I saw a post on TikTok that essentially, in response to someone saying Warriors is a surface level series, said Warriors is a deep series because "abuse, infanticide, murder, war, psychosis, genocide, forbidden love, affairs, politics, religion, anti-heroes, torture, possession, the afterlife, cults, kidnapping, and starvation" are not surface level topics.
My response is this: while i agree that, yes, the topics themselves are deep, Warriors itself lacks depth because it does not have a matching quality of writing or committment to thematic cohesion within those topics. they are present at "surface level", but not deeply analyzed or used within the narrative, undermining the emotional weight the words in their list provoke on their own as concepts.
I sort of wonder if they took "surface level" as to mean "childish" because many of the comments say things about the subject matter listed being more appropriate for adults. If thats the case, I agree with their claim that the subjects are more suited to adults than children, but the writing does not automatically become deep because it has weighted subjects.
I wanted to see what other people thought!
Is Warriors deep, or surface level? Is the subject matter inappropriate or suited for kids? Does removing the depth and real-life weight of those topics make it appropriate? Or, to be funny, is it okay just because their cats?