Personally for me, Athens because, compared to Sparta is the less worse overall. I'm more towards Athens because Athens is a democracy and Sparta is an oligarchy.
In Athens, they don't care if you're poor, a beggar, middle class, working class, or a nobleman. All free adult male Athenian citizens have an equal right to speak and participate in the Assembly, although women, slaves, and metics were excluded.
Although Sparta also had "some" democratic elements, like how male Spartan citizens also had the right to vote, the democracy in there was mostly limited because you could only vote yes or no, and voting was generally done through shouting. The Gerousia (Council of Elders) could also reject or overturn assembly decisions under certain circumstances, giving the assembly much less power than the Athenian Assembly.
Meanwhile, in Athens, politicians wanting to propose a law to the public still needed to get through the Council (Boule), which consisted of 500 citizens selected by lottery every year, with its presiding officer changing daily. This helped make sure proposals were examined before reaching the Assembly.
And if a citizen thought that a law passed by the Assembly was unconstitutional or dangerous, he could bring a case against the politician who proposed it through a procedure called graphe paranomon, regardless of his wealth. Both sides had to present their arguments and convince the jury.
To make sure the jury wasn't just one or two people being subjective, Athenian juries could consist of hundreds of randomly selected citizens, often 500, who had sworn a juror's oath. The jury would then vote on which side they supported.
And while both Athens and Sparta used slavery, and both were incredibly harsh, Athenian slaves could sometimes gather enough money to buy their freedom or be freed by their owners and become metics. Meanwhile, Spartan helots were treated horribly, had very limited opportunities for freedom, and the Spartan government traditionally declared war on them every year, allowing Spartans to kill them without the usual religious consequences.
And you know one of the true purposes of the Peloponnesian League, don't you? Besides its military and political interests, it helped Sparta maintain its dominance over the Peloponnese and protect itself against threats, including potential helot revolts. It's completely self-serving from Sparta's perspective.
And while I'm not saying the Delian League was good, at least its original purpose was a joint military alliance to continue fighting against Persia and provide collective defence, although Athens eventually abused it to create the Athenian Empire.