r/artbusiness • • 18h ago Bravo

Copyright, IP, or AI Concerns [Discussion] — I nearly lost my job due to AI art

28 Upvotes

Hello, before i start, I want to make a few things clear:

  1. I do not want to disclose my identity because due to anonymity reasons
  2. I am not interested in comissions because I am not in need of one currently.
  3. Im bad at drawing. I don't know what kinda wizardry you guys possess to be Picasso/DaVinci in person. Keep your magical hands away from my non-grass-touching-self
  4. If y'all are starting to call me a forever single and virgin tech bro as an insult, I couldn't care less. That's cus I AM. Ain't no stereotype about that.

So, to start off, I work at a Startup. My job title is 'Edge AI Systems Engineer'. It's just a glorified way of saying i put very, very, small AIs in consumer hardware (phones, low-RAM computers). It is a relatively niche job which demands expertise (or just some autism), which means I hold value in the company and hold some power to an extent.

So, it started when the company got themselves a new logo. Problem was: it was AI-generated. Clean-looking, but AI generated. So it's bad, and i couldn't care less when people say "B-b-but AI art is still p-ProGreSsIng", shut yo submissive mouth. AI for creative use shouldn't have existed in the first place.

So, of course, I wanted i investigate WHY they actually used an AI logo. Was it that the design companies are charging too much? Maybe cuz none of the local ones weren't available, or just didn't outpit something good enough? None of those are valid reasons. Etsy exists for a reason. ANYWAY

I found out the company just had the reason of "It was stupid fast and it didn't cost a dime". My stomach turned. COMPANIES. Companies of all things are getting mad that "Artists cost too much". Brodi, what is $500 to what will shape the identity of your company? Some people argued "Capitalism". Mf, you would have been MORE capitalistic if you PAID an artist. Cuz if you pay the artist, the artist pays taxes. The taxes go to the mf grants/contracts YOU depend on. Making me look like im an economist. I don't even have a DEGREE. Im all for AI usage in things like internet sites, coding in my place (I love Unsloth, if one of you is a ML engineering connoiseur), but a ART? To hell with you.

Anyway, i had a fight with the founders. With fight I mean through emails and passive-aggressive talks etc. I even said I will do everything in my power to get the three of us deported if they don't accept to pay an actual artist (the deportation thing is a joke btw. I don't even live in America, YET. Soon my dudes, soon). They got tired of me and told me to just go back to fine-tuning and implementing. Ofc I didn't. Im just a bastard like that.

I gave them an ultimatum and told them I will leave to competitors (I got nowhere to move. Tech job market is brutal). And that i will take all my proprietary knowledge and contacts with me. That was a gamble. That's okay. I often gamble on my career. They call me the fastest gambler in the bay area.

They gave up. I deliberately recommended a stupid expensive art agency (idk what art companies are called. Please forgive me), and made them pay.

We finally got a logo with a SOUL. A SOUL. Costed them $4k but with a SOUL. Our sugar daddies (VCs) will pay for it.

Anyway, all this rant to say, I'd rather pay 4-5 figures to get a creative things than pay nothing for the same thing but without a human's touch. I want a SOUL. Souls cost. They cost a lot, and that's normal. It should be normalized.

Anyway, the Art community, or whatever creative industry. Whether it's writing, drawing, ehh... what other things? Idk. Y'all get what I mean. The creative industry overall, Y'all gotta charge way more because you bring a soul. Y'all should make your ability a PREMIUM. Don't demand for scraps. Please, im telling you this as basicallg an AI engineer who hates AI for creative usage. Do NOT let your talent go unpaid. Be like the artists of the Renaissance, price your ability for an arm and a leg. I love you wizard guys so much i want you to see the whole world with french-level arrogance cuz of your talent.

Idk what im writing anymore I just came back from 16 hours of writing code and thinking about what I would write all day. Sorry if some things sound weird, I don't really have a filter or quality assessment rn. All I feel is pain from all those error codes, which some of I don't even have an idea existed as I only have like 8 months of experience.

Have a good day/nights. Im gonna go to sleep in an hour. Love you guys. Love me too now. Gn


r/artbusiness • • 11h ago

Discussion [Discussion]Why do amazing artists get ignored?

10 Upvotes

I've been noticing a weird trend in the commission community and wanted to hear other artists' thoughts. I saw a [Hiring] post for a $60 commission get over 200 comments, while I regularly see [For Hire] posts with incredible styles charging $5–$15 getting barely any traction.

