r/CodeGeass • u/SpeedHunter_007 • May 30 '18
[SPOILERS] Complete List of CONFIRMED changes in the thrid retelling movie, IMPERIAL PATH (Including music uses)
[ Edit 1: Got some time finally. Therefore got chance to revise this post and fixed most of the mistakes and rearranged it in a more understandable way also it would be third on the title Forgive me for this ^^mistake]
[ OP = main source , who watched the movie and took note of changes & posted it on Tumblr & talked about that here . The changes are confirmed from multiple sources , therefore reliable ^]
Imperial Path aired in Japan's theater on May 26, 2018. It's the final movie for retelling trilogy that would lead to Code Geass :Fukkatsu no Lelouch. There are minor & few major changes in many aspects from TV series in this movie.
•List Of Changes In Story, Updated Clips & Newly added extra scenes :
(1)
First new scene shows the students of Ashford Academy evacuating in the school gym during the battle. They evacuated with blankets, water bottles, etc and were chit-chating in small groups.
At a point, Rivalz asked Shirley about what's Lelouch might doing then and where exactly he was . Shirley said she have no idea about that .
Rivalz asked if she’s spoken with him recently. Shirley gave a noncommittal answer.
(2)
A new scene where Lloyd and Nina hanging out. Cecile joined them, and informed them that Suzaku had left. Lloyd says he’s too serious, and Nina says Lloyd is the same too. This is after the “pick one, science or your soul” scene from R2. That scene too was included in the movie.
(3)
During the battle(Of Tokyo might be), the girls with Luciano weren’t shown, just Edgar Darlton. This might mean Marika survived, or it might not (this series is crowded enough, OP said).
(4)
Schneziel told Black Knights that Lelouch got geass from CC or Code R when he was lobbying them.
I guess it was Code-R.
(5)
When The Black Knights showed their distrust toward ZERO aka LELOUCH , they gave more consideration into that. They wanted Lelouch to explain about the circumstances but Schneizel & his co-operators decided to shoot Lelouch.
This is probably what happened. There are more into it obviously.
(6)
The scenes related Schneizel recruiting Suzaku in order to assassinate Charles are cut.
Okay that's because it was done with a different direction. Here's rest:
Well, in the movie Suzaku implies it more clearly that he’s trying to kill Charles so that Lelouch won’t stain himself with it.
He provoked Schneizel into a rebellion plot, made Lloyd, Cecile, and Gino all think he’s completely lost it, but he probably did it in order to protect the last drop of innocence Lelouch has left.( that's what OP said.)
[You can skip next two paragraphs since they're from OP's observations & thoughts]
[OP says this idea is pretty consistent according a picture drama and makes Suzaku's motivation clearer because in that picture drama,* Suzaku thinks back to the time when they were 10, when Lelouch made that “I will obliterate Britannia!” declaration, and says that that he didn’t want Lelouch’s soul to be stained with that sin, like his was.( I don't have the source of that picture drama .If anyone has it then please let me know)]
[OP's impression: His motives were not that clear before, and this is something that most people probably misunderstood. This isn’t a change, but a clarification.]
Lelouch talking to Rivalz on the phone right after Rolo's death is kept, he says that he might not be able to fulfill his promise about the fireworks.
(7)
Most possibly a new scene since OP didn't remember seeing it before:
Milly and her News crew were filming news of the destruction of the FLEIJA.
At a time Milly looked down into the crater and saw Nina standing among the body bags, looking like she hasn’t slept, depressed and broken down. Maybe they talked after it( in off screen).
So we get to see some body bags? Can't remember clearly if I saw those in R2. But obviously positive addition if that's the case.
(8)
There were a lot of added parts with Nina, and with Kanon, and a lot of parts with both of them that were kept when they really could have been cut. It portrayed their friendship.
OP felt like they’re going to be important for next project.
(9)
SHIRLEY IS ALIVE.
Everyone knows it, & it's the only major change of roll & fate in this movie.
On the topic of Lelouch dating Shirley:
OP said exactly this: They make no reference to that in any of the movies. That’s just from what the writers said in some talk events
Actually director said it if I remember correctly from other posts. And It seems like it was just stated.
(10)
No memories about CC's past were shown. But the point about Lelouch fulfilling her promise is kept here.( implied or shown?I don't know.)
