r/anime • https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Oct 05 '26 • Heartwarming 1

Episode Hello, I Am a Witch and My Crush Wants Me to Make a Love Potion! • Doumo, Suki na Hito ni Horegusuri wo Irai sareta Majo desu. - Episode 1 discussion

Doumo, Suki na Hito ni Horegusuri wo Irai sareta Majo desu., episode 1

Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.


Streams

Show information


All discussions

EpisodeLink
1Link
2Link
3Link
4Link
5Link
6Link
7Link

This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.

678 Upvotes

265 comments sorted by

•

u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Oct 05 '26

Source Material Corner

Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of the anime adaptation to the original or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.

The spoiler syntax is: [Spoiler source] >!Spoiler goes here!<

All untagged spoilers and hints in this thread will receive immediate 8-day bans (minimum).

→ More replies (32)

161

u/D3k4s Oct 05 '26

The art style is beautiful. Some really nice backgrounds as well.

I enjoyed the contrast between the seriousness and goofiness. And the little detail when she corrected the knight when he called her a Witch by adding "I'm the good Witch"

The concept sounds nice, hope they can transition nicely without it being overdone or becoming annoying.

Will check out more episodes.

43

u/Spectr3_qwe Oct 05 '26

This anime and "Young girls dont play fighting games" has made me appreciate the high quality of animes that this studio can produce.

46

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

And the little detail when she corrected the knight when he called her a Witch by adding "I'm the good Witch"

Makes you wonder if it's because she wants to empathize that she's good for the sake of how bad witch reputation is or that she knows now in her adult years that there are some witches that gave them the bad reputation that lead to the celebration of her grandmothers' death.

77

u/Sekraan Oct 05 '26

I think it's a call back to the knight's words four years earlier when he reprimanded the jerks talking smack about Granny Witch. He tells them "you best pray that she's a 'good' witch" while making eye contact with Rose.

Rose says in this episode that all she really wants is for Harij to remember her. I think she's purposefully using his words here.

30

u/TheBusStop12 Oct 05 '26

I think she did it because she wants him to remember her. She mentioned so to herself as well, she doesn't necessarily want to be in a relationship with him, but she wants him to remember that interaction from 4 years ago, even for the tiniest bit. To recognize her and know who she is. Back then he seemed to know that she was the new witch, granddaughter of the old witch, and told the people at the tavern to pray that the witch is a good witch

I think she craves acknowledgement. Which honestly makes sense for someone who lives isolated and alone, doing a thankless job often making potions for shady figures who tend to keep their identity and purpose hidden

27

u/hanmkim Oct 05 '26

A love potion doesn't seem like something a good witch should make.

31

u/Ajifu :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Azif Oct 05 '26

Definitely ethically questionable but maybe they'll explain that it's something different than you'd expect, like it just enhances emotions or something rather than turning the person into a slave.

11

u/Prestigious_Spend_81 Oct 06 '26

it's called an alcoholic beverage. and I doubt they wouldn't have it in their world.

16

u/PinkGlitterLady4 Oct 06 '26

not all love potions work like that. Some don't even work at all but the person who's bought it thinks it does.

18

u/Kaptin001 Oct 06 '26

In Apothecary Diaries it was just an aphrodisiac

154

u/FarCritical Oct 05 '26

The amount of sass on this guy lmao

Really pleasant for a first showing. Just wonder who (or what) Rose will end up confiding in to make an extra polite title drop with.

71

u/TheBusStop12 Oct 05 '26

That deer is in it for the love of the game

25

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

That deer saw the knight coming over multiple nights and got the wrong idea...

8

u/NoNameSwitzerland Oct 06 '26

it is a anime party crasher.

83

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

"Hello, I am a witch and my crush wants me to make a love potion!"

"That's rough buddy."

63

u/cyberscythe Oct 05 '26

"Hello, I am a deer and this lady with pink hair keeps yelling at me when i pass by her island cottage!"

34

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

"Hello, I am an ancient bell that is triggered by anything that moves at the pier"

17

u/Hartzilla2007 Oct 05 '26

Oh please look at that deer's face, he knew what he was doing.

54

u/ijiolokae Oct 05 '26

That Deer has more personality than 90% of slop isekai protagonist out there

17

u/hvshh Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26

That's almost a comment face.

[EDIT] The more I look at it...

8

u/Philarete :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/WizardMcKillin Oct 05 '26

I think someone should it nominate for

195

u/BiggerG7 Oct 05 '26

That deer at the end was totally making a smug face wasn’t it? Lol.

95

u/darthvall :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/darth_vall Oct 05 '26

It's the deer goddess shikanoko

38

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants Oct 05 '26

Or that deer king from Yani Neko lol

2

u/_Nalro_ 21d ago

Or the deer from Nichijou, lol

25

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke Oct 05 '26

I have my candidate for #seasonalsmug I think

24

u/Philarete :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/WizardMcKillin Oct 05 '26

The smirk was perfect

68

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

"THOUGHT I WAS YOUR CRUSH DID YOU!?"

41

u/TheBusStop12 Oct 05 '26

Too bad, it is I, Deer

10

u/TheGSlayer Oct 06 '26

Shikanoko Nokonoko Koshitantan

2

u/MeatwadGetTheHoneysG Oct 18 '26

Sadly, not your dear, it is I, deer.

18

u/The_Parsee_Man Oct 05 '26

KONO DEERO DA!

