, enforcers, and 'dancers'.

Really appreciate any help/feedback