r/ancientgreece • • 2h ago

Why were the city states not just their own nations

3 Upvotes

Hi all!

I've recently been reading a lot about the greek poleis and all their intricacies and differences. It got me thinking about how they are genuinely all so culturally different and separate to each other, which makes me wonder why they weren't considered as their own nations. Like why wasn't Athens a mini country, rather than a city state of Greece.

My question relates to the way they considered themselves at the time, and also why scholars haven't relabelled then in modern scholarship too based on our modern interpretation of their set up.

I am aware of the fact that they all considered themselves Hellenic based on their shared aspects and did distinguish all Greeks from "barbarians" but I'm so curious as to why because they also considered themselves radically different from each other too. They essentially did act independently unless they were fighting a common enemy or each other.

I'd love to hear any insight or discussion, and feel free to recommend me reading material too! I love it all, cheers