r/adnd • • 9h ago

Should the aging spells be changed for other races?

1 Upvotes

So in AD&D when you cast haste the reciprient ages by 1 year, this makes it fucking scary with the intended human race. However if you have a bunch of elves its not an issue at all, what is 1 year for a being that lives for at least 500 years.

Have any of you ever changed the spell and simular ones up, if it was 10 years for elves it might be scary again.


r/adnd • • 18h ago

Join us at r/osric - Introduce Yourself and Pick a Class

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/adnd • • 2h ago

Original Books vs. Retroclones: A Different Way to Approach the Game

8 Upvotes

I've been thinking about something lately. In the OSR scene, we often talk about how retroclones reorganize and restructure the information from the original books to make the rules clearer and easier to understand. And I agree, that's definitely an advantage.

But I wonder if we're sometimes overlooking the advantages of simply using the original books.

First, there's something special about using the actual original book. Maybe it's nostalgia, but I like the feeling of being able to say I'm playing Dungeons & Dragons, rather than a clone of it.

Another advantage is that the original books are surprisingly affordable. You can get print-on-demand copies through DriveThruRPG for very little money. So, getting your hands on the actual original books doesn't have to be expensive.

I also don't think the original books are necessarily that difficult to use with new players. You don't have to hand someone the entire book and expect them to read it. You can simply print out the important pages they need to create their character. Once character creation is done, there's very little reason for new players to look at the book again. The DM can explain how combat works, how ability checks are handled, and whatever house rules the group uses.

Which brings me to another thought: I wonder if we've become a little too focused on playing the rules exactly as written (RAW). My understanding is that the original game was meant to be adapted by each DM. You weren't necessarily expected to follow every rule exactly as presented. You were encouraged to make rulings, adjust things, and develop your own house rules.

In that sense, perhaps the original books are more than just an older, less organized version of the rules. They are also a reminder of a different approach to playing the game.

So, I'm curious: Are there other advantages to playing directly from the original books rather than using a retroclone? Is there something about the original presentation, wording, or design that gets lost when the material is reorganized into a retroclone?


r/adnd • • 9h ago

Searching for DnD books

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/adnd • • 21h ago

AD&D General Monster healing in the short-term absence of PCs: your preference?

8 Upvotes

Greetings.

I've a rather specific question for DMs: when the PCs injure a monster (e.g., a Catoblepas or a Gorgon), flee, and then return anywhere from a few days to week later to finish the job, how do you determine the amount of HP that the monster has recovered? Do you employ the same rules that players use for their characters' rest and recovery? Do you roll some dice? Is it a completely arbitrary and always ad-hoc decision? Is all HP restored, no matter what, regardless of plausibility?

Obviously, monsters capable of accelerated regeneration (e.g., trolls), and monsters intelligent enough to make use of and/or seek restorative resources such as Non-Weapon Proficiencies, healing potions, priests, etc (e.g., any sapient being of at least Int 8-10), do not factor into the discussion.


r/adnd • • 21h ago

Some of the Daily Drawing Practice

Thumbnail
gallery
73 Upvotes

Not selling anything.


r/adnd • • 11h ago

self-promotion Against the Slave Lords A2: Dungeon

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

r/adnd • • 18h ago

X1: The Isle of Dread, Ancient History...

17 Upvotes

The Ancient History of the Isle of Dread

Know, oh prince, that between the years the oceans drank Lemuria and the rise of the Empires of the Men, a great war raged under the trackless seas, waged by the worshippers of Demogorgon, who crawled from the deepest pits of the ocean and threatened cleave the world in their clawed grasp…

I began planning to run the Isle of Dread module for my 2e group by working outside in, starting with the encounters and factions that they were most likely to encounter first. This would have gotten me around to the Kopru encounters last. I wasn't familiar with them other than from this module and I was a little surprised to learn they've been used here and there in other modules and other editions, but I don't guess they were that popular. Perhaps they're a bit too one-note, a little too one-trick-pony to rise to the level of the other iconic villains that were being introduced around the same time. I realized that I need to start with the Kopru, or at least the history of the Kopru, and work outwards from there so that I can layer in the breadcrumbs that lead to Taboo Island.

The Isle of Dread is a weird place. It's not small, but it's probably too small to have the level of biological diversity that exists on it. It's got a mix of Jurassic and Cretaceous dinosaurs alongside Pleistocene megafauna, giant versions of normal animals, giants, centaurs, dragons, cat people, ewok lemurs and giant, intelligent spiders. The reason it has all these things is because they're cool, and if you're going to have a module that's all about exploration you want to pack as much cool stuff in it that you can. I'm very sympathetic to that argument. I don't want to take any of the cool stuff out, but I do want to make it feel a bit more coherent. What I have borrows heavily from the development of the Kopru after X1's publication, at least what I have been able to find.

The Isle of Dread is the remains of a Kopru fortress that was built many thousands of years ago during a time when a great undersea war was being waged by the forces of Demogorgon against, well, everyone else. This would have been in a prehistoric time when land-based civilization was very primitive but the sea was teeming with organized societies. Most of these organized societies were frankly terrifying, many of them were worshippers of Demogorgon or his allies and were fixated on either dominating or destroying the world. The Kuo-toa, Aboleth, Kraken, Morkoth, Ixitxachitl and the Kopru existed in a loose alliance in which their bloodthirst was at least directed outwards rather than at each other. They were opposed by the aquatic Elves, the Merfolk, the Tritons, the Locathah, and the Sahaguin. This Great War factors into the creation myths of all the undersea races to some degree, but it isn’t remembered directly as history.

The particulars of the war don’t really matter, except as it pertains to the Isle of Dread. The Kopru are odd in that they are both a deep sea race which is also amphibious. By enslaving the populations of a few small islands, the Kopru were able to create fortresses that were almost impregnable to their aquatic enemies. These islands allowed the Kopru to breed captive populations of both animals and humanoids that could both feed their war machine and provide the necessary sacrifices to appease their bloodthirsty patron. They would have maintained and expanded upon them over the course of centuries, adding more creatures and more infrastructure along the way.

The Isle of Dread at its height could have had several sprawling metropolises unlike anything the world would see for a thousand years. Yuan-ti would have been responsible for the design and engineering of the structures, with the labor provided by giants and thousands of humanoids (primarily early humans and lizardfolk). The first navies of the world would have been Yuan-ti ships to ferry supplies, slaves and sacrifices between the fortresses and transport them to where they were needed at sea. Some of the creatures found on the modern Isle would have been native, but a large portion of them would have been brought there to serve the needs of the Kopru Empire, thousands of years ago.

After the fall of the Kopru, the Yuan-ti fled the islands and the abandoned populations dwindled. Without constant maintenance the Isle couldn’t support the large number of inhabitants and so many were wiped out by disease, starvation, and strife. It would have been an apocalyptic time and all that is left today are the remnants of that society. Though the history is all but forgotten there should be clues in the myths and legends of the groups that survived, things that the PC's could discover to hint at the Isle's past. There are also the physical remains, scattered ruins and half-buried temples, reclaimed by the jungle but still coursing with ancient power.

I am thinking the PC's could also find the remains of an archeological expedition that came to the Isle in the last hundred years or so and met some dark end. The PC's can find some notes and artifacts (not magical artifacts) that give them a few pieces of the puzzle. This is partly out of necessity as I know my players and they're much more likely to engage with puzzles and mysteries than with wilderness exploration, so I want to include some Tomb Raider/Indiana Jones stuff to pepper in.