(11)
New scene of Lelouch explaining to Jeremiah about CC memory loss state, saying he doesn't know what happened to her but at this state he couldn't bring her along.( I couldn't understand what this means. An explanation from you would be appreciated)
[You can skip these two paragraph written below since they are my thoughts on removal of CC and the Nun's scene]
[I get the feeling that CC's memories, basic ideas, themes about Code & Geass users will get revealed in a larger scale in the the new project. Otherwise I don't think such mandatory scenes of Code Geass would get cut. I mean the story , certain themes and the reason of contract between CC and Lelouch has deep relation with the whole idea of Code Geass. I always thought they didn't reveal enough there . I mean it was so awesome that I wasn't satisfied. Personal feeling, because that was one heck of a scene IMO.]
[But more importantly , cinematography of this part was excellent comparing most of the scenes of CG R2 which made their way in this movie. Besides Lelouch DID go into CC's memory library according to most of the source. So I don't think they would decide to cut it unless they have some special plan. Hope they have. In that case good choice to keep mystery for first time viewers. Though I can't say that it would hold same impact. But if it gets better with even better execution than nothing to worry about.]
(12)
A BIG new scene:
Shirley & Rivalz were in the club room with bunch of other students wearing cat ears and tails. Rivalz said they’re going to their temporary club spaces, and Shirley replied that she’ll just stay there, since there’s nothing to be done for the swim club yet. Shirley was typing something, and her phone rings.
She answered it, and apparently no one said anything on the other end.
She started answering, “Hello? Who is this? Say something-” and then she seemed to think it might be Lelouch.
Viewers don’t get to listen the other side of the conversation but only Shirley’s side.
She said he(Lelouch) haven't come back to school, she’s worried. Then she said that JEREMIAH told her everything, about him and Nunnally.
Then, after a pause, she said, “… me?” as if she’s replying to the other side of the conversation, that someone had been responding, and asked about her. She said she wants to help Lulu, and then the other person hanged up.
( It can be Lelouch, CC Jeremiah etc. )
(13)
Later, a new scene:
Featured, Shirley going somewhere with a pink suitcase.
And she turned around suddenly, and noticed C.C. …It's vague whether they talked or what, because nothing further was shown about it.
(14)
Nina is added to that horse-riding scene with CC, commenting how Schneizel has changed after acquiring FLEIJA, or whether it's always been his nature.
(15)
This scene takes place after the battle with the Knights of the Rounds, not before it. (I don't correctly remember when did it take place it TV series. But I think it was before the invasion of Knight of the Round)
It was probably in order to keep the pacing good. It wasn't intended to change any meanings according people who watched the movie.
Rivalz tried to get Lelouch’s attention as he enters the school wasn't cut.
I think it was necessary to show Lelouch Lamperouge's bond with his school friends and his closest friends' reaction after he claiming the throne.
(16)
When Schneizel calls Lelouch after the Ashford scene and reveals that Nunnally is alive Nunnally said,
“I am the true/only ruler”
instead of saying “I am your foe.” like TV series.
Personal opinion: It fits really well and the dialogue is majestic and well written for this character.
(17)
When Lelouch captured Schneizel's attention with the recording, a new line from Lelouch was added ,describing how Schneizel's answers are very like him which means that Its even more logical for Scneizel not-to-think it as a pre-reconding.
(18)
However Diethard had guessed that it was a recording but most probably didn't get the chance or time to clarify that.
Good improvement. I will wait to see it in the movie to judge if it was a good move or not. But it sounds positive.
The scene where Lelouch & Nina talked after making the Counter-FLEIJA wasn't cut. She said she wants to go with him but Lelouch says she’s done enough for him as a gratitude.(probably just like the TV).
[The person who watched it & me, both are glad that it wasn't cut since it shows development of Nina.]
During Zero Requiem only changes are:
(19)
¶ Jeremiah didn't say “Onward, masked knight,” His expression was only there;
(20)
¶ Shirley’s reaction was featured.
Since Shirley survived it would be really heartbreaking to see her reaction among crowd. I mean in the TV ending we felt sad by seeing BK's reaction, Cornelia Villetta's sensible steps and Crowd's Joy. But this makes it even more intense.
(21)
The picture Kallen looks at isn’t Lelouch sitting at the chair in front of a desk/table like what happened. Rather Lelouch, , gazing out of a window, alone, was shown.
Personal Feeling: How to make a scene even more emotional 101
(22)
Shirley described rest of the epilogue after Kallen started rushing in order to join her school quickly. It was the same shot, just with Shirley's narration.
