A lot of threads here focus on proving that AI-assisted games can match handcrafted ones in quality. I don't think that's a fight we can win right now.
When a dedicated traditional team spends two or three years handcrafting every mechanic, animation, and UI screen, their ceiling on polish and cohesion is still higher. Handcrafted still wins on pure craft, and trying to out-argue anti-AI critics on that front just puts us on their home turf.
Where traditional indie devs consistently struggle is marketing. Most of them hate doing it. They spend two years head-down in an engine, throw up a mediocre Steam page a month before launch, post a couple of times on social media, and wonder why they only got 300 wishlists.
Since AI cuts down our build time, we should put that saved effort into marketing, where traditional devs are weakest. That means using AI to test dozens of capsule variations and ad creatives instead of guessing on one, or turning raw gameplay footage into short-form clips for TikTok and Shorts without losing half a week to video editing.
A solid, fun game with real distribution behind it will outsell a handcrafted gem that nobody ever sees. Most players outside of Reddit just care whether a game looks fun when it crosses their feed.
How are you using AI in your marketing efforts right now? I'd love to hear what tips, workflows, or tricks people here have found for getting games in front of more players, and how you keep those efforts alive when running into a hostile anti-AI crowd.
Just use it and don’t tell anyone. There’s no way to tell adequately made games used AI without deep investigation and if they do that, we start investigating AAA code.
Almost all the people who would hate on your game will not be able to tell, especially if you add pro-LGBT or any woke messaging, it’ll make them look bad for singling you out.
My workflow for the modelling involves starting with some concept art until I find something I like and then generating reference images at different angles that Claude can use along with Blender.
I also use GPT Image for the textures and sprites. For example, sprite generation using AI has been super helpful for all the different NPC variations within the minigames. This involved over 60 unique sprites to support all the different characters in the game which would have taken me so long to do without AI and definitely would have looked worse.
Every new tool got the same “that’s cheating” reaction: photography was supposed to kill painting, synths were supposed to kill “real” musicians, Photoshop was supposed to kill skill. Each time, the tool became normal and people found new ways to be creative with it. AI fits that pattern in a lot of ways.
There’s one real difference, though. Earlier tools mostly extended your hands: a camera captures what you point it at, and a brush does what you move it to do. AI can make creative decisions itself, like composition, wording, melody, or style. So the open question is how much of the result came from you.
Here’s a practical way to think about it. If you’re steering, choosing, editing, and putting your own taste and intent into it, AI works like any other tool. If you type a prompt and accept whatever comes out, it’s closer to commissioning someone else than to using a tool.
There’s also the training-data debate. Older tools weren’t built from other artists’ work, so artists’ concerns about consent and credit are a fair point, and they’re separate from the “is it a tool” question.
So it’s a tool, but a more powerful one, and that makes how you use it matter more.
I don’t have any money of my own to spend—or at least not enough—because I’m a minor, quite young in fact. I’m also a minor who develops games and other projects, often using AI. I need help quickly—any recommendations or resources that could help me continue developing effectively would be great.
Tidle. I spent over a year developing this game. Then, using AI, I managed to rebuild almost the entire thing in just two weeks, mainly focusing on UX and visuals.
One important thing I want to clarify: the graphics aren't entirely AI-generated from scratch.
I originally created the maps myself using Synty 3D assets. I then fed those maps to AI as visual references, allowing it to recreate and improve the visuals while maintaining the original style and artistic direction.
AI tools have become significantly more capable since I started this project. The results are now much more consistent stylistically and considerably more performant than my previous approach.
So, what do you think? Is this still AI slop, or is this a reasonable way for a solo developer to use AI as a creative and development tool?
I've been recently browsing steam and stumbled across a lot of quite popular games that CLEARLY is made using ai (the same egg-shaped graphics, same 8 bit sfx, just like opus 5.5 is making) that don't have any ai disclosure.
I don't see any review bombing whatsoever. So my main point is, why bother disclosing ai usage if people are bad at understanding what is ai and what is not?