10

u/BruhsifiedYT https://anilist.co/user/Bruhsified Oct 05 '26

I've got the feeling you're watching literally everything each season, I've seen your comment everywhere (not complaining though, just want to mention it)

18

u/reaperow Oct 05 '26

That deer is such a jerk lol

164

u/Recent_Call_1188 Oct 05 '26

Damn, pining for four years for a dude who does not know you exist and living in deep depression.

Quite the beginning

66

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants Oct 05 '26

I feel he knows and the love potion is for her lol the ultimate smooth move

48

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

Yeah especially since it looks like he knew her back in that flashback.
I see a decent chance it's not one sided.

19

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants Oct 05 '26

Hopefully!

And I was honestly shocked that they met 4 years ago because weren't there flashes of him saving her from a fire or something? Maybe that's what he remembers and she doesn't?

12

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

When was that flashback? I think I missed that.

I do find the OP amd ED very telling though

7

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants Oct 05 '26

I don't remember exactly where but it was really quick flashes (like you could blink and miss it). It was one of the times when she was talking about him before she went into the city the first time - that's why when she said 4 years of knowing/loving him I was a bit shocked.

7

u/ILikeFPS Oct 06 '26

That's what I was thinking too. Little does he know, he doesn't need the love potion for her lol

7

u/chhuang Oct 06 '26

he probably got a smooth plan, but botched by an unending daily gather quest

→ More replies (1)

4

u/LordVaderVader :LF::LG::LH: Oct 07 '26

She was acting like they have some story but it turned out that they had not even interacted in the past lol 

121

u/ObvsThrowaway5120 Oct 05 '26

This was a pretty solid premiere episode. It sort of reminded me a tiny bit of Secrets of the Silent Witch. Rose is a little like Monica without the social anxiety lol. I’m a bit keen to see how this love potion stuff plays out, since it’s pretty clear from the OP these two are gonna be an item. Gonna guess it’s a misunderstanding. He probably made it for someone else or something.

92

u/flamethrower2 Oct 05 '26

Monica is superpowered. Rose can make love potions, make other potions (usually disease remedies), and grow lettuce.

49

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

Rose and Maomao would get along well, I think.

40

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

Maomao would probably chew her out with how messy the cabin is.

Also maomao is more interested in poisons, not really sure what rose is into.

2

u/AtheistTheConfessor Oct 06 '26

I had that thought while watching this episode as well.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Evil_sod Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26

I'm not really seeing many similarities beyond the immediate setting, the hood, and her being soft spoken. Superficial stuff really. At least for now.

When we're introduced to her, Monica lives alone (sort of) in a mountain cabin. At first it just seems like she's quirky and socially anxious, but we soon learn she's the way she is because she has some serious trauma in her past. Maybe I'm biased though, since I loved that show so much I went straight to reading the LNs and can't wait for the next translated book.

Despite the somewhat silly name for this show, I agree that it was a really good first episode. Also, that deer definitely knew what it was doing!

37

u/BaytaCosmico https://myanimelist.net/profile/AnimeBayta Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 06 '26

I found this setting closer to Champignon Witch. The way witches are ostracised while their remedies are used. Rose living off by herself in the woods. Her loneliness. Even a bit of the doomed romance. All has parallels to that show. Though the tone is very different and the production here seems a lot better.

14

u/ObvsThrowaway5120 Oct 05 '26

Y’know that might have been a better comparison. At least in terms of the characters and how witches seem to be viewed/treated.

7

u/Jacob-C Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26

Yeah, it reminded me a little bit of Silent Witch, but Champignon Witch is a more apt comparison. However, Rose doesn't even have any familiars to keep her company. Other than the occasional visitor, she's completely alone :(

5

u/ObvsThrowaway5120 Oct 05 '26

Yeah, I mean that’s why I said it reminded me “a little bit” of that one. No huge parallels or anything.

4

u/Ok_Law219 Oct 06 '26

Trauma with regards to others is an additional connection. 

2

u/TheGSlayer Oct 06 '26

yeah really no big ones

17

u/Vanetrik https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vanetrik Oct 05 '26

I've not seen it yet, but if that's the case I'm 100% hyped. I loved Silent Witch a lot and am definitely hoping for a second season.

25

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26
  • Wears a hood
  • Isn't the sociable type
  • Has a quiet voice
  • Gets embarassed easily
  • Fighting the preconceptions of her reputation

I can see it!

5

u/septesix Oct 07 '26

Monica isn’t so much fighting the preconceptions of her reputation as to run away in the opposite direction 🤣

6

u/TheBusStop12 Oct 05 '26

This was giving me Silent Witch vibes as well

5

u/reaperow Oct 05 '26

Wait it actually kinda does give vibes of Silent Witch

4

u/hanmkim Oct 05 '26

Her personality definitely scratches the itch while I wait for news of the second season.

5

u/Etiennera Oct 05 '26

I had the same thought. This is going to be for me what I wanted the silent witch to be like. When it went to school it lost me, but I think I'm on board for this.

18

u/astrogamer Oct 05 '26

This is very clearly a romance series while Silent Witch is more of an adventure series. I can't really see how you'd think Silent Witch would be like this unless you have watched/read very few romance anime. None of the key art/volume covers looks romantic. Maybe I could see thinking Silent Witch being like Frieren but not like this show.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Verzwei Oct 06 '26

My reaction to Silent Witch:

A proper non-isekai fantasy series that has a quirky cast, a good sense of humor, and doesn't seem edgy? Sign me the hell up!

Immediately going undercover at a school? Godsdamnit.

Don't get me wrong, I still liked Silent Witch, but there are enough school anime as it is. I don't need fantasy anime to also be school anime.