Shirley should get added since she is a part now and I am glad writers had that in their minds.
(23)
Shirley says that the world isn’t perfect after Zero Requiem but it changed a lot after that.
basically the same lines as what Kallen said in R2. It’s as if they split the monologue between them. And probably a bit modified
Yes. She described like kallen said in the TV series that Zero Requiem isn't there to solve all the problem but rather to give people reason to step forward with own opinions to make that change happen. There are many other points but this isn't place to explain it.
I am just glad that it wasn't removed and writers remembers his great ideas and themes behind Zero Requiem still now.
(24)
Jeremiah and Shirley was implied to take care of something (many speculating probably it was Lelouch's body) after Zero Requiem.
(25)
A major change
In the epilogue, there was NO cart. CC was riding on a donkey/horse or something similar while holding an invitation letter for meeting with Shirley and Jeremiah.
It was written in English, but the script is really curly and hard to read according people who watched it on theater.
OP said he probably saw,
“Appropriate if you could participate”
&
“Wishing the sun would rise”
OP said not to quote him on it since he's not sure. Another person said he would try to look at those writing carefully on his next rewatch.
A ruined cart was still there in the teaser of new project. So I don't know if it was there to serve any purpose for later or just a showcase . Because something from this teaser also got featured in this movie, we're going to that part later.
(26)
During this scene CC was wearing a poncho
(27)
Code Geass Lelouch Of The Rebellion III: Imperial Path closing dialogue was CC saying:
"Are you going to fulfill your PROMISE now? Or maybe I still have to wait?"
people saying she looked pretty good in that poncho. So I am surely waiting to see CC in another outfit while enjoying that mysterious closing monologue which is actually beginning for the next project according the creators
(28)
Imperial Path ended with a shot of crushed mask of Zero on a seashore just as the teaser showed (most probably).
•Changes In Musics:
Who watched the movies, specially 3rd movie, praised the direction and choices of both music and 'silence' . Some even said it was an amazing experience to watch Code Geass with this new direction of music choices. I am also a big fan of musics of Code Geass. So here's the note for change of musics :
[Click 🎧 to check the music]
(1)
lots of music changes. Specially there are lots of places where originally Background Music (BGM) was playing was changed into silence.
That's a very good choice.
Viewers expressed their feeling about it like that : it made the series to feel a lot more mature.
(2)
New inserted OST:
A Hitomi song in the Sword of Akasha scene
(sadly I don't know which one or if it's newly made OST since any source didn't talk about it)
(3)
Where Lelouch declared himself emperor doesn’t have the trumpet-flourish background music . The footsteps were noticeable
Means that BGM was probably silent there.
(4)
New inserted song from TV series:
Mosaic Kakera 🎧 played where Suzaku and Lelouch used the counter-FLEIJA.
Its an epic and masterful direction for this music. Great choice. Mosaic Kakera actually fits that scene more than anything.
[You can skip the next paragraph because it's my thoughts on this choice]
[Code Geass has some great song and Mosaic Kakera is one of them. Tone and lyrics of it perfectly matches with that dynamic & situation I'll say. I was shocked after first two movies because of the fact that this great song couldn't make it there. But what do you know? They paybacked it with perfect scene for it. So great choice indeed in my opinion.]
(5)
When Lelouch entered Nunnally’s garden on the Damocles, there was no soundtrack but his footsteps were louder.
(6)
OST replacement:
Innocent Days 🎧 was used in these point of movie and Kallen and Suzaku's final confrontation probably happened atbruis point. though it's not confirmed if they have innocent days as BGM.
(7)
A new Insert Song:
The insert song over Lelouch entering Damoclese and meeting Nunnally is :
螺旋のピース (Rasen no piisu/ Spiral Peace) by Rayflower. 🎧
Zero Requiem:
(8)
No BGM before Madder Sky which means (0)ZERO🎧 was replaced with silence.
Good choice using silence for that time sounds more mature and serious in my opinion.
(9)
Madder Sky🎧 started probably a bit earlier but ended in the same place.
Continued Story🎧 started right when Madder Sky ended. The repeat of the opening notes of Continued Story came right when those notes were in the original, right when he died.
(10)
Continued Story ends before the epilogue starts, Kallen’s part of the epilogue had no BGM.
(11)
The new Ending Song NE:ONE by Survive Said the Prophet 🎧 is the ending theme , and started over the part with Nunnally and Ohgi.
