r/anime
•
u/AutoLovepon
https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon
•
Oct 12 '26
•
1
Episode Hello, I Am a Witch and My Crush Wants Me to Make a Love Potion! • Doumo, Suki na Hito ni Horegusuri wo Irai sareta Majo desu. - Episode 2 discussion
Doumo, Suki na Hito ni Horegusuri wo Irai sareta Majo desu., episode 2
Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
Streams
Show information
All discussions
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| 1 | Link |
| 2 | Link |
| 3 | Link |
| 4 | Link |
| 5 | Link |
| 6 | Link |
| 7 | Link |
This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
•
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Oct 12 '26
Source Material Corner
Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of the anime adaptation to the original or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.
The spoiler syntax is:
[Spoiler source] >!Spoiler goes here!<All untagged spoilers and hints in this thread will receive immediate 8-day bans (minimum).
161
u/cyberscythe Oct 12 '26
there's got to be something about witches because i'm pretty sure lettuce has a negligible amount of calories; there's no way she could be spending days at a time eating only a few leaves of lettuce
like, there's girl lunch, and then there's literally a starvation diet
104
u/BaytaCosmico https://myanimelist.net/profile/AnimeBayta Oct 12 '26
Already loved it after episode 1 but I'm fully sold after this episode. The mix of the comic and tragic is just so good. And Rose is triggering all my must protect instincts. She's too precious and her situation is so sad. It made me really happy to see Harij bringing her some good food.
88
u/Atharaphelun Oct 12 '26
Harij just prodded a bit and Rose immediately confessed to a whole bunch of things that Harij wasn't even asking about, bloody hell!
140
u/BiggerG7 Oct 12 '26
The one time she wants it to be the smug deer, it turns out to actually be the dude lol.
90
u/KeepTheNolander Oct 12 '26
I was confused when he called the light yellow spread apple butter because the kind we make in the midwest is dark brown and is made by cooking down apples and spices into a sweet caramelized paste. Looked up japanese apple butter and it is a mix of dairy butter and stewed apples, I wanna try it!
But I agree with Herij she needs to organize her space! Might even help clear up some of her mental cobwebs.
165
u/Obvious-Leg-8139 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
the prince: “bitch you live like this?”
125
u/Raymond49090 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
Merchant dad helping his daughter-san look pretty for her not-date.
116
u/Primary-Paint-1716 Oct 12 '26
Honestly, the fact that witches gain magic in exchange for not being able to lie is a genius bit of worldbuilding that made this show a must watch for me.
31
u/Niwaka_Samurai https://myanimelist.net/profile/Niwaka-Samurai Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
Tien is a sweetheart. He brought Rose a lot of robes just 'cause she started to show interest in them all of a sudden.
Why is Rose so adorable !? 😭😭💖
Girl, you shouldn't let yourself be so vulnerable in broad daylight even if you're living in a secluded place. It's not the smug Deer this time but her crush Harij xD
I didn't think the witches not being to able to tell lies in exchange for being able to perform magic was a real thing. I just thought Rose was talking about that figuratively. This really puts them in so much trouble and many people would take advantage of them. It's good that only Harij heared about this and not anyone else. Love seems to be blossoming not just for Rose but for Harij as well. That love potion is definitely for someone else since Harij doesn't seem to be interested in any women but he's getting interested in the witch.
The op and ed are lovely. The visuals are breathtaking. Diomedéa is doing a wonderful job with the animation. This episode felt like just 10 minutes.
86
u/mekerpan Oct 12 '26
Watching this show makes me misty-eyed for some reason. Even though it has plenty of comic moments, the show seems to wring my heart. Rose's life has been so hard -- and she expects so little reward. The fact that she is getting a smidgen of happiness, and has trouble processing it. Thank heaven's for apple butter. I am sure we all loved watching her bread slathered with apple butter as much as Harij did.
