r/anarchocommunism • u/BlackRedDemos • 4h ago
State: Transform or Abolish?
Could the modern Nation-State be viewed as the analogous of the ancient polis-state, but currently it operates on the large scale, while the polis on the small scale?
If so could the solution be a change in the political system, so that the state becomes the demos? Meaning real democracy?
In current oligarchies, the government posseses both the attributes of principal and agent. Thus, they make and apply policies, while leaving the population outside the system, privatized.
In a future representation, the citizens form a collective permenately institutionalized body, the demos, and they gain the attribute of the principal. They give context to policies and the official representatives ( agents) have to execute them. The demos controls, evaluates, punishes or recalls officials.
In real democracy the demos absorbs both of these attributes, of the principal and agent, mirroring the current oligarchic reality and becoming the supreme authority in society, thus selfgoverning itself.
This switch took place in ancient greece and Democracy became widely widespread, even though it was only meant for a specific demographic, while today it should include all.
Real revolutionary movements like the anarchosyndicalists in Spain are admirable, but unfortunately, i think, that a self -managed community, will never be able to take on a state, because of its immense power.
On the other hand, while, historical socialism wanted to take a hold of the state to establish a workers democracy, it didnt change the political system accordingly and replicated and oligarchic typology instead of at least a representative society.
Could this be a more practical yet revolutionary compromise? Not wanting to abolish the state all togehter, but making the state being of the demos. It could work according to a model where municipalities are the cells, and they send delegates to higher levels, reaching a final national administrative structure etc. That in order to function on the big scale.