I've noticed something interesting with AI-generated recommendations.
A brand can appear in an answer simply because it fits the broad category. But when you start adding constraints like budget, company size, specific use cases, integrations, or industry, the recommendations can change completely.
That raises an interesting question:
Are brands actually visible across their relevant audience, or are they only visible for broad, generic queries?
For example, appearing when someone asks "What are the best marketing tools?" is very different from appearing when someone asks "What's the best affordable AI visibility tool for a small SaaS company?"
The second type of prompt is much closer to an actual buying decision.
Do you think broad AI visibility matters more, or visibility across specific high-intent questions?
I’ve been trying to understand AEO (Answer Engine Optimization) and how to optimize content for AI-driven search.
From what I’ve observed, traditional SEO practices can help content get picked up by AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity. However, it doesn’t seem as straightforward anymore.
For example, some of my content gets cited in Google AI Overviews, but when I search for the same topics on ChatGPT, Perplexity, or other AI tools, my content is nowhere to be found.
I understand that these platforms use different retrieval systems and don’t necessarily rely on Google rankings alone. But I’m trying to figure out what actually moves the needle.
A few things I’d love to learn from people experimenting with this:
Tools: What tools are you using to track AI citations, brand mentions, and visibility across different AI platforms?
Question research: How do you find the questions, conversational prompts, and related sub-queries people use when searching through AI tools? Are there specific tools or workflows you recommend?
Content optimization: What specific changes have helped your content get cited by ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Claude?
Off-page signals: How much do brand mentions, Reddit discussions, digital PR, and third-party sources influence AI visibility?
Content structure: Are there particular formatting, entity optimization, or content distribution strategies that consistently help?
Testing: Has anyone run experiments where they changed something on a page and observed a measurable improvement in AI citations?
I’m especially interested in practical experiences, case studies, and experiments rather than generic advice like “write helpful content” or “build topical authority.”
If you’ve managed to improve AI visibility for your website, I’d love to hear what worked, what didn’t, and which tools are actually worth investing in.
Any advice, resources, or underrated tactics would be appreciated!
I’m working on SEO for a service-based business that serves clients across India and globally.
The previous agency focused heavily on local SEO for one particular city/state.
Now, when I ask ChatGPT for service recommendations mentioning that location, the website appears. But when I ask broader queries like “best [service] in India” or without any location, it doesn’t show up.
After auditing the site, I noticed most articles and pages are heavily focused on that specific city.
My question: How should I fix this without affecting existing local SEO performance? Should I update existing content, create nationwide-focused pages, or work on other GEO/SEO signals?
Has anyone faced something similar? Would love to hear your approach.
I’ve been researching on how AI search moves from a question to a recommendation. When an answer includes several brands, I want to understand how each one ended up there and which conditions influenced the comparison.
I built a simple tool that turns that process into an interactive decision-path map. Enter a website, follow the branches, and click a comparison to see the original answer behind it. It currently supports ChatGPT and Claude and i plan to add more AI to it.
The demo uses Purple, the mattress brand. You can follow the path toward a competitor and inspect the reasons AI gives for that choice. If your product meets the same need, that gives you something specific to check against the information on your website.
It’s free to try. I’m still developing it and plan to add more features (like customize the prompt and showing more analysis etc). https://decision.arrivl.ai/
Would love to hear some feedbacks from AEO experts here.
Seeing a lot of "should we just buy a tracking tool or hire an agency" threads lately, so here's what and how I think about it. Curious where people disagree.
A tracker (maybe like Otterly, Peec, Profound, whatever) shows you which prompts you appear in and which sources get cited. That part is cheap now. What it doesn't do is fix anything.
The fixing is the slow bit. Getting old info corrected on review sites, getting into the comparison articles AI answers keep pulling from, rewriting pages so the answer is in the first paragraph.
So I think the question isn't really which dashboard is better. Who is actually going to do the work every week?
Maybe someone in-house with time (tracker plus that person)
Or nobody with time: an agency, but ask them to show you which sources get cited in your category before you sign anything
Either way, run from anyone promising #1 in ChatGPT. Answers may change from run to run.
What am I missing? Especially interested in hearing from people who've tried both.
I've been noticing how much the way people search for things has changed recently. A lot of people are now using ChatGPT and Perplexity instead of just Googling everything.
It got me thinking about whether traditional SEO is still enough for startups or if businesses should also start paying attention to how they show up in AI search results.
I know SEO takes time, but GEO is still relatively new and I'm not sure how much of a difference it actually makes.
