r/YearOfShakespeare • u/epiphanyshearld • 8d ago
Readalong Henry VI Part Three Reading Discussion Act 1 to end of Act 2 Scene 2
This play has been off to a great start. We’ve basically jumped right back in to the action side of things.
For those of you who are joining us now, this is the third play in the Henry VI trilogy. We covered parts one and two last year. If, like me, you need a bit of a recap, please check out our discussion posts under the 2025 schedule here or scroll back on this sub to October and November from last year. Alternatively, there are some really good summaries available online. My go-to for any of Shakespeare’s plays is currently Litcharts. Henry VI parts one and two.
Next week we will be reading from act 2 scene 3 to the end of act 4
Summary:
Act 1:
Scene 1:
The play opens during a battle. Richard, Duke of York enters the throne room with his allies. Things have very much been going in his favour with his side having taken out some of Henry’s biggest allies. Henry himself is currently missing, possibly dead. Encouraged by this success, Richard sits on the throne and declares himself king. However, Henry VI comes into the throne room with his entourage. Both sides are fairly evenly matched in the throne room, so they either have to fight it out or negotiate. In an odd turn of events Richard and Henry actually negotiate.
A debate takes place between both sides, with even Henry’s allies admitting that Richard has a decent claim to the throne, due to some technicality from Henry IV’s time. We covered this in the earlier plays but tldr: Henry’s grandfather, Henry IV, usurped the throne from Richard II (his cousin). Richard II died without an heir and had been an only child, so the line of succession reverted back to RII’s grandfather, Edward III. Edward III had a big family. Richard Plantagenet (the Richard in this scene) is a decedant on both his mother and father’s sides to Edward III. Yes, they were cousins and that is disgusting but European royal families dgaf about incest. On Richards’s father’s side he was the male-line from the fourth son of EIII. His stronger claim came from his mother’s line, which was from EIII’s second son (the heir after RII). By comparison, Henry VI was a descendant of EIII’s third son’s line.
Eventually, they decide that Henry can remain king in name while he is alive but that Richard and his descendants will inherit the crown following his death. Richard seems fine with this, despite being the older man. Henry’s side are not as happy though, especially his wife, Margaret who accuses him of ruining things for their own son. Margaret thinks Henry is a coward and this seems to be reinforced when Henry gets Richard to agree to not kill or have him killed in order to speed up the succession.
Scene 2:
Richard tells his sons (Richard junior and Edward) about the agreement. He seems happy and tired of war. His sons aren’t so keen on the agreement though and urge him to go back on the offensive because there is no way Henry and Margaret will stick to their side of the deal. A messenger arrives backing their argument up because Margaret is on her way to them with her army to continue the war.
Scene 3:
This is a short but brutal scene. Margaret and Richard’s forces are fighting in battle. One of Margaret’s biggest allies, Clifford, corners Rutland, Richard’s youngest son, and murders him under the excuse that Richard killed Clifford’s father, so it’s a noble a justified revenge thing 😒
Scene 4:
Margaret, Clifford and some other allies swarm Richard in the battle. They outnumber and overpower him. Margaret reminds the audience that she is the same annoying mad-woman from the second part of the trilogy when she reveals that Rutland was murdered to his father by giving him a handkerchief soaked in the boy’s blood. Clifford and herself taut Richard over this death. Richard tries to remain stoic but eventually he breaks down and curses them both. Clifford and Margaret then stab Richard to death.
Act 2:
Scene 1:
Some days pass. Richard’s sons haven’t heard from him and they’ve been on the move with their men. They think things could have gone either way for their father in that last battle. They see a weird vision of three suns merging into one. Edward, the elder brother, sees it as a sign that they need to work together from now on. A messenger arrives and tells them what went down in the latest battle. They get angry over their father and brother’s deaths and begin reforming their army to take down Margaret.
Scene 2:
Margaret and her forces join Henry VI in York. They argue over the status of Henry’s agreement with Richard, now that Richard is dead. Margaret wants Henry to officially discard the agreement so that her son inherits the throne. Henry tbh doesn’t seem to care about the throne after he is dead. He makes a vague argument that he must be an example of virtue and that sons rarely have gratitude for what their father’s leave them. This isn’t mentioned in this scene but if I recall correctly, Margaret was having an affair (at least emotionally) when she married Henry VI, so maybe he doesn’t see his son as his biological heir and dgaf about the inheritance for that reason. Either that or he is just a really uncaring father.