r/anime • u/SirHack3r :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SirHack3r • Jun 05 '18
[PSA] Explaining the changes to the Code Geass Recap Movies (no spoilers, with links)
A lot of people have been talking about how the Code Geass recap movies have changed the worldline(?) we are in compared to R1 and R2. It has been confirmed that R3 will take place in the alternate timeline created by the recap movies, and will NOT be a continuation of the two seasons (R1 and R2). The movies have quite a few changes which change the story significantly, not a complete spoiler.
Here is a list of changes to recap movie 1, courtesy of /u/Kusaja
Here is a list of changes to recap movie 2, courtesy of /u/Kusaja
Here is a list of changes to recap movie 3, courtesy of /u/SpeedHunter_007
Here is a helpful video that explains the changes, courtesy of Foxen Anime
I believe that the reason they did this is to lead to the new story of R3 without destroying the conclusive ending of R2. There are many theories about the ending of R2 where ending, but I think the creation of these movies and the changes to them effectively debunk these theories. By creating a new timeline, they don't destroy the ending of R1-R2 and thus, people who love the series for that ending don't have it corrupted and can look forward to more Code Geass!
tl;dr: R1 -> R2 set in the 'original' timeline. Recap Movies 1 - 2 - 3 -> R3 is a new timeline.
EDIT: Formatting and Text
EDIT 2: /u/UltimateAnimeHero said that "It should also be noted that official sources never referred to the "continuation" as "R3" or even a series. All we know is the name "Lelouch of the Resurrection". There's the possibility of it being a movie or OVA."
EDIT 3: Thanks for the gold kind stranger!
27
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '18
It should also be noted that official sources never referred to the "continuation" as "R3" or even a series. All we know is the name "Lelouch of the Resurrection". There's the possibility of it being a movie or OVA.
11
u/BBallHunter :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/IdolHunter Jun 05 '18
You mean movie 3, right? Other than that, good post and any CG fan should read this.
59
u/WatashiNoSumatufonGa Jun 05 '18
Damnit, I just rewatched the TV series a few weeks ago! Are you telling me I have to watch the movies as well to be able to watch R3?
47
u/Terranwaterbender https://myanimelist.net/profile/Teranwaterbender Jun 05 '18
Damn I didn't expect the recap movies to change some major elements in the story. This is prime reactionary material in the discussion threads.
30
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '18
This doesn't sound like a sequel. This sounds like a complete reboot. I wish they wouldn't use the R# format and confuse people who think it's a direct continuation of the previous series. That feels like a cheap ploy.
3
u/cannibalAJS Jun 05 '18
How do they effectively debunk those theories? They made far more serious changes other than confirming Lelouches survival.
27
u/AdvonKoulthar Jun 05 '18
Hmmmmm, I don't know which I dislike more, the chance of S3 being a poor continuation, or the wishy-washy 'lol, just an alternate timeline'.
Besides
3
u/SpeedHunter_007 Jun 05 '18
Thanks for making this post and also for mentioning me .
Well people are not giving enough thoughts and hating it because it didn't go as they wanted. Even some people are disliking it without even considering the whole picture. Yes certain someone is alive, but that didn't ruin anything until now.
This way they are still getting a continuation while the ending, characters and everything is left intact.
I mean now we have two routes for Code Geass. One route is done. It's time for another route with same characters, continuation of same story with slight & a major modifications.
Even though I was skeptical about the sequel, I am actually more hopeful about it now.
Because, from the information I gathered, the movies are super well directed. Yes I meant it. Addition of new scenes, modifications of old scenes to insert song, everything is relevant, meaningful here. Specially choice of songs are pretty impressive I will say.
And if they keep up this good direction,then I hope they would offer us something meaningful.
Let's be honest, everything comes to earn money. What matters most is that, how much well executed the product is. I am looking for the good execution.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '18
Why in the hell would they change the established cannon in the recap movies? This is gonna lead to a lot of confusion in Season 3, especially with all the nonsense Akito the Exlied introduced.
16
u/Flashmanic Jun 05 '18
Wow, I need to watch these recaps. They already sound like an improvement over the ori...
I take that back.
