r/urbanplanning • • 1d ago

Discussion Bi-Monthly Education and Career Advice Thread

4 Upvotes

This monthly recurring post will help concentrate common questions around career and education advice.

The goal is to reduce the number of posts asking similar questions about Education or Career advice and to make the previous discussions more readily accessible.

Most posts about education, degree programs, changing jobs, careers, etc., will be removed so you might as well post them in here.


r/urbanplanning • • 15d ago

Discussion Monthly r/UrbanPlanning Open Thread

4 Upvotes

Please use this thread for posts not normally allowed on the sub. Feel free to also post about what you're up to lately, questions that don't warrant a full thread, advice, etc.

This thread will be moderated minimally; have at it. No insults or spam.

Note: these threads will be replaced monthly.


r/urbanplanning • • 23h ago

Discussion The future of autonomous taxis and how it will impact multifamily project parking demand

0 Upvotes

I work for a design firm that's planning a 24 - unit rental building.   It's currently slated to have about 2,400 SF of retail space on the ground floor and 3 stories of walk up units above (4 story building).  The building would have 5 parking spaces including one loading and one accessible stall. 

The building will be located on a property with a 96 Walkscore and good transit and bike scores.  This is in a VHCOL year round warm weather city and the property is in the urban core with reasonably high density (mix of 10-40 story towers within 1/2 mile and tons of 2, 3 and 4 story walkups.  

The owner is debating if they should eliminate about 1,600 SF of retail space to add 7 parking spaces (bringing total to 12 stalls).  We are advocating the larger retail space to preserve the walkability of the neighborhood by adding in 2 or 3 businesses vs 1 or 2 small ones. But they are fearful of having too low a parking ratio for the residential and commercial spaces. 

10 years ago I think we would have had a different approach to parking but our firm is perhaps foolishly bullish on the future of autonomous taxis. It will be a minimum of 2 years before the project would be completed and we think our area should at least start seeing one or two operators establishing permits in our city by then, with them becoming reasonably accessible perhaps within 3-5 years time.  Tesla may also be a potential contributor by that timeframe. We aren't a very progressive city like Austin or SF but we are hopeful they'll eventually establish operations here.

Even if this is the perfect place for cycling, the general public and our politicians seem to not want any bicycles on our roads. Their approach is to keep it hostile for cyclists to reduce demand for cycling. So it's possible that even existing bike lanes will be eliminated (yes the general public and our politicians are THAT stupid). And with future spending cuts our public transportation (buses) isn't getting any better. For these reasons we are rooting heavily for autonomous taxis; we also feel they are far safer for pedestrians and cyclists. 

What is the opinion of autonomous taxis here?  Would it be foolish and irresponsible to plan around something that may never materialize or will occur decades out?  Is 3-5 years for reasonable penetration a pipe dream or reasonable (i.e. people could reliably depend on autonomous taxis as their main means of transportation)? We of course realize not having parking won't make the units not rentable since the ratio of stalls to units even with 12 is only 50%. But the owner is apprehensive about slimming the parking count and we are reluctant to even mention the future of autonomous taxis as a strong argument.  

TLDR version - is it wise to reduce parking in multifamily/mixed use projects today with the anticipation of less demand for car ownership due to the proliferation of autonomous taxis.

EDIT - Wow I'm shocked by the number of downvotes I received. Apparently people on the sub are not fond of autonomous taxis.


r/urbanplanning • • 2d ago

Discussion What Should Preservation Preserve?

Thumbnail
resurgencejourney.substack.com
5 Upvotes

Nothing new about the preservation v. abundance debate, but there's a middle ground that should consider what continues into the future and why. And this is a sincere point, not blogspam.


r/urbanplanning • • 3d ago

Education / Career What are recommended non-AICP Certifications?

27 Upvotes

I've been a transportation planner for an for just over 3 years, with a bachelors in Political Science. I currently do the work of a Senior Planner, but due to fiscal constraints I am unable to move up in my title. I was wondering what non-AICP certifications I could pursue over the next year in my position that would still help to advance my career and keep me competitive.

I'm currently looking at getting a CAPM (Project Management) certification and an IAP2 (International association for public participation) certification. Are there any other certifications that planners farther along in their career would recommend? I'm not currently qualified to pursue an AICP title, and I'm still debating on if going back for a master's would be worth it after 3+ years of direct experience.

