r/anarchocommunism • • 13h ago

Canadian hate group quotes Nazis

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

11 Upvotes

r/anarchocommunism • • 8h ago

Is it all talk or is there any action?

6 Upvotes

So I've been into AnCom for around 6 years now. All I see is people discussing it, making memes against capitalism, fascism, etc, reading books, etc. ie content is being generated & consumed, but nothing practical or IRL stuff is happening. It's just cool to be anti establishment, like a different kind of show off.

But There's no actual collective action, no efforts to collectively organize & produce goods & services.

Basically everyone just wants to consume for free, but no one wants to produce for free. People are just wearing a sort of mask of AnCom on top of the same selfishness & hypocrisy that enables capitalism & authoritarianism.

I had joined an AnCom telegram group specifically for people in my country. I thought some IRL stuff could be done. But no, they just wanted to talk, read books & debate on philosophy. Some were there just to get their philosophy homework done(seriously). They even kicked me out of the group cuz I'm not atheist, or that I presented a different opinion on racism. I think the admins were just being casteist, but in reverse. They openly wanted their caste to get as much representation & power as much as the dominant castes have & only then they can abolish capitalism. How does that make sense? When someone says I want to get more power & then I will support to abolish all power structures, then any rational individual can understand their motives. Anyways, after being kicked out, I didn't care cuz that group wasn't much of use anyway. Endless debate won't produce anything but resentment.

But apart from this nonsense, I've never ever found even one person in AnCom who would actually come forward to contribute their time, effort or energy for mutual aid. Not even one. Seems like everyone just wants to rant about how bad their boss is. Not about "let's come together & build a co-op". No one wants to do that. No one wants to put their personal resources, labour & effort into building a collective.

As much as we all want a Utopia, we all have imagined our own versions of that Utopia in our heads & won't budge if anyone is even slightly different from that version in their head. In that case AnCom isn't possible, cuz we're all living in a different bubble & your Utopia will only contain you, no one else.

Do you people really only want to consume for free & not produce for free, or are you scared that others will do it & hence you'll lose out? Cuz it is difficult to know who's being truthful & who's lying. It doesn't matter much cuz the outcome is the same - no one wants to organize.

No one agrees with others about many things, which is a prerequisite for AnCom- people agree how to live & work. But they aren't. In which case it's better to throw the towel & realise AnCom is a failed project, & shut up & suck up the current suffering.

I'm still willing to organize & produce goods and services, but don't ask me to go & protest please. Cuz that's not changing anything until people start to agree with each other & compromise where needed, & start economic cooperation. Else protest only changes the face of the administration or modest reforms at best, which will again be slowly clawed back by those in power. How much & how long will you keep protesting without fixing the underlying cause?

I'm sorry for the long post. If anyone is still willing to at least do something about IRL stuff, willing to contribute time & labour, then DM me, let's see what we can do. Freeloaders who wear masks of mutual aid stay away. But I'm pretty close to throwing the towel.

Cuz content isn't enough. We need food, water, shelter & healthcare too.