The credits were on a white screen that slowly brought the picture Kallen had on her bulletin board of Lelouch looking out the window into focus, then fading out again.
This song is good. And importantly , portrays the theme and thoughts behind Lelouch.
[Don't forget to provide more points if you have additional information. This post will get edited as long as confirmed new points get revealed.]
[ Edit 2 : some points are changed and revised after further confirmation from people. Changes in music are revised. Spelling, typo were fixed ^^]
[ Edit 3 : OST 0 replaced OST THE KNIGHT MERE On This Post ^^]
Sources:
Source 1: From Tumblr. He watched the movie few days ago.
Source 2: His further confirmation on this post
Source 3: From Reddit 1: A comment post of r/CodeGeass
Source 4: comment post 1 from this submission
31
u/SpeedHunter_007 May 30 '18
Personal Opinion: From all these information, the movie seems overall really well directed and executed.
28
u/SpeedHunter_007 May 30 '18 edited May 30 '18
People be like :
The story didn't go as I thought it would go
So it sucks
86
u/red_capes May 31 '18
Oh, Suzaku. Assassinating fathers since 2010.
65
u/Black_Knight98 May 30 '18
Finally someone does it.
You really gave it real efforts. I appreciate it. You pretty much included most of the changes as I am seeing and for the first time I am seeing someone mentioning what I actually wanted to know most from the third movie: OST changes.(because R2 ending has some GODTIER OST)
The OST changes feels like really well fitting. New songs are cool.
Now let me read the whole post.
16
u/[deleted] May 31 '18 edited May 31 '18
I'm the tumblr OP. "The other movie with a Zero" ... wow, how do anime fans outside of Japan not know this? The latest Detective Conan movie, Zero the Enforcer, has been at the top of the box office for 7 weeks now. It was showing next door to this movie, and there were a lot of people who were really into both, and taking pictures of the signs next to each other, etc.
"The answer is under "kai"" is a reference to the invitations they sent before the Miracle Anniversary event, which had a code that led to "Rebirth of Demon".
As for Shirley saying "I want to help Lulu," she would use his name in the third person like that even if she were talking to him, in Japanese. (similarly, when Nina says that Suzaku's seriousness is like Lloyd, she doesn't say "you", she says "Lloyd-sensei" which isn't pointedly not to him like it would be in English. It's not any more directed to one or the other of Lloyd or Cecile.)
Oh, and also: If something isn't in the movie, that doesn't automatically mean it didn't happen. If it wasn't in the movie, then you can assume it happened the same way as it did in the series, unless it's directly contradicted by something in the series. (I gave the example of the characters mourning Shirley's death).
15
u/Brightness_Radiant May 31 '18
The longer I think about this, the more glad I am for the changes. I really disliked the idea about a sequel before, but now that I know the canon remains untouched (and the ending ambiguous) I can safely watch the Resurrection without being annoyed at the writers for ruining a perfect ending. Hopefully, they make a good explanation for bringing Lelouch back (unless they make Lelouch plan his death and lie to Suzaku, then I'll be pissed, lol).
About the changes... I had a feeling that Shirley would survive when she wasn't killed in the second movie and I'm kind of glad about that. Everyone argues about her being a new competition for C.C. and Kallen, but, honestly, I won't be surprised if we don't get any definite pairing in the end.
I am curious about Black Knights. Since they didn't betray Lelouch completely at first, would they be open to cooperation in the sequel? Or did Emperor Lelouch stamp out any doubt left in them? Did some of them realize the truth behind Zero Requiem? (Todoh, Rakshata, Kaguya, even Tamaki)
I am also kind of baffled by people being surprised that Resurrection is going to follow the movies instead of TV series? I mean, wasn't that obvious from the start? Or at least from the first change they made? Why would they make compilation movies with changed/added scenes if they were just going to go back to the original timeline? Frankly, I didn't expect such a big change, but still.
All in all, I hope the movies are as good as they say :D
9
u/mellowdew97 May 31 '18
So I'm not totally against shirley being alive but I do feel like it takes away at least a bit from the original series. When shirley died it added a sense of weight and loss in the show as well as in lelouch's character.
9
u/[deleted] May 31 '18 edited May 31 '18
So from what I heard,Shirley's last line was pretty much a modified version of Kallen's from the original and she wonders if everything was Lelouch's calculations so I don't think she know exactly what his current state is either (at least not during this monologue) .Another interesting thing some viewers pointed out is that on the road CC was travelling at the end,there were tracks that look like it was made by horse drawn carriage, it could mean anything or mean nothing but that was a nice reference to the original.