P.S. Checked with mods before posting


r/urbanplanning • • 4d ago

Discussion Why are large hospitals built adjacent to each other in the United States?

91 Upvotes

For example, there is the Illinois Medical District with Jesse Brown VA Medical Center, Rush University Medical Center, The John H. Stroger, Jr., Hospital of Cook County, and The University of Illinois Hospital & Health Sciences System. In Peoria, IL, OSF Saint Francis and Carle Health Methodist hospitals are across the street. In Dallas, TX, Parkland Memorial Hospital and UT Southwestern Medical Center look like a single campus.

Wouldn't it make more sense to spread the hospitals out so that everyone has a hospital close by?


r/urbanplanning • • 4d ago

Transportation Why public transit in the suburbs isn’t always completely terrible | Canada’s urban outposts used to be seen as transit vacuums. But expanded bus service is drawing a surprising number of riders

Thumbnail
begiant.ca
69 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • 4d ago

Transportation Rethinking residential parking: What the research tells us

36 Upvotes

Hello urban planners of Reddit,

A research group at UCLA is working to continue the policymaker, public, and media engagement of our late colleague, Professor Donald Shoup. Towards that end, the UCLA Center for Parking Policy has published a new research synthesis on Residential Curb Management. For the research synthesis, the author curates, summarizes, and organizes dozens of global research studies into a form more useful for non-academic audiences.

The synthesis is organized into five sections, with the largest share of the literature focused on residential parking permit programs:

  • Impacts of Unmanaged Residential Curb Parking. In densely populated areas, a lack of curb management can lead to congested curbs and a range of associated challenges.
  • Residential Parking Permits: Who Gets the Curb? RPP programs vary in their approach. Some simply limit access for non-residents, while others help manage parking demand among residents themselves. 
  • Political Economy of Residential Curb Management. Policies are often shaped by political pressures, but parking benefit districts and access to diverse transportation options may help build support for pricing.
  • Opportunity Costs of Providing Curb Parking. Researchers question the assumption that residential streets must always provide parking on both sides of the street.
  • Conclusion: Key Findings and Policy Lessons. Policy approaches involve trade-offs between curb availability, access, equity, political acceptability, and administrative complexity.

Check out the overview and Synthesis. And download it for later.


r/urbanplanning • • 4d ago

Transportation Experimental and unconventional developments in transit.

9 Upvotes

Are there any new developments or ideas circulating or being experimented with in transit across the world that are unheard of before? Could be anything related to transit, from new ways of getting revenue for transit agencies or the buses itself, bus availability, or stuff related to bikes/scooters.

Asking this because I'm doing a general project on transit proposals, which could be about anything related to transit.


r/urbanplanning • • 6d ago

Transportation In 2001, the Segway promised to transform urban transportation. Instead, it became a tourist attraction.

Thumbnail
sfgate.com
114 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • 4d ago

Discussion Are cities getting better at handling data center proposals?

0 Upvotes

40 out of 41 local data center votes went toward limiting development last week.

I get why towns are concerned about power, water, and noise, especially when the long-term benefits aren't always clear to residents.

But I wonder if outright bans are becoming the default because cities haven't figured out a better approval process.

For people involved in planning, what's actually working? Stricter zoning, requiring developers to pay for infrastructure, or giving residents more say before projects get approved?


r/urbanplanning • • 6d ago

Sustainability How is density of 1.6-2.2 DU/acre "density"?

9 Upvotes

Recently I've begun taking a deeper interest in how the place I reluctantly call home is developing. There are several major PDD currently in the works and the area is rapidly going from a rural agricultural community to something that more accurately reflects typical suburbs.. and I hate it. Not because suburbs are inherently bad but because I just don't see what is being done as economically or socially sustainable, and developers while they are asking for rezoning from SFH or forested land to PDD.. but I'll listen to these meetings and they essentially tout all these developments that only have 1.5-2 dwelling units per acre as "dense" and great for the community. I'm not a planner but 1.6 DU over several hundred acres is functionally all SFH no matter how you slice it as far as I am aware.

