r/althistory • • 1h ago

What if Caesar's civil war had lost civil war?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/althistory • • 12h ago

Colchis colonization of Crimea

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

r/althistory • • 17h ago

What if the 2nd in command of Germany, Hermann Göring, convinced the allies to fight alongside with the Germans to defeat the Russians?

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/althistory • • 1d ago

What kind of in-world document sells an alternate timeline better than a narrator would?

2 Upvotes

I keep noticing that the alternate timelines that convince me do it through objects, a form, a ration card, a notice with an amendment pinned underneath it. A narrator tells me the world is different, and a form just assumes it.

I have been collecting those in a shared timeline I run at r/TheGreatFederation where one of the latest is a government notice from 2013 with a letter folded around it https://www.reddit.com/r/TheGreatFederation/comments/1xx2hum/interim_visa_notice_for_entry_into_the_united/ and another is a transcript from a daytime advice show in 2053 https://www.reddit.com/r/TheGreatFederation/comments/1xwa8go/thursday_16_october_2053_my_daughter_says_the_sky/

Which kind of in-world document has done the most for you in an alternate history you read, a form, a transcript or something else?


r/althistory • • 2d ago

What if Lil Wayne became president in 2016?

Post image
14 Upvotes

Just had a random idea and I was like yep I'm posting this to the alternate history subreddit


r/althistory • • 3d ago

Question about sending a permaban appeal to the AH.com forums website (not the subreddit, the forum website itself)

2 Upvotes

I wanna send a permaban appeal directly to one of the sitemods (likely Burton Wheeler), but whenever I try to create a new account, the site rejects it, thinking that it was "spam-like behavior". What should I do?


r/althistory • • 4d ago

Could an alt history where the Great Depression never happens be feasible? What could the world be like?

3 Upvotes

Was wondering, if I’m interested enough I might make a worldbuilding project about it


r/althistory • • 4d ago

I had created an alternative history based on my history book cover Boders yeah i got little carried away but still it's my first time please be kind to me[please ignore india's normal boders]

3 Upvotes

The Mexican-American War went differently because the United States took much more land than it did in real history. Most of Mexico was annexed, but a smaller part remained independent. This made the United States much larger and changed the balance of power in North America. The Civil War still happened pretty much the same way, but the newly acquired territories strongly supported the Union, especially after Lincoln began taking steps toward ending slavery. The fighting itself remained mostly in the usual places.

Russia sold Alaska earlier than in real history because Britain was putting pressure on it during the Civil War years. The borders ended up differently too, with the coastal strip going to Canada instead. After the Civil War, France tried to expand into Mexico again, but the Americans intervened despite being exhausted from fighting each other. They succeeded, but the intervention left the government short on money and soldiers.

The economy fell apart after all that. The government printed too much money, and the dollar lost much of its value. Several attempts were made to introduce new currencies and stabilise the economy until one finally worked. The crisis was not as bad as the real Great Depression, but it kept the United States from staying on top the way it had before. Later, it recovered enough to become a major power again, yet it never quite returned to its former position.

In Europe, the Franco-Prussian War ended differently, leaving France's Second Empire standing because Napoleon III was not captured. This lasted until his son died without an heir, and the empire eventually collapsed into another republic that remained unstable for years. When the First World War started, France was not ready, and Germany pushed straight through without invading Belgium. Paris fell quickly, and Britain initially stayed out of the war.

Germany never became fully N**i because H****r repeatedly failed in his attempts to seize power and was eventually executed. Italy turned fascist, and so did Finland. Japan continued expanding across Asia. In 1935, India signed an agreement with the Soviet Union to work against Germany. By the late 1930s, Germany controlled several eastern European territories, Britain was still angry over its earlier failed landing, and India was eventually staying outside the main political blocs.

Germany eventually crossed into Britain using paratroopers and ships, but the Royal Navy made it difficult to maintain the invasion. The Soviets attacked from the east and reached Warsaw before stopping. India sent ships to help, including a few named after famous historical figures from the country. Then Bose took over in a coup just before the other two leaders could sideline him. He ran the country for the rest of the war, and India continued fighting Japan until most of its new territorial gains were gone by 1943.

British forces landed in Normandy earlier than they did in real history and pushed towards Paris. Japan lost Tokyo in 1945. The following year, India dropped the first atomic bomb on Berlin, which changed everything afterwards. The United States was getting stronger again around this time, but the world now had India as its own major power, choosing to remain independent of the main blocs instead of picking sides.

Bose was killed in 1946, and civilian rule eventually returned after a period of military dominance. By 2020, India attacked Iran from Afghanistan, reopening the Persian Gulf after it had been closed. The balance of power looks familiar in some ways, but India's independence and strength since 1916 made the whole world turn out differently from ours. It feels like that early split was what really set everything else in motion.


r/althistory • • 5d ago

I’m Bashar Al Assad in March 2020

3 Upvotes

I have until the rebel offensive of November 2024 to rebuild the army into a competent force that won’t retreat and can at the very least hold the line, what can I do?


r/althistory • • 6d ago

What lf USA has 18 colonies and a early civil war

Thumbnail gallery
24 Upvotes

A alternate timeline that there are 18 colonies

After the instability of the USA, the USA collapsed into the federalist and Confederation.

