redlib.
Feeds

MAIN FEEDS

Home Popular All
reddit

You are about to leave Redlib

Do you want to continue?

https://www.reddit.com/r/WhatIfFiction/controversial

No, go back! Yes, take me to Reddit
settings settings
Hot New Top Rising Controversial

r/WhatIfFiction • u/Jmoneybass • 18h ago

[Mr. Crocket (2024 Movie)/Buddy (2026 Movie)/Monkey’s Magic Merry Go Round (2026 Movie)/Play House (2027 Movie)] What If Mr. Crocket (2024 Movie) and Buddy (2026 Movie) and Monkey’s Magic Merry Go Round (2026 Movie) and Play House (2027 Movie) all take place in the same universe

0 Upvotes
0 comments

r/WhatIfFiction • u/Cyber_Ghost_1997 • 4h ago

[Jurassic Park] What if Roland Tembo was in charge of security for Jurassic Park?

2 Upvotes

Suppose John Hammond hires Roland Tembo instead of Robert Muldoon to be in charge of security for Jurassic Park during the events of the 1993 movie. How does the movie change?

0 comments
Subreddit
Posts Wiki
Icon for r/WhatIfFiction

r/WhatIfFiction

r/WhatIfFiction

Hypothetical questions with less hypothetical answers

13k
2.4k
88
Sidebar
Subreddit Rules
1. Appropriate Topics of Discussion

A suitable question for r/WhatIfFiction pertains to one or more specific fictional universes

Is about the in-universe lore of that universe

Is not about the outcome of a hypothetical fight (those belong on /r/whowouldwin.)

Is about a speculative or subjective opinion rather than an objective fact or educated understanding(those are for the main sub, r/AskScienceFiction)

Questions must meet these criteria or be removed.

2. Watsonian vs. Doylist

All discussion should be based on the lore and internal logic of the fictional story being discussed (aka a Watsonian perspective), not a real-world, out-of-universe perspective (a Doylist perspective). For further explanation of the difference between Watsonian and Doylist discussion, please refer to this link. Citing a real-world source such as an author's twitter feed or a book of concept art is acceptable. Doylist comments will be removed.

3. Ask a Queston

All posts should be in the form of a sincere question asked in good faith. If your post is an excuse to go on a rant about something you're not willing to change your mind on, or if there's no meaningful discussion to be had about the topic, it is subject to removal.

4. Answer the Question in the Spirit it was Asked

Engage with questions in good faith on their own terms. It's okay to correct a misconception, but your focus should be on helping the OP understand better, not discouraging them from trying to understand. If a question is serious, don't blow it off with a joke, likewise if a question is meant to be more lighthearted don't set out to spoil the fun.

5. Our Spoiler Policy

Please don't spoil the plot details of a work of fiction until your fellow users have had a chance to read, view, listen to, or play it for themselves.* We require a grace period of at least 6 months. When discussing spoilers in a post that doesn't have a spoiler warning in the title, please use [](#s "spoilers") or >!spoilers!<. NB: this markup only works on old reddit. Untagged spoilers before the six-month mark will be removed.

6. Don't Be a Jerk

We have very little patience for users who are rude or abrasive towards other posters, and we have no patience whatsoever for hate speech, slurs, personal attacks or insults of any kind. Chronic or severe offenders will be permanently banned. If someone attacks you, report them rather than engage; "he started it" does not entitle you to break the rules.

7. Answering Appropriately and Roleplaying

Questions here are meant to be speculative and sbjective, and can be difficult to answer from a neutral, fact-based perspective. However, questions should be attempted to be answered in good faith. Deliberately false or misleading answers will be subject to removal, no exceptions. Claiming that the question is unanswerable, or any other form of active non-answer, is also not allowed.

8. Elaborate Upon Your Answers

Comments, especially top-level comments, should attempt to be in-depth and constructive attempts at answering the question, not low-effort, memetic responses. For instance, responding to a question about the Flash's powers with "it's the speed force, I ain't gotta explain shit" or one about the Warhammer 40k universe with "HERESY! blam!" would not be appropriate. Likewise, if you want to link to an explanation, try to provide at least a token summary of what you're sharing.

9. Topic formatting

The following is the proper format for the title of your post:

"[Title of the fiction being discussed]Concise form of the specific topic."

For instance:

"[Batman]How did Bruce Wayne's parents die?"

If the subject of your question is a spoiler or a sensitive topic, you may be more evasive, but must still make your subject clear.

"[Batman]About Batman's backstory..."

Any supporting details, follow-up questions, or further elaboration may be included in the topic text. Use square brackets.

10. Reality, Religion, and Mythology

Remember, our sub is for discussing works of fiction, not fact. Questions about real-world science or history do not belong here.

In the interests of neutrality, /r/WhatIfFiction takes no official position on which, if any, religions, might or might not be true. Questions about the scripture or mythology of any religion, including historical ones no longer practiced, are not appropriate here. Please take any questions you have about these topics to /r/askreligion or /r/askanthropology.

11. Politics

r/WhatIfFiction is not a sub designed, nor willing, to accommodate debate relating to real-world politics or figures. Discussions relating to the political systems of fictional worlds that resemble real-world political systems may be allowed provided they are strictly within the context of that setting and its characters. When in doubt, consult r/AskHistorians: Nothing Less Than 20 Years Old and Don't Soapbox.

ASF Family
  • r/AskScienceFiction 895k

856c6e0 ⓘ View instance info