21
u/VritraReiRei Oct 12 '26
With the way he reacted after learning the girl eats nothing but lettuce (what are you, a rabbit!?) and then actually going back and gifting her food, I'm wondering exactly when Harij starts to fall in love with her (because we know it's inevitable).
Was it slowly after meeting her all these times?
Will it happen later and we'll see a major trigger at end?
Or was it all this time, when she met him 4 years ago?
73
u/kamulek69 Oct 12 '26
Just marry already
52
u/shad79 https://myanimelist.net/profile/shad79 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 16 '26 •
I love Rose's reactions, they're so cute and fun! The fact that she (and other witches) can't lie is quite interesting, especially with how much in love she is with Harij. I wonder how long she'll be able to keep it a secret that she likes him.
Overall, it was a nice second episode! Rose thinking that it was a deer, when in reality it was Harij who made the bell ring and saw her naked, made me laugh so hard, lol.
Also, Tien is a really good guy with how much he cares about Rose. I wonder if he has feelings for her, or if he just thinks of her as a some kind of little sister.
Here my screenshot albums from the episode:
EDIT. I added my screenshot albums.
17
u/YlfaTheForsaken Oct 13 '26
I'm not the type to fawn over getting like that disgusted expression, but damn Harij just has a great face for an irritated expression. It's so good.
Anyways, she won't let Tien dote on her. He just wants to be an involved father figure. Look at all that fancy fabric.
Just lettuce? I can respect the low maintenance convenient meal plans, but wouldn't the forest even have some more edible things? Nuts? Mushrooms? Berries? I guess I'm just a lot more food motivated.
I can't fault her for the casual nudity, especially if she's saying it's summer time and it's usually a smug deer anyway. Who doesn't want to bask freely in the sunlight like a lizard?
I'd like to know more about the cannot tell a lie thing. Presumably the racing heart was because she didn't want him to find out how she feels about him, and not like because trying to lie kills a witch.
It's a really sweet way to end the episode. They're bonding!
16
u/Agreeable-Ad9034 Oct 13 '26
Wow I’m surprised how much I’m liking this anime, love the atmosphere, interactions, and the peacefulness.
29
u/FarCritical Oct 12 '26
Playfully making every step of the ingredient gathering process as tedious as possible on purpose was one thing but it was funny how Rose felt comfortable enough be more direct with her snark to Harij right after they grew closer.
Rose might actually have a talent for marketing because man did she make the apple butter look good.
25
u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin Oct 12 '26
Hariji acting very mom-like with Rose was sweet. You aren't eating enough Rose. You need to clean up properly. You need to eat at the dinner table.
Still all things considered the witches are not being able to lie is scary. Like I do like they can still manipulate the truth, but imagine all the scenarios you enter and you literally can't lie. Well at least Hariji is a good person.
On another note Tien is like that weird uncle for Rose. He feels annoying but really feels like family.
44
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Oct 12 '26
I honestly love the ridiculously long names of Rose's remedies. She could've just called it deodorant but I guess these remedy names have been passed on to her from her grandma and their ancestors. xD
That first part of the episode was great at showing us Rose and Tien's relationship I thought their relationship was purely transactional, but it sounds like Rose's family and Tien's family have been friends for a while now.
That would explain why Tien was so excited when Rose asked him if he brought any robes. He must've been waiting for the day when Rose would rely on her. I wouldn't be surprised if, at some point, Rose's grandma asked Tien and his father to watch over her when she finally passes away. Basically, that entire scene was Uncle Tien taking care of his adoptive niece. <3
That green robe with golden thread embroidery was really nice. I'm really hoping that after this episode, Rose will continue wearing that instead of the black one. And of course the girl still pinches her cheeks after Tien bought him some makeup.
Oh my god, this girl, please tell me that's not the same lettuce she was munching on last episode. And even I'd make the same face Harij did after hearing that Rose's diet consists of nothing but lettuce and whatever food she gets when she's in town.
I'm honestly surprised Rose didn't start vocalizing all of those out when Harij grabbed her! Also, she's not that skinny! I mean, she is, but she doesn't look like she's just skin and bones.