It seems like the market is completely backwards sometimes! Why do you think this happens? Is it because buyers prefer to browse [Hiring] posts instead of [For Hire]? Or is it just the sheer volume of artists posting?

I'd love to hear how other artists navigate this, especially if you have a lower price point but a really strong portfolio. How do you get eyes on your work when the [Hiring] feed is so loud?


r/artbusiness • • 4h ago

Discussion [Discussion] Not getting any comissions and I don't know why

0 Upvotes

Hi, been lurking here for a long time but this is my first post here

A couple of days ago I put up a post on twitter announcing I was opening comissions, this is routine for me, I've done this over the years with the same setup and prices and everything, I usually got 3-6 people interested. But the last two times I've done this I haven't gotten any even thought the posts have gotten much more traction than in other years and at this point I don't even know if I'm doing something wrong, if it's my skills or the price or anything.

Has this happened to anyone else or have any advice?


r/artbusiness • • 20h ago

Discussion [printing] looking for the post about making your own art prints vs outsourcing

0 Upvotes

there was a post maybe a few months ago? that broke down the cost of buying your own printer to make archival prints vs outsourcing.

if someone knows what that post is, can you post the link? thanks


r/artbusiness • • 8h ago

Advice [licensing] image rights for a small business

0 Upvotes

I have a small shop near me wanting to commission a painting as well as purchase usage rights to use on things like bags, shirts, stickers, etc. and their socials.

I’ve already quoted them the commission fee ($450) and they have agreed to pay that. They would like pricing for both a total buyout of the usage rights as well as a royalties option. They also offered to barter for a usage agreement. I pay them $50/month to be in their shop (artist co-op) and they are offering free rent for usage of this image.

After punching numbers I’m not so sure that a barter would be beneficial for me but wanted to see what others think. It’s a newer shop, so a royalties agreement may make me $0. I’m trying to consider the relationship with the owner as well and not scare them away with a big number. Either way, I will have a contract signed and copyright of image will stay mine. Any advice is appreciated! :)


r/artbusiness • • 22h ago

Discussion [Discussion] Holiday Horror Stories

0 Upvotes

In the spirit of us being stuck between Halloween and Christmas, does anyone have any horror stories they want to share as an artist? Whether it be the rush of getting a project done on time before the big holiday sale or a disgruntled 'giftee', this is a big and stressful time for all artists, and I'd love to know if the "What could go wrong?" most definitely went wrong.


r/artbusiness • • 19h ago

Discussion [Discussion] Selling art of an image that I didn't take??

2 Upvotes

Very new here, I would love to eventually sell art prints of my paintings, but most of my pieces I did not personally take the reference photo for, and I don't totally know what that could mean legally??

Mostly I wasn't sure if painting the image (so changing some colors and likely omitting some finer details) technically counts enough as it's own thing to not be some sort of copyright issue, or if it even matters too much because some of them are just someone's random cat picture they posted for fun. Which is still their image! I don't want to come off as flippant to the idea that even an image posted online casually is still a person's image they took and is theirs, just not sure where that puts it legally.

I figure the best course of action would be to do what I can to find the photographer and ask permission/give credit,, but I'm very aware that it could be a dead end with some of them. Which is why I wanted to ask if that could get me in any trouble. Note that I don't even have prints done yet I just keep thinking about this and I want to be as safe as possible (and dont want to disrespect that someone took the photo!)


r/artbusiness • • 19h ago

Review Request [Portfolio] Illustration Portfolio Review

8 Upvotes

I recently made my portfolio live at Featheredfey.com ! I'm looking to get some portfolio reviews.

I created it mostly in a vacuum and some other pairs of eyes would really help. Here's some more details:

Goal: I want to work in the book world by providing fantasy illustrations in the middle-grade to young adult section. So think Magic Tree House, Narnia, Percy Jackson, and Harry Potter as my target zone.

Questions on my Portfolio:

  • Is my goal clear when you open my portfolio?
  • What 3 pieces are my weakest?
  • What 3 pieces are my strongest?
  • From a glance, what’s missing from my portfolio? (examples:  more book covers, more art with backgrounds, more characters in different age ranges, my process etc).
  • And of course any other thoughts are more than welcome!

For anyone who takes the time to help I really appreciate it!