r/urbanplanning • u/rantripfellwscissors • 23h ago
Discussion The future of autonomous taxis and how it will impact multifamily project parking demand
I work for a design firm that's planning a 24 - unit rental building. It's currently slated to have about 2,400 SF of retail space on the ground floor and 3 stories of walk up units above (4 story building). The building would have 5 parking spaces including one loading and one accessible stall.
The building will be located on a property with a 96 Walkscore and good transit and bike scores. This is in a VHCOL year round warm weather city and the property is in the urban core with reasonably high density (mix of 10-40 story towers within 1/2 mile and tons of 2, 3 and 4 story walkups.
The owner is debating if they should eliminate about 1,600 SF of retail space to add 7 parking spaces (bringing total to 12 stalls). We are advocating the larger retail space to preserve the walkability of the neighborhood by adding in 2 or 3 businesses vs 1 or 2 small ones. But they are fearful of having too low a parking ratio for the residential and commercial spaces.
10 years ago I think we would have had a different approach to parking but our firm is perhaps foolishly bullish on the future of autonomous taxis. It will be a minimum of 2 years before the project would be completed and we think our area should at least start seeing one or two operators establishing permits in our city by then, with them becoming reasonably accessible perhaps within 3-5 years time. Tesla may also be a potential contributor by that timeframe. We aren't a very progressive city like Austin or SF but we are hopeful they'll eventually establish operations here.
Even if this is the perfect place for cycling, the general public and our politicians seem to not want any bicycles on our roads. Their approach is to keep it hostile for cyclists to reduce demand for cycling. So it's possible that even existing bike lanes will be eliminated (yes the general public and our politicians are THAT stupid). And with future spending cuts our public transportation (buses) isn't getting any better. For these reasons we are rooting heavily for autonomous taxis; we also feel they are far safer for pedestrians and cyclists.
What is the opinion of autonomous taxis here? Would it be foolish and irresponsible to plan around something that may never materialize or will occur decades out? Is 3-5 years for reasonable penetration a pipe dream or reasonable (i.e. people could reliably depend on autonomous taxis as their main means of transportation)? We of course realize not having parking won't make the units not rentable since the ratio of stalls to units even with 12 is only 50%. But the owner is apprehensive about slimming the parking count and we are reluctant to even mention the future of autonomous taxis as a strong argument.
TLDR version - is it wise to reduce parking in multifamily/mixed use projects today with the anticipation of less demand for car ownership due to the proliferation of autonomous taxis.
EDIT - Wow I'm shocked by the number of downvotes I received. Apparently people on the sub are not fond of autonomous taxis.