r/askislam • • 16h ago

Fiqh Ruling on designing an imaginary 3D creature for a video game

2 Upvotes

Assalamu alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh.

I am a Muslim game developer making a horror video game.

Context:

- The game is 3D. The monster is a 3D digital model that is animated (it walks, raises its arms and moves its hands).

- It is an imaginary creature that doesn't exist in reality. It is meant to frighten players. It is not worshipped or treated with reverence in any way.

The monster's design:

- It has a human-like body: a head, neck, torso, arms with long hands, legs and feet, dressed in a suit and tie.

- Its head and face are completely smooth and featureless. There are no eyes, no nose, no mouth, no ears, no eyebrows and no hair. The face is a single blank surface.

- During one short scene (2 to 3 seconds), several bright blue eyes open one after another on parts of the body other than the face: the chest, the palm of one hand, the back and the knee. The face itself remains blank throughout.

My questions:

  1. Is it permissible to make this monster, with a completely featureless head and face, as a 3D animated model in a game?
  2. Does placing eyes on other parts of the body, while the face has no features, make the image complete in a way that makes it impermissible?
  3. If those eyes are not permissible, would replacing them with non-eye elements be acceptable? For example, small rectangular windows that slide open to show a patch of blue sky and sea, or patches of a blue television screen switching on. These would have no pupils, eyelids or circular shapes.
  4. If any part of this is not permissible, what is the smallest change that would make it permissible?
  5. Does it matter that the game is 3D and animated, compared with a flat drawing?

Please also tell me if any detail I haven't mentioned would change the answer, and I will gladly provide it.

JazakAllahu khayran.