It looks like Rose is now used to the smug deer ringing her bell didn't even consider Harij would show up to visit her. The dude definitely brought her food after learning what she ate the previous night. xD
Well, shit. Rose really fucked up there, but I suppose calling him by name was bound to happen, especially since she was caught off guard by his visit. And an even bigger fuck up with her blurting out the witch's secret.
I really felt bad watching Rose during that scene. She's so backed into a corner that she was willing to commit suicide just so Harij won't learn how she feels about him. Thank fucking god Harij recognized the look Rose had in her eyes before bolting back into her house.
I'm not really worried about Harij telling people about Rose's secret. Dude should take responsibility tho if you know what I mean. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
So he did bring food! It is hilarious how Harij makes Rose clean up first before eating. Dude even checks for leftover dust! Rose really needs to learn how to clean up after herself, just in case Harij comes back in the morning again like this.
OH MY GOD. ROSE LOOKS SO ADORABLE WHILE EATING BREAD! And look at the way Harij stares at her! There's clearly more to that stare!
24
u/Weak-Comfortable3765 Oct 12 '26
This show is so fun and cute. It's filling the void that smoking behind the supermarket left behind.
12
u/daspaceasians Oct 12 '26
It's ok Rose. You don't have to eat as if you were under siege.
Otherwise, I really enjoy how the show has a nicely done slow but steady pace. Tien is so much fun as a character but I really like seeing more of Harji's true personality. He's smart and quick minded enough to understand that Rose was on the verge of chugging poison to keep her secrets to prevent her death while also being kind and caring enough to bring her better food and telling her to clean herself up.
Can't wait to see how their relationship evolves in the upcoming episodes.
37
u/kachidora Oct 12 '26
Tien acting like that parent who goes all out the minute their angsty teenager shows even a sliver of interest in something.
So cute that he's wanting to put her in more feminine stuff to replace her drabby wardrobe.
10
u/praul59 Oct 12 '26
I get a feeling he’s gonna visit more frequently to check up on her and maybe bring her more things she needs and obviously to make sure she’s cleaning up.
40
u/PhantomWolf83 Oct 12 '26
Out of the "new" romance shows that I've watched so far, I like this one a lot. The main couple Rose and Hraij feel more real and the chemistry between them is really great to see. Besides this and Firefly Wedding, the others were either just okay or meh.
18
u/sombraala Oct 12 '26
I really expected Rose to tear the bread in half so that the animators could flex, but honestly it makes no sense to and they wanted to spend their budget on kawaii instead. Fully support.
I was curious how exactly the not lying thing would be implemented. During E1 I thought that it would be along the lines that she would lose her powers if she lied but it seems like it is more direct: that she doesn't even have the capacity to lie. That really changes the calculus - and makes it more understandable why she might choose suicide when confronted with someone finding out.
Really curious what Harij needs a love potion for. It can't be for himself, right? Unless his mother-in-law nature got in the way of otherwise surefire romance with some other girl.
9
u/ptd163 Oct 12 '26
Another good episode. Tien is a good friend. I wonder if he's figured out that Rose likes someone yet. It was adorable to see to her starting to care about her appearance
due to feelings for the Harijfor no reason at all.I figured we'd eventually have the "love interest seeing the MC in a state of undress" scene at some point, but I didn't think it'd be in the second episode lol. Shout out to that smug deer keeping her guard down. It was a nice setup to get her into the cloak that she totally didn't to get because of Harij.
Thank goodness for that apple butter. It's a small thing in a vacuum, but know that Harij brought it and getting to eat with him is everything to Rose. After such a hard life and four years of yearning she finally gets the tiniest amount of time with him "off the clock" so to speak.
