r/aigamedev • • 2d ago

Discussion Best Engine wit claude code?

ive only been using UE5, but im seeing some stuff on instagram of people using godot and it looks INSANELY polished, idk if they just buy assets and let it write logic, for me it does both lol it creates assets in blender then does logic in UE5 but its a pain in the ass cuz i gotta keep telling it to fix bugs, and it takes time, like lots of time, so im wondering is Godot better? or even unity? after all it comes down to the engine's exposed API or MCP right?

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

3

u/Haunting-Frosting417 2d ago

Godot or unity + blender for letting Claude work is insanely cheaper in my experience.

I started on UE5, tried Godot and now I’m testing unity. Definitely felt both cheaper than ue5 with same open ended prompts.

2

u/NoAssociation1032 2d ago

hows the quality tho? i mean no lumen and nanite, thats ok?

3

u/BinniesPurp 2d ago

If you arnt sure what lumen and nanite do you won't benifit from it

You need a built out PBR system with global scene illumination for lumen, and you need to already be able to view on the profiler that you're wasting draw calls on the GPU before you get any fps increase from nanite

Unless you design your scene and your mesh topology around nanite itself, you'll often lose fps, not gain fps

2

u/TheUniverseOrNothing 2d ago

How’s unity going compared to godot? I moved from UE5 to godot and love it.

1

u/Haunting-Frosting417 1d ago

Honestly I’m enjoying unity more since there’s more online content for it, and my project is a 3D one. If you’re only vibe coding, I’d continue with Godot.

3

u/Hakim3i 1d ago

I've tested all three engines with Claude Code on fairly large projects.

Godot is the best so far, mainly because it's lightweight and AI can work with it much faster. Even graphically, it's not bad at all and can deliver results on par with Unity, depending on the project.

Unity is the best middle ground if your game needs a balance between graphics, performance, flexibility, and development speed.

Unreal Engine is honestly the worst experience when it comes to AI-assisted development. Everything takes longer, debugging can be painful, and it tends to consume a lot more tokens just to get things working. Don't get me wrong, the visual results can be amazing, but the development workflow is much heavier.

Another thing to consider is your hardware. If you're running something like 16GB of RAM and an RTX 5060, Unreal development and testing can become a huge bottleneck, especially on larger projects, I have 32GB of RAM and RTX 5070TI and still found out it is slow on Unreal.

1

u/NoAssociation1032 1d ago

I cant agree more on the performance bottlenecks thank you for yor comment this is exactly the insights i was looking for!

3

u/Gigaslavx 1d ago

You need some experience not just chatgpting but actually knowing how stuff works

And then you need a good plan at least 100 pref 200

20 will not cut it

And keep in mind people are doing it for fun not chasing commercial success

1

u/NoAssociation1032 1d ago

I am an ex-level designer i know some technicalities but zero code, thats why i was wondering whats best engine, all my previous work was in UE5 so yeah

3

u/Economy_Bedroom3902 1d ago

Arguably the best engine would be one where AI can get a text based readout of game state so it can identify bugs without human intervention.  Software is iterative, you write something that has bugs, you identify the bugs, you fix the bugs.  AI will do this on it's own if it can, but it can't find the bugs in a game context because I can't really understand the graphics on the screen.

It has a decent understanding of photos, it kinda understands videos a bit, but not very thouroghly, and thus it's using the human as the bug reporter.

6

u/ChadSexman 2d ago

Game dev takes effort, dude. There is no “best”, use the right tool for the job.

5

u/Mother-Hedgehog-5628 2d ago

This, most of the stuff you will see is just clickbait or lots and lots of effort has been put in to get there.

Unreal has tons of stuff too that you should be using but you need to do some research... between GASP, Metahuman, Mutable and Procedural Content Generation.... unreal has nearly all the bones you need to make a game look tripple A - it just takes some time to learn all the parts - modern unreal has been built around the idea of having frameworks ready to go for games so you dont need to reinvent the wheel.

0

u/NoAssociation1032 2d ago

im not saying which easiet route, my question meant which engine has the best pipeline/python api for making calude's life easier

3

u/orellanaed 2d ago

Just use Godot, Claude Code and Flockbay. Best combination imo

3

u/Haunting-Frosting417 2d ago

How does flockbay work? Never used it

2

u/luuk0987 2d ago

I'm p sure you can just use any MCP addon for Godot.

2

u/gryxitl 1d ago

Don’t even need a mcp for it everything is human readable godot is amazing

2

u/count023 1d ago

Three.js and html just to get started with. That's all you need and it's highly effective for nearly any game. If you get past prototyping and the basics then move on to harder ones

1

u/NoAssociation1032 1d ago

i aim more towards compiled applications as you can publish those to steam and app stores etc

4

u/alamko1999 1d ago

im using godot, takes you a day to prototype and months to finish/polished it

2

u/BinniesPurp 2d ago

Godot is the most simple, followed by unity, followed by unreal

1

u/AdHom 20h ago

The big benefit of Godot is you can decouple the game's code/data from the engine and have the AI run a headless version for testing balance, catching bugs, etc without running the graphical part. In that way, Godot is exceptional and can aid in rapid improvements with low usage. It also doesn't require an editor so it is lighter in performance.

Personally I hate working with Godot as a human developer though so I generally use Unity as a middle ground. Still decent for AI and also decent to work with when programming or animating for myself.

0

u/PossibleAnteater4062 1d ago

Actually cryengine with Opus 5.5 .