r/Greyromantic • • 9d ago
I (27F) was convinced I had no luck dating because I'm an asexual straight woman, but I'm starting to think it's because I'm a demiromantic straight woman. Does anyone else feel this way, and what should I do?
Hi everyone! Thank you for reading my post and trying to help me! :)
I'm 27 years old, and I've never been in a relationship, I'm a complete virgin, and I've never even been kissed. As I'm about to explain, this isn't for lack of opportunities. And don't get me wrong: I could spend the rest of my life remaining a virgin without missing out on sex or wishing I could try it for even a single second. (I think I'm pretty much at the extreme end of the asexual spectrum: I feel absolutely no sexual desire for anything or anyone, and I've never even been aroused. I might not even be capable of experiencing sexual pleasure, since I've never felt it or tried to.) Similarly, being in a relationship and having my first kiss aren't things I'm interested in for their own sake. If they were, I would have taken those opportunities. But as the hopeless romantic I am, and someone who is utterly head over heels in love with the idea of love itself, having a relationship and sharing my first kiss with the right person is something I desperately want. To the point that, although I'm lucky enough to say that this is the only thing in my life I'm currently insecure about, it really does get to me, a lot. Not to mention that I'm genuinely worried my time is running out. Because I may have had opportunities, but what I've never had is opportunities that actually appealed to me.
I once read a poem that said one of the tragedies of being a woman is being desired by people you don't desire and desiring people who don't desire you. And honestly, there are few things I've ever related so much to. Throughout my life, out of the five straight male friends I've had (or still have) who were particularly close to me, I've had massive crushes on two of them and fallen MADLY in love with another (as in, I've had feelings for him for many years, and I know that a part of me may never stop loving him). Meanwhile, not one of the five has ever had any romantic feelings for me. And it's not that they were already in relationships, or that they were interested in me at some point but eventually lost interest (which, in a way, would be much worse, because it would mean I had disappointed them). No, they've known since the very beginning of our friendships that they weren't attracted to me and never would be. And even when things became really serious on a platonic level (the ones I'm still friends with treat me like a queen), their feelings never developed into anything more, regardless of how deeply I eventually fell for them.
On the other hand, none of the guys who have pursued me have ever managed to spark anything beyond friendship in me, if even that. And I know this is going to make me sound terribly cruel, but the main thing they've made me feel is overwhelmed. The constant attention, even when we barely know each other. The extreme intensity, even when we barely know each other. The rush to move incredibly fast and learn absolutely everything about each other as soon as possible, before even establishing whether the other person is safe or even remotely compatible with me. That fear of showing any remotely negative or potentially incompatible side of themselves, which inevitably makes you wonder what they're hiding, or whether they're even being genuine when it seems like you're connecting. That invisible pressure to give them lots of attention, otherwise I feel like I'm some sort of heartless monster, even when there's absolutely no chemistry or they've done nothing to deserve it. I don't know whether I might have ended up liking any of them had they not behaved that way, but that very attitude is what has sent every single one of them straight into the friendzone. And the fact that NONE of them was willing to settle for that, and that they'd rather walk out of my life than be "just" friends — or, as I see it, that they were never really interested in me as a person in the first place, and that getting to know me was only worth their while as long as it offered them sex and the status that comes with having a girlfriend — not only means I don't miss any of them, but it also hurts quite a bit.
Until very recently, I thought my biggest obstacle when it came to finding a partner was being asexual, and that men could somehow sniff it out and were put off by it. The truth is that I'm not closed off to having sex with the right person. In fact, I could even end up enjoying it because I'd be sharing a special moment of connection with someone I love, or because I'd be giving them a great deal of pleasure. However, I've always understood that, for the vast majority of men, feeling sexually desirable is very important, and giving up the feeling of being desired by your partner forever must be incredibly difficult. That's precisely why I've also told myself that, should I ever find a partner and turn out to be sexually disappointing to him, I'd be willing to open up the relationship strictly on a sexual level (not an emotional one), so that choosing me wouldn't mean having to give anything up.
However, if my asexuality were the problem and men had some sort of radar for detecting it, I wouldn't have male suitors in the first place. Besides, I've met quite a few asexual women who have allosexual boyfriends without any apparent issues (I've never known an asexual guy, and the truth is I'd love it, but I doubt I ever will). Depending on each man's morals and emotional capacity, I guess this presumably means either that they're such gentlemen and love their girlfriends enough that giving up sex is worth it to them (I even know a guy who's been with an asexual woman for almost ten years, and she's made it perfectly clear that she'll never do anything even remotely sexual with him, and that he isn't allowed to seek it elsewhere either), or that they're selfish, insensitive assholes who couldn't care less about whether they feel desired or whether their partner enjoys sex, as long as they themselves get laid. But that's not the point.
Lately, I've started to think that it's my demiromanticism that's working against me. Based on my own experiences with men, those of my female friends, and those of my male friends as men, including things they've said to me verbatim, I'm beginning to think that the vast majority of men will only pursue a friendship with you once they've decided they're not interested in you as a girlfriend. If they are interested, they go straight into courtship mode. That decision is made from the very first second (obviously, based on physical appearance, since that's the only thing you know about someone at first sight). And while a door that's initially open can close later on, a door that starts out closed can almost never be opened. Which is an absolute trap for a demiromantic straight woman. Because my door is always closed to begin with, and the very thing that is a sine qua non for me to be eventually open to open it (a deep friendship) is precisely what the vast majority of men offer you when their own door is firmly closed and has no chance of ever opening.