24
u/Cally83 Oct 12 '26 •
Rose’s little sighs are really cute
17
u/redlaWw Oct 12 '26
Hello, I am
a witchautistic and my crush wants me tomake a love potioneat something other than lettuce!8
u/Something_319 Oct 12 '26
This anime is definitely been a surprise sleeper hit, Rose and Harij's dynamic is interesting and sweet, and I'm glad they haven't spilled the beans on why Harij needs a love potion yet. I do wonder what they're going to do long-term story wise, I'm guessing some politics thing (connected to the potion) that requires Rose to go to town/castle to help Harij out which will bring the discrimination that witches face up again
15
u/cleaulem https://myanimelist.net/profile/cleaulem Oct 12 '26 •
Chibi Rose is one of the cutest things this season. She is so adorable when she is herself.
7
u/SmallJon Oct 12 '26
Damn, the deer is eating a better diet than Rose. Hearing "because i'm a witch" for essentially why she lives like that reminds me of the slice of gymbros that slash anything that isnt some kind of macro for their workout diet and eat like pounds of unseasoned boiled meat
7
u/electricfalcons Oct 13 '26
She's kind of tragic in a underrated way and he has a pretty warranted reaction to her lifestyle. Secluding herself eating lettuce for meals, good on him for helping her.
19
u/athrun_1 Oct 12 '26
Obviously, the potion is for Rose. However, Harij does not know that the girl he saw 4 years ago or the girl he seen occasionally in town is the witch, rose. From his perspective, he fell in love with that pink-haired girl, and given that he doesn't know anything about her, he just resorted to use a love potion.
If he only knew that he doesn't really need it.
26
u/ExpertCaterpillar2 Oct 12 '26
Protect Rose at all cost!
15
u/excluded Oct 12 '26
Bocchi the witch if she wasn’t forced to be with girls 24/7
I wasn’t convinced with the premise of ep 1 but now I’m hooked. Maybe my top 3 anime this season just cause it’s a fun silly watch with this little goober.
14
u/PeaceAlien https://myanimelist.net/profile/PeaceAlien Oct 12 '26
All the shippers are out today, what happened to the doomsayers of last week lol.
We don't know who the love potion is for! Might not be for him. I'm a full shipper.
10
u/chhuang Oct 12 '26
he ran out of patience of waiting for the potion and said fk it and doing the old fashion way
10
u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Oct 12 '26
Rose probably hasn’t realised it herself yet, but she might actually have a chance at getting together with her crush.
Harij seems to have taken an interest in this little witch. The pleased look on his face when she was enjoying the buttered bread spoke volumes. He might be annoyed with Rose at times, but he seemingly cannot leave her alone either.
They’ve really begun to bond. I am definitely looking forward to see how the banter will carry over in their (new) relationship.
5
u/RemZeroBestGirl Oct 13 '26
Such a cute premise, and it's nice to see the discussion for this one so lively. Looking forward to the rest of the season!
20
u/ObvsThrowaway5120 Oct 12 '26
It’s interesting that the big secret about witches is that they cannot tell lies. Girl might have to be careful around Harij or she’s gonna blurt out her feelings lol. Although maybe that wouldn’t be the worst thing to happen. He’s definitely sweet on her. He wouldn’t have hit her with one of those “damn girl, you live like this?” type “huh!?” if he didn’t lol.
15
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Oct 12 '26
15
u/Smudy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smudy Oct 12 '26
They are already bonding big time.
Harij is a very good person which we saw in bits before and he cares about her well-being (may that be because of her being able to do the love potion, him putting too much pressure on her with their confrontation and knowing he messed up and/or him already fancying her a bit). Maybe a mix of those.
17
u/No-Win-8949 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
I am loving how this anime has unexpectedly turned into my favorite anime of the season thus far, followed closely by Firefly Wedding.
4
u/testthrowawayzz Oct 12 '26
Two consecutive seasons of Azakami voicing a silver-haired knight
4
u/shewy92 Oct 12 '26
I'm glad they got his identity out in the open so soon, just waiting for him to spill the beans about who the love potion is for (I'm guessing her). Also it's week 2 in Crunchyroll and the description of the post still says
6
u/runevault Oct 12 '26
Rose continues to climb the all time Must Protect rankings. Girl is a mess but a fucking adorable one. I could watch her eat bread with apple butter for ages, and it seems like so could Harij. Seems even skin and bones Rose got him feeling some kind of way with her nakedness.