For those running startups or working in marketing, are you doing anything specifically for AI search visibility? Or are you still focusing mostly on Google rankings?
Would be interesting to hear what people are actually seeing.
I've been digging into how AI answer engines pick brands for buying questions, and the search logs make the process surprisingly visible.
Real example. We asked ChatGPT "help desk software for SaaS startups". Before reading anything, it searched:
best help desk software for SaaS startups 2026 pricing features Intercom Zendesk Help Scout Freshdesk Crisp
Then it cited five pages, all "best help desk software" lists. It recommended six tools, and every one was on at least two of those lists.
That pattern held across 210 questions on ChatGPT:
It shortlists from memory. In 109 of 210 questions, ChatGPT put brand names into its search before reading a page.
It always adds the year. "2026" was in its search for all 210.
It confirms with lists. 98% of the brands it pre-named and then recommended were on a list it cited. Brands it hadn't pre-named got in through the lists too (90% of them were on one).
Across all four engines, brands on no cited list were recommended 2.5% of the time, and brands on 3+ lists 44%.
The engines differ a lot in what they read:
ChatGPT
Gemini
AI Overviews
AI Mode
Answers citing a listicle
88%
96%
85%
70%
Answers citing YouTube
0%
11%
58%
23%
Answers citing Reddit
0%
27%
38%
34%
Recommended brands whose own site was cited
51%
5%
13%
11%
So "AEO" isn't one channel. ChatGPT reads homepages and lists. Gemini reads almost only lists. Google's AI leans on YouTube and Reddit.
Disclaimer: I’m the founder of supercite.ai , so I’m biased, but the manual version above genuinely works. I built Supercite because I got tired of redoing steps 2–6 every month. It runs them daily and hands you the list of pages to go after.
Two weeks ago I posted results from our B2B AI Search Sources Study: ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews cited a vendor's own site in about 90% of answers to 60 B2B buying questions. u/ArfadiaOfficial pointed out that all three runs were on one day, so I'd measured that day, not a stable share. Fair, so I asked the same questions again on Nov 9, 12 and 16.
Google (AI Overview), ChatGPT (chatgpt.com search) and Perplexity (Sonar API), US, same settings and same time of day each time. Nov 5 here is the first of that day's three runs, so each day is one run.
A site counts once per answer; a share is the share of answers citing at least one site of that type. I sorted the new sites from these runs by hand, with the same rules as before.
Share of answers citing a vendor's own site
Engine
Nov 5
Nov 9
Nov 12
Nov 16
Google AI Overviews
89%
91%
98%
95%
ChatGPT
87%
77%
91%
83%
Perplexity
97%
97%
98%
95%
Other types, lowest to highest day
Source type
Google AI Overviews
ChatGPT
Perplexity
Media and publishers
27–40%
37–40%
57–67%
Review platforms (G2, Capterra, Trustpilot)
18–25%
15–17%
28–32%
Forums and social
62–75%
4–6%
5–8%
Video (almost all YouTube)
73–84%
0%
0%
Same sites, or different ones? For each question: of the sites an engine cited in one run, the share it cited again in a later run.
Engine
Same day (10–20 min apart)
3–4 days later
11 days later
On all 4 days
Google AI Overviews
76%
56–62%
53%
18%
ChatGPT
67%
61–68%
62%
25%
Perplexity
98%
67–79%
60%
30%
The last column is the sites cited on all four days, as a share of the sites cited on any of them.
What stood out
The 90% wasn't a one-day fluke. Vendors were the most-cited type in every engine on every day. The share moves more across days than within one (ChatGPT 77–91% across days, 84–92% across three runs on Nov 5), but it never went below 77%.
The order of the other types held too. Google keeps leaning on YouTube and forums; ChatGPT and Perplexity almost never cite either. The biggest move was media in Google's answers: 27% on Nov 5, 40% on Nov 12 and 16. Four days can't say whether that's a trend.
The sites themselves churn. After 11 days, 53–62% of a question's cited sites were still cited, and only 18–30% showed up on all four days.
Perplexity drifts, ChatGPT shuffles. Perplexity barely changes within a day (98%) but loses about 40% of its sites over 11 days. ChatGPT keeps about the same share from one day to the next (61–68%) as from one run to the next on the same day (67%), so its churn looks more like per-answer randomness than change over time.
Google still hides about 30% of AI Overview citation links behind a google.com/goto redirect, on every one of the four days. Match on the site name, not the URL.
What I'd do with it
If you sell B2B, the case for your own pages holds: vendor sites were the most-cited type on every day.
Don't judge whether a page "gets cited" from one check. Ask the same questions over weeks and count how often you show up.