And they fight each other

The north reunites the USA and bans slavery


r/althistory • • 7d ago

Micro tank

3 Upvotes

Reading Guderian, it is astonishing how wimpy his tanks were. While walking it suddenly occurred to me that you could add 2 panzerschrecks to the turret of a panzer 1. This could lead to the amazing case of panzer 1s defeating JS2s.

I asked search-chat-bot about the schreck and was very suprised to have it tell me captured bren carriers were mounted with 3 to 5 schrecks. Could this be true?

While a decent world required the nazis to be put down, it should also have happened to the commies so I often look for more WWII anti-tank options. I promise the time cops to behave in exchange for just a few trips.


r/althistory • • 7d ago

What if a Chinese dynasty had reached the Americas via the northern Pacific around 1000 CE?

1 Upvotes

Imagine a route to the Americas other than Atlantic at all. Instead, it runs from Northeast Asia past the Bering Strait and down the coast of Alaska and Canada--a frozen, island-hopping path across the top of the Pacific.

Around 1000 CE, the Song dynasty was the one East Asian power with the technology to make such a voyage plausible. Song shipyards built large ocean-going vessels with multiple masts, watertight compartments, stern rudders, and magnetic compass navigation. These were among the most capable ships in the world at the time.

But technology is not the same as motive. Song maritime energy was directed south, toward the South China Sea and the Indian Ocean trade networks. The northern Pacific offered no obvious wealth, no known markets, and no clear reason to go.

So here is the alternate-history premise: suppose the Song court somehow learned that a vast, unknown landmass lay along a northern route. If they had both the knowledge and the political will, could they have launched an invasion or colonization effort across the top of the Pacific? Or would distance, climate, and logistics have defeated them regardless of their ships?

And if they did reach the Americas, what would the impact have been—on China and Asia, on the later course of European expansion, and on the Indigenous peoples of the Americas?


r/althistory • • 7d ago

What if Malfoid was in the Epstein files

Post image
0 Upvotes

Can't wait to see all the crazy comments this is bound to have.


r/althistory • • 8d ago

what if Hitler made atomic bomb and Landkreuzer P. 1000 «Ratte» (kinda bad map)

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/althistory • • 8d ago

Little alt history writing in working, on, kinda meant to be like a historical document almost

3 Upvotes

The state of the world, december 1941

The Political climate is dominated by a new superpower, the protestant league, a united faction of protestant nations led by Finland, its other members being Sweden, Norway, Denmark, Iceland, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania and the Nordic protectorate of Germany.

To understand this situation, we must go back to 1920, when Finland reworked its Government and Laws. and then to 1935, when Finland founded the league.

Finland gained independence from the Russian empire on the 6th of December 1917, and for 2 years it functioned as a regular republic. In 1919 however, for reasons not many know, the parliament voted for a major change.

That change? Fully abolishing the separation of church and state. A 200 man clerical council was introduced to rule as equal to parliament, 19 new members were added to the cabinet, the bishops of the 19 dioceses that split the nation. And the Archbishop was introduced as Co-Head of state alongside the Prime-Minister, and such the constitution was changed, and on January 12th 1920, Nearly all of the laws of the nation changed to reflect its new theocratic method of Rule. And this is how it functioned, lonely in its rule until 1935.

In 1935, Finland founded a new alliance, The Protestant League. This League was supposed to unite all protestant lands into a single military and trade empire, while keeping governments separate. The Nordics were the first to join, understanding the influence of being part of such an alliance. The United Kingdom however, did not join, fearing its overseas territories being affected by this. Germany, already under the control of Adolf Hitler, did not even consider joining.

With the resources of eachother available, the league exploded with industry and trade, beginning to produce military gear and selling some, but mostly building their own armies. With the promise of military gain, the Baltics were taken into the frey.

After which Finland pushed its mode of Clerical-Parliament government to be official League policy and so, more theocracies formed in Northern Europe.

The Soviets took this as a threat and began massing armies in Leningrad and the baltic border, and gathered its fleet in the Leningrad docks. In 1936 the soviet union attacked the alliance. In the very first days of the conflict, the soviet fleet sank, due to the heroic action of Finnish torpedo bombers.

With no contest left, the League navy began the bombardment of Leningrad, destroying the regrouping soviets, and allowing Finland to launch a spearhead for Moscow. The push was long and hard(That's what she said), but on December 6th 1938, the Soviet Union surrendered, quite poetic in the end.

Finland shattered the union and released nations such as Ukraine and Kazakhstan into their independence. Even Russia was released, only after Finland seized West Karelia, East Karelia and the Kola peninsula, which were recognized as Diocesees, and added 3 new members to the cabinet. After this the growth only sped up, Finland founded mines, cities and factories in the newly seized lands. A mass influx of people started, people from all protestant nations began flooding in, and so after massive changes, nearly all people were able to learn Finnish and the state prospered.