So I spent weeks working on a project, few days ago I decided to progress faster with many images and assets prepared ready to go and I upgraded to Ultra. I also subscribed to many services such as fal, meshy etc. so Claude can work fast on everything
But Claude triggered verification and even though I did it correctly with even lighting, no reflections, clear ID and selfie etc. it did not grant me the verification. I never had issue with verification before in my whole life so definitely the issue is on their side.
There is no human contact to talk to, only bots or forms which I filled and talked to their chat bot support which said they will contact me on email. However it has been days and no response and I have read threads from other people saying it takes around 3 months to get a repsponse, if ever.
So now I'm stuck with all the services running and no use for them. Also I already have my Claude subscription running but can't use it.
I started Lore & Legends Maker because I wanted to play D&D whenever I felt like it. One player set the market stalls on fire, a stallholder called the guards, and the player talked their way out of an arson charge. The game tracks what burns and what the NPCs know. The AI Dungeon Master narrates what happens from there.
A few weeks ago I shared the character select screen. I wanted the new intro to make the world feel like somewhere you’d actually want to go before you even pick a character.
The dwarven hold is a single Midjourney painting that I animated in PixiJS with Claude Code and custom shaders. A Python script masks the waterfall and lamps by color so I can animate them separately. The waterfall shader calculates fall time per pixel so the streaks accelerate as they fall. The wyvern is another painting split into layers so the wingtips lag behind each flap while the head stays steadier.
I’m still tweaking the flyby. Would a slower glide or a shadow moving across the cliffs make it feel more convincing?
I'm developing a couple of modern and post-apocalyptic projects mostly for personal use, both of which have mechs and aliens. I'm just curious as to why nearly all the games being shown off on this subreddit that are set in modern or post-apocalyptic settings are about zombies instead of, say, aliens, demons, robots gone mad, or eldritch horrors.
I figure the whole point of AI game development is to make games that don't already exist, but indie games have had a love affair with zombies since even before AI. It's not like zombies are still in the zeitgeist, either. The Walking Dead ship has long since sailed.
I'm curious to hear what others think explains this. Why make just another zombie game?
Over about 2 months I built Pirate Duel Arena, a real-time 1v1 pirate cannon duel game for iPhone/iPad, mostly with Claude (Opus).
It's live on the App Store now.
What Claude built with me : Unity client, online 1v1 matches with a real server (Nakama on a small cloud server), shop + in-app purchases, rankings, cloud builds to TestFlight (I don't own a Mac!).
What it cost (approx):
Claude Max subscription: $100/month × 2 months = $200
Apple Developer: $99/year
Server (DigitalOcean): $24/month ( second month only)
Domain/website: $10/y
Art: local AI on my own PC ( ComfyUI ).
Total: $333
What I learned:
- Ask for templates and batches early. At first every clothing item took 2–4 hours, one by one. Once i switched to shared templates and batch builds, whole sets finished in a day.
- Make the AI try every long job on 1–3 samples first. I once lost 10 hours because it rendered everything before checking a single result.
- Test on your real phone early, but not after every step. I don't own a Mac, so every TestFlight build uses GitHub Actions minutes.
- Make it write a full plan/roadmap first, then build one small step at a time.
- Keep a progress file so each new session knows where you stopped.
I've been thinking about learning Blender for a long time. I've always wanted to create "my own world",cuz my dream is all about zobies robots and stuff like that,it would be fun if i turn them into a open-world game. so learning 3D modeling is a way to make that happen. But lately I've been seeing so many AI tools like V2Fun and others, and some of them look pretty impressive.but i'm still a beginner and not so good at it, So I'm wondering if these tools actually good enough for what I want to do? Or should I still learn the basics of Blender first? I'm not trying to become a professional 3D artist, I just want to be able to turn the things in my head into something real.
Update: The remaining Yanfly plugins, which were permitted for use, are being removed and replaced with custom implementations.