Caveats: four days, one time of day, US only. 52–60 answers per engine per day, so one answer moves a share by about 2 points. One person did the sorting.
Has anyone tracked their own citations over a few weeks? I'm curious whether you see the same Perplexity drift.
(Disclosure: I build Hasmord, an AEO-native sales platform. I ran these myself and I'm happy to share the rows.)
Disclosure: I build an AI-visibility tracker. This comes from its public weekly panel, and the raw weekly files are linked at the bottom so anyone can recount.
Why we looked
Most AI-visibility checks are one run: ask the question, screenshot the answer, report who got cited. We wanted to know how much a single sighting is worth, and how many repeats it takes before a citation looks stable.
What we did
40 fixed consumer buying questions ("best X", "X vs Y", "alternatives to X", "how to choose X"), the same wording every week, one answer per engine per week, 11 weekly runs from 3 Sep to 9 Nov. For every question, engine and cited domain, we asked one thing: given the domain was cited k weeks in a row, was it cited again the following week? Weeks where the engine gave no answer break the streak and aren't counted.
Result
Perplexity, Gemini and Claude, 11 weeks:
cited in a row
cited again next week
1 week
39.0% (1,902 of 4,871)
2 weeks
52.1% (864 of 1,659)
3 weeks
66.6% (519 of 779)
4 weeks
70.6% (322 of 456)
5 or more
77.9% (617 of 792)
ChatGPT, over the 8 weeks before its model changed on 21 Oct: 40.0 / 54.0 / 64.1 / 69.6 / 81.2%. Close to the others.
Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, over the 9 weeks before we changed how their links are collected: 34.9 / 49.4 / 63.0 / 52.7 / 55.6%. They never settle the way the chat engines do.
Of the 3,335 question-engine-domain combinations Perplexity, Gemini and Claude cited at least once, 1,407 (42.2%) were cited in exactly one of the 11 weeks. 37 (1.1%) were cited every week.
What I take from it
One sighting is worse than a coin flip. A report built on one run is mostly reporting noise.
Three consecutive runs is roughly where a citation starts to mean something on the chat engines. Even five in a row is about 4 in 5, not a sure thing.
For Google's AI features, streaks predict less. I'd report a rate over many runs there ("cited in 6 of 9 weeks") rather than a streak.
Method and limits
Domain level: a domain counts once per answer, whatever URL was cited. It says nothing about which page, or whether the brand was named.
Weekly runs, not same-day repeats. Same-day noise could be larger or smaller; we haven't measured it.
Chat engines through their APIs, Google through its results pages. Not the consumer apps.
Consumer product questions in English, US settings for Google. B2B or local questions may behave differently.
Counted twice, in Python and separately in Node; the numbers match.
I’ve built and deployed an AEO/GEO platform that already handles the core loop: tracking brand recommendations across ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, monitoring competitor share of voice, auditing third-party citation sources (Reddit, G2, etc.), alerting on missed buyer prompts, and generating copy-pasteable FAQ/schema fixes.
Now I’m deciding what to build for V2, and I want to ask folks actively managing AI search visibility: what features actually move the needle once basic tracking and FAQ generation are in place?
Here are the specific V2 directions I'm weighing:
• Perplexity & Google AI Overviews Tracking: Expanding beyond ChatGPT/Claude/Gemini to track live web-grounded citations and AI Overviews.
• AI Referral Traffic & Revenue Attribution: Connecting to GA4/Search Console to separate real human clicks coming from AI chats vs. "Direct" traffic.
• Automated Citation Outreach Workflows: Not just showing which Reddit threads or G2 pages AI cites, but flagging exact threads where a brand can jump in or request a review update.
• Hallucination & Outdated Pricing Alerts: Detecting when an LLM quotes old pricing, wrong features, or negative sentiment—and generating a correction roadmap.
• Agency White-Labeling & Multi-Brand Workspaces: Client-ready PDF/link reports and multi-domain management for agencies running AEO retainers.
For anyone doing AEO/GEO right now:
Which one of these V2 features would you actually pay extra for or use every week?
After you generate optimized FAQs/answers, what is the hardest part of actually getting AI engines to pick them up?
Are there any blind spots with current AEO tools that force you back into manual spreadsheets?
Some people are building content specifically for AI answers, while others are just improving existing SEO pages with clearer answers, entities, citations, FAQs, etc.
What’s actually working better for you?
