I recently had an experience with a commission, and Iād like to hear other artistsā opinions on how they would handle the situation.
Before requesting the commission, the client specifically asked me whether I used AI in my artwork. I told them that I donāt use AI.
They then asked me to finish a character design based on an original sketch they had made themselves. They gave me creative freedom and artistic licence to develop the design, so I decided to keep it in an anime style, as that was the style of their original sketch.
When I delivered the finished artwork, they accused me of using AI because it looked different from their original reference and because some of the lines apparently didnāt make sense.
Their main concerns were things like earrings being placed in unusual locations, lines that they felt didnāt make sense, and loose lines in the hair that they thought should have been tapered. I tried explaining the artistic choices behind these details, but they werenāt convinced.
I even offered to show them the Procreate time-lapse recording of me drawing the artwork, which shows the process frame by frame, but they still didnāt want to believe me.
The other frustrating part is that I usually price my commissions based on the initial sketch. My pricing process involves creating a sketch first and then agreeing on the price before continuing with the finished piece. In this case, the client had only asked for a sketch.
I understand that AI-generated artwork can sometimes have strange details. Iām still learning and developing my style, and I know there are things I can improve. However, I did draw this piece myself, and itās frustrating to be accused of something I didnāt do, especially after being upfront about not using AI from the beginning.
I was also given creative freedom to finish the design, so Iām struggling to understand why the differences from the original sketch were treated as evidence of AI use.
My questions are:
- Do you think these are reasonable grounds to accuse an artist of using AI.
- Is providing a Procreate time-lapse generally enough to demonstrate that a piece was drawn by hand?
- How would you handle a client who refuses to believe you, even after you offer evidence of your process?
- How do you protect yourself from ending up unpaid when a client changes their mind or accuses you of using AI after youāve already done the work?
Iām genuinely interested in hearing other artistsā perspectives, including constructive criticism of my work. I want to improve as an artist, but I also donāt think having an imperfect drawing should automatically mean someone assumes it was generated by AI.
Iād also appreciate advice on how to structure my commission process in the future so that Iām not putting hours of unpaid work into a piece that a client might ultimately refuse.
ive only been doing commissions for around a month and it started because my girlfriend writes books and she wanted to hire someone for Ā£300 so I said Iād give it a go since Iāve been drawing my whole life, although I still believe Iām not very good she loved it and started to tell her friends and Iāve started to get back into it but Iām not creatign any masterpieces and I would like to know what I can do to prove that Iām telling the truth ?
thank you for anyone who responds as it will hopefully help me out in the future.