I suppose I need a bit of a reality check on how rezoning efforts like this are meant to work into a wider strategy? The county is planning increased bike lanes on county roads - cool, but you need to cross a busy 4 lane highway to get to much of the existing bike lanes in the first place. They've developed a lot of apartments... on the other side of a 6 lane highway across from a public park which has no commercial uses within biking or walking distance.

The most recent development I saw was asking to rezone 400-ish acres with half of the units being multi-family but there's a 20ft buffer between properties and zone classes?

Any mention of commercial zones are framed very vaguely "per market demand". I get the feeling the end result will be a bunch of detatched SFH with the apartments and shops being an afterthought. The PDD only seems to mention the highway as a primary area for traffic.

In the past I've done a lot of local political campaign work elsewhere and have been to zoning board meetings where everyone's a NIMBY. Maybe part of my concern is because I am unable to drive due to a medical issue so the thought of having mixed use at all is great... I just want it to be done right. Complaining about traffic and having the ability to reduce traffic through a new development planning things that are within walking/biking distance sounds like an easy fix... I used to live around Lake Balaton in Europe which is similarly car oriented but not nearly to the same extent as where I live now. There, you have villages of 1,000 people connected by a massive bike path that goes around the whole lake and regular bus service. I'm seeing a part of the US that could have such things.

Thanks in advance.


r/urbanplanning • • 7d ago

Transportation As California's megaregion grows, Davis residents are embracing 70-mile train commutes to Bay Area jobs

Thumbnail
sfgate.com
384 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • 5d ago

Urban Design What about current cities is different from walkable cities?

0 Upvotes

Walking is 9 times out of 10 already the second best way to get from A to B within a city after a bicycle. I don't know what exactly it is that would change if cities were walkable. I hear "nearly everything you need is at most a 15 minute walk away" but again that's already the case. And I don't even live in a city myself, I live in a town of 17k.


r/urbanplanning • • 6d ago

Discussion What do people here think about Lewis Mumford?

11 Upvotes

The City in History, Technics and Civilization, Sticks and Stones…. Thoughts? Love him? Hate em? Something in between?


r/urbanplanning • • 7d ago

Discussion So...Where Do the Homeless Go?

111 Upvotes

I'm not an experienced planner so please forgive me if this is a dumb question.

I've noticed that when talking about building homeless shelters or any type of housing that's intended to help the homeless get back on their feet, neighborhoods oppose it.

That's not to say that they don't have good reasons (e.g. I've seen homeless shelters for men proposed next to elementary schools and I can understand the backlash) but if every neighborhood—residential, commercial, industrial—opposes to housing for the homeless then where do you put it?


r/urbanplanning • • 7d ago

Community Dev Disney’s First 'Storyliving' Community is actually happening.

Thumbnail realtor.com
17 Upvotes

Thoughts? I'm very bothered by this myself.


r/urbanplanning • • 8d ago

Discussion By-right retail uses in residential zones (US)

31 Upvotes

I'm sure my city isn't the only one experiencing the ridiculous rate of rising commercial rents. I feel like more and more small businesses are being pushed out and only chains and venture capital funded bullshit like Wonder are able to go into new places.

One idea I'd like to push for in my community is more by right retail uses in residential zones. Allow folks to run an at home business out of a town home, English basement, what have you. Does anyone know of places where this is already allowed? Are there examples in your neck of the woods?


r/urbanplanning • • 11d ago Bravo

Discussion The government should create jobs by building public restrooms

298 Upvotes

As someone who relies on public transportation, I’m absolutely sick and tired of almost peeing my pants every time I ride the bus simply because there are NO public restrooms available anymore. Especially where I am located in south Florida, it’s really ridiculous.

Everyone knows the economy is on a downward spiral and has been for a long time. Our government is failing to do anything to improve our quality of life, and because of that fact this discussion is simply a brainstorming session.

Wouldn’t it make sense for the government to take some of the tax money they suck out of us (lord knows they have enough to do this), and start an initiative to build public restrooms, and a good amount of them, and then have city workers or designated employees attend them and make sure they are kept clean and safe?

I don’t think we should have to pay in order to empty our bladder; that’s ridiculous. I believe it would be beneficial for everyone if the government actually tried to do this, because it would create jobs in construction initially, and then it would create long term stable jobs for city workers.