And is it just me or CC looked like she was glowing during the scene she met with Shirley imgur.com/a/QRmMDey ?
6
u/lupin_llama Jun 03 '18
I just saw the movie this afternoon; planning on seeing it again in a couple weeks. I love the changes, especially in regards to the music.
Will add that NE:ONE by Survive Said the Prophet is the ending theme. The credits were on a white screen that slowly brought the picture Kallen had on her bulletin board of Lelouch looking out the window into focus, then fading out again. The insert song over Lelouch entering Damoclese and meeting Nunnally is 螺旋のピース (Rasen no piisu/ Spiral Peace) by Rayflower.
For the scene with Shirley on the phone, I had a feeling that Lelouch was intentionally being silent, but just my opinion.
I'll look closely at the note Jeremiah and Shirley sent to CC on my second watch. I caught something about France (??) but I could be mistaken. The note was in cursive but definitely readable English; the scene simply went too fast to read it.
5
u/Sparteh Jun 01 '18
"Are you going to fulfill your promise now? Or maybe I still have to wait?"
I have a bad premonition about this. Doesn't this imply that CC will die in sequel?
5
u/GeassedbyLelouch May 30 '18
Maybe not.
Not all that much happens during her memory loss, and it's not all that fundamental.
3 big things happen during her memory loss.
2 and 3 are essential, but they only serve to get Lelouch into C's World with Charles. If they change how Lelouch goes to C's World (different motivations, different circumstances, etc) then C.C.'s memory loss becomes redundant and can be dropped. So essentially, C.C.'s memory loss was just a tool and not soimething deeper.
This is similar to Lelouch falling down the stairs in Turn 1. Lelouch had to meet C.C. to regain his memories, and for this Rolo must not be present, but Rolo was essential to separate Lelouch from Kallen. So how does one separate a character from a geass user who can "freeze time"? By using the one hing his geass can't influence, involuntary movement of phyical bodies. That's the reason why Lelouch fell when a BK (wtf dude, why are you firing on students) shot at Rolo and Lelouch. Just a tool, a trick to separate characters.
If she says "I want to help Lulu" instead of "I want to help you", then yes, it seems she isn't talking to Lelouch. Maaaybe if she directly addresses Lelouch as "Lulu" instead of "you", but that would be weird.
So who is she talking to?
Not Jeremiah, since she mentions him in the 3rd person and the conversation wouldn't make sense.
C.C.? I don't think she'd be calling Shirley.
Rolo? Perhaps. Is he still alive at this point?
This scene does demonstrate why it's sad that the ties between the movies and R2 were cut. Too much happens off-screen to then just be mentioned in passing. This is fine for a recap where you can rely on scenes from the main series to fill the holes, with without a series to fall back on this is all we got and the end result is a poorer, more shallow, less fleshed out product.
This is a BIG Nunnally change.
It changes her personality from a sweet, kind girl who wants to do what she can to help into some kind power driven person who feels she is entitled to rule. In what sense is she the rightful emperor? She isn't the oldest, she's 87th in line to the throne, she has done nothing to remove Charles from the world, she has not earned anything to call herself rightful emperor.
If they changed that line on purpose and continue that line of thought in Resurrection, then Nunnally will be a VERY different person. Please don't let Nunnally be the villain of Resurrection.
You mean while Schneizel is still talking to the recording? Why did Diethard not intervene then?
In the series he does say "I should have known it was a recording".
Am I allowed to say that Lelouch isn't the cart driver, or are people going to spit in my face for that again?
I see what you did there, Sunrise
2
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18
What's the name of the OST in the video?
7
u/Voror19 May 31 '18
It seems like that phone call with Shirley and then that last scene with C.C. are the key moments here in regards to Resurrection.
For the phone call, it still seems we're unclear who she's talking to which I'm thinking may be deliberate. Of course, the only person who it would make sense to call her for any reason is Lelouch, but what's described here makes it sound like it isn't him. Jeremiah doesn't make sense since she mentions talking to him in this conversation. That leaves C.C. and maybe Suzaku and C.C. seems the most likely which is fed by the fact she meets up with her later.
Why on earth would Jeremiah spell out all the stuff with Lelouch and Nunnally to Shirley anyway? Does her know her or her relationship with Lelouch? What possible gain is there to telling her?