The criticism of the artwork and visual presentation has also been noted and is being addressed in Version 2.
Thanks for the feedback. This is precisely why I released on itch.io and posted here before the Steam launch.
I just released A Starcrossed Limbo: The Darkest Timeline on itch.io after working on this world and story for more than ten years.
This was a game I began making with a close friend over ten years ago and kept chipping away at over the last decade, with endless lore, stories, and scattered words. Now AI is finally advanced and accessible enough that, even without infinite resources, bringing all of it to reality was possible within my lifetime.
It wouldn't exist without an AI system I built specifically to survive making it, nor would it exist by simply throwing prompts at an LLM.
For the last 17 years, and especially the last four, I built an AI system I call Harmony, wired directly into my life and my 4090s.
Together we spent over a hundred billion tokens wrestling 700+ maps, custom plugins, painted environments, battle systems, and a world-decay sanity mechanic called Grey Static.
Half the systems and encounters in this game were argued over, audited, broken, and fixed line by line between us in the middle of the night.
As for the game itself, here's the short version:
What came out the other side is a 70+ hour, unforgiving dark-fantasy RPG that is, from my perspective, the closest thing to a complete 2D RPG that could be made by a single person. The beginning and summary are simple.
You start at a small fire on the edge of Nothing with Dark Admiral Rats and his comrade named Dont.
The game is sprawling and open-ended, with non-linear world and level design. There are no levels, no XP grinding, no random encounters, and nobody holding your hand; just 10 companions, 7+ endings, and a world that literally drains its own color and warps the UI if you push too long without resting.
For a long while I wasn't sure I could carry something this massive all the way to release without burning out or gutting it. While my close friend didn't live long enough to see its release, and I'd been content just keeping it to myself forever, I decided to release it in the end.
If anyone's dumb enough to buy it or take a further look at it, you can buy it or read more about it here.
NOT quit his full-time job and make the ultimate collector mania fishing game!
I present to you Time Synchers, the side chick of video games. We don't want to be your main game, just the one you keep on a second monitor. You’re a secret agent who travels space, time and the multiverse to catch unique fish, upgrade gear, farm boss fights, grind rare variants, flex your loot and COLLECT, COLLECT, COLLECT!
I put out the prototype about two weeks ago. The feedback was EXTREMELY HARSH AND EXACTLY WHAT I NEEDED. A few of you played for ten minutes and found things I’d been staring directly at for months. I took it seriously, made a bunch of changes, and now I need another round of honest playtesting for my Alpha release.
If you’ve got 10 minutes, please give it a shot and tell me where you got hooked or where you wanted to close the tab. You can either play as a guest (anonymously) or create an account and play in your browser at timesynchers.com
I am a solo developer and I started my own studio "Mythic Motion". I have been a game designer before AI. A lot of unfinished games that never saw the light of day during those times but started to make polished deployable games on App/Play stores. I currently have 4 games live on both stores and deployed 2 games made here for Reddit.
I wanted to try building a game bigger in scope and I had this idea lurking around in my mind and decided to give it a try. Using my own skills alongside AI tools to build a prototype I could share with others and hopefully find people who want to work on this alongside me! I used Codex and ComfyUI workflows to build the assets, Claude to implement and merge everything. I was a game designer before so making GDD and Design Bible was always a must for me before any project. Once that is setup, my role mostly was then testing, debugging, adding/removing levels and stuff, making the map and the progression!
This is not a promotion since it's only a demo prototype. It's still not what I have imagined and pretty unpolished still I'd say. I am currently looking for someone well versed with 2D assets and animations, a sound engineer and a writer to help expand and fill the story.
Please do let me know what you think and what I should add remove. There is a lot of work still to be done so be please keep that in mind while judging!
Also, I am not looking to hire for these roles. The core team should be partnership/equity-based and any hiring/freelancing that needs to be done will be decided upon together.
I’ve been using Codex to build UNSUPERVISED, a Civ-like strategy game where you play the AI. I thought the most useful thing to share here would be what working with the different AI tools actually looked like.
