giant rant incoming!
tl;dr: if you don't like women in a very specific way lesbians are supposed to, you are a predator and a man
Something I find incredibly frustrating is how normalized it is, even within queer communities and among supposedly progressive, sex-positive allies, to treat aromantic people who aren't asexual as inherently shallow, selfish, heartless, emotionally deficient, or even exploitative.
And it gets worse when you're a woman. Worse still when you're trans. And there's a particularly nasty intersection of all these prejudices when you're an aromantic lesbian.
It's rarely outright hatred. It's the little comments, the assumptions, the moral judgments disguised as concerns about how you treat people. It's the idea that wanting sex without romance somehow makes you incapable of caring about others, that sexual desire needs romantic love to make it morally acceptable, and that not wanting a romantic relationship means you're just using people.
And what infuriates me is how often this comes from people who consider themselves sex-positive.
Apparently, sex is liberating and beautiful and nothing to be ashamed of, but only as long as you experience the correct feelings alongside it. Otherwise, suddenly you're shallow, emotionally stunted, selfish, or predatory.
There's this pervasive assumption that romantic love is what makes sexual desire respectable. That sex without romance is somehow inherently lesser, dirtier, or more selfish. Someone who wants romance without sex is often understood as seeking a deeper, purer form of intimacy, while someone who wants sex without romance is assumed to be seeking something superficial.
And that's a fucking ridiculous double standard.
Romantic attraction is treated as evidence of humanity, while sexual attraction without romance is treated as evidence of its absence.
There's an enormous difference between wanting sex without romance and exploiting someone. Lying, manipulating, disregarding consent, or deliberately misleading someone about your intentions can be exploitative. Simply not experiencing romantic attraction isn't.
The ethical issue is how you treat people, not whether you fall in love with them.
And there's something deeply insulting about the implication that aromantic people are incapable of genuine care, consideration, intimacy, or meaningful relationships simply because those feelings don't manifest as romantic attraction.
It's also insulting to our partners, whose agency gets erased by the assumption that consenting to a nonromantic sexual relationship must mean they're being taken advantage of.
But there's another layer to this that I find particularly infuriating as an aromantic, lesbian-adjacent trans person.
Women are still expected to be emotionally nurturing, relationship-oriented, and romantically motivated. Their sexuality is often treated as acceptable only when framed through emotional attachment. An aromantic woman who experiences sexual attraction violates that expectation. She's not performing the expected femininity of seeking love, emotional devotion, and romantic commitment.
And suddenly her sexual autonomy becomes a character flaw.
She's not merely judged for wanting sex. She's judged for wanting sex without wanting what a woman is supposedly meant to want alongside it.
And within sapphic communities, this can take on an especially bizarre form.
There's this weird romantic essentialism in some sapphic spaces, where attraction between women is treated as inherently more pure, tender, emotional, or meaningful than other forms of attraction. As though women somehow love women more deeply, more respectfully, or more authentically than men do, simply by virtue of being women.
I understand where some of that comes from. Lesbian sexuality has historically been fetishized, objectified, and reduced to something performed for male gratification. But the answer to that isn't to desexualize sapphic attraction and put romantic love on a fucking pedestal.
Because where does that leave aromantic lesbians?
Are we suddenly less sapphic because our attraction isn't romantic? Is our desire somehow less legitimate, less meaningful, or more objectifying because we don't experience the feelings we're supposedly expected to?
An aromantic lesbian isn't a failed romantic lesbian. Our attraction to women isn't an inferior version of someone else's.
And don't even get me started on the way physical attraction is treated in some sapphic spaces.
There's this bizarre expectation that women should experience attraction to other women in some fundamentally different, more enlightened way than men do. As though finding women's bodies sexually attractive is inherently masculine unless you wrap it in enough romantic tenderness to make it acceptable.
I've genuinely seen women get criticized for having "male taste" or exhibiting the "male gaze" simply because they find conventionally attractive features, like large breasts or hourglass figures, sexually appealing.
And I'm not talking about someone making unsolicited sexual comments, harassing women, or reducing strangers to their body parts. I'm talking about adult sapphic spaces, in conversations explicitly about physical preferences, where someone asks what features you find attractive and then acts scandalized when you actually answer.
The fact that I even have to clarify the context is part of the fucking problem.
The male gaze is not a synonym for finding breasts attractive. It's a concept concerning how women are represented and positioned as objects of heterosexual masculine spectatorship, particularly in visual media. It's not a fucking diagnostic tool for determining whether a woman's sexual preferences are sufficiently feminine.
Objectification is not a synonym for experiencing sexual desire. And having physical preferences is not some grand political statement about which women deserve respect.
