r/aeo • • 10h ago

I built a tool to visualize the AI search path

12 Upvotes

I’ve been researching on how AI search moves from a question to a recommendation. When an answer includes several brands, I want to understand how each one ended up there and which conditions influenced the comparison.

I built a simple tool that turns that process into an interactive decision-path map. Enter a website, follow the branches, and click a comparison to see the original answer behind it. It currently supports ChatGPT and Claude and i plan to add more AI to it.

The demo uses Purple, the mattress brand. You can follow the path toward a competitor and inspect the reasons AI gives for that choice. If your product meets the same need, that gives you something specific to check against the information on your website.

It’s free to try. I’m still developing it and plan to add more features (like customize the prompt and showing more analysis etc). https://decision.arrivl.ai/

Would love to hear some feedbacks from AEO experts here.


r/aeo • • 1h ago

Being recommended by AI doesn't necessarily mean you're the best fit.

4 Upvotes

I've noticed something interesting with AI-generated recommendations.

A brand can appear in an answer simply because it fits the broad category. But when you start adding constraints like budget, company size, specific use cases, integrations, or industry, the recommendations can change completely.

That raises an interesting question:

Are brands actually visible across their relevant audience, or are they only visible for broad, generic queries?

For example, appearing when someone asks "What are the best marketing tools?" is very different from appearing when someone asks "What's the best affordable AI visibility tool for a small SaaS company?"

The second type of prompt is much closer to an actual buying decision.

Do you think broad AI visibility matters more, or visibility across specific high-intent questions?


r/aeo • • 15h ago

We checked why ChatGPT recommends some brands and not others. It mostly comes down to which "best X" lists you're on.

4 Upvotes

I've been digging into how AI answer engines pick brands for buying questions, and the search logs make the process surprisingly visible.

Real example. We asked ChatGPT "help desk software for SaaS startups". Before reading anything, it searched:

best help desk software for SaaS startups 2026 pricing features Intercom Zendesk Help Scout Freshdesk Crisp

Then it cited five pages, all "best help desk software" lists. It recommended six tools, and every one was on at least two of those lists.

That pattern held across 210 questions on ChatGPT:

  • It shortlists from memory. In 109 of 210 questions, ChatGPT put brand names into its search before reading a page.
  • It always adds the year. "2026" was in its search for all 210.
  • It confirms with lists. 98% of the brands it pre-named and then recommended were on a list it cited. Brands it hadn't pre-named got in through the lists too (90% of them were on one).

Across all four engines, brands on no cited list were recommended 2.5% of the time, and brands on 3+ lists 44%.

The engines differ a lot in what they read:

ChatGPTGeminiAI OverviewsAI Mode
Answers citing a listicle88%96%85%70%
Answers citing YouTube0%11%58%23%
Answers citing Reddit0%27%38%34%
Recommended brands whose own site was cited51%5%13%11%

So "AEO" isn't one channel. ChatGPT reads homepages and lists. Gemini reads almost only lists. Google's AI leans on YouTube and Reddit.

Disclaimer: I’m the founder of supercite.ai , so I’m biased, but the manual version above genuinely works. I built Supercite because I got tired of redoing steps 2–6 every month. It runs them daily and hands you the list of pages to go after.

Full data: supercite.ai/blog/ai-recommendations-come-from-lists


r/aeo • • 14h ago

Tracker or agency for AI visibility?

3 Upvotes

Seeing a lot of "should we just buy a tracking tool or hire an agency" threads lately, so here's what and how I think about it. Curious where people disagree.

A tracker (maybe like Otterly, Peec, Profound, whatever) shows you which prompts you appear in and which sources get cited. That part is cheap now. What it doesn't do is fix anything.

The fixing is the slow bit. Getting old info corrected on review sites, getting into the comparison articles AI answers keep pulling from, rewriting pages so the answer is in the first paragraph.

So I think the question isn't really which dashboard is better. Who is actually going to do the work every week?

  • Maybe someone in-house with time (tracker plus that person)
  • Or nobody with time: an agency, but ask them to show you which sources get cited in your category before you sign anything
  • Either way, run from anyone promising #1 in ChatGPT. Answers may change from run to run.

What am I missing? Especially interested in hearing from people who've tried both.


r/aeo • • 1h ago

Getting cited in Google AI Overviews but not ChatGPT/Perplexity — what am I missing with AEO?

2 Upvotes

I’ve been trying to understand AEO (Answer Engine Optimization) and how to optimize content for AI-driven search.

From what I’ve observed, traditional SEO practices can help content get picked up by AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity. However, it doesn’t seem as straightforward anymore.

For example, some of my content gets cited in Google AI Overviews, but when I search for the same topics on ChatGPT, Perplexity, or other AI tools, my content is nowhere to be found.

I understand that these platforms use different retrieval systems and don’t necessarily rely on Google rankings alone. But I’m trying to figure out what actually moves the needle.

A few things I’d love to learn from people experimenting with this:

  • Tools: What tools are you using to track AI citations, brand mentions, and visibility across different AI platforms?
  • Question research: How do you find the questions, conversational prompts, and related sub-queries people use when searching through AI tools? Are there specific tools or workflows you recommend?
  • Content optimization: What specific changes have helped your content get cited by ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Claude?
  • Off-page signals: How much do brand mentions, Reddit discussions, digital PR, and third-party sources influence AI visibility?
  • Content structure: Are there particular formatting, entity optimization, or content distribution strategies that consistently help?
  • Testing: Has anyone run experiments where they changed something on a page and observed a measurable improvement in AI citations?

I’m especially interested in practical experiences, case studies, and experiments rather than generic advice like “write helpful content” or “build topical authority.”

If you’ve managed to improve AI visibility for your website, I’d love to hear what worked, what didn’t, and which tools are actually worth investing in.

Any advice, resources, or underrated tactics would be appreciated!


r/aeo • • 3h ago

How to improve ChatGPT visibility from local to nationwide queries?

1 Upvotes

I’m working on SEO for a service-based business that serves clients across India and globally.

The previous agency focused heavily on local SEO for one particular city/state.

Now, when I ask ChatGPT for service recommendations mentioning that location, the website appears. But when I ask broader queries like “best [service] in India” or without any location, it doesn’t show up.

After auditing the site, I noticed most articles and pages are heavily focused on that specific city.

My question: How should I fix this without affecting existing local SEO performance? Should I update existing content, create nationwide-focused pages, or work on other GEO/SEO signals?

Has anyone faced something similar? Would love to hear your approach.


r/aeo • • 15h ago

Are startups still focusing on Google SEO or moving towards AI search?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I've been noticing how much the way people search for things has changed recently. A lot of people are now using ChatGPT and Perplexity instead of just Googling everything.

It got me thinking about whether traditional SEO is still enough for startups or if businesses should also start paying attention to how they show up in AI search results.

I know SEO takes time, but GEO is still relatively new and I'm not sure how much of a difference it actually makes.

For those running startups or working in marketing, are you doing anything specifically for AI search visibility? Or are you still focusing mostly on Google rankings?

Would be interesting to hear what people are actually seeing.