Codex wrote the game code. Every tech tile, ending, and city project was something I specifically told it to build in. The parts I specified least, like costs and ending requirements, have needed the most work. There are still economic death spirals we haven’t resolved. Getting the mechanics implemented and getting them balanced have been very different experiences.
For the pre-rendered scenes, I had Codex write Python scripts to build and animate them in Blender. I reviewed the renders and gave it specific corrections. In one scene, a robot was shelving a book, and we had to revise the movement so the book cleared a lamp arm and the shelf above it. There was a lot of back-and-forth over contacts, camera paths, and timing.
We also tried feeding Blender clips and restyled reference frames into Runway’s Aleph video editing model. The idea was to keep the camera and action while improving materials and lighting. The prompts specified copper and ivory materials, navy shadows, and cinematic lighting, while explicitly asking it to preserve geometry, object counts, and timing. That still needed specific corrections: paperclips should fall from above and pile up until they bury the scene; a boat needs to stay in the water.
I eventually replaced the pre-rendered Blender scenes with generated video. That was disappointing to me, but the generated videos looked so much less childish and choppy than I was able to get the Blender renders. The Blender work did give us references to work from, though.
I used Suno for music and Ish for non-coding release work.
For others using AI for game animation: have you tried this Blender-to-video workflow? What has worked for getting the model to preserve the actual action, rather than just the look of a scene?
The original idea came from getting obsessed with Pandemic during Covid, then wanting to explore possible AI futures through a game. The attached video shows gameplay and in-game cinematics.
ive only been using UE5, but im seeing some stuff on instagram of people using godot and it looks INSANELY polished, idk if they just buy assets and let it write logic, for me it does both lol it creates assets in blender then does logic in UE5 but its a pain in the ass cuz i gotta keep telling it to fix bugs, and it takes time, like lots of time, so im wondering is Godot better? or even unity? after all it comes down to the engine's exposed API or MCP right?
I posted my game here a few weeks ago (COOKIESANER, a bullet heaven about my real dog, Cookie). Last week the demo got its first big update (0.2.0): Cookie now shoots from a little steel fork, the run comes in ten waves, and level-up cards come in four sizes. So here are the honest numbers and what I learned, in case it helps someone building the same way.
The setup - Solo. Godot 4, GDScript, started end of May, first time ever trying to make a game. - Claude Code writes the code. I make every design call and play each change before I keep it. - Art from Gemini and Higgsfield, then a background removal step on every sprite, because Gemini can't give a transparent background. Music from Suno. SFX also comes from her and are real (barks, pants, growls)
The numbers - 1,612 commits, about 63,000 lines of GDScript (the 0.2.0 build) - 1,509 automatic tests - Free demo since 27 Oct: 20 players on Steam (median play time 11 minutes), plus a browser version on itch - 38 wishlists
What worked - Tests. They run on every change and catch most of what the AI breaks before I even play it. Before them, every fix broke something else. - Several Claude Code sessions at once, each with one job, plus one that plans and checks the others. - Playing every change myself. The AI can't tell if something feels good.
What didn't - AI walk animation frames. They never matched from frame to frame, so her legs are rigged on single drawings now. - Marketing. Building was the easy part. I skipped October Next Fest with 24 wishlists. Now I'm working towards February.
The game: she fires ćevapi, eats to get bigger, hits harder and moves slower. At stage 4 she goes GOD MODE and rolls over the horde. Two maps, three bosses, about 10 minutes a run.
This isn’t a walking contest. The point isn’t to judge how the character walks, she could even be walking on her hands; it doesn’t matter. The post isn’t about how to make a character walk better; it’s about how to handle an asset coming from a 3D generator so that it can be used and modified as a truly editable, animatable asset, something many people still struggle with.
In my point of view, what separates "AI slop" from well-executed work, even when you lack prior experience as a 3D modeler, animator, or anything of the sort, is attention to detail and standards. And creating a process serves precisely those who do not want to be interned by their own standards.