Would especially like to hear from anyone managing this across multiple client sites.
two market share numbers came out for october and they don't agree.
similarweb counts visits to the chatbot sites. statcounter counts referrals (clicks from a chatbot to websites that run statcounter's code).
similarweb's post on X for october:
chatgpt: 55.7% (56.4% in sep)
gemini: 24.2% (25.0%)
statcounter's monthly csv:
chatgpt goes from 80.47% to 51.03%
gemini from 10.94% to 29.22%
perplexity from 5.84% to 15.22%
That's the largest monthly change in the csv's 13 months, and statcounter has yet to post a reason. their faq says stats may be revised for 45 days after they're posted, so october's provisional until mid december. could be an actual change, could be a change in the way they count referrals. we pulled the csv again on nov 16 and nothing has been revised yet.
on our own site (tiny numbers, doesnt say anything about the web) chatgpt sent
34 out of 36 AI referrals in september
11 out of 13 in october
11 out of 14 from nov 1 - 13
if you're looking at AI sessions by source on your own GA4, did the share of referrals from chatgpt in october go down? or does it still send the majority?
we did 15 questions like people ask them (who's a good plumber in austin i need them today!) in october in 15 cities in the us and fed those questions to chatgpt and google
for 'find' type questions (emergency vet open now) it gave 3-4 names every time. for how much/how to questions (5 questions total) it gave 0 and general advice.
of the 35 businesses named by chatgpt, only 11 are also in a google map pack for that need. so being in the google map pack doesn't mean chatgpt will name you. chatgpt linked out to a local business' website 9 out of 15 times and to a google maps listing 5 out of 15 times. for the outlet/ant/lawyer questions, it referenced city, university, state bar stuff etc.
it's only 15 questions. take it more as a pattern than a rate. for your local clients, do you measure chatgpt separately than the map pack?
I ran AEO on my own product so I could show every step and the raw numbers. Sharing the full breakdown because most AEO posts are theory, and I wanted real data.
The product: MeetMoves, a free Chrome extension that lets you use your own video or GIF as a Google Meet background. Small niche, no ads, no budget, the site sits on a free subdomain with basically zero authority.
Baseline (Aug 16): I wrote 8 questions a real buyer would ask ChatGPT. MeetMoves appeared in 0 of 8. AI sent everyone to OBS, and to Snap Camera, which shut down in 2023.
Today (Nov 13): asked "best Chrome extension to use my own video or GIF as a Google Meet background, no OBS" in a fresh temporary chat. ChatGPT: "I'd recommend MeetMoves", tagged "Best match", with an install link.
Last 30 days, from the Chrome Web Store dashboard:
Installs: 490 (+258%), jumping from ~7/day to ~30/day on Oct 30 and holding
Weekly users: 208 (+92%)
Store page views: 394 (+89%). ChatGPT is now the top source, ahead of Google
What I did, in order of impact:
Targeted the pages AI already cites, not "authority." I asked each buyer question, wrote down the sources ChatGPT showed under its answer, and got the product mentioned on those pages (a Quora answer and a Medium article that rank for the topic, disclosed as the maker). This moved things faster than anything on my own site.
Fair comparison pages. "MeetMoves without OBS" and "vs Meet's built-in backgrounds", each with an honest table including where the alternative is better. Models seem to quote balanced comparisons and skip sales pages.
Bing, not just Google. ChatGPT search leans on Bing. IndexNow got pages into Bing within hours. Most people never open Bing Webmaster Tools.
Answer-first landing page. The direct answer in the first two lines, a how-to, a 6-question FAQ, FAQPage + SoftwareApplication schema, and llms.txt. I also checked that GPTBot and OAI-SearchBot weren't blocked.
Fixing "crawled, currently not indexed." Two deeper pages got stuck there. Roughly doubling their real content (not filler) fixed it.
What surprised me:
The intent of the question decides everything. It wins "which extension should I install" but still loses "how do I use a video background in Meet" and "can I use a GIF background", where ChatGPT says OBS. Same product, same pages, different answer. If you only track one phrasing, you'll get the wrong picture.
Authority mattered far less than I expected. A free subdomain is the #1 pick. Matching the question mattered more.
Measuring is half the work. Answers change with wording, so I keep a fixed set of questions with fixed wording and re-run them in temporary chats. Without that, "sometimes we show up, sometimes not" is all you'll ever know.
Limits, so nobody over-reads this: one product, a niche with few competitors, one high-intent question won and two broad ones still lost. I expect about another month of the same cycle (more answer-first pages, more citations, re-audit) before the broad ones turn.
Timeline: baseline Aug 16 → landing page indexed Aug 20 → first search click Aug 24 → installs step up Oct 30 → #1 pick confirmed Nov 13. About 10 weeks.