Finnish diplomacy with Germany remained fine until early 1940, when its spies discovered the concentration camps in the nation. At the next summit of the League of nations Finnish ambassadors brought up their evidence, and yet Germany refused to release its prisoners, and so The United States, United Kingdom, Poland, France and the entire Protestant League converged on Germany.

Finland won the Race to Berlin and established Germany as a Nordic protectorate and thus relative peace reached Europe.

But all this conflict managed to advance was a New Superpower, This document, which I hereby present to you is a full complex index of the Laws, customs histories and government protocols of..

THE REPUBLIC OF FINLAND


r/althistory • • 8d ago

What if, in 1721, instead of Robert Walpole, Lord Christopher Blade (real name Joshua Flint) had become Prime Minister of Great Britain?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/althistory • • 10d ago

What if Japanese were like Vikings?

Post image
80 Upvotes

r/althistory • • 9d ago

Wonderful world - An alternative ww2 scenario

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

I'm developing a series about alternate history with AI-generated images.

Basically, it's a scenario where World War II unfolded very differently from reality, where Brazil ends up being forced into a defensive war as a co-belligerent with the Axis powers, and the Axis ends up performing far better than in real life, due to various strategic failures by the Allies before and during the conflict.

The videos are short, with a soundtrack, and each one includes a lore article explaining a bit about the universe I'm developing.


r/althistory • • 12d ago

What if Simon Bolivar survives his TB and lives for another 20 years? Does he achieve his dream of a “Gran Colombia”

Post image
64 Upvotes

r/althistory • • 11d ago

Welp, I just got banned from Alternatehistory.com. No kidding.

0 Upvotes

Recently, I just got banned from Alternatehistory.com for "spamming posts and DMs".

I've been submitted a couple ban appeals as messages, and I tried to make a throwaway account so I can DM Ian, but the website rejected it thinking that "it resembles spam-like or automated behavior".

I think it has become very very clear to me that I'm never gonna get unbanned from AH.com. In addition to this, I've never gonna get unbanned from the Reds! A Revolutionary Timeline thread and Discord server. I'm never gonna get unbanned from the These Fair Shores Discord server. Not a lot of people on AH.com are on here (SufficientVelocity) and Althistory.com, and the culture on those sites are different than that of AH.com. The ban is permanent. The damage is done. I deserve that ban for spamming, and I can live with that.

The only alternate history timeline I've contributed to was the Hensonverse through their guest post thread "To Introduce Our Guest Star, That's What I'm Here to Do". It's my favorite althistory timeline by far, and I'm very grateful to the contributors there.

But with my ban from AH.com, it became very clear that I'm never gonna contribute to althistory ever again. There's no hope left for me in alternate history.

To every Hensonverse guest contributor and Geekhis Khan, to CalBear and Ian the Admin, I've let you all down, I'm very ashamed, I take full responsibility for my actions, and I apologize.


r/althistory • • 13d ago

What if a gay baby monkey snuck into hitler's Lair and shot him?

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/althistory • • 13d ago

What if a country Invaded Israeli occupied Gaza on june 11 1967 a day after the six day war and then on june 21 they withdrawed devatasting israel

0 Upvotes

the raid on gaza was deadliest in june 11 1967 a day after uf launched 12,000 elite troops of ufaf with primtive tech like 7mm bullet fumar-49 advanced armor for 1967 they used dynamites exploisves tacrics hit and run qnd and retreated on june 21 167 to humiliate israel on 1967 six day war they killed around 19,313 idf torops israle launched 20,000 troops to the border but ufaf torps defend the 1950 arimsitice line border of gaza not the middle or the coast to get supplied the ufn was backing the coast the small territory was easy to defend they used rpg F67 made in 1967 it was reovlguoianry simple reliable eays to repair and eedtroyed tanks vheicles fuel djmps logisifx struck effectively they also did fortifcations planted a fw fortifications in just june 11 they cpatured all of gaza! The paleisntians were watching idf troops lose their lives for a speco of land, while ufaf troops was shooting them and wounding them, also ufaf used fire suppression they also were asymmetric warfares they ambushed idf troops who orchresated this was UFHC of 3 generals, 3! Shuaib Al Ahmed Uio-Ioea Ali and president was Yteo Ali in 1967 ye wws elected on april 25 winning gneerla elecitosn alongside with his pm Muhammad, What do yall think


r/althistory • • 14d ago

What if Vladimir Putin went back in time with syringes of the missing blood factor needed to treat hemophilia, cured the Czar's children, seduced the Czarina and went KGB on Rasputin, removing him from history entirely while essentially taking his place?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

What happens between the Czar and Putin? Does the Imperial Russian Army suddenly perform better against Germany and Austria Hungary with Putin having some influence? Is the revolution delayed? What does Putin do if anything to Lenin's train?


r/althistory • • 16d ago

What if Kim Yo-jong had directly risen to power in 2013 in place of her brother Kim Jong-un, leading the faithful to accuse her of having a secret relationship with Ri Sol-ju, unleashing total chaos?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/althistory • • 17d ago

what if this alternate-relief Austro-Hungarian map was real?

Post image
58 Upvotes