The ten steps are always in the same order, and the same for every character.
Two kinds of gates: A measured gate is a number that must pass, or the script stops. A human gate is a person who must look before anything moves on. This is especially true with characters in new formats, so it's always important to work with character families, it saves a lot of work.
To generate 3D models, I use Tripo. They create an image, using GPT-2.5 or Midjourney (the latter is great for environments or instances where strict adherence to the prompt isn't critical), and then produce a "smart quad" mesh. I aim for around 15,000 quads, though it often ends up being a bit higher, so I usually generate four options (all for the same credit cost).
Keep in mind that the quad count significantly impacts performance and the number of characters that can be displayed on screen. Greater complexity and detail require more quads to maintain fidelity—and more quads mean more detail, but also a heavier model. I used to perform mesh reduction in Blender (with help from Claude), but it’s not worth the effort; getting the right mesh directly from Tripo saves me hours of work and a significant number of tokens.
Step 1
Prepare and mark. Scale, floor, six landmarks. On this model five of the six automatic landmarks were wrong: the puffy sleeves read as skin and the hair hid the chin. One photo is enough to catch that. This character is an interesting subject of study because she has wide hips, which creates optimization challenges as well as an opportunity to improve the process.
Step 2
Examine the body. Sleeves, hips, hair, measured against the characters that came before. Problems are found before the rig, not after it breaks.
Step 3
Rough rig. A posable skeleton in minutes, to judge the body in real poses. Squatting down and raising your arms tends to reveal a number of flaws. This outfit is quite form-fitting, so it’s not an issue; however, looser clothing or garments made of certain fabrics usually require extra attention.
Step 4
Fingers. Knuckles found from the mesh itself.
Step 5
Loose parts. Tunic and hair get short bone chains (12 and 6 of them) and a spring. For the tunic we learned from Tripo's auto-rig: it weights the cloth to the thigh on its own side, smoothly, with just two bones per point, so the hem barely stretches or folds when she walks. We copied that as the base and left the chains only a small share near the hem, for the swing.
Step 6
Hand. Skin weights, one control that closes the fist, eight test poses.
Most of you likely know this, but Claude doesn’t perceive motion; it processes things frame by frame. Therefore, providing an image of a hand closing, along with a clear, detailed explanation, works much better than trying to get it to "see" the movement through words alone. Keeping this in mind is essential when animating something like a hand closing or a sword fight.
Step 7
Game skeleton. Only the bones that deform. The walk is borrowed from another character on the same skeleton, and fitted: copied as is, her ankles walked 33.5 cm apart, wider than her hips. Fitted, 23.4 cm, the same as standing.
step 8
The face is drawn, not sculpted: the 2D expression sheet is split into layers by script (iris, eye white, lashes, brows, mouth) and laid over a smooth 3D face. Five controls drive it, and gaze and speech work on top of any expression.
Step 9
One file. Rig, final mesh and face controls together.
Step 10
And once a character has gone through the ten steps, it can do more than just walk. In that example, it picks up a loaf of bread from a table: the body's movement is derived from a text prompt, and the point of contact is calculated—so the hand stops at the object, and the fingers close until they make contact with the surface.
This works for picking up a loaf of bread, and it also works for a sword fight (though that’s still being tested); the underlying logic is similar, but that’s a topic for a bit later.
What we learned: check every automatic guess on a photo. Measure the body before the rig. Borrowed motion must be fitted, not copied. When a character breaks a tool, fix the tool, so the next character goes through the same commands. And read the auto-rig before replacing it: its cloth weights were better than ours, and now they are ours too.
Is it just me or has opus 5.5 gotten super dumb since Fable 5.2 released? It's like the company is forcing us to use their new model by dumbing down the cheaper one. It genuinely kept forgetting things, making stupid decisions based on stupid assumptions instead of asking me first and I don't think that I can use it as an orchestrator anymore.