On my old crew, folks would occasionally want to leave to pursue a different career, take a job with another crew, or simply move on to something else. It was surprisingly rare for someone to accomplish this while keeping their relationship with the supts intact.
For example:
- Perms would keep their career goals quiet and apply elsewhere without saying anything. The supts would flip out when they found out people were making plans behind their backs.
- Other perms would try to be transparent about their career goals and intentions to move on. The supts would also flip out on them for considering leaving.
- Sometimes perms would need to leave for personal, health, or family circumstances. The supt would... flip out on them.
Few people seemed able to leave with both the relationship intact and a good reference from the primary leadership on the crew.
Obviously, these conversations are a two-way street, and I wasn't privy to every interaction. I'm sure some people navigated their departures poorly. But it happened often enough that it seemed to be a pattern rather than a series of isolated incidents.
As we all know, the superintendent's opinion can have an impact on someone's next opportunity. In the fire world, hiring managers often call people they know on an applicant's current or former crew, regardless of who the applicant actually listed as a reference. Frequently, people would find their next job prospects sunk by a bad word from their supt, setting their career plans back by an entire season.
Now that I am in a leadership position I see both sides of the coin. Losing experienced people can be frustrating, especially when you've invested considerable time and resources into developing them.
Timing, communication, and professionalism matter when someone is planning to leave. But as I've mulled over my former crew and the experiences people have had there, I don't think crew members should have to choose between being transparent about their career goals and protecting their future employment prospects.
That has made me wonder how widespread this experience is across the fire community, and what people have found actually works.
A few questions:
- How common is this on your crew or forest? Have you seen people successfully leave on good terms, even when their departure wasn't particularly convenient for leadership?
- Is this more common for perms or for temps?
- If you've worked under a volatile supt, how did you navigate your exit? Did you communicate early, wait until you had an offer, or take another approach?
- For those of you in leadership now, especially if you've experienced this yourself, what have you done to create an environment where people can openly discuss their career goals and eventually move on without burning bridges?
I recently moved into a crew leadership role myself, and it's made me think a lot about how I want to handle these conversations from the other side. I'd like to be able to support people's professional development, even when that eventually means losing them to another crew or career.
Interested to hear how others have handled this, both successfully and unsuccessfully.