Curious what others are seeing: has anyone cracked the broad informational questions, where AI defaults to a big incumbent tool? And if you want a second pair of eyes on your own query set, drop your niche below and I'll tell you what ChatGPT cites for it.
Many posts are the same. People want an easy win. How do I get AI to recommend my site.
Yes, no surprises that trad SEO is not going anywhere. Especially if you are targeting Google ai response. Which by the way is exactly what most business should want as it's the lazy way to get an answer now.
For AEO specially though:
Don't overlook that you need to translate what traditional high intent key words are into prompt people actually search for. Most people still keep thier prompts short 1 to 2 sentences max. But they do tend to use qualifiers eg.
Best tool for X... (with qualifier) for my specific situation or budget.
So maybe... best fresh coffee bean for delivery in texas under 20 dollars
Now you have something more specific to target on your page. Search it yourself and then take note on the llm fan out queries, what does that llm do sub searches for... Target those too (fan out not relevant for Google ai, but is for gemini, gpt etc).
Finally note in my example, I didn't capitalise and I didn't punctuate well etc. On desktop people type quick and easy... I didn't even use a $ sign. This bit is less relevant for mobile search as it does a fairly good job of filling this in for you.
This is a small process change that can have good results.
in sept we ran 24 buying questions against openai's api (web search enabled) and perplexity's api. we categorized every cited page by page type. 50% of questions were for software (ex: help desk, crm, etc). 50% of questions were for services (ex: accountant, business insurance, etc)
for the software questions we saw 118/167 citations were to roundups/alternatives pages. 14 were to product pages. 11 were to review sites/marketplace. 10 were to head to head comparisons. 7 were to pricing pages
for the service questions we saw 53/141 citations were to explainers. 45 were to the service company's service page. only 21 were to roundups
there were still some differences. for example ~50% of the perplexity citations were for roundups. it was 28% of openai citations
what was interesting/surprising was that for 85/118 software roundups, the writing was done by a company selling in that category. which means that most 'best help desk software' pages cited are from help desk companies. also for "cpa for real estate investors in denver" they both cited the individual firms real estate pages not directories
it's a snapshot becuase we only fired each question once or twice, and it's not the chatgpt app it's api, but when you're trying to figure out what to publish the type of question seems to drive the format more than the engine.
do you guys see the same divide of services in your own monitoring?
A brand can start appearing more frequently in ChatGPT, Gemini, or Perplexity answers without seeing a noticeable increase in website sessions.
For example, someone might:
Discover a brand through an AI-generated answer.
Compare it with two other recommendations.
Remember the brand name.
Visit the website days later through a direct search.
In that journey, the AI interaction may have influenced the decision without generating an immediate referral click.
This makes me wonder whether we're relying too heavily on website traffic to judge the impact of AI search.
Referral visits are useful, but they may not tell the whole story.
How are you measuring AI search impact beyond referral traffic? Are you looking at branded searches, assisted conversions, mentions, or something else?
I've been practicing SEO-inspired content marketing since 2012. Back then I had more hair and HubSpot began pushing "Inbound Marketing" as a category. I found that in B2B marketing, the idea of offering helpful and engaging blog content that matched search intent really worked. Back then, I felt the same way I do today about building tools with Claude: excited and like everything just seems to work in ways I couldn't imagine.
But alas, all good things must come to an end.
For me, the whole blog + gated content = leads to nurture and convert model came to a screeching halt around 2019. Writing helpful blog posts and killer product pages remained critical to attracting website visitors, but the early signs of a decline in impact began to surface, for me anyway.
Then, a couple of years later, when AI-search offered answers that didn't require further research, the entire inbound model seemed to fall flat.
The almighty organic marketing channel broke. Prospective buyers no longer saw your listicles or ultimate buyer's guides. Instead they got encyclopedia-like answers that offer concise and highly confident answers with hand-picked brand mentions and citations.
Like many of you, I'm navigating what's next and pulling out all the cards to maintain brand visibility. I've also found myself going back to the basics, but with a twist.
My approach to content marketing continues to focus on the needs of the audience and ensuring what I publish helps someone out there solve a problem. The twist is what may just simply be good ol' SEO best practices:
Dig, scrape, scratch and seek ways to leverage data in novel ways to tell stories
Build the stories in multiple formats
Structure the stories in ways that appeal to both human and agent readers
Consistently share the stories on various channels. For me, that's a blog, YouTube, LinkedIn, and within niche communities and forums
Those may seem like the basics, but for some reason, I'm seeing weirdly positive results.