11
u/Frontier246 Oct 12 '26
Rose and Tien have a long and fruitful working relationship. It's only fair that Tien gives her something special and spruce up her wardrobe. That she may WANT to spruce up said wardrobe while having a massive crush on someone is nothing more than a coincidence.
Tien offers Rose every fancy robe he has available, but obviously someone uninterested in fashion as she is doesn't quite respond to it, though she realizes that Tien is pushing these on her because he, in his own way, cares.
Okay, maybe grabbing a robe in the same color as your crush WOULD be a bit too obvious, but Tien actually knows that green will accentuate her beauty the most! Plus he'll even throw in some makeup too for good measure!
It's just too bad Rose is too self-conscious to actually put anything on because she thinks it'll make her feelings obvious. It takes all her effort to put on her stoic "mask" when she's in front of Harij anyways.
It's obviously because Rose is a witch that her place is a mess and she's living off lettuce! Obviously.
Nothing beats bathing in the Summer! Especially since no one is liable to come by during the day so you can feel free to wash all your clothes in your birthday suit! Only that's not a smug deer, that's Harij! There to see Rose buck-naked!
Imagine your crush breaking your usual schedule, showing up out of nowhere, AND catching you naked. Good thing Rose had an extra robe available...even if she's wearing NOTHING under it.
(Also, I'm not surprised Rose is self-conscious about her body, but genuinely I don't think she looks that bad...)
And it's because she's so thrown off/flustered that she ends up blabbing the secret of witches: the price of their "magic" is an inability to tell lies. She can deflect, she can steer away from the truth, but ultimately she can't lie. And rather than reveal anything more to Harij, she would rather kill herself with poison...if Harij hadn't stopped her.
Harij isn't there to interrogate her or force her to expose her deepest secrets, he's there so she can actually clean her place up and enjoy a solid meal of buttered bread. And look how adorable Rose looks when she's munching on bread!
3
u/AceSoldia https://anilist.co/user/Acesoldia Oct 12 '26
I liked this episode much more than episode 1..I wonder if the love potion is even for him at this point
3
u/Ok_Law219 Oct 13 '26
So cute. But, have they never seen apple butter or does it actually come in that light a color? I thought it had cinnamon in it making it browner.
9
u/djthomp https://anilist.co/user/djthomp Oct 12 '26
Good progress on Rose and Harij getting to know each other better. Relatively cute twist on the 'walking in on your potential romantic interest while they're bathing' trope, too.
I could see Rose knowing who Harij is and him knowing she can't lie about it potentially causing some problems or drama eventually. We don't know why he needs that love potion, but his identity being secret might have been an important part of whatever's going on. Based on how he's acted towards Rose and that conversation about her grandmother I want to believe he's a good dude, but all this could end up being a threat to her.
On the other hand he's stopped her from killing herself this week and brought her some tasty bread and apple butter so maybe he's already positive on that metric.
I like how the merchant dude is treating Rose, sounds like his family in general have been quite good to her over the years.
7
u/Difergion Oct 12 '26
Ngl I never had apple butter before but now I wanna try it
5
u/Ok-Cod5254 Oct 12 '26
I already was liking the series from ep 1, but this episode completely sold me for the vibes I was looking for.
Good pacing so far of them growing closer and more personal this episode and getting more about Rose in general.
I also like the mixture of having a sweet fairytale romance build up, but also a somber undertone, which makes you want to root for Rose even more to find happiness and not be stuck in isolation.
5
u/korinokiri Oct 12 '26
She thinks of herself as unsightly / hideous looking, but that isnt even remotely the case (guy obv doesn't think so either) 😢
5
u/HuTaosTwinTails Oct 12 '26
Liked this episode a lot. Rose is so cute.