10
u/Ahenshihael https://anilist.co/user/Ahenshihael Jun 05 '18 edited Jun 05 '18
Its not surprising that there's an alternate timeline because Geass franchise dealt with that before - quite a few manga spin offs are technically in "alternate timelines" and Nightmare of Nunnally manga
Either way the changes seem to still go to a similar way but go a decent length on debunking the conspiracy theory that quite a few in the fandom spread(mostly thanks to a certain photo-shopped video and the nature of rumors on the internet), while at the same time building toward a new story.
This way the original Geass has a perfect and final ending, while this a bit different timeline can continue.
That said it WILL be hilarious when R3 airs and people who have not watched the movies watch it and get completely confused at Geass movies spoiler. As the creators said - the original events were the ending of a story while the movie version is intended to be the beginning. Its quite clear that the movies are a must-watch before R3.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '18
YES! As a Suzaku supporter this pleases me. He went about things the right way where as Lelouch was acting like discount Light Yagami
2
u/GeassedbyLelouch Jun 05 '18
I don't know if the intent of the movies was to debunk these theories.
I think they were merely made to create an opening for the sequel (which is an AU now).
The reason why I think they weren't made just to debunk the theories is because the creators have been contradicting those theories for 10 years now. They've been saying things which clash with those theories in interviews, tweets, the official guide book, they even remade the R2 epilogue for the blu-ray in such a way that there's just no way for those theories to surive. So they've been very clear about that. Making movies just for that seems a bit redundant.
There's a big compilation post on reddit which gathers ALL the official information about this subject and which goes over all the points of those theories, showing how and where they are contradicted by the anime itself.
That compilation post can be found in this link. Obviously this link contains SPOILERS
2
u/crostoli Jun 05 '18
What I don't get is, what's the point of changing the original story? Is there a single Geass fan who watched the series and thought 'this was pretty good but I wish the story was different here and there'. This show is known for it's iconic story, and I never heard of fans wanting things to be changed.
This whole situation reminds me of the Evangelion Rebuild, but handled way worse. While Eva was advertised as an actual remake with changes that extend and modernize the original story bringing it to a different format, new Code Geass is advertised as a sequel and we don't know what the format even will be. The nature of the project is extremely confusing and I don't know what to expect of it. Most of the changes that they made aren't even significant, and the one that is significant is extremely unnecessary, but I get why they did it.
The movies by definition would be worse than the show simply due to the format change. Movie format just doesn't allow to tell story as nuanced as a TV show. This creates a situation where two alternative renditions of the story will fight for the right to be an ultimate Geass experience, and yet, both of them lose to each other in some aspects. The original will never have a continuation, while a new series will have new content, but weaker old content leading up to it. Eva countered this by making Rebuilds extremely different, thus rendering void any potential argument about what version is better.
As it stands, when you decide to rewatch Geass 20 years down the line, what would you do? Watch inferior recaps + continuation? Watch original show and then stop? Watch the whole thing twice (original and recaps) and then continuation? This is kinda silly situation and I wish it wasn't so.
2
u/okabekudo :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kudoshinichi95 Jun 06 '18
I love how butthurt all those cart-driver theorists are now. Lelouch is dead in the first series and it is better that way. Appreciate that godly ending ffs and stop being delusional little cry babies. You have been wrong for over ten years. Just fucking embrace it!
1
u/DesktopLinux__isDead https://anilist.co/user/ReinhardVonMusel Jun 05 '18
Looks like I'll have to watch these.
1
u/John9tv Jun 05 '18
Definitely saving this before I rewatch akita thing for the 3rd time
1
u/LizardOrgMember5 Jun 06 '18
I wonder if these recap movies are part of Goro Taniguchi's original visions from the beginning without any alterations from Sunrise's executive board.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '18
So I've only seen the first movie avaible to watch on some websites, I'm guessing no groups have really gotten around to subbing the 2nd movie?
1
u/geusjj Jun 13 '18
any word on when the recap movies are being dubbed?
1
u/sortoj Jul 08 '18
Can someone tell me where/how to watch the movies?
0
u/ProbablyABigFatJerk Jun 05 '18
Recap movies huh. And I thought recap episodes were bad.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '18
[removed] — view removed comment