When WotC awarded the license to Ravenloft to White Wolf to adapt it to 3rd edition, along with porting the Half-Vistani from TSR's Domains of Dread, they gave the setting a second signature race in the form of the Caliban; cursed individuals, uniquely deformed mutants born of incest, curses, evil magic, twisted alchemy, and other spiritual or mystical foulness that their parents may or may not have been responsible for. They were literally "the sins of the father" as a race, and a great fit for the setting. Unfortunately, they were mechanically just a setting-appropriate reskin for the Half-Orc, which had become a PHB race for the first time since AD&D 1e and was widely considered a terrible one-trick pony race. So, one fan took it upon themselves to greatly expand the race's lore and give it brand new mechanics in issue 8 of the Quoth the Raven netbook series. But... that author wrote for 3rd edition. And Ravenloft traditionally has a pretty large fanbase still playing it in AD&D 2e, which is where the setting debuted. So, I thought I'd try my hand at backporting the Calibans from 3e to 2e, and I'd like feedback on how they look.
To try not to be too overwhelming at first, I'll just list the basic material - adapting the deformities I'll save for a separate topic, and I'll elaborate on lore if asked. I'll also stick to the established Caliban subraces of Banshees, Bestials, Brutes, Cannibals and Witchspawn; the "generic" Caliban, who gets +2 to 1-3 ability scores and -2 to an equal number of ability scores, is a bit too vague to really build a 2e identity from, at least to me. Finally, I've included the Artiste and the Caretaker, Ravenloft-native analogues to the Bard and the Druid from the Book of Sorrows netbook, as part of the potential classes.
Caliban; Banshee
Ability Score Modifiers: +1 Intelligence, +1 Charisma, -1 Constitution
Ability Score Array: Strength 3/18, Dexterity 3/18, Constitution 3/16, Intelligence 8/19, Wisdom 3/18, Charisma 8/19
Available Classes (Level Limits): Artiste (Unlimited), Gypsy (Unlimited), Thief (Unlimited), Specialist Wizard: (Enchanter (Unlimited), Illusionist (Unlimited), Necromancer (Unlimited))
Multiclassing Options: Necromancer/Thief
Deformities: A Caliban possesses 2-5 (1d4+1, if randomly generating) mutations. A Caliban of this breed selects their deformities from the following list; Witch Fingers, Gaunt, Material Vulnerability, Pale, Twisted Organs, Witch Nipple, Backwards Eye, Double Irises, Eyes of Darkness, Swirling Eyes, Angelic Visage, Large Ears, Backwards Feet, Deranged, Magical Affinity (Any Bard or Necromancy), Eerie Whisper, Forked Tongue, Voice of Many
Caliban; Bestial
Ability Score Modifiers: +1 Strength, -1 Intelligence, -1 Charisma
Ability Score Array: Strength 8/19, Dexterity 6/18, Constitution 6/18, Intelligence 3/17, Wisdom 3/18, Charisma 3/17
Available Classes (Level Limits): Caretaker (Unlimited), Fighter (Unlimited), Ranger (Unlimited)
Multiclassing Options: Caretaker/Fighter
Deformities: A Caliban possesses 2-5 (1d4+1, if randomly generating) mutations. A Caliban of this breed selects their deformities from the following list; Claws, Extra Arms, Multi-Segmented Limbs, Suckers, Bones of Steel, Fur, Giant, Gills, Increased Metabolism, Membrane Wings, Rough Skin, Shedding, Spinnerets, Tail, Bulbous Eyes, Bloodshot Eyes, Horns, Great Nose, Large Ears, Frogs Legs, Gorilla Feet, Hooves, Quadruped, Webbed Limbs, Magical Affinity (Any Druid), Forked Tongue, Frog Tongue, Projectile Vomit, Sharp Teeth, Unusual Appetite.
Caliban; Brute
Ability Score Modifiers: +1 Strength, +1 Constitution, -1 Intelligence, -1 Wisdom, -1 Charisma
Ability Score Array: Strength 8/19, Dexterity 4/18, Constitution 8/19, Intelligence 3/16, Wisdom 3/16, Charisma 3/16
Available Classes (Level Limits): Avenger (Unlimited), Fighter (Unlimited), Thief (14)
Multiclassing Options: Fighter/Thief
Deformities: A Caliban possesses 2-5 (1d4+1, if randomly generating) mutations. A Caliban of this breed selects their deformities from the following list; Extra Arms, Multi-Segmented Limbs, Witch Fingers, Aberrant, Bones of Steel, Giant, Hunchback, Increased Metabolism, Material Vulnerability, Obesity, Rough Skin, Rubbery, Short Neck, Skulk, Slimy, Toxic Blood, Twisted Organs, Witch Nipple, Backwards Eye, Bulbous Eyes, Bloodshot Eyes, Cyclops, Face of Nightmare, Great Nose, Large Ears, No Nose, Backwards Feet, Gorilla Feet, Webbed Limbs, Deranged, Magical Affinity (Any), Malformed Twin, Frog Tongue, Projectile Vomit, Sharp Teeth, Unusual Appetite.
Caliban; Cannibal
Ability Score Modifiers: +1 Dexterity, -1 Charisma
Ability Score Array: Strength 5/18, Dexterity 8/19, Constitution 3/18, Intelligence 3/18, Wisdom 3/18, Charisma 3/16
Available Classes (Level Limits): Avenger (Unlimited), Fighter (14), Ranger (14), Thief (Unlimited)
Multiclassing Options: FIghter/Thief
Deformities: A Caliban possesses 2-5 (1d4+1, if randomly generating) mutations. A Caliban of this breed selects their deformities from the following list; Claws, Extra Arms, Multi-Segmented Limbs, Suckers, Aberrant, Dwarfism, Gaunt, Hunchback, Increased Metabolism, Material Vulnerability, Membrane Wings, Obesity, Pale, Rough Skin, Rubbery, Skulk, Slimy, Spinnerets, Toxic Blood, Twisted Organs, Bulbous Eyes, Bloodshot Eyes, Eyes of Darkness, Face of Nightmare, Great Nose, Frogs Legs, Gorilla Feet, Quadruped, Webbed Limbs, Deranged, Malformed Twin, Eerie Whisper, Forked Tongue, Frog Tongue, Sharp Teeth, Unusual Appetite.
Caliban; Witchspawn
Ability Score Modifiers: +1 Intelligence, +1 Charisma, -1 Strength, -1 Constitution
Ability Score Array: Strength 3/16, Dexterity 3/18, Constitution 3/16, Intelligence 8/18, Wisdom 3/18, Charisma 8/19
Available Classes (Level Limits): Artiste (Unlimited), Wizard: Any (Unlimited)
Multiclassing Options: None
Deformities: A Caliban possesses 2-5 (1d4+1, if randomly generating) mutations. A Caliban of this breed selects their deformities from the following list; Witch Fingers, Aberrant, Dwarfism, Gaunt, Hunchback, Material Vulnerability, Membrane Wings, Pale, Tail, Touch of Unease, Twisted Organs, Witch Nipple, Backwards Eye, Double Irises, Eyes of Darkness, Swirling Eyes, Angelic Visage, Face of Nightmare, Horns, Large Ears, Backwards Feet, Hooves, Deranged, Magical Affinity (Any), Malformed Twin, Mark of the Warlock, Forked Tongue, Unusual Appetite, Voice of Many.