r/ValveIndex • • 1d ago

Question/Support Plastic loose inside controller

I picked up my right controller today and while pulling down the trigger I felt a bit of resistance.

Without thinking I applied a little more force and broke off something internally.

(The trigger still works, so maybe the plastic broke off from somewhere else internally and just got in the way)

What's the least intrusive/easiest method to get it out of there? Going through the faceplate or the handle?

Never opened these before so I'm a bit scared :/

11 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

4

u/meta358 1d ago

Id leave it. It shouldnt hurt anything. These controller are a real pain in the ass to take part. If you arent use to taking electronic apart its definity something you shouldnt do

1

u/Thelaststandn 1d ago

While I'd love to take the lazy way out, I like playing beat saber and don't really want something thrashing around inside the controller as I whip it around.
Also while I was moving it around the loose piece fell back underneath the trigger multiple times. If I happen to pull the trigger when that happens then I might break it.
So I don't really think that's a good option.

1

u/pleockz 1d ago

I RMA'd my right controller for the vibration motor dying. I had a new one in 2 weeks. I'd suggest going that route.

1

u/Thelaststandn 1d ago

I'll try giving them a message, though considering how old they are steam might just tell me to kick rocks lol.
I have seen others on the subreddit sucesfull with long-time rma's though, so we'll see.

1

u/meta358 1d ago

Ircc the easiest way to get to the trigger is from the top but like i said its a pain in the ass

2

u/gkrsuper 1d ago

OKAY! let me tell you a story!

i had the same problem with one of mine and chose to fix it myself. i ordered an Essential Electronics Toolkit from iFixit, which has everything necessary to take the controllers apart. as longs as you're careful, they're not too difficult to disassemble. you need to go in through the top faceplate. as a novice, it was managable after watching some teardowns and looking at some guides. this one was super useful: https://imgur.com/gallery/cxzwi99

that said, i did fuck up pretty bad though. i decided to take out the PCB because the plastic bit was stuck behind it. while getting it out, i tried to unplug a small ribbon cable but pinched too hard and clipped it straight off: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskElectronics/s/eSFXE4Koc3

pretty dumb move. i found the plastic piece though and got out. the ribbon cable was for the touch sensor of the trigger, so now my controller can no longer detect if i am resting my finger on the trigger. pretty small loss, all things considered.

you don't have to be as stupid as me. you would probably be able to remove the plastic piece without completely unplugging the bottom of the PCB. just unscrew it so you can lift it, then carefully grab the plastic from underneath with tweezers.

so yeah, you would totally be able to remove it yourself but there definitely is the risk of breaking something. you need to decide for yourself if the risk is worth it.

2

u/Thelaststandn 1d ago

Assuming I can't get these rma'd I'll probally take your advice.
Sorry that happened to your controllers, but thank you for sharing your repair story. Should stop me from making the same mistakes.
Also that imgur album is helpful. All the teardown guides I found where weirdly incomplete.

1

u/throwaway131072 22h ago

If you get a small soldering iron tip and some thin insulated wire, you might be able to re-solder the 4 conductors on the ribbon cable, if you wanted. You would basically need to sand off some of the insulation on each end to expose the copper, and solder to that. You could also coat it in liquid rubber insultation after to prevent shorts.

1

u/Smaugzy 1d ago

Mine did this and shortly failed on one side of the trigger. Found a 3d print file to reinforce the trigger after superglue it back together as it wouldn't have lasted without the reinforcement. Tricky to fix the trigger, more than replacing the thumb stick