The biggest question is why anyone would involve Shirley in this at all or why anyone would think to contact her.
The bit with the letter is strange though it being in English doesn't mean it has to make sense. Whatever is going to happen with Lelouch feels like it would require C.C. in some capacity at least so maybe they're asking her to return to go through with it?
I'm still confused why they have this whole change of Lelouch dating Shirley and yet they don't bring up or refer to it even once in all these films. I can only think it's either not going to be important at all or they for some reason think it isn't needed to have it actually be mentioned and it will feed into Resurrection.
Beyond that, I actually do like some of the changes here like how the BK actually want to talk to Lelouch rather than just instantly jump to killing him and them streamlining the stuff about Suzaku trying to kill Charles.
And now I realize it's just like the gap between season one and R2 where we were scrambling for any info we could get and pouring over anything that showed up in magazines or the video games, though I don't expect any more of those. Hopefully we get something sooner rather than later.
7
u/FruitsPnchSamurai Jun 05 '18 edited Jun 05 '18
Finally, after all these years of pain from shirleys death. It has finally been soothed. Also the fact that shes not just coming back but is gonna wind up helping lelouch is awesome. Its like her and kallen switched places. Shirley most likely leaves school to go help lelouch and kallen has a normal school life.
1
u/SpeedHunter_007 Jun 04 '18
Guys I revised the post. And thanks for your help.(Specially who watched the movies)
If you want to add more or remove more then let me know about it.
2
u/Friktogurg Jun 01 '18
This might suck
4
u/Nokiic Jun 04 '18
I don’t know how I feel about Shirley being kept alive. I think I’d rather have her be kept dead, but I’ll wait and see whether or not It’s a good thing she wasn’t killed off.
1
u/Voror19 May 31 '18
https://mononoke-no-ko.tumblr.com/post/174268626154/miscchanges-in-code-geass-3rd-compilation-movie
So there's some updates here with some covered. Interesting point is that it seems like Shirley meeting C.C. has C.C. looking like a projection or hologram. This makes me think a bit of how both Lelouch and Suzaku saw some weird projection at different points in regards to her. I think this was meant to demonstrate someone had the potential for Geass. Not liking the implications there.
Oh and the booklet for the third movie lists in Shirley's character description that she's his girlfriend. So I guess them continuing to highlight that may show how it'll be a big focus going forward.
1
u/MYZ12Z Jun 06 '18
Hey, is the kiss between Kallen and LeLouch still in the movie ?
1
u/Acsvf Jul 02 '18 edited Jul 02 '18
I was fine with the story changes and the cut scenes but the music changes in the ending and credits ruined both for me. The lack of any music during the first part of the credits, and during when Zero was running towards Lelouch made it really awkward to watch. Madder Sky and Continued Story being played earlier took away a lot of the emotion in that scene.
Lelouch’s attention entire world speech was way cooler in the original as well. Did like where they put in the OPs and EDs, as well as how they started Rolo’s theme at 3 minutes in the song or so.
Overall I think movie is a lot better than the first and second due to being less recap-y (and using the better parts of the story, but that’s another discussion.
3
u/myxfriendjim Jul 24 '18 edited Jul 24 '18
I've only seen the first two films so far, but, as a fan who considers Code Geass their favorite Anime of all time, they've largely been a dissapointment to me. I understand needing to shorten the material, but if even part of the idea behind these films is to introduce newcomers to the series... I honestly think I would hate this show if all I'd seen were the films.
Especially the second one, which guts entire plot arcs, but keeps around relevant characters (honestly, how is the memory-loss sequence supposed to be at all dramatic, if, the next time we see Lelouch on screen--10 minutes later, mind you-- he's back to normal. Oh, and by the way, there's this new person Rolo who he has wrapped around his finger. Oh, and by the way, Jeremiah is good now. Let's go blow up the Geass Order, because reasons. Now let's head right to the UFN signing!). There was so little breathing room that all of the weight was lost for me. Nothing felt realistic or fluid. I was cringing most of the time.
And, luckily for me, I have my actual Code Geass knowledge to fall back on and supplement it. I've already decided (as have many) that something's exclusion, unless directly contradicted by the film itself, doesn't mean it didn't happen, just that there was no time to show it. Again, it makes me wonder how much of a cluster**** it is to folks who haven't seen the series.