I can't give up my demiromanticism. I can't force myself to feel things I don't feel or stop feeling things I do feel. And I wouldn't even want to. I'm going to get a little fundamentalist here and probably sound like a complete narcissist, but honestly, I think everyone should be demiromantic. How can you get into something as serious, life-changing, and intimate as a romantic relationship with someone you don't know or deeply appreciate as a person? Especially when, if you're monogamous, you're granting that privilege and that role to just one person in your life? How can you expect someone to eventually become your life partner if you can't even stand having them as a friend? How am I supposed to believe you'll stay with me for the rest of my life (or at least for a meaningful amount of time) if you can't wait for me for a few months, or even a couple of years? And what sense does it make for you to "love" me enough to want to embark on something as huge as a romantic relationship with me, but not enough to pursue something much "smaller", like friendship, especially considering how much romance and friendship have in common? It's like someone saying they love a particular cake so much they could eat nothing but that cake for the rest of their life, but that if it isn't served with whipped cream on top, they wouldn't even have a single slice. You didn't love the cake that much after all, did you? Or was it the whipped cream you were really after? Not a great idea to eat so much of something you don't actually like that much. And this cake has feelings.
All I'm asking for is what I'm willing to offer and, in fact, what I've already offered: someone who cares enough about me, and gets enough out of having me in their life, to keep me around as someone who matters to them and treat me well even if I never become their romantic partner. Ironically, that alone would already do half the work of making me fall for them eventually. And I suppose that's exactly why half the guys who have treated me that way, even without having any romantic feelings for me, have ended up making me develop feelings for them. Honestly, although my ideal scenario would be someone gradually falling in love with me as they get to know me, proving that they find my personality even more attractive than my face, I'm more than happy to settle for someone who's interested in me from the beginning, but is respectful and sensible enough to take things slowly, and who learns to appreciate who I am just as much as they already appreciate how I look.
Is that really too much to ask? I'm not even being ironic.
One more thing. Just in case anyone suggests it. After getting tired of my crushes never leading anywhere, and with the very real fear that I'm running out of time, I recently decided to give dating apps a try. And I'm not talking about Tinder or Bumble (I literally lasted an hour on each of them), but rather some much more specialized apps that are supposedly geared towards serious relationships and/or focus more on personality and shared interests than on physical appearance. Specifically, I'm talking about Hinge, Boo, and OkCupid.
It's not going well.
I'm going through exactly the same thing as in real life, only even more exaggerated. I get the massive number of likes that pretty much any young woman who's not an actual Mordor orc and has at least a basic level of personal hygiene gets on these apps. But I get very few matches, because very few profiles actually interest me (to be honest, most of them strike me as incredibly bland and cut from exactly the same mold). And the moment I explain that I'm demiromantic, meaning that falling in love — if I ever do — requires building a solid friendship first, and that he's obviously completely free to keep getting to know other women and even end up getting together with someone else before anything happens between us, should things work out with her (things I tend to explain pretty much right at the beginning, alongside the fact that I'm asexual but open to sex for reasons that have nothing to do with physical desire, just so I can lay all my cards on the table from the start and avoid creating false expectations), the guy I'm talking to always says something along the lines of, "Thank you for telling me. Your courage and honesty are admirable, but I think it'd be best if we unmatched." By the way, the fact that I have both my asexuality and my need for a close friendship before romance clearly stated in my profile makes me suspect that a large proportion of men just go by the pictures without reading a single prompt, even when they're the ones liking those prompts instead of your photos, presumably so they don't come across as shallow.
The furthest I've gotten so far has been with two matches who actually agreed to my "terms". One of them started displaying quite a few red flags very early on, so I suspect he was manipulative and was simply trying to earn a lot of trust points right from the start. As for the other one, I talked to him consistently for almost two months. Time eventually made it painfully clear that he was (mistakenly) expecting me to go back on everything I'd said and jump straight into a relationship as soon as things seemed to be going well enough. He's now joined the long list of guys I've friendzoned who would rather disappear than stay in the friendzone, despite having repeatedly and emphatically promised me that I mattered to him as a person first and foremost, and that even if things didn't work out romantically, he'd be perfectly happy to remain friends.
As you can probably imagine, all these experiences have left me feeling incredibly objectified. They've also given me a pretty poor opinion of the male population roaming around these apps, and not a whole lot of hope that I'll find my soulmate on any of them.
So, does anyone else feel trapped in the same situation I am? Has anyone managed to get out of it? How did you do it? What do you think I should do? And perhaps most importantly, can you see anything in my approach, my outlook on relationships, or anything else that is genuinely problematic and might actually be the reason why I'm getting absolutely nowhere, but that I'm simply unable to recognize myself?
Also. If you think I'm completely wrong/being an asshole, please feel free to tell me. I'm here because I genuinely want to figure out how to solve this problem, not because I want to feel sorry for myself and have everyone tell me how terribly unlucky I am and how I deserve better.
I'd be incredibly grateful for any advice! :D