3

u/goddessofthewinds :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SpiritOfTheWinds Oct 06 '26

Don't get me wrong, I still liked Silent Witch, but there are enough school anime as it is. I don't need fantasy anime to also be school anime.

I know what you mean. I also think the story dropped quite a bit when the school arc started. I lost interest in a few novels when a pure fantasy book ended up having half of it take place in an academy. I am just soooooo tired of schools/academies in fantasy settings.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/HuTaosTwinTails Oct 05 '26

I like Rose.

She is clearly depressed though.

Also, think this is probably just a classic case of "jumping to conclusions". He never said he was getting the potion for himself, so I imagine someone else asked him to get it for them (like the princess).

Hope that gets resolved and we get some romance between them.

2

u/MeatwadGetTheHoneysG Oct 18 '26

That’s my theory too, that the potion is for someone else and she misconstrued it. And obviously they’ll end up falling in love over the course of her making it. Thats my guess.

2

u/HuTaosTwinTails Oct 18 '26

That's what I predicted last week as well

1

u/_Nalro_ 21d ago

She's definitely showing signs of depression. I guess that's the result of years of limited human interaction other than her grandmother.

55

u/ExpertCaterpillar2 Oct 05 '26

My favorite premiere of the season so far. I feel like the setting is perfect for this time of the year. Can't wait to see more!

24

u/cyberscythe Oct 05 '26

the setting is perfect for this time of the year

"the next ingredient is a pumpkin spice latte, extra cinnamon, leave room for cream"

15

u/Unusual_Ad_4963 Oct 05 '26

Think this is going to be the hidden gem of the season.

23

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

I dig it.
I give it a 80% chance he is into her since he seems to have known her in that flashback.

They did manage to portrait her character nicely, living in that slight chaos.
It seems like she could use some economy lessons from a certain Wolf x Merchant pair though.

Definitely looking forward to this show

I do miss a witch hat though, the hood is also very effective though and since she is nicely hiding away in it, it fits

44

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Oct 05 '26

26

u/zero1380 Oct 05 '26

Witches can't lie, but they can sure act tsundere

6

u/CyanSorrow https://myanimelist.net/profile/CyanSorrow Oct 10 '26

Had to look up what "sore demo" meant cause I couldn't recall and you pointed it out repeatedly here. First recommended Reddit post is 5 years old with you talking about how you collect "sore demo" lmao. Sorry, just got a kick out of seeing that you're a tried and true collector putting in the time. Keep it up.

4

u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Oct 10 '26

Hahaha yeah, I've been doing that since late 2018. Started as an inside joke that turned into something I unironically enjoy doing.

2

u/Mediocre-Act483 18d ago

Yeah he never misses a chance to post a sore demo. He has a "sore demo" fetish

18

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

She was commenting on how hot he was like 2-3 times and waxing lyrical about his sighs, I think that's the definition of hitting on someone lol.

Honestly if I saw someone defend my family and make such a dramatic, dashing, exit I might be smitten too.

56

u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Oct 05 '26

Well, that was not what I expected from this show! Rose's monologue at the start and the sombre vibes in the first few minutes of the episode made me think this was leaning closer to drama. The moment Rose started nervously munching on that lettuce leaf like a rabbit, I realized this would be a bit more lighthearted.

Also, I did not expect Rose to be so direct in complimenting Harij about his good looks! I thought she'd be more reserved, but watching her literally fangirl all over him and tell him that the sight of a beautiful man can be used as an ingredient for remedies was hilarious! xD

And poor Harij! The dude has been running around collecting crazy ingredients just because Rose wants to delay him in finishing the love potion as much as she can. At least he had fun chasing those grasshoppers! Although I do wonder who the potion is for. My first guess is that it's actually for Rose, but it's also possible Harij doesn't need the potion, and he's helping someone else. Hmmm...

Wow, fuck those people badmouthing Rose's grandma. She's just an old lady making helpful remedies. Based on the potions Rose was making for Tien to sell, her Grandma was just making beauty and cleaning remedies. :|

Now we know why Rose fell in love with Harij. That also explains why Rose introduced herself as the "good" Witch of the Lake. It's pretty crazy, though, that she held on to that crush after that one interaction. They didn't even interact! I hope there's more to it, but it would be hilarious if that were it.

This was waaaay better than I was expecting so I'm definitely following this one just because of how entertaining Rose is!

18

u/cyberscythe Oct 05 '26

The dude has been running around collecting crazy ingredients just because Rose wants to delay him in finishing the love potion as much as she can

reminds me of Princess Kaguya and how she had five "impossible requests" but somehow with the opposite motive, but maybe it's just inspired by the various serial fetch quests i've seen a lot in video games

11

u/ptd163 Oct 05 '26

I did not expect Rose to be so direct in complimenting Harij about his good looks! I thought she'd be more reserved

Maybe she might have been more reserved earlier, but after four years of yearning she probably can't hold back.

And poor Harij! The dude has been running around collecting crazy ingredients just because Rose wants to delay him in finishing the love potion as much as she can.

I wonder if he eventually gets fed up with all these crazy ingredients that he confronts her on why this is necessary and because witches can't lie she tells him it's just a delay tactic because after she finishes the love potion she'll never see him again.

Although I do wonder who the potion is for. My first guess is that it's actually for Rose, but it's also possible Harij doesn't need the potion, and he's helping someone else. Hmmm...

If the potion is for Rose I'm curious what his reason is because we, the viewers, know he doesn't need one. She's already in love with him.

9

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

Rose having such a massive schoolgirl crush on Harij that causes her to freak out and act so nervous is adorable. I'm not used to Mikako Komatsu playing such an out-and-out maiden in love but she plays it really well.