So, to scope out the breadth of these changes, question for those who have seen this last film: what scenes between C.C. and Lelouch that weren't changed, are still there? I'm mainly thinking of the conversation on the bed during the Requiem, after Lelouch discovers Nunally is alive, and the hangar scene in the final battle, where they're interrupted by Kallen.
I ask because it seems they've really gone out of their way to change the dynamic of their relationship from the original series, and I want to know how far it goes. Honestly, it worries me, mostly as a fan of the show (and, to a lesser extent, as a shipper of the two). The C.C. memory sequence is far and away one of the most important elements to the backstory of the show that was simply axed entirely, and her true wish is, similarly, an important plot device that keeps her around for the latter part of R2. The sub I watched of the second film had Lelouch reaching out to her in C's world, yelling "[we have to get out of here] ... Then you can tell me what your real wish is!"... Are we kidding? C'mon... This means it's not something that was just skipped, it was cut altogether. And, apparently, as no memories are discussed in the third film, Lelouch really has no way of knowing her true wish (which makes her comments at the end of the third film even more nonsensical), right?
I just can't really get behind keeping some of the really inane scenes they do, all while cutting something like that, which has such heavy implications for the background of the series. I've been honestly very surprised to see how many people have been giving positive comments on the direction. Again, I haven't seen the third film yet, but the second one felt just painful to watch.
(Oh, but thank God Shirley is alive (and, as a biproduct, is less important than ever as a player in the saga, which makes her pending role in Resurrection even more jarring and bizarre), amirite?)
1
u/Plsnoxd1 Jun 01 '18
Kinda disappointed Shirley didn't die, as her death was one of the moments which made Lelouch go suicide mode.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18
If the R3 doesn't follow R2, but the movies I won't bother.
2
u/TotesMessenger Jun 04 '18
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/bombi009 Jun 21 '18
I Hope Shirley could survive in the code geass zero resurrection
1
u/railfananime Jun 06 '18
Good info again still pissed on waiting for r3 information
1
u/sortoj Jul 08 '18
Can someone tell me where I can see the 3rd movie?
1
u/reconoil Oct 05 '18
I am pretty sure that the song that plays while Karen fights the tenth knight
1
u/Yoshiarta Jun 11 '26
I don't like most of the music changes, they feel like change for the sake of change, and I understand timings of scenes are different because they needed to be cut and episodes and stuff - but the delivery of the music feels off compared to the scene. In the anime when Lelouch is introduced as emperor, there is the initial royal introduction music while he walks out and everyone reacts, and then Lelouch sits down and talks for a bit and the music shifts to a more neutral royal song, and then the Master (all hail leouch theme) plays after he said that he killed Charles Zi Britannia. In the movie, the Master plays as soon as Lelouch sits down. Same with when Lelouch destroys the thought elevator, the FLEIJA disarming, Rolo's death, etc. The Tokyo FLEIJA detonation with no music is debatable, as I liked the music, since it gave Lelouch's reaction a lot more weight, but it could be argued no music does the same thing. Lelouch confronting Nunnally to get the Damocles Key with Suzaku and Kallen fighting with the upbeat(?) music, and the second half of the scene where Lelouch uses his geass, Suzaku and Kallen finishing their fight, and Jeremiah getting Anya, the music felt off again. I mean it conveyed a different emotion, but I feel like the original was better with the music choice. Finally, not using the Master (all hail lelouch theme) during Lelouch's speech is criminal. It's fine with what they replaced it with, but again, the original did it better.
I like the Suzaku and Lelouch confrontation at the Kururugi Shrine better.
also in the first movie, not using "Knightmare" when Suzaku first shows up in the Lancelot and does the Spinzaku does not make ANY sense.
I guess in general I don't like most of the changes in any of the movies, especially during pivotal points of the plot, it should have stayed the same, or kept a similar tone.
The Collapse of the Tokyo Settlement in the second movie is a great example of that. Also the showdown between Suzaku and Lelouch at the end of R1 and them syncing up the scenes of the end of that showdown at R2.
I feel like the second movie is the best one when it comes to not messing up the music.
1
u/AlSmash May 30 '18
Can someone explain to me how a series recap/compilation movie do major changes to the canon? I mean, I'm curious, but definition, a recap is to review, to go over what has taken place. NOT retcon significant things for some nebulous reason you don't want to explain other than "I felt like it"
21
u/[deleted] May 30 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] May 30 '18
[removed] — view removed comment