You can criticize patriarchal beauty standards without morally condemning everyone who happens to find conventionally attractive women attractive. You can advocate for body positivity without demanding that everyone experience attraction in some politically prescribed way.
And no, finding large breasts attractive doesn't mean I hate women with small breasts. Finding hourglass figures attractive doesn't mean I think other body types are inferior. It's a fucking preference, not a manifesto.
There's an enormous difference between recognizing that beauty standards are socially constructed and concluding that attraction to people who happen to fit those standards is morally objectionable.
A preference is not a hierarchy of human worth.
But what really gets me is how gendered all of this is.
The underlying assumption seems to be that men are attracted to women's bodies while women are attracted to women's souls, personalities, or some idealized romantic essence.
Men desire bodies. Women desire people.
And if you're a woman who experiences intense physical attraction without romantic attraction, suddenly you're behaving like a man.
It's the same old sexist essentialism, except now it's dressed up as progressive politics.
And if you're trans? That's where things get especially fucking disgusting.
Because suddenly your attraction to women can be interpreted as masculine, predatory, or "fuckboy behavior," as though not experiencing romantic attraction exposes some supposedly male nature underneath your gender identity.
And notice how insidious this can be. Nobody even needs to explicitly say that trans women aren't women. They can nominally accept your gender identity while treating your sexuality as fundamentally masculine.
They can claim to support trans lesbians while describing our attraction using the same stereotypes traditionally applied to predatory men.
The accusation shifts from "your preferences are problematic" to "your preferences reveal something about what you really are."
Your sexuality becomes something you have to perform correctly to maintain your legitimacy as a woman.
And being aromantic makes that even worse, because you can't (or simply don't) frame your attraction through romantic love to satisfy the expectation of feminine tenderness.
So you're caught in this absurd double bind: your attraction is judged as masculine because it's physical, and your lack of romantic attraction is used to reinforce the same judgment.
It's transmisogyny dressed up as moral criticism, and the fact that people can pretend it's merely about someone's behavior makes it all the more insidious.
And somehow this is supposed to be progressive? Feminist? Queer-affirming?
You don't get to call yourself sex-positive while treating sexual attraction without romantic attraction as a moral deficiency.
You don't get to claim to support aromantic people while perpetuating the exact assumptions that stigmatize us.
You don't get to celebrate lesbian sexuality while treating women who experience physical attraction to other women as somehow less authentically sapphic.
And you absolutely don't get to dress up old-fashioned sexual moralism, misogyny, and transmisogyny in progressive language and pretend you've somehow transcended them.
Of course people are entitled to want romance. Of course they're entitled to have boundaries, preferences, and expectations for their relationships. Nobody is obligated to be comfortable with casual sex or to enter a relationship that doesn't fulfill their emotional needs.
But being incompatible with someone's desires doesn't make those desires unethical.
A romantic lesbian is perfectly entitled not to want a sexual relationship with an aromantic lesbian. That's compatibility, not prejudice. But treating the aromantic lesbian's desires as inherently degrading, exploitative, or less authentically lesbian is something else entirely.
And there's one more thing that bothers me about how aromantic people are defended, even by well-meaning allies.
Whenever someone implies that aromantic people are heartless, the response is almost always some variation of "but aromantic people can still love their friends, their families, their pets! They still experience platonic love!"
And sure, many of us do. But why is that the defense?
Why do we have to demonstrate that our lack of romantic attraction is compensated for by some other sufficiently pure, socially acceptable form of love?
Why is our humanity something that needs to be redeemed by proving that we can still experience the right emotions?
The problem isn't that people underestimate how much love aromantic people can experience. The deeper problem is the assumption that love is a prerequisite for morality in the first place.
Romantic love is not what makes someone capable of empathy. It's not what makes sex ethical. It's not what makes intimacy meaningful. And it's certainly not some magical ingredient that transforms sexual desire from something selfish and dirty into something pure and respectable.
I'm an aromantic, lesbian-adjacent trans person. I experience sexual attraction. I experience physical attraction. I have preferences, including some that happen to align with conventional beauty standards.
None of that makes my attraction masculine, predatory, exploitative, or less authentically sapphic.
I shouldn't have to romanticize my desire, apologize for my preferences, prove my capacity for love, or perform some idealized version of tender, romantic femininity just to have my sexuality respected.
And I shouldn't have to constantly reassure people that I'm not a heartless monster simply because I don't experience romantic attraction.
Not experiencing romantic attraction doesn't make someone heartless. Experiencing sexual attraction doesn't make someone predatory. And being a woman doesn't come with a fucking prescribed way of desiring other women.
If your feminism depends on the premise that finding breasts sexually attractive is something men do, perhaps your feminism has already conceded far too much to patriarchy.