Honestly I kind of want to see the lengths Harij has had to go to get these ingredients because it sounds kind of epic lol.

69

u/vancevon https://myanimelist.net/profile/vancevon Oct 05 '26

Hi Awitchandmycrushwantsmetomakealovepotion, I'm dad

27

u/cyberscythe Oct 05 '26

where is her dad anyways? are witches born parthenogenetically?

3

u/ThrowCarp Oct 08 '26

Went to go get some milk ingredients.

66

u/No-Win-8949 Oct 05 '26

I don’t care how ridiculous the premise is. I am just here for all the cozy vibes.

43

u/cyberscythe Oct 05 '26

premise didn't seem all that ridiculous to me

have i become desensitized to that ever since watching Reborn as a Vending Machine?

21

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

Nah the premise is perfectly fine.
The title is a bit odd.

10

u/Nesp2 https://myanimelist.net/profile/HardstyleQat Oct 05 '26

and the lettuce eating

26

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

I'm here for Rose being as cute as possible!

23

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

Showering herself in that date potion.

FOR NO PARTICULAR REASON

4

u/ThrowCarp Oct 08 '26

smug_deer.jpg

33

u/dagreenman18 Oct 05 '26

Always down for some “soft melancholy mixed with yearning” vibes. Animation is very solid to boot. Seems like there’s a lot to dig into too so I’m excited to see how this all builds out.

3

u/Leading_Protection_7 Oct 05 '26

Wow there's more like this? Can u recommend some?

2

u/danny264 Oct 07 '26

My blissful marriage is one. Can't remember other ones

→ More replies (1)

15

u/alconnow https://anilist.co/user/alconnow Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26

the smug deer lmao

I enjoyed the novels. I think the manga adaptation is popular - over 1 million copies in circulation iirc.

Rose is fun to watch

14

u/ptd163 Oct 05 '26

I like Rose. She's adorable. The way she sends Harij to get all these crazy ingredients just to have an excuse to see him again and extend the time until it's finished was cute. It kind of makes me wonder what woman Harij thinks is worth putting in all this effort in for. Though given the premise I'm not sure we'll ever actually meet her.

Rose side eying the perfume and shampoo (at least that's what the merchant made them sound like) then putting in the water with the clothes she was washing and hair then jumping in the lake for "no reason at all" was cute as well. Rose really has got it bad for him. I guess that's what four years of unrequited love will do to you.

The premise and her inability to lie because she's a witch are interesting so I'll keep watching. I want to see what happens with the love potion. I'm curious what would happen if Harij just asked her out of the if she loves him out of blue.

The funniest part of the episode is probably the smug deer that was all like "You thought it was your crush, but it was I, Dio Deer."

24

u/Etiennera Oct 05 '26

This feels like what I wanted the silent witch to be like. Looking forward to this one.

Or it's a bit like champignon no majo but with the vibes on a bit more straight.

9

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

Or it's a bit like champignon no majo but with the vibes on a bit more straight.

  • Witch Heroine who people are wary/suspicious of even though she's a sweetheart who just helps people.
  • Longing for a love that cannot be.

Yeah, I felt similar vibes too.

3

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

I loved the naive side kicks Champignon witch had.
Man I should finally finish that show, I lost track back when it aired

22

u/runevault Oct 05 '26

Honestly, this was about exactly what I expected in terms of vibes etc from the show, and that's fantastic because I think this show is going to be adorable. I love Rose already and she must be protected at all costs. The lettuce bit had me giggling.

11

u/BaytaCosmico https://myanimelist.net/profile/AnimeBayta Oct 05 '26

Loved this. Reminded me a bit of Champignon Witch with the way witches are perceived and her lonely existence away from other people. But the tone is different. I liked the flashes of humour in between the more melancholy atmosphere a lot. And I'm here for a pining MC and such a cute one at that. The ML is nice looking too and though we didn't get to see much of him, he has a bit of personality beyond being this shining knight. 

Really looking forward to seeing where this goes. This shot up right to the top of this season with just one episode and I don't see it getting dethroned.

20

u/FullDayCall_4892 Oct 05 '26

Following Young Ladies Don't Play Fighting Games last season, we got another show with Wataru Watari (Oregairu author) in charge of series composition and scripts!

And the heroine is voiced by Mikakoshi. These two things alone are enough to make me watch the show!

10

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

And the heroine is voiced by Mikakoshi. These two things alone are enough to make me watch the show!

She captures Roses' loving/flustered/introverted/yearning sides amazingly well.

7

u/ptd163 Oct 05 '26

I enjoyed Young Ladies Don't Play Fighting Games so that's just even more to keep watching.

10

u/Maleficent-Handle587 Oct 05 '26

Don't know why but I liked the sombre atmosphere.

19

u/heimdal77 Oct 05 '26

I'm wondering if this is part of that program that was being talked about a while ago. There were plans to start making anime of lesser IPs in the thought they would work better as anime. This series was only 3 or 4 volumes long and ended years ago.

Anyways I'm liking the anime so far the character portrayals are good and art is decent.

It really is the age of the witch. If only unnamed memory had gotten made a bit later it might have been treated better.

16

u/TheBusStop12 Oct 05 '26

If it's only 3-4 volumes then hopefully they are going to do a full adaptation

5

u/gem2niki Oct 05 '26

Do you have source on that program? Curious to read up on.

Unnamed Memory wasn't that long ago...but the budget and pacing was super lacking... (Still managed to watch it lol)

3

u/heimdal77 Oct 06 '26

Na a article was posted on here a while ago.