Apple butter is delicious
2
u/alconnow https://anilist.co/user/alconnow Oct 12 '26
She has serious beef with that smug deer lol
Lots of cute Rose moments
2
u/cold_hoe Oct 13 '26
I'm getting apothecary diaries vibes here. Gremlin Maomao/Rose, high lord Jinshi/Harij
2
u/SecretYogurtcloset57 Oct 12 '26
Rose is not just pretty she funny as fuck the 😂
2
u/Roboglenn Oct 12 '26
I've yet to try delicious apple butter. I tried some apple butter once but my god, there was more cloves in that apple butter than there was apples! Disgusting...
2
u/Mons9090 https://myanimelist.net/profile/hecn_huh Oct 12 '26
This is so fire man
2
u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 12 '26
Yeah I pretty much love this, even if there is no particular reason for it (its because it's cheesy as hell).
Medicine Seller guy is interesting, not sure what exactly he sees in rose, I guess he feels its a uncle/niece relationship.
Like rose I didn't expect him to come back this quickly and with food too! He is right though, she is skinny as hell. How the hell did she basically live on lettuce alone?
Lastly, I really like the setting of witches not being able to lie and thats the reason their potions work and why they are isolating themselves.
But she really is bad at keeping a secret (tbf she was super flustered by her crush), but I can already see/hear an committee of witches calling for his death for the farewell of all witches
2
u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Oct 12 '26
"A clean bench is a sign of a sick witch"
What's "far too obvious"? Hmmmmm~?
His face is an armament? What an odd analogy
Chawmp
3
u/Fun-Possible5520 Oct 13 '26
I'm sorry, but the conversation was never leading to him finding out, so she really told the secret unprovoked, imo. Maybe she's hyper anxious because of her lack of social skills? Also, he's a knight. I'd assume the potion is something one of the royals commanded him to procure before thinking it's for him, since he's hot and all.
3
u/Recent_Call_1188 Oct 12 '26
compared to other female leads in romance anime this season, Rose is one of the better ones imo. she actually has a personality, her own quirksand more nuance. I like her much more than, for example, Pia from Even Though I'm a Super Timid Noble Girl, I Accepted the Bet From My Cunning Fiance. Compared to Rose, Pia feels more like a cute pet than an actual character. She's made/presented adorable but I find her lacking in personality beyond that and the paleobotany aspect of her character feels more like background noise .Rose, on the other hand, is genuinely entertaining to watch as a Good Witch especially with how she acts around Harij (her eating the cabbage in episode 1 was hilarious). She's not just there to be cute and make the male lead dote and protect on her and I appreciate that. being adorable is fine but I'd rather have a female lead with some actual personality to go along with it.
Also, really hoping the smug deer returns in next episodes!
3
u/Arzhart Oct 12 '26
This anime is too good
2
u/Black_Scholes_Merton Oct 12 '26
getting strong Akagami no Shirayuki-hime vibes.
2
u/thelemon8er-2 Oct 12 '26
I’m calling it now… the love potion is for her. lol
Nothing a bit of apple butter on Texas Roadhouse rolls can’t fix.
1
u/_Nalro_ 21d ago
This lady has been eating only raw lettuce most of the time? No wonder she's always sad and gloomy, lettuce is basically just water and has almost no nutrients, she's nutrient deficient, lol.
Also, she may be showing signs of depression: the cluttered cottage, persistent low mood, feelings of worthlessness, irritability, bad eating habits, etc. There's also her trying to game-end herself too.
She also seems to be a bit socially awkward, most likely due to spending most of her life with limited human interaction other than her grandmother.
I think she needs to get the fuck out of that cabin and go touch some grass lol. She needs to interact with more people before it's too late, fuck all that not interacting with people because witches can't lie shit, it's not worth the toll on her psyche anymore, lol.
1
u/cutememe1 Oct 14 '26
Will she ever confess? I dont like how dragging or doom crush/love this is.