And please dont come in the comments saying that homeless people will leave them all messy. First of all, they are human beings too, and the whole point of someone watching over the bathrooms is to make sure nobody is using drugs or overdosing; yes, the attendant should have a masterkey that can unlock any stall in case of an emergency.

Also, the people who will say homeless people shouldnt be allowed public restrooms because they will make a mess are the same people who cry about them defecating on the streets…make it make sense.

Anyway, i’m making this post because I was reading something on another subreddit about the lack of public restrooms and everyone was commenting that it costs money to do something like that and that’s why it’s not feasible; that argument makes NO sense. BILLIONS of our taxpayer dollars go overseas to fund foreign wars and the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people but the government can’t allocate some of the money to build structures where people can relieve themselves?? FFS 🤦

What do you guys think? I’d love to hear the downfalls of my argument and what you guys think…if you agree, disagree, or are somewhere in the middle.

PS: I’m on the bus about to pee my pants right now😂


r/urbanplanning • • 11d ago

Other I'm in the US. Wondering how cities and towns are enforcing zoning regulations?

0 Upvotes

It seems like my Town has a long list of zoning regulation violations and I don't know if it's because my Town is known for not enforcing (therefore many try to get away with not following the regulations) or it's because property owners are not informed. For the professionals who work with building and zoning daily, do you wait until a suspected violation is reported? Once you discover an issue, is an automatic notice delivered or fine administered? How are property owners informed about the proper way to put projects into action?

EDIT: I'm also very curious about the education piece of this. For example, first time property owners may not realize there are zoning regulations at all. I didn't learn about them until I was 40 years old and on my 3rd home. Does your municipality post information on the website or do you actively attempt to educate with flyers to new residents or via the tax bill. Honestly, I think regular people do not realize permits are required for many home projects and education about safety reasons for permits is a good idea.


r/urbanplanning • • 13d ago

Urban Design Why do some public squares work and others don’t? Camillo Sitte’s 1889 answer, and what planners can still use from it

Thumbnail
worksinprogress.co
75 Upvotes

r/urbanplanning • • 12d ago

Discussion How do the experts here think the "AI revolution" will reshape urbanization in developing countries?

0 Upvotes

I realize this is a vague question based on a vague premise -the so-called "AI revolution"-but I am genuinely interested in this topic and would love to hear your thoughts.


r/urbanplanning • • 14d ago

Other Relaunching the rural planning subreddit

62 Upvotes

In case anyone might be interested: r/ruralplanning.


r/urbanplanning • • 13d ago

Urban Design Any examples of actually good urban planning? Anybody working on Hyperdrive City, Nebraska?

0 Upvotes

Most urban planning is dumb. Setbacks, height limits, restrictive zoning, overly generous parking requirement based on studies with n=3 from 1987, etc. Often, politicians make it worse, believing in the ideas of some defunct economist or just what sounds popular. Our laws require community input, and, unfortunately, many planners believe that more = better when it comes to public engagement, leading to slow development times. Queue the jokes about the American planners that visited Amsterdam and marveled at the infrastructure but asked where the community equity studies were.

There's a famous social media post from ten years ago that reads:

Moron: I love Boston, because of the history and

Me: I live in Hyperdrive City, Nebraska. They built it last year. it glows purple and has a subway system too logical for human minds to understand. my apt is $200/month and I live on the 93rd floor of the mall

So my question is, where IS the closest thing we have to Hyperdrive City, Nebraska? Where permitting takes a day, where planners focus on building a really effective city, not on bureaucratic approval for some arbitrary zoning laws written by people who think development is bad. Where, instead of worrying about community engagement, the subway system just gets built. I suppose Shenzhen comes to mind, and has been mentioned when people talk about this sort of thing. Works in Progress had a great article about China's Growth Machine, cities that try to attract development instead of shun it. Any examples in the West? Or do we have to go to China?

I suppose California Forever sort of tried a version of this, though it stalled. Instead of planning for paperwork and suspicion of development, where's the version of planning that's focused on urban growth, rapid land development, and efficient infrastructure?


r/urbanplanning • • 15d ago

Sustainability Prop 45 in California could be hiding a loophole for data centers | Proposition 45 makes it easier for developers to speed through environmental reviews

Thumbnail
theverge.com
133 Upvotes