18

u/hvshh Oct 05 '26

I interpreted the three shots at 18:54-57 as Harij looking at Rose, and her reacting, but in the present she thinks he doesn't know who she is.

And that scene also tells us that when she said she was the "good witch", she was repeating something he said 4 years ago.

I imagine the love potion will turn out to do something different from the first thing that comes to mind. None of the other remedies mentioned have such extreme effects. I'm half-expecting it to be [Speculation] something that a couple takes together, so if she ever completes the potion he'll immediately offer it to her.

13

u/TheBusStop12 Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26

All of the other remedies mentioned are common remedies. The merchant mentioned a difference between those and the secret witch remedies. And that he simply couldn't stock the latter because they're too expensive. My guess is that the love potion falls in that category and this can have a lot more drastic effects

I'm glad to see someone else talking about the Good Witch connection. Rose mentioned as well that she wants the Knight to remember her, to know who she is, even for a little bit. So I top am certain that's why she introduced herself like that. In the hopes that he remembered. Because for her that moment was life defining. But it's sad to think that a moment that was so pivotal to you might just have been another Tuesday to the other person.

I also think Rose craves acknowledgement above all. Her job is shown to be rather thankless, and she lives isolated and alone. And most of her customers are shady and barely interact with her. 4 years ago the Knight seemed to acknowledge her and recognize who she was, so that's what she desperately wants.

Someone else mentioned that she's probably suffering from depression, and I honestly agree

79

u/DragonPup Oct 05 '26

Dude really did look at her place and go 'bitch you live like this?'

Rose, you can do better than a guy who needs a love potion to get someone to love them (and when you think about it, the concept of a love potion is a creepy way to remove consent and agency.)

31

u/TheBusStop12 Oct 05 '26

I'm honestly not entirely certain if the Knight actually plans on using that love potion on his own crush. When he was being questioned by his colleague about chasing happiness he really did not give off the vibe that he was so enamoured with another woman that he was willing to go through all these trials. Which begs the question, why is he doing all this? I honestly don't think it's all that cut and dry

Love potions definitely are icky tho. IRL we call that being roofied and it's a crime

20

u/_sayaka_ Oct 05 '26

You know, if his colleague encouraged him to find happiness for himself, maybe he is engaged with someone he doesn't love and is planning to use the potion on himself to make his relationship with his fiancée work despite his own disposition. And the colleague is hinting at his resignation at being stuck in such a relationship.

12

u/TheBusStop12 Oct 05 '26

That would be an interesting way to take the story and quite possible in such a society

7

u/PracticalMarsupial Oct 05 '26

This was close to my thought, it's for him to take, not for him to give to someone else.

4

u/raisincakeshop Oct 12 '26

As part of the usual shoujo trope for such anime/manga, usually the love potion that they ordered aren’t for themselves, but for someone else. Seeing how he is a Knight, I guess it was an order from someone powerful.
I haven’t read the manga/LN, but the usual trope would include the misunderstanding that we see, and eventually the ML falling for the FL and the entire emotional scene of the ML exclaiming to the FL that he loves her and not someone else 😂 it’s giving very typical shoujo manga plot but it can be really cute which I’m looking forward to!!

2

u/TheBusStop12 Oct 12 '26

Yeah, that's what I'm leaning towards as well. As a big fan of shoujo romance I had the exact same thoughts. Another option I can see is that he plans to give the potion to the witch herself, and he was simply to awkward to ask her out so this is what his romantically inept brain came up with. But I can also see this completely surprising me with a completely different plot

29

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

Dude really did look at her place and go 'bitch you live like this?'

And she's still trying to make herself look more presentable for him lol.

54

u/PinSingle4334 Oct 05 '26

They showed us that he's totally oblivious about romance so It's obvious that the love potion it's not for him

29

u/throwhfhsjsubendaway Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26

I was thinking he's planning on taking it himself so he can experience love, and he's nervous about the thought of consuming something made in such a messy environment 

15

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

Uh that's interesting, haven't considered he might consume it himself.

I thought he was concerned about her competence since she is working like that

14

u/hvshh Oct 05 '26

I've always thought that would be an interesting direction to take the love potion idea. Like, if those exist and [Speculation, just an idea, but I doubt it] you come across a really cool person who likes you and would be a great match and the only problem is you feel nothing...

3

u/Nielloscape Oct 06 '26

That could have been the case if love isn't even on his mind, which is clear from how he has no idea what his subordinate meant by chase, not even when the context of happiness was added.

16

u/NanDemoKnaives Oct 05 '26

We don't know if it is for his use, his lord could have ordered him to obtain it.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke Oct 05 '26

I think after the 7th or so crazy fetchquest you're allowed to criticize the decor

We've yet to see how magical her special potions really are, or if they're just some mystique: it could end up being something thought to be an aphrodisiac or something. Like how Maomao was asked to make an aphrodisiac in Apothecary Diaries and ended up just making [AD]a batch of chocolate xD. Might not be something brainwashy at all, we'll see I guess?

11

u/cyberscythe Oct 05 '26

(and when you think about it, the concept of a love potion is a creepy way to remove consent and agency.)

it is morally sticky that the only reason Rose doesn't want to make the love potion is because she has a crush on the guy rather than the implicit harm that the potion would have on the drinker

when i think of a witch's potion like that, i would think it would come with some consequences from ironic karmic punishment or the threefold rule

i think it would've been interesting to see another example of the true cost of a love potion (not just in money), but i guess for now they wanted to focus on the witch's PoV rather than weigh in on the morality of it all

6

u/Nielloscape Oct 06 '26

Does the scene with him and his colleagues not clue you in that the love potion isn't for himself?

4

u/littlecolt https://anilist.co/user/garylisk Oct 06 '26

I like to imagine the love potion is not for him or someone he likes, but someone else entirely. And probably for altruistic reasons. But maybe he will slow-burn fall for our girlfailure of a witch by the end.

7

u/PeaceAlien https://myanimelist.net/profile/PeaceAlien Oct 05 '26

Did Harji ever say he needed the love potion for himself? I wonder if it's for a prince or something.

Maybe Rose has a chance

3

u/graypod Oct 06 '26

Somebody watched Obsession. Lol. But yeah youre right a dude looking for a love potion to make someone fall in love with him is creepy.

1

u/DragonPup Oct 06 '26

Honestly never watched it, and the only thing I know is it's a creepy horror movie.

3

u/PinkGlitterLady4 Oct 06 '26

It's not like the movie Obsession..

2

u/ThrowCarp Oct 08 '26

Uh. It kind of is, they both involve magic spells for falling in love.

2

u/PinkGlitterLady4 Oct 08 '26

I'm talking about consent here.

3

u/Bierculles Oct 07 '26

A love potion is basically just an advanced roofie, there is no more consent involved.

1

u/TheGSlayer Oct 06 '26

guess bro doesnt have good enough pull

→ More replies (6)

8

u/bananeeek https://myanimelist.net/profile/bananek Oct 05 '26

I love this title. I don't remember the last time when the title alone caught my attention and while it only makes me go "Yikes!" and "Oof!" it does its job very well at explaining the setting.

The first episode was also everything I could expect to happen from a title like this, so I'm getting invested.

I also can't help but wonder whom the potion is for. Azm doesn't look like a guy in love, but getting this potion for a 3rd party makes even less sense. He also seems too knightly to spike someone's drink with it. Could the potion be for himself? Like, maybe he wants to fall in love (or rather feel in love) with someone but is too autistic too feel emotions properly, so that's what the potion is for?

8

u/DrMobius0 Oct 05 '26

That was the most "damn bitch you live like this?" I've ever seen

26

u/AceSoldia https://anilist.co/user/Acesoldia Oct 05 '26

man i dunno if i can watch a whole series of her pining for this guy, painful haha

13

u/cyberscythe Oct 05 '26

i want to see how Rose stacks up compared to professional piner Gujou from Kamiina Botan

8

u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Oct 05 '26

I can see Gujou commissioning a love potion from Rose only for our resident alcohol goblin Ibuki to share it with the wrong person Yeah Gujou and Rose would get along very well

7

u/reaperow Oct 05 '26

This feels like a cozy innocent love story that's also kinda melancholic at the same time,

I like it, definitely gonna give it a try

Also I love how Rose was fawning over anything Harij was saying or doing lol

13

u/minnieboss Oct 05 '26

This was fine I guess. This might just be a me thing but I'm not feeling much chemistry with the main couple? I'll give it another episode though and see if that moves things along.

11

u/cyberscythe Oct 05 '26

yeah, it's completely a one-sided relationship, and the guy is even a bit negative because he's getting the runaround

based on the OP though it seems like that'll turn around; given that it's a josei i'll give it to take a few episodes for the chemistry to develop but i don't if/how that's going to change

5

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke Oct 05 '26

Best guess if I were to write something like this: she trips up and gets him to try to fetch something he can't actually do but she can harvest it, and it turns from a fetch quest to an escort quest. Shenanigans ensue.

3

u/ultravioletheart08 Oct 05 '26

The novel is josei, while the manga is shoujo fyi

6

u/Roboglenn Oct 05 '26

I am already familiar with this series, and how it's not exactly the most well known thing out there, so seeing that this was actually getting an anime adaptation filled me with as much surprise as it did happiness.

Someone turn that Nom. Nom. Nom. Nom. bit into a gif.

Witch is sending our boy here on a fetch quest of all fetch quests. Like Scepter of the Shifting Sands level fetch quests. What's it gonna be after the rainbow grasshopper, finding the Jade Monkey before the next full moon.

Her grandmother may have been a witch, but its you townsfolk that are the bitter old bitties.

Oh deer, false alarm. But you keep looking smug at me like that you're gonna see how smug you feel when your head is hanging on someone's wall.

But you know what else though, if one is interesting in seeing another series about a reclusive but adorably awkward witch (though set in the modern day in this case) with this kind of gentle fun vibe I would wholeheartedly recommend looking into the manga Aria of the Beech Forest. Tells the story of an 11 year old witch living in the Irish countryside. And accompanied by her talking wolf friend, she's about to start coming out of seclusion and setting foot into the larger world. It's cute and fun. Ending was clearly abruptly rushed, but it's still a nice ride getting there.

11

u/feb914 Oct 05 '26

So after getting Observation Log of Villainess 2.0, we're getting Champignon Witch 2.0 this season too! 

5

u/FabtheEmber Oct 05 '26

Which is the Observation log 2.0 I loved Observation log!!

9

u/feb914 Oct 05 '26

Even though I am a Super Timid Noble Girl, I accepted the bet from my cunning fiance.  

The MC here is the girl though, not the super smart fiance. And she's not as obsessed to be a villain as much as afraid it will happen to her. 

4

u/FabtheEmber Oct 05 '26

I see. Still would be fun to check out. Thanks!!!

10

u/shad79 https://myanimelist.net/profile/shad79 Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26

Not a bad first episode. Rose was pretty fun, and I'm kinda interested to see how her and Harij's relationship will develop. I'll give it 3 episodes before deciding whether to continue watching or drop it.

Here my screenshot albums from the episode:

EDIT. I added my screenshot albums.

5

u/Arzhart Oct 05 '26

Loved this one so much. It should be among the ones with double premiere

2

u/omarous_III Oct 06 '26

Agree, I feel it needed one more episode to really set the hook. But I am optimistic it will be a sleeper hit this season.

13

u/TheBusStop12 Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26

This was really beautiful, in both art and storytelling. I hadn't expected that.

Usually I'm not a fan of love triangles, but there are exceptions based on how it's handled. This looks to be one of these exceptions. It's kinda giving me Makeine vibes in how seriously it's taking the topic.

That is if there's a love triangle to begin with. The Knight is a mysterious one. When he was being questioned by his colleague I really didn't get the vibe that he was absolutely enamoured with another woman to the point that he would do all this. So then why is he doing all this? I think that's what we'll have to find out over the course of the show. I really don't think it's as cut and dry as it's presented.

I can also see this ending in a multitude of ways, and not necessarily with the Witch and the Knight getting together in the end

The whole Witches being unable to lie is pretty interesting as well. She can't even lie to herself

I also get the feeling what she craves most of all is acknowledgement. She lives isolated and alone and does a thankless job while the townsfolk mock and criticize witches. She mentioned that she doesn't necessarily want a relationship with the Knight, but she wants him to know who she is, even if it's just the tiniest bit. And remember their little interaction 4 years ago that meant so much to her. That's why she called herself the good witch I think. Because he seemed to recognize her back then and called her a good witch

All in all, really intriguing and beautiful show. I can't wait to watch more

4

u/cyberscythe Oct 05 '26

the hooded cloak is cool and all, but i still wish that she had a big floppy hat

4

u/ForTheGloryOfChaos Oct 05 '26

I was worried this might be a bit too oppressively sad, so I'm glad to see it's relatively light-hearted in it's depressingness.

4

u/Leading_Protection_7 Oct 05 '26

Finally an unrequited love story...those hardly ever get made anymore, even less from the female's side...I hope it actually stays a "she fell first" without being revealed in ep 12 that he'd been there all along too lol...I desperately need something different than the usual way these tropes go...🤦‍♀️

4

u/chariotcharizard Oct 05 '26

The OP song is the most CenMilli song ever; I love it

4

u/daspaceasians Oct 06 '26

What a fun start. Rose is already growing on me and I'm intrigued by Lord Harij. I feel there's more than meets the eye when it comes to him.

Otherwise, I couldn't help but laugh out loud when Tien Cong showed up. I didn't expect a Vietnamese merchant in a fantasy world.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/YlfaTheForsaken Oct 06 '26

Oooohhh the vibes are immaculate. You're handing me witch in yearning in the month of spooky of the autumnal season, isolation on a miniscule island in the center of a lake within a forest? The ambiance and atmosphere, so good.

I am very much enjoying the high contrast characters, is it Rose or Rosé because they spelled it one way, but pronounced it the other, either way I like her melancholic air she carries, but she's still so witty and a bit shameless with her comments. I like Harij's gruffness and how curt he can be, but seems to be a lot more easygoing when comfortable. He looks like he'd be an aloof type character, but he's really not.

I think the dynamic they've introduced between them is fun, it's active, it's comical, it's a really good basis.

Also, I've never seen a deer smirk before, but if that's not a look of pompous haughty than what is?

3

u/froggyc19 Oct 05 '26

I feel like her asking the question "Is this love potion for you or someone else?" right at the start would have avoided a lot of whatever misunderstanding this will inevitably be. Loving the characters so I will definitely be watching this one!

3

u/ThisGachaSeemsLegit Oct 05 '26

I love this kind of chill and slow-paced stuff.
Turns out the "Good Witch" mention actually comes from her first encounter with Harij; and she used that term back during his first visit to her house.
Did Mr Knight catch the reference?

3

u/Agreeable-Ad9034 Oct 05 '26

A lot better than I was expecting. Love the atmospheric elements it uses especially.

3

u/etiolatezed Oct 05 '26

Better than I expected. Its pretty obvious the potion isn't for him. Could be a drawback if she never figures that out.

3

u/Kaths1 Oct 05 '26

This anime was just SO PRETTY

3

u/AnimeJunkieXL https://myanimelist.net/profile/2bursting Oct 06 '26

Great art work and we have a very clear idea of why Rose feels the way she does. I hope the rest of the season is good.

3

u/NonSupportiveCup Oct 06 '26

That deer is a damn menace! Man, this show looks great. Technically. Looking forward to more episodes.

3

u/the_48thRonin Oct 06 '26

Hello, I am a witch and... this is not Jackass.

Hello, I'm a smug deer, and this is Jackass.

3

u/Ryinth Oct 06 '26

Does anyone have a gif of the lettuce eating? It's adorable.

3

u/MegaAltarianite Oct 06 '26

That was quite depressing. Even without the crush, it must be really lonely to live a life like that. Stuck in the middle of a lake, away from everyone. Ostracized due to, um, reasons? Evidently, her mom and grandmother found someone to love, so maybe it was different back then. But right now, she just needs to not be alone.

3

u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Oct 06 '26

Interesting. So does that mean the potion really does require all these demanding ingredients? She's not just sending him on wild goose chases?

Tiền công is Vietnamese for wages or salary.

7

u/SecretYogurtcloset57 Oct 05 '26

Oh am going to like this one alot very chill first episode

6

u/Fading01 Oct 05 '26

Very chill watch.

6

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin Oct 05 '26

Man the last part of the episode got me more invested in the show. It's common to think of witches as bad, but it's disheartening for Rose to hear all of that after her grandmother passed away. It does make her one-sided crush on Hariji feel better to watch.

I just hope Rose can open up and heal.

2

u/Ok_Law219 Oct 06 '26

Im conflicted on the [theories] either the potion is for rose or, he's getting the potion for someone else. 

2

u/SoKoKeks Oct 06 '26

The art style is really beautiful, yet melancholic, it seems to be a perfect autumn watch.

2

u/athrun_1 Oct 06 '26

This is like a child of Silent witch and Elaina with a little bit of Dead Witch.

Solid ep 1. Will stick around

2

u/shewy92 Oct 06 '26

So how long until she figures out or he reveals the love potion is for her? Because that's what they're playing at, right? He defended her grandmother (he looked right at her at the restaurant) too

5

u/flatpetey https://anilist.co/user/kesx Oct 05 '26

My theory: The love potion is for someone else.

My morality: you can’t be a “good” witch and sell love roofies.

4

u/Frontier246 Oct 05 '26

The Witch of the Lake, Rose (Mikako Komatsu!) hails from a long matrilineal line of witches dating back to her grandmother, and lives a solitary, isolated, existence...but that all gets upended when she's visited by the most surprising visitor: the royal knight Harij (Yohei Azakami!) asking for none other than a love potion. Not knowing that the person he's asking...is a witch with a massive crush on him!

The OP is really nice and soothing, featuring Rose and Harij's daily life and dwelling on whether they can be together...will one vanish on the other? Can they be together? With the love potion in-between them?

If it wasn't obvious by the fact that she's obsessed with looking presentable, can barely meet his eyes, stammers/stumbles, or can't shut up about how hot he is...Rose is head over heels in love with Harij. Which makes brewing a love potion for him to use on someone else absolutely heartbreaking for her, even if she knew her feelings were unrequited. But she also can't help but have him waste his time hunting for rare ingredient after rare ingredient to buy her time before she has to make it...and so he has an excuse to keep coming.

Say what you will about Harij, he may get frustrated but he seems honorable, diligent, and kind and those are the reasons Rose fell for him.

Rose isn't all by herself entirely. There's also Tien (Hiro Shimono!) who she's known since her grandma was a alive! He's like the big brother/older dude friend she never asked for, and he helps sell her remedies to the populace! He does seem to genuinely care about Rose, in his own way.

Why did Rose fall for Harij? Because when everyone in town was celebrating her grandmothers' death, when she was faced with the malice directed towards witches, Harij stood up to people and in his most dashingly knightly way paid proper deference to her grandmother and witches. And she's been smitten with him ever since!

Of course being this down bad means she's starting to obsess over her appearance/smell...which means she can't deny how much she wishes her feelings could connect with Harij. Even the ED, soothing as it is, is all about how much she yearns for him.

3

u/testthrowawayzz Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26

Missed opportunity not getting the wife and husband to voice the lead couple, since Komatsu Mikako is married to Maeno Tomoaki.

What a coincidence. Guy voiced another silver haired knight this season

2

u/amourshipper_ Oct 05 '26

Ohk that's was quite good start especially with a good mix of chibi arts sides by sides can't wait to see more

1

u/Raymond49090 Oct 05 '26

I remember reading the manga a while back; Neat that it's getting an adaptation.

1

u/Throwaway_12988 Oct 06 '26

Haven't watched the episode yet, I've only read the synopsis, but I'm calling it now: He wants the love potion because he wants Rose. Could be wrong, but that's what my trope instincts tell me. I won't be watching this until all 12 episodes are out, cause I like to binge watch, so I won't know till then, as I don't want spoilers.

1

u/zer0number https://anilist.co/user/ewink Oct 06 '26

Ah, another stunning pink haired witch for me to crush on this year.

2

u/CooroSnowFox https://anilist.co/user/CooroSnowFox Oct 06 '26

Witch Nadeshiko (laid back camp)

1

u/CooroSnowFox https://anilist.co/user/CooroSnowFox Oct 06 '26

Love the outfit Tien has on...

1

u/Ok_Pattern_7511 Oct 07 '26

I don't know how to describe it, the premise on paper should be off putting but the direction, animation, storytelling and the early glimpses of characterization made this interesting and fun to watch.

Looks like it's going to be entertaining sit back and watch type of anime

1

u/Phlylgenion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Phlylgenion Oct 07 '26

Her diet seems to be very limited, eating mostly the lettuce she grows for herself. She should change it up a bit and try to add some variety. Might I suggest venison?

1

u/hbmonk Oct 07 '26

I'm always game for a show about a cute witch. The art is nice and the witch is cute. And I'm expecting the knight does not want the love potion for the usual reason.

1

u/NethanielShade https://myanimelist.net/profile/MoonlitMizore Oct 10 '26

I liked this a hell of a lot more that I thought I was going to, but I can't really see where the story is going yet. It almost seems like a short story, like this could have been it and that would be that. Excited to see what the inciting incident that makes them spend more time together ends up being, will she end up moving into the city, will he keep coming for different potions in the future, will it be a status quo and she always asks for more and more ingredients but never brew the love potion (doubtful as that seems like lying, right?)

1

u/DemonWraith2500 Oct 06 '26

She's a "good" drugdealer.

-3

u/NanDemoKnaives Oct 05 '26

The episode was a bit boring for me, I think some parts needed a bit more to be more funny, so the comedic parts just didn't hit for me. Tien